Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 13 Oct 1993

Vol. 434 No. 5

Written Answers. - Beef Tribunal Costs.

Ivor Callely

Question:

81 Mr. Callely asked the Minister for Agriculture, Food and Forestry the total costs involved for the Beef Tribunal to date; if he will give a breakdown of all witnesses who have submitted an expense claim for consideration of payment; and if he will make a statement on the matter.

Minister for Agriculture, Food and Forestry (Mr. J. Walsh)

The total cost of the Beef Tribunal to date is £6,942,817.

A breakdown of witnesses' expenses payable by the Tribunal Office was given to the Clerk to the Committee on Public Accounts in a letter from the sole member of the tribunal on 28 September 1993. A copy of the letter is being circulated.

In addition to these, my Department paid expenses to the civil servants listed below in accordance with the standard Civil Service travelling and subsistence regulations:

Name of Officer
1. G.K. Barry	48. D. Kiersey
2. D. Butler	49. E.J. Kelly
3. G.M. Butler	50. J.R. Kelly
4. B. Brady	51. P. Kieran
5. M.F. Brislaine	52. T. Keane
6. L. Brady	53. M. King
7. L. Buckley	54. J. Looney
8. T.J. Bracken	55. G. Listan
9. K. Byrne	56. D. Lynch
10. J. Carthy	57. M. Long
11. J. Comerford	58. T.P. Lyons
12. B. Cannon	59. P.J. Ledwith
13. J.F. Connelly	60. R.A. Malloy
14. D. Carroll	61. A.J. Matthews
15. L. Cassen	62. J.J. Mitchell
16. C.J. Carr	63. H. MacCloskey
17. A. Conway	64. T.F. Mockler
18. P.C. Casey	65. P.J. Mangan
19. P. Connolly	66. G.J. Mahoney
20. P.E. Cannon	67. W. Moorhead
21. P. Connaughton	68. J. Melville
22. M. Durkin	69. R.A. Maloney
23. A. Doyle	70. M. Mullen
24. G. Davey	71. G. Mellett
25. S. Dalton	72. A. McCarthy
26. J. Doherty	73. H.O. Maguire
27. P. Feeney	74. D. Murphy
28. S. Fogarty	75. J. Murphy
29. P. Gallagher	76. K. McDonagh
30. J. Gallagher	77. G. Mulligan
31. P. Gregan	78. M. Morrissey
32. D. Gavaghan	79. J. Meade
33. M. Good	80. M. McGoahan
34. C. Caffey Godman	81. A. Nevin
35. K. Galligan	82. B. Nevin
36. P.J. Garvey	83. S.P. O'Connor
37. M. Galgey	84. M. O'Farrell
38. M. Harvey	85. W. O'Connor
39. W. Healy	86. J. O'Callaghan
40. P. Heslin	87. C. O'Brien
41. P. Hand	88. W. O'Rourke
42. J.S. Hughes	89. T. O'Donnell
43. J.G. Higgins	90. G. O'Hagan
44. M. Hessionn	91. P.E. O'Neill
45. Margaret Hogan	92. C. O'Carroll
46. M. Heraghty	93. M.J. O'Sullivan
47. V. Keane	94. A. O'Farrell
95. E. Phelan	103. M. Staff
96. L. Queeney	104. J. Sheridan
97. D. Ryan	105. P. Smyth
98. P. Rooney	106. P. Timmins
99. P. Rice	107. P. Sexton
100. J. Ryan	108. J. Vaughan
101. D. Russell	109. M. Windle
102. H. Sweeney	110. V.T. Whelan
	111. J.E. Walsh

The following is a copy of the letter:

28 September, 1993

Eoin Faherty,

Clerk to the Committee of Public Accounts,

Leinster House,

Dublin 2.

Re: Tribunal of Inquiry — Beef Processing Industry.

Dear Sir

A copy of your letter dated 17th September, 1993 to the Accounting Officer, Department of Agriculture, Food and Forestry regarding witnesses' expenses at the Tribunal of Inquiry into the Beef Industry has been forwarded to the Registrar to the Tribunal together with a request for material for reply.

