Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Thursday, 24 Mar 1983

Vol. 341 No. 5

Adjournment Debate: Private Rented Dwellings .

: Our concern refers to section 13 of the Housing (Private Rented Dwellings) Act, 1982, and the courts interpretation. The Bill clearly says that there must be a just and proper rent. There is a feeling abroad among tenants who have been subjected to this court procedure that this is not being carried out in accordance with the Act.

What is taken into account is the valuer's recommendation of what would be a market rent — and this is usually detrimental to the tenants — and as a result the court awards astronomical rents to landlords. I want to ask the Minister if it would be possible for him at this stage to examine this section and issue a directive to the courts ——

: The Minister has no responsibility for giving directives to the courts nor would it be in order for a Minister to give a directive to the courts.

: In the assessment of the rent the court is totally dependent on the value put on the house by the valuers. In some cases the tenants employ valuers but in most cases it is the landlords who employ the valuers. In the court they hear the rent suggested by the valuers and then split the difference. That is a very haphazard way of assessing a rent, which in most cases is to the detriment of the tenants. I ask the Minister if it would be possible to re-examine this section as soon as possible.

: In speaking to this debate on behalf of my fellow Cork Deputies — Deputy Lyons, Deputy Gene Fitzgerald and Deputy Wyse who, unfortunately, because of time will not be able to make their own contributions—I urge the Minister to bring before the House as a matter of urgency legislation to set up rent tribunals to deal with the unsatisfactory situation that prevails in Cork and throughout the country. If the tribunals are not set up soon there will be no cases left for them to deal with because they are going through the courts very fast. We were told it would take years before these cases would be heard in court but they are going through very quickly.

People, especially old people, are being brought into court, some of them are helped into court, to have their rents assessed by the judge. For many of them this is a traumatic experience. It is the first time they have ever been in a courthouse. The Minister will agree that it is a sad state of affairs when such people have to go to court to have their rents assessed.

When the rent restrictions legislation was introduced we welcomed it because previously there was no protection for the tenants. The previous Government brought in the legislation with the best of intentions, but it has not worked out that way. Valuers for the landlords and the tenants go into court but their figures do not agree and the judge fixes a figure in between. This has not worked to the advantage of the tenant; it appears to favour the landlord.

I would also ask the Minister when he is setting up his tribunals to appoint people who would be familiar with the set-up, such as architects and engineers. They could go out and look at the houses and be fair to all sides concerned. There are cases of people who were paying £1 and £2 a week and suddenly it has gone up to £25 or £30. This is causing great hardship to old people and people with young families. I would appeal to the Minister to deal with this as quickly as possible.

Another point is that the tribunal should not be located in a courthouse. If possible it should be in local authority buildings or community buildings. Would the Minister give consideration to the subsidy? With the social welfare cuts there is great hardship being experienced.

: I have been asked to represent my Fine Gael colleagues — Deputy Liam Burke, Deputy Coveney and Deputy Peter Barry. Like my colleagues in the Labour Party and in Fianna Fáil I am appalled at what is happening in Cork city and I agree that if moves are not made quickly to bring in the rent tribunals as promised every case that is due for consideration in Cork will have been heard. Elderly people are being brought into court. They are being terrorised and intimidated by the legal system and I would ask the Minister, when setting up the tribunal to locate it out of the court system and have it under the control of either the local authority officers or perhaps social welfare.

The alarming thing is the application of the law as it stands. Deputy O'Sullivan has mentioned section 13 which is not being applied as the Act sets out at all. It is a question of the landlord's valuer and the tenant's valuer putting values on the property and the judge splitting the difference. The valuers are familiar with what is happening so the landlord's valuer is inflating the value and we are getting very unjust decisions.

: I do not think the Deputy should refer to decisions of the courts as unjust.

: What I am saying is that unless somebody advises or intervenes we will be left with a situation in Cork especially—I can only speak for Cork — where there have been travesties of justice. They have happened.

