Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 8 Mar 2000

Vol. 516 No. 1

Adjournment Debate. - Hospital Waiting Lists.

Recognising that the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin, is a man of action I hope he will do something about Tralee Hospital. What is happening there is an absolute disgrace. I know it is not the Minister's fault but something has gone wrong with the level of staffing and resources. Last week we received the figures for public in-patient waiting lists. For example, from March 1997 to December 1999, the increase of those on the waiting list was 132%. It was 204% in 1997 and it has increased to 475%. The hospital is being forced to have such a long waiting list delay because it is under-resourced.

Recently, I wrote to Tralee Hospital concerning a woman who was having major difficulties with varicose veins, a common enough problem, which was affecting her work and mobility. I received this response from the surgeon in the hospital, which sums up the whole situation:

Dear Jimmy,

Thank you for the copy of your patient's letter and the GP's letter. I note that this lady has varicose veins. Unfortunately, this is a non-urgent condition and she is not likely to be seen in this hospital for five years. At present there are over 4,500 patients waiting to be seen in the surgical out-patients' clinic. Many of these have malignant conditions and we will not discover which of these have malignant conditions until we actually see them. As of today there are people waiting from 1992 to be seen in the hospital. At present the surgical out-patients' clinic is filled to capacity. We see more new patients in each surgical out-patients' clinic than any other surgical department in the country. Because of the continual refusal of the health board to provide us with sufficient staff and resources this situation is unlikely to change until the Southern Health Board and the Department of Health decides that it needs to be changed.

The Minister has a major responsibility as regards this situation. The Kerryman ran this article on its front page last week and there is major concern in the county about hospital waiting lists. People who have medical complaints are afraid that by the time they will be seen as public patients it will be too late for them. I have knowledge of an instance where a letter calling a woman to a medical appointment was sent to the person one year after she had died. I am afraid that by the time some people are called they will not be around because they will have passed on.

In its explanation to the Kerryman, the Southern Health Board disputed the figures for waiting lists, stating:

This arises because this list, which was built up over the past eight years, is currently being validated and many of the people on this list will have been seen either through the accident and emergency department in Tralee General Hospital, in another hospital or may no longer need treatment.

I agree with them on the latter point, because the people concerned are probably dead. The health board spokesman insisted that people on the list were non-urgent cases and that all urgent cases are seen immediately. That totally conflicts with what a reputable surgeon said in his response to me.

According to the Southern Health Board, Tralee General Hospital has two general surgeons who dealt with over 6,900 patients in their surgical out-patients' clinic in 1999. If they dealt with that number of people I cannot see how there could be such a waiting list. Obviously, therefore, that is not accurate.

There is a problem in Tralee Hospital and I would advise the Minister to visit the facility. The Minister is a man of action and I know he will take on the problem. Since 1997, the increase in the in-patients' waiting list at Cork University Hospital, for example, has been only 5% compared to 135% in Kerry. Obviously, there is not the same problem in Cork hospitals as in Kerry. We are being victimised because we are lumped in yet again with Cork for our medical services. Something is radically wrong.

I welcome the opportunity provided by Deputy Deenihan to discuss the current waiting list position at Tralee General Hospital. I wish to emphasise that I am conscious of the fact that the waiting times endured by many patients for access to acute hospital procedures are unacceptable. The multi-faceted nature of this problem was con sidered by the expert review group which reported to my predecessor in 1998. I am currently reviewing progress to date in the implementation of the wide ranging measures of a short, medium and longer term nature recommended in that report. In attaching a serious priority to tackling lengthy waiting lists and times, a number of practical steps can be taken to accelerate progress, including achieving more flexible use of available capacity and closer collaborative arrangements between the different parts of the system.

I have allocated a further £23.5 million to agencies under the waiting list initiative for the year 2000. This represents an increase of 17.5% over the £20 million allocated in 1999 and is almost three times the amount allocated by the previous Government in 1997. The Southern Health Board has this year receive £1,340 million in waiting list money which represents an increase of approximately 63% over 1999. In developing their service plans for 2000, agencies may include appropriate investment in aspects of out-patient services where they consider that the funding would help to address some of the underlying causes of unduly lengthy waiting lists. As part of this initiative Tralee General Hospital has appointed a third general surgeon who took up duty last month. This appointment is expected to have a significant impact in reducing both the in-patient and out-patient waiting lists for general surgery in the hospital.

I am confident that these developments, together with longer term measures associated with the investment of resources available under the NDP will achieve real progress in addressing the underlying causes of waiting lists and unacceptably long waiting times for certain specialities.

In relation to the waiting list position at Tralee General Hospital, I understand from the Southern Health Board that a validation process of the waiting list is currently under way at the hospital. Following the outcome of this validation process the hospital's primary objective will be to establish ways in which the quality of the out-patients' service to the public can be improved. In regard to the scheduling of hospital appointments, patients' GP referral letters are reviewed by the relevant consultant who classifies them into urgent, intermediate or routine. I have been advised by hospital management that urgent cases are seen at the consultant's next clinic.

I am confident that the substantial additional resources provided to the Southern Health Board under the waiting list initiative, coupled with the validation procedures and the appointment of the additional consultant, will show a marked improvement in the waiting list at Tralee General Hospital.

I can also assure the Deputy that when I do travel to Kerry I will call into Tralee General Hospital, as I have already indicated to the hospital authorities. I was due to do so two weeks ago but I could not. Hopefully in the next month or so I will be able to pay a visit there.

Top
Share