At a time when the Tribunal is engaged in the task of collating and evaluating the evidence, oral and documentary, adduced before it, it is regrettable that the work in this regard should be interrupted by the necessity to deal with queries raised by the Committee of Public Accounts in connection with expenses incurred by the Tribunal in connection with securing the attendance of witnesses before the Tribunal for the purpose of carrying out the Inquiry which both Houses of the Oireachtas considered of urgent public importance.

The Tribunal fully appreciates the concern expressed by members of your Committee with regard to the costs of the Tribunal, including the expenses of witnesses attending before the Tribunal, and has decided to clarify the position in regard thereto by direct communication to the Committee of Public Accounts.

The necessity for the attendance of witnesses before the Tribunal, the steps necessary to secure their attendance, and the expenses incidental thereto were the concern solely of the Tribunal and not of the Department of Agriculture, Food and Forestry or any other Department of State.

In order to enable the Tribunal to discharge its obligations in this regard, funds were made available to the Tribunal by the Department of Agriculture and Food, but the disbursement of same and the reasons therefor were solely a matter for the Tribunal.

Detailed particulars of such disbursements and vouchers in support thereof were and are at all times available to officials of the Department of Agriculture and the Comptroller and Auditor General.

The necessity and reasons for any particular payment were never given to the Accounting Officer of the Department of Agriculture and Food because these were matters for determination by the Tribunal only.

It appears from your letter dated 17th September, 1993 that the Committee of Public Accounts required clarification of the following:

(a) A breakdown of all payments made to Mr. Patrick McGuinness including professional fees and travelling expenses.

(b) A breakdown of the 492 payments totalling £96,122.85 witnesses' expenses.

While the Tribunal questions the propriety of the Committee of Public Accounts seeking this information at a time when the Tribunal is in the course of preparing its Report to the Minister for Agriculture, Food and Forestry, it has decided in the public interest and to avoid any misunderstanding to give the clarification sought by the Committee.

The expenses incurred by the Tribunal in connection with the attendance of Mr. Patrick McGuinness before the tribunal were as follows:—

	£
(1) Travel expenses of Mr. McGuinness and his lawyers from Canada to Dublin.	9,290.00
(2) Hotel expenses of Mr. McGuinness and lawyers (while in Dublin)	5,756.23
(3) Legal expenses	47,767.44
(4) Amount paid to Mr. McGuinness in respect of loss of earnings (23 days at 188 Canadian Dollars per day)	2,356.38
(5) Travel, Hotel and incidental expenses incurred by Counsel to the Tribunal in connection with three necessary and authorised visits to Canada in connection with Mr. McGuinness' attendance at the Tribunal	13,133.31
	£78,303.36

Vouchers and receipts in respect of the foregoing items of expenditure were examined by the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General and found to be satisfactory.

Annexed to this letter is a schedule of payments to other witnesses in respect of expenses and, where appropriate, loss of earnings.

The Committee of Public Accounts has sought in the case of payments to Mr. McGuinness, including fees paid to lawyers acting on his behalf a breakdown of these fees together with the reason they were met. The Tribunal does not intend to make such information available to the Committee pending the presentation by it of its Report as it would be quite improper for it so to do, the Tribunal's obligation is to report to the Minister for Agriculture and it will do so in due course in respect of all relevant matters including the matters referred to in your letter and will not — indeed cannot — report to any other body.

Yours sincerely,

Mr. Justice Liam Hamilton,

President of the High Court,

Sole Member of the Tribunal of Inquiry.

