Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 20 Oct 1999

Vol. 509 No. 5

Adjournment Debate. - Suicide Prevention Programme.

I thank the Leas-Cheann Comhairle for allowing me to raise this matter on the Adjournment and thank the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform for his presence at this late hour.

A remand prisoner hanged himself last Saturday afternoon in Mountjoy Prison. This tragic death took place despite a previous history of self-harm. The person was in the high risk group for suicide – he had had two drug overdoses in prison, one of which led to his being rushed to hospital. I sympathise with the victim's family and recognise that their hurt is most profound. In a suicide death there are special difficulties for the bereaved which are compounded by the circumstances of the young man's death. I also sympathise with the governor and prison staff. Suicide profoundly affects those who deal with the situation. We should recognise the personal trauma with which they are dealing and hope the necessary services are available to assist them to come to terms with their situation.

The number of suicides in prison is far too high. One is too many. I ask the Minister to outline to the House the suicide prevention programmes in place in our Prison Service. What training is given to staff in the implementation of such procedures? Are staff aware of the signs which should alert them to a person who is displaying suicidal feelings? Research in the United Kingdom estimated that the risk of suicide for prisoners was five times that of the general population. Is there a special understanding of the unique pressures on the prison population?

Will the Minister outline the way the needs of relatives of a prisoner who has committed suicide are handled after the trauma of the suicide itself? What treatment is available to prisoners suffering from mental illness, including depression? In California state prisons, psychiatric technicians were introduced into the prisons to deal with this important issue. It is estimated in California that one out of every 12 inmates suffers from serious mental illness. Are figures concerning Irish prisons available?

The psychiatric technicians in the state prisons in California function in various aspects of a new programme which they have introduced. It includes crisis intervention, mental health screening, patient assessment, implementing treatment programmes, supervising suicide risks, administering medication, maintaining medical records and quality assurance. Another function involves parole programmes which prepare inmates for productive lives after release.

The national task force on suicide published its recommendations in a report in January 1998. Perhaps the Minister will outline his response to the developments in regard to its recommendations. The report stated that the national task force on suicide was concerned about the level and organisation of mental health services provided in the prison system. It stated that there is a need to augment significantly existing provision of what could be considered the caring services in the prison environment, for example medical services, which include psychiatric and psychological services.

The task force endorsed the recommendations of the report of the advisory group on prison deaths published in August 1991. Perhaps the Minister would inform the House how his Department and the Prison Service have responded to that report. This group examined the level of suicide in Irish prisons and considered that a more positive and intensive approach to suicide prevention was required. The group made recommendations concerning the provision of medical, psychiatric, psychological, welfare and counselling services in prison. A number of recommendations in relation to the physical design of prisons and cells and the collection and analysis of prison data were made. In its report, the task force recommended to the Minister that the mentally ill in prison be given appropriate treatment in view of the marked association between drug abuse and both self-injury and death, including suicide in prison, that particular effort and resources be devoted, in conjunction with community strategies, to addressing the drug dependency problem of prisoners and that medical and caring services within prison be developed to a level equivalent to community services. It would be appreciated if the Minister would indicate the progress made in implementing in the prison service the recommendations contained in the report of the national task force on suicide.

I express my deep concern at any loss of life in the prisons and particularly death by suicide. Every such death is a tragedy, not just for the family, relatives and friends of the deceased but also for the Prison Service. I take this opportunity to extend my sincere sympathy to the family of the deceased. I know these sentiments have also been conveyed directly to the family by some of the most senior officials in the Prison Service, including the Director General, who spoke to a sister of the deceased, and one of the governors attached to Mountjoy Prison who also met with a member of the deceased man's family.

I have been briefed by the Director General of the Prison Service who is responsible for all operational matters in relation to places of custody. He has informed me that the deceased was committed on remand to Mountjoy Prison on 28 June 1999. He was placed on protection sharing a single cell by choice with another prisoner and was being kept under special observation every 15 minutes. On Saturday, 16 October at 3.45 p.m., he requested permission to use the toilet on the landing. Shortly afterwards an officer found him hanging from the ceiling in the toilet. He was immediately attended to by prison staff and medical orderlies who tried to revive him. An ambulance was called and he was taken to the Mater Hospital where he was pronounced dead at 4.35 p.m.

The Director General has informed me that he is satisfied, from the information in his possession at this juncture, that in the circumstances nothing more could have been done to prevent this tragic loss of life. In accordance with normal practice, this death will be the subject of a public inquiry in the form of a coroner's inquest. The circumstances of the death will also be examined by the suicide awareness group in Mountjoy Prison.

There are, of course, strategies in place for the prevention of suicide in each prison. However, unless there is to be a total denial of all personal privacy to all prisoners at all times, the possibility of suicide in custody cannot be prevented, no more than it can be prevented in the wider community.

The preventative measures currently in place to deter suicide are kept under continuous review. As I have already mentioned, the circumstances of each death in custody are examined by the suicide awareness group in each prison. The examinations carried out by these groups cover the background and circumstances of each death. Their objective is to identify, where possible, measures which might be taken in the future to contribute to the prevention of tragic deaths of this nature. This is an important mechanism for absorbing the lessons to be learned in each case.

There are also procedures in place for identifying and monitoring offenders at special risk. Such offenders are usually placed under special observation. However, we cannot escape the fact that where an offender is determined to take his or her life, and not infrequently there is no prior warning of any such intent, the scope for prevention is limited. Suicide is not a completely preventable act in a free society or in a prison system which accords any respect to the personal dignity and privacy of prisoners.

In May this year, my Department published the report of the national steering group on deaths in prisons. The group which was established under the chairmanship of a senior prison governor comprised representatives of various disciplines involved in the care of prisoners. They had been assigned the task of reviewing and overseeing the implementation of the recommendations of the advisory group on prison deaths published in 1991.

The group reported that there are good policies in place and a good level of awareness among prison staff in relation to suicide awareness. The group also reported that many possible deaths are saved by the alertness and vigilance of staff. Following the publication of its reports, I invited the group to continue to meet on a regular basis to provide a forum for collating the reports of the local suicide awareness groups within the institutions and to disseminate significant findings and lessons learned through the prison system. The group was also invited to organise an annual forum for the suicide awareness groups in each institution. I am informed by the Director General that the first such forum took place recently.

I hope, in conjunction with all concerned, that the Prison Service will continue to build on its existing policies aimed at suicide prevention. I can assure the Deputy that the Director General is similarly committed and that every effort will continue to be made in this regard.

In accordance with an order of the Dáil of yesterday, the Dáil stands adjourned until 2.30 p.m. on Tuesday, 2 November 1999.

The Dáil adjourned at 12.40 a.m. until 2.30 p.m. on Tuesday, 2 November 1999.

Top
Share