: As long as the Deputy is not attributing travesties of justice to the courts, to having been knowingly handed down by the courts, it is all right. He certainly should not do that because it is not in the interests of the country and it is not in the interests of justice or anything else.

: The court proceedings will have to be stopped. I am looking for advice from somebody in authority, some Minister, to indicate how these cases can be suspended pending the setting up of the tribunal. The tribunal was planned to cater for these cases but there will be no cases left.

: I welcome the initiative taken by the Deputies from Cork who have represented all the representatives of the Cork region. I am aware of the problems. They are not particular to Cork but they are acute in the Cork area because of some of the points made by Deputy Wallace.

In relation to the rents tribunal I want to repeat the commitment made by the Taoiseach here on the Order of Business some weeks ago to the effect that legislation to establish these tribunals will be introduced between April 20 and when we rise for the summer recess. The outline of that legislation has already been signalled by me in a public statement and we are now in the process of having it finalised. I recognise fully, as everybody else in this Chamber recognises, that it was the clear intention of the legislators in the making of the legislation the second time around that section 13 of the Housing (Private Rented Dwellings) Act, 1982 should be interpreted in such a manner as to ensure that market rent described in the way that Deputy O'Sullivan described it is not applied. I am aware of the delicate and independent relationship between the Oireachtas and the courts, but I am also aware that perhaps section 13 is not being interpreted in the way that the legislators wanted it to be interpreted. If that is the case we should look at that and see if clarity can be obtained on both sides. I will take very seriously the request by Deputy Allen to see in what manner, and without in any way interfering with the due process of the courts, the interpretation of section 13 can be properly applied. That interpretation, mind you, extends as much to the solicitors acting on behalf of the defendent tenants as it does to anybody else within the process.

The desire to decriminalise the process of the fixing of rents is one to which we are very committed. For that reason, I accept the request of Deputy Wallace to locate the rents tribunals in a non-legal environment. I want to emphasise what I mean by the word "decriminalise". I am aware in my own constituency of an 87 year old woman who had to get in to the witness box and be cross examined under oath about the house in which she had lived practically all her life. For a person like that to find herself in court at all is a presumption of some kind of guilt. Therefore, it is better to establish rent tribunals in an informal and non-threatening manner so that the kind of terrorism to which Deputy Allen refers does not exist.

I should like to tell Deputy Wallace that there is a commitment to review the relationship of social welfare payments to the rent subsidies. This commitment I repeat again. Increases in social welfare payments will not prevent people, in cases where they would otherwise have qualified for rent subsidies, from qualifying for those subsidies after the increases in social welfare payments take effect.

I want to put on record, as the Minister of State responsible for introducing this legislation, that I am aware of the concern that has been expressed. I would hope that the courts in the general manner would take note of what we have said today, and of what has been said during the passage of the Bill last July so that the proper relationship between what the legislators want, on the one hand, and what the courts have to administer on the other is clearly seen and that our intentions are clearly seen. I will take the representations that have been made and bring them to the notice of the Minister for Justice to enable him to handle it in the manner that is appropriate for his jurisdiction.

I will make my own personal commitment to introduce the legislation here as quickly as possible and to establish the tribunals as quickly as possible throughout the country. It is envisaged that each local housing authority will have a rents officer who, in the first instance, will be the person who will fix the rent and in the event of either party not being satisfied with the proposed rent they will then have the right to appeal to the rents tribunal and the rents tribunal will be a panel modelled on the Employment Appeals Tribunal under the aegis of the Department of Labour and will be mobile and capable of locating itself in different venues throughout the country so as to bring justice and equity on the question of rents to the people rather than as at present bringing people into the District Court when in many cases the courts are not the correct venue for this.

During the passing of the legislation the Minister of the day, Deputy Burke, accepted the argument in principle for rents tribunals, but due to pressure of time was unable to introduce it at that stage. This is a matter where there is all-party agreement. That gives me confidence to believe we can get the legislation enacted before the end of the summer session.

Top
Share