Witness Payments (by cheque)

Date	Particulars	Debit	Comments
21-8-1991	Payment to B. Solan, Witness	30.00	Witness expenses
11-9-1991	T. Ruddy (Stg)	30.00	Witness expenses
26-9-1991	Aer Lingus	167.00	Witness Travel — Ken Brennan
27-9-1991	J. Lynch	40.00	Witness Expenses
1-10-1991	Pay Cash	20.00	Witness Expenses — K. Brennan
21-10-1991	E. McGonigal SC	40.00	Witness Expenses — J. Lynch
4-11-1991	Aer Lingus	154.00	Witness travel — K. Brennan
17-12-1991	Allied Signal Inc.	99.04	Witness expenses — J. Wallace
18-12-1991	Clarence Hotel	197.75	Witness expenses — K. Brennan
19-12-1991	B. Solan	11.00	Witness expenses
7-01-1992	Clarence Hotel	255.60	Witness expenses— J. Fowler, J. Wallace, J. Meaney, B. Solan
20-1-1992	Nacanco Irl.	158.76	Witness expenses — J. Fowler
11-2-1992	R. Watson	25.00	Witness expenses
11-2-1992	Ashling Hotel	166.50	Witness expenses — R. Boylan, B. Wall, P. Phelan
11-2-1992	Central Hotel	192.36	Witness Expenses — J. Lynch
11-2-1992	Dublin Port & Docks	897.00	Witness Exps. — K. Kinlan, M. Curtin
6-3-1992	Clarence Hotel	1,700.67	Witness expenses — Mr.
			Chawke, O'Doherty,
			O'Connor, Horgan, Dunne,
			Carey, Rea, Forde, Howard,
			Heavey, Botham, Sweeney,
			Whelan, Galvin, Rea &
			Kearney, Forde, Frisby,
			Conroy, Sweeney,
			Courtney, O'Brien, Keenan,
			Conroy, Jones.
25-3-1992	P. Dunne	25.00	Witness Expenses
25-3-1992	J. Lynch	429.00	Witness expenses
25-3-1992	P. Dunne	4.20	Witness expenses
25-3-1992	Ormond Hotel	198.40	Witness expenses — Galvin, Sweeney, Boylan, Grier
9-4-1992	F.J. McDowdall	366.70	Witness expenses
15-4-1992	Network Investigations	756.25	Witness expenses — W. Meagher
2-6-1992	Clarence Hotel	1,154.03	Witness expenses — Jones, Rea & Kearney, Whelan & Galvin, Keenan, Conroy, O'Brien, Courtney, Conroy
6-10-1992	S. O'Neill	527.16	Witness expenses
9-10-1992	S. O'Neill	273.66	Witness expenses
6-11-1992	A.C. Fitzpatrick	52.00	Witness expenses
11-12-1992	Quid Ltd.	290.40	Interpreters for witness
13-1-1993	J. Meade — W.	728.00	Witness expenses
20-1-1993	G. McGrath — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	T. Dunne —W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	K. McKnight — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	S. O'Donoghue — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	J. O'Sullivan — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	T. Murphy — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	P. Lynch — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	J. Horgan — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	D. Horgan — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	A. Barry — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	B. Kennedy — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
25-1-1993	D. Lynam — W.	30.00	Witness expenses
29-1-1993	B. Kennedy — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
5-2-1993	J. Collins — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
	P. O'Connor — W.	35.00	Witness expenses
11-2-1993	G. Lambe — W.	56.79	Witness expenses
	P. Bendon — W.	46.96	Witness expenses
	J. Leahy — W.	49.19	Witness expenses
	J. McGrath — W.	118.98	Witness expenses
	Clarence Hotel — W.	585.00	Witness expenses: G. McGrath,
			K. McKnight, J. Horgan, P.
			Benson, W. Harrington, B.
			Kennedy, T. Dunne, A.
			Barry, S. O'Donoghue, J.
			O'Sullivan, T. Murphy, D.
			Hogan.
12-2-1993	D.B. Geary — W.	139.40	Witness expenses
3-3-1993	Clarence Hotel — W.	367.00	Witness expenses — J. Collins, P. O'Connor, P. Lynch, A. Murphy, P. Cahill
	J. Higgins — W.	30.00	Witness Expenses
	A. Murphy — W.	36.83	Witness Expenses
	E. Vereker — W.	16.82	Witness Expenses
10-3-1993	M. Jinks — W.	175.50	Witness Expenses
10-3-1993	Executive Catering — W.	52.80	Witness Expenses
11-3-1993	D. Hanley	352.10	Witness Expenses
29-3-1993	M. Byrne	52.00	Witness Expenses
18-5-1993	P. McLoughlin — W.	70.00	Witness Expenses
	J. Egan — W.	70.00	Witness Expenses
	D. Cogan — W.	70.00	Witness Expenses
	P. Ennis — W.	74.00	Witness Expenses
	P. Lydon — W.	74.00	Witness Expenses
28-6-1993	T. Byrne — W.	103.84	Witness Expenses
	B. McArdle — W.	50.00	Witness Expenses
	E. Gleeson — W.	288.28	Witness Expenses
	B. O'Beirn — W.	136.80	Witness Expenses
	L. O'Brien — W.	341.40	Witness Expenses
	G. M. Butler — W.	273.40	Witness Expenses
	T. Collins — W.	140.00	Witness Expenses
	P. McAleer — W.	15.00	Witness Expenses
	B. McAvinney — W.	90.00	Witness Expenses
	J. Smyth — W.	90.00	Witness Expenses
	Clarence Hotel	15.50	Witness Expenses — K. Phelan,
			W. Maher
29-6-1993	G.M. Butler — W.	188.30	Witness Expenses
	Total	13,679.37

