Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 17 Dec 1996

Vol. 473 No. 1

Adjournment Debate. - Doneraile (Cork) Garda Station.

Thank you, a Cheann Comhairle, for being so magnanimous in allowing our Deputy Leader to take my place on the second matter. I am very disappointed at the failure of the Minister for Justice to come in here to address one of the most serious problems that has arisen in my constituency.

On 1 July 1996 the Garda station in Doneraile was transferred to an office in the community hall measuring ten square feet by eight square feet. It is unbelievable that this could have happened. There is inadequate heating and lighting in that building. There is no privacy as voices can be heard through the slab walls which are not sound proof. There is a sergeant and one garda in the area and to date this year, of 24 reported crimes 16 have been successfully solved, an outstanding achievement in poor working conditions.

The transfer took place because the original Garda station was in a state of decay and the conditions posed a threat to the health of those working there. The garda and sergeant would like to return to that building as soon as possible. The undue delay in having the building restored is unreasonable and the whole community is dissatisfied with the present position.

The old station was a Georgian streetscape. It was used as an RIC barracks many years ago and Doneraile was served well at that time by the Royal Irish Constabulary. The building was originally part of the Doneraile estate. Since the 1920s when this great State was founded — we all identify with that great era — there was a sergeant and four gardaí in Doneraile, but the numbers were gradually reduced.

I sympathise with the Minister of State who has done an excellent job for Cork — there is no Minister from Cork in the Cabinet — and I admire him for that. I wish him many days of success. The population served by the Doneraile Garda station is 2,000. There are 3,000 acres of forestry in the area, which must be properly policed. The area covers 15 square miles by nine square miles, including two villages and a town, with four hotels, a golf course, a bank and seven public houses. I appeal to the Minister of State to use his influence in Government to solve this problem.

A question was put down recently to the Minister for Arts, Culture and the Gaeltacht about the Georgian status of the Doneraile Garda station. If law and order is to be upheld good working conditions must be maintained. I ask the Minister to meet the needs of Doneraile, which is a historic place. Canon Sheehan, the great literary writer who wrote many great novels, was from that area. The Minister should give a commitment that before the next general election a new facility will be put in place so that the Garda Síochána can uphold the law and protect the citizens of my constituency.

The Minister for Justice has often failed to come into the House to reply to these issues. If it was not for Fianna Fáil there would be no law and order. Deputy O'Donoghue and other Front Bench Deputies have put approximately 11 Bills through the House to protect the citizens and we see the fruits of those daily in our courts.

Deputy O'Keeffe started very well by praising me and generally taking part in the Christmas spirit, but matters deteriorated as he proceeded. I share the Deputy's concern for the position in Doneraile. I apologise for the Minister for Justice who is absent for very good reasons and sends her apologies.

I thank Deputy O'Keeffe for raising this issue and affording me the opportunity to explain the latest position regarding work on Doneraile Garda station. In June 1993 a report was published following a review of the Garda building programme. The object of the review was to assess the existing stock of accommodation and, among other things, to examine the various options for replacing Garda stations. One of the recommendations to emerge from the review was that to make the best use of available financial resources, consideration should be given to sharing buildings with other users.

A local developer put forward a proposal to the Office of Public Works that a new Garda station be incorporated in a new retail development on the existing station site. Following approval by the Garda authorities of the plans for the new station in this development, sanction for the project was received by the Office of Public Works from the Department of Fianance. In the normal way Doneraile would have taken its place on the Garda building priority list. When the developer made his offer the Minister grasped the opportunity to expedite the project.

The Minister had inquiries made of the Office of Public Works and it is understood the contract has not been signed yet because the Department of Arts, Culture and the Gaeltacht had requested that a number of conservation steps be incorporated into the new building under section 10 of the Heritage Act, 1995. The Minister has been informed that these conditions have been accepted by the developer. The necessary revisions to the contract agreement are now being attended to by the Chief State Solicitor and it is expected that the revised documents will be executed before Christmas thus enabling the developer to commence on site in the new year.

The Minister was aware that accommodation in Doneraile was less than adequate and was glad to lend her support to this venture. As the project entails the demolition of the old site, arrangements were made to provide the gardaí with temporary accommodation. A local community hall was made available and it was occupied by the gardaí last July. That explains the position outlined by Deputy O'Keeffe.

I take this opportunity to stress that a great deal of work has been done in recent years in improving standards of accommodation at Garda stations. It is, however, a large scale operation. This programme of improvement has a high priority with the Minister and the Government. This year, for instance, almost £9 million has been provided to build and maintain Garda stations. The gardaí occupy 704 Garda stations and other accommodation, including married quarters, large complexes like Templemore and Garda Headquarters, and a variety of smaller units. Many of the buildings are old RIC and DMP stations designed for a different age and need major upgrading or replacement.

A great deal of work has been done in recent years to improve the situation and I am sure Members will all be aware of examples of improvements to Garda stations and of new stations provided in recent years. The Deputy knows, for instance, that work commenced recently on the building of Douglas Garda station and Clonakilty District Headquarters in County Cork——

I am only concerned about Doneraile.

——and the Minister recently opened the refurbished station in Castletownbere. He hopes in the light of what I said earlier that this much needed project in Doneraile will be started early in the new year.

Could the Minister name the date? Will it be in the first quarter of the year?

It will be early in the new year. In view of what the Deputy said about the urgency of the matter, I am sure it will be started as quickly as possible.

I want a definite date——

Please, Deputy, let us proceed with Deputy O'Dea's matter. The Deputy has had a good innings tonight.

Top
Share