Witness Expenses Paid in Cash

Date	Witness	Amount	Receipt No.
		£
13-11-1991	Ken Brennan	230.50	PC13
21-11-1991	John Macklins	87.00	W1
21-11-1991	M. MacCurtin & E. Kinlan	72.13	W2
11-12-1991	Timothy Ralph	276.20	W3
30-01-1992	Patrick Casey (UFA)	95.00	W4
13-02-1992	Des Carey (UFA)	90.00	W5
14-02-1992	Supt. P. Smith	20.00	W6
14-02-1992	Messrs. Galvin & Sweeney	50.00	W7
16-09-1992	Mr. Hodgers	51.86	W11
16-09-1992	Mr. Kelly	199.48	W12
16-09-1992	Mr. O'Donnell	139.50	W13
12-01-1993	B. Devenney	15.50	W14
12-01-1993	T. Byrne	6.00	W15
03-02-1993	John O'Sullivan	36.00	W16
03-02-1993	Kevin McKnight	8.00	W17
03-02-1993	William Harrington	35.00	W18
03-02-1993	Pat Benson	35.00	W19
03-02-1993	Raymond Gilbourne	35.00	W19
03-02-1993	Thomas Murphy	5.00	W20
09-02-1993	Anthony Murphy	36.00	W21
09-02-1993	Pat Lynch	19.00	W22
09-02-1993	James Higgins	15.00	W23
09-02-1993	Ger O'Grady	5.00	W24
09-02-1993	Liam Quirke	4.50	W25
09-02-1993	Pat Lane	5.40	W26
09-02-1993	Colm Quirke	4.75	W27
09-02-1993	Barry Twomey	5.00	W28
09-02-1993	Paul Cahill	5.00	W29
09-02-1993	James Leahy	5.00	W30
09-02-1993	Gerard Shinney	5.00	W31
10-02-1993	Liam O'Shaughnessy	30.00	W32
10-02-1993	Messrs. E. Vercker & T. Hayes	32.00	W33
10-02-1993	E. Vercker	3.40	W34
16-02-1993	Eoin Maher	12.00	W35
16-02-1993	D. Hanley	10.00	W36
16-02-1993	E. O'Shaughnessy	6.30	W37
11-05-1993	Bernard Kelly	5.00	W38
20-05-1993	Michael Ely	25.00	W39
20-05-1993	P. Bourke	40.00	W40
	Total	1,760.52

Viatica

Date	Witness	Amount	Summons No.
		£
8-11-1991	Seán Robinson	20.00 (Rtd.)	V1
8-11-1991	Fionnuala Fenton	20.00	V2
8-11-1991	Ger Kelly	20.00	V3
11-11-1991	Eric Kinlan	10.00	V4
11-11-1991	Michael Curtin	10.00	V5
15-11-1991	John Meaney	20.00	V6
15-11-1991	John Fowler	20.00	V7
15-11-1991	John Wallace	20.00	V8
18-11-1991	Peter O'Reilly	20.00	V9
18-11-1991	Peter O'Reilly Jnr.	20.00	V10
18-11-1991	Mark Murphy	20.00	V11
18-11-1991	Denis Murphy	10.00	V12
18-11-1991	Pat O'Neill	10.00	V13
18-11-1991	Michael O'Cleary	10.00	V14
18-11-1991	R. McCabe	20.00	V15
18-11-1991	M. McMahon	20.00	V16
18-11-1991	T. Deery	20.00	V17
18-11-1991	M. McGivern	20.00	V18
18-11-1991	A. Finnegan	20.00	V19
18-11-1991	R. McDonnell	20.00	V20
18-11-1991	C. O'Reilly	20.00	V21
18-11-1991	H. O'Connell	20.00	V22
18-11-1991	M. Hamilton	20.00	V23
18-11-1991	E. Freeman	20.00	V24
19-11-1991	Seán Sheehan	20.00	V25
19-11-1991	Colm Finnegan	20.00	V26
19-11-1991	Gerry Morgan	20.00	V27
19-11-1991	Francis O'Reilly	20.00	V28
19-11-1991	Michael O'Reilly	20.00	V29
19-11-1991	Matthew O'Reilly	20.00	V30
19-11-1991	Pat Birdy	20.00	V31
19-11-1991	John McDonald	20.00	V32
19-11-1991	Gerry Thornton	20.00	V33
19-11-1991	Don O'Brien	20.00 (Rtd.)	V34
19-11-1991	John Macklin	10.00	V35
19-11-1991	Ray Watson	10.00	V36
19-11-1991	Liam Fleming	10.00	V37
19-11-1991	Susan Molloy	10.00	V38
19-11-1991	Philip Meade	10.00 (Rtd.)	V39
19-11-1991	Lorraine McMahon	20.00 (Rtd.)	V40
19-11-1991	Sharon Casey	20.00 (Rtd.)	V41
19-11-1991	Peter Goodman	20.00 (Rtd.)	V42
19-11-1991	Jim Walsh	20.00	V43
19-11-1991	Michael Mullowney	20.00	V44
23-11-1991	John Conroy	20.00	V45
23-1-1992	Paul Courtney	20.00	V46
23-1-1992	Anthony O'Brien	20.00 (Rtd.)	V47
23-1-1992	Gerard O'Brien	20.00	V48
23-1-1992	Patrick Frisby	20.00	V49
23-1-1992	Oliver Forde	20.00	V50
23-1-1992	Dennis Galvin	20.00	V51
23-1-1992	John Ray	20.00	V52
23-1-1992	Seán Keenan	20.00	V53
23-1-1992	Frank Wallace	20.00	V54
23-1-1992	William Mackey	20.00	V55
23-1-1992	Patrick Sweeney	20.00	V56
23-1-1992	John McLoughlin	20.00	V57
31-1-1992	Christy Jones	20.00 (Rtd.)	V57A
31-1-1992	Shane Hourigan	20.00 (Rtd.)	V58
31-1-1992	Patrick Dunne	20.00	V59
31-1-1992	Patrick Liston	20.00	V60
31-1-1992	Denis O'Connor	20.00	V61
31-1-1992	John Horgan	20.00	V62
31-1-1992	William Chalk	20.00	V63
7-2-1992	Con Howard	20.00	V65
7-2-1992	John Duffy	20.00	V66
7-2-1992	Brendan Dooley	20.00	V67
7-2-1992	Ellen Heavey	20.00	V68
7-2-1992	Noel Carroll	20.00 (Rtd.)	V69
7-2-1992	John Grier	20.00	V70
7-2-1992	Michael Telvin	20.00	V71
7-2-1992	Peter Bourke	20.00	V72
3-4-1992	Oliver Murphy	10.00	V73
10-4-1992	John Stanley	20.00 (Rtd.)	V74
1-5-1992	John Stanley	15.00	V75
6-5-1992	J. Egan	10.00 (Rtd.)	—
7-5-1992	Pascal Phelan	10.00	V75
22-5-1992	Pascal Phelan	10.00 (Rtd.)	V76
11-6-1992	Pascal Phelan	10.00	V76
5-11-1992	Tony Byrne	5.00 (Rtd.)	V77
5-11-92	B. Devenney	10.00 (Rtd.)	V78
5-11-1992	Gene Lambe	10.00 (Rtd.)	V79
3-12-1992	Granada Television	5.00	V80
3-12-1992	Granada Television	5.00	V81
3-12-1992	Susan O'Keeffe	5.00	V82
1-12-1992	C. Peyron	10.00	V83
1-12-1992	V. Broderick	5.00	V84
7-1-1993	T. Byrne	5.00	V85
7-1-1993	B. Devenney	10.00	V86
7-1-1993	Gene Lambe	10.00	V87
12-1-1993	Niall O'Carroll	5.00	V88
12-1-1993	Sean Mooney	5.00	V89
18-1-1993	John O'Sullivan	10.00 (Rtd.)	V90
18-1-1993	John Lynch	10.00	V91
18-1-1993	Patrick Lane	10.00	V92
18-1-1993	James Leahy	10.00	V93
18-1-1993	Maurice Barry	10.00	V94
18-1-1993	Anthony Murphy	10.00	V95
18-1-1993	Raymond Gilbourne	10.00	V96
18-1-1993	Gerard Shinny	10.00	V97
18-1-1993	Gerard McGrath	10.00	V98
18-1-1993	Gerard O'Grady	10.00	V99
18-1-1993	Thomas Murphy	10.00	V100
18-1-1993	Colm Quirk	10.00	V101
18-1-1993	Liam Quirke	10.00	V102
18-1-1993	Anthony Barry	10.00	V103
18-1-1993	Seamus McGrath	10.00	V104
18-1-1993	James Higgins	10.00	V105
18-1-1993	Thomas Dunne	10.00	V106
18-1-1993	Pat Benson	10.00	V107
18-1-1993	Paul Cahill	10.00	V108
18-1-1993	Pat Lynch (Park View)	10.00	V109
18-1-1993	David Morrissey	10.00	V110
18-1-1993	William Harrington	10.00	V111
18-1-1993	Kevin McKnight	10.00	V112
18-1-1993	Sean O'Donoghue	10.00	V113
18-1-1993	Denis Hogan	10.00	V114
18-1-1993	John Horgan	10.00	V115
18-1-1993	Patrick Lynch (St. Mary's)	10.00	V116
18-1-1993	Peter O'Connor	10.00	V117
18-1-1993	Brian Kennedy	10.00	V118
18-1-1993	John Collins	10.00	V119
18-1-1993	Michael Lawlor	35.00	V120
18-1-1993	Barry Twomey	10.00	V121
18-1-1993	David Geary	10.00	V122
18-1-1993	Michael Jinks	10.00 (Rtd.)	V128
5-2-1993	Edward Vereker	10.00	V124
5-2-1993	Trevor Hayes	10.00	V125
5-2-1993	Jean Ryan	10.00 (Rtd.)	V126
5-2-1993	Liam O'Shaughnessy	10.00	V127
15-1-1993	Michael Byrne	10.00	V123
12-2-1993	Dermot Hanley	10.00	V129
12-2-1993	Eamonn O'Shaughnessy	10.00	V130
12-2-1993	Eoin Maher	10.00 (Rtd.)	V131
12-2-1993	Martin Finucane	10.00	V132
12-2-1993	Sean Goodwin	10.00	V133
12-2-1993	Larry Kelly	10.00	V134
12-2-1993	Denis Murphy	10.00	V135
12-2-1993	Thomas Keating	10.00	V136
12-2-1993	Matthew O'Doherty	10.00	V137
12-2-1993	Tony Butler	10.00	V138
12-2-1993	Sean Hartnett	10.00	V139
12-2-1993	Ger Kirwan	10.00	V140
12-2-1993	Michael Dunne	10.00	V141
12-2-1993	Barry Shanahan	10.00	V142
12-2-1993	Sean O'Shea	10.00	V143
12-2-1993	Michael O'Neill	10.00	V144
12-2-1993	Michael Meehan	10.00	V145
12-2-1993	Aisling Melvin	10.00	V146
12-1-1993	Sean Geoghegan	10.00	V147
22-2-1993	John McLaughlin, Dundalk	10.00	V148
22-2-1993	John McLaughlin, Waterford	10.00	V149
22-2-1993	John McLaughlin, Cahir	10.00	V150
22-2-1993	John McLaughlin, Carlow	10.00	V151
22-2-1993	John McLaughlin, Longford	10.00	V152
22-2-1993	John McLaughlin, Cloughran	10.00	V153
22-2-1993	John McLaughlin, Nenagh	10.00	V154
19-2-1993	John McLaughlin, Rathkeale	10.00	V155
31-2-1993	Senator Michael O'Kennedy	10.00	V155
4-5-1993	Veronica Guerin	5.00	V157
4-5-1993	Timothy Lloyd	5.00	V158
4-5-1993	C.G. Smithson — Foxton	5.00	V159
4-5-1993	Arthur Ormsby	5.00	V160
4-5-1993	C.G. Smithson — Foxton (Docs)	5.00	V161
4-5-1993	Anthony Dunne	5.00	V162
4-5-1993	Bernard Kelly	5.00	V163
4-5-1993	Paul McLoughlin	5.00	V164
4-5-1993	Denis Cogan	5.00	V165
4-5-1993	Daniel Brady	5.00	V166
4-5-1993	Patrick Ennis	5.00	V167
4-5-1993	John Egan	5.00	V168
4-5-1993	Paul Lydon	5.00	V169
4-5-1993	Patrick Hegarty	5.00	V170
7-5-1993	Bernard McArdle	20.00	V171
18-5-1993	Peter Bourke	10.00	V172
18-5-1993	John Roberts	10.00	V173
21-5-1993	Seán Clarke	10.00	V174
21-5-1993	Sean McNamara	10.00	V175
21-5-1993	John Stanely	10.00	V176
21-5-1993	Chris Kett	10.00	V177
21-5-1993	Jack Fox	5.00	V178
21-5-1993	Christopher O'Brien	5.00	V179
21-5-1993	Bernard Smith	10.00	V180
24-5-1993	Brian Donovan	5.00	V181
25-5-1993	Edward Gleeson	10.00	V182
25-5-1993	Thomas Murphy	10.00	V183
25-5-1993	Michael J. Behan	10.00	V184
25-5-1993	Noel Flood	10.00	V185
3-6-1993	C. Lynch	10.00	V186
3-6-1993	D. Hogan	10.00 (Rtd.)	V187
3-6-1993	John O'Connell	10.00	V188
4-6-1993	Brian O'Beirn	20.00	V189
8-6-1993	Jim Cahill	5.00	V190
10-6-1993	Norbert Quinn	10.00	V191
10-6-1993	Martin Collier	10.00	V192
10-6-1993	Fintan Phelan	10.00	V193
10-6-1993	George McKenna	10.00	V194
10-6-1993	T. Collins	10.00	V195
10-6-1993	Michael Walshe	10.00	V196
10-6-1993	Jim Meehan	10.00	V197
10-6-1993	T. O'Loughlin	10.00	V198
10-6-1993	Martin Dolan	10.00	V199
10-6-1993	Liam O'Brien	10.00	V200
10-6-1993	Jack Fox	5.00	V201
10-6-1993	Carol Miller	5.00	V202
14-6-1993	Richard McCann	5.00	V203
18-6-1993	Kevin Phelan	5.00	V204
18-6-1993	William Maher	5.00	V205
16-6-1993	Joseph Halpin	5.00	V206
21-6-1993	Brian McAvinney	10.00	V207
21-6-1993	Ronnie Flanagan	10.00	V208
21-6-1993	Margaret Flanagan	10.00	V209
21-6-1993	John Smith	10.00	V210
21-6-1993	Jimmy Flanagan	10.00	V211
21-6-1993	Raymond McGovern	10.00 (Rtd.)	V212
22-6-1993	Ronnie Flanagan	10.00 (Rtd.)	V213
25-6-1993	Daniel McGrattan	10.00	V214
28-6-1993	Michael Connolly	10.00	V215
		2,700.00