Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 8 Nov 2000

Vol. 525 No. 3

Ceisteanna–Questions. - Dublin-Monaghan Bombings.

Ruairí Quinn

Question:

12 Mr. Quinn asked the Taoiseach the progress made by the former Chief Justice, Mr. Liam Hamilton, in his investigation into the bombings in Dublin, Monaghan and Dundalk; when it is expected that his report will be available for consideration by an Oireachtas committee; if the co-operation of the British authorities has been sought in relation to the investigation; if he has satisfied himself with the level of co-operation offered; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [19844/00]

Joe Higgins

Question:

13 Mr. Higgins (Dublin West) asked the Taoiseach if he will report on the resignation of the former Chief Justice, Mr. Liam Hamilton, from the investigation into the Dublin and Monaghan bombings; the state at which the investigation now stands; and the plans he has to complete it. [21140/00]

John Bruton

Question:

14 Mr. J. Bruton asked the Taoiseach if he will make a statement on the appointment of the former Justice, Mr. Henry Barron, to lead the investigation into the Dublin and Monaghan bombings following the resignation of the former Chief Justice, Mr. Liam Hamilton. [22941/00]

Tony Gregory

Question:

15 Mr. Gregory asked the Taoiseach the implication for the completion of the investigation into the Dublin and Monaghan bombings arising from the resignation of the former Chief Justice, Mr. Liam Hamilton; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [22943/00]

I propose to take Questions Nos. 12 to 15, inclusive, together.

The independent inquiries conducted by the former Chief Justice, Mr. Liam Hamilton, continued through the summer months. I understand that Mr. Hamilton had advanced his examination considerably and had hoped to have his work concluded and his report prepared within a period of months.

Regrettably, on 29 September last, Mr. Hamilton informed me that he would be unable to continue with his inquiries for health reasons. Mr. Hamilton has undergone operative intervention which is being followed by a period of treatment. I thank Mr. Hamilton for taking on the task and for the tremendous commitment, dedication and hard work he brought to his inquiries. I convey to him my good wishes and those of the House for his full and speedy recovery.

The Government has now appointed the former Supreme Court judge, Henry Barron, to succeed Mr. Hamilton. On behalf of the Government, I thank Mr. Barron for agreeing to take on this task and I wish him well in his work.

With regard to the issue of assistance from other jurisdictions, when Mr Hamilton began his inquiries the Government conveyed to the British authorities that this examination had been put in place and our wish and expectation of co-operation from them, together with the likelihood that there would be more specific requests for their co-operation as the examination developed to the point where detailed requests could be formulated. This remains our expectation and Mr. Hamilton has not indicated that any difficulty has arisen in this regard.

I wish to be associated with the Taoiseach's remarks about the former Chief Justice, Liam Hamilton, and I wish him a full and speedy recovery. I thank him for the work he has undertaken.

Is the Taoiseach satisfied that the recently published work by Mr. Don Mullan on this outrage is a positive contribution towards the inquiry? Has the Taoiseach had any indication at this early stage from the former Justice, Mr. Barron, as to when he will be in a position to submit his preliminary report which, if I recall correctly, will be the basis on which a decision to have a full-blown inquiry will be taken?

Mr. Barron will require some time, possibly a few weeks, to familiarise himself with Mr. Hamilton's work in progress which is well documented. I hope at that stage we will have a firmer view of the task ahead. We will give him every assistance.

The book by Don Mullan and the work of the Justice for the Forgotten group have contributed effectively to the process. We assist them in every way to do that, including offices, facilities and finance. Unfortunately, we have been delayed by a few weeks, but I hope we will not lose too much time.

What is the approximate timetable?

Mr. Barron would rather he had the chance to read himself in first, but we will try not to lose any time, and we will keep the Justice for the Forgotten group and the House informed.

As it was intended that Mr. Hamilton's investigation would be completed by the end of this year and would have been referred to the appropriate Oireachtas committee, and given that the Taoiseach said he expects the report will be ready in a matter of weeks, although he did not specify a date, would it not be helpful to have an interim progress report for the Oireachtas committee if there is no completion date by January of next year, if only to allay the concerns of relatives and demonstrate that this matter has a degree of priority with the Government?

I will correct myself in case I did not make myself clear. I said Mr. Barron will require a period of weeks to read himself in. I did not say his report would be available in a period of weeks. When he has had that opportunity, he will inform us how long he believes it will take.

It is not for me to set a timescale for Mr. Barron. He is the sole member of an independent commission, is not obliged to report progress and does not report to me. Mr. Hamilton informed that he hoped to try to advance his work towards the end of the year. As in all cases such as this, one thing leads to another and Mr. Hamilton had progressed extensively on these matters through files and examinations and discussions with other jurisdictions. Rather than state a time limit on the record, I would rather state that I will keep the House informed of Mr. Barron's progress.

I wish Mr. Hamilton a speedy recovery. Will the Taoiseach bring us up to speed on the co-operation of the British authorities and the position on the possible taking of evidence from witnesses outside the jurisdiction? Is it intended that such witnesses will be examined by Mr. Barron? Had that been the intention of Mr. Hamilton?

I wish to be associated with the remarks about the former Chief Justice, Mr. Hamilton. I met him in Monaghan and he was certainly very dedicated. I wish Mr. Barron well.

Will the Taoiseach assure us that this will be dealt with urgently? It has been ongoing for a long time and people want to know if there will be a full inquiry or what will be needed. I am also interested to know if the full co-operation of those across the Border and in other jurisdictions is being received by those conducting this investigation. They demand it in one way and we should get it in another.

Does the Taoiseach accept that the relatives deserve a completion date and that it should be specified here? This has dragged on for a long time.

The Deputy has asked his question; the Taoiseach to reply.

The relatives would appreciate a completion date for this investigation.

I will pass on the remarks of Deputies to Mr. Hamilton on the work he has done. I am more interested in letting Mr. Barron get on with the job. I accept this has gone on for a long time, since May 1974, but this inquiry and its work began in February 2000. We want to see the work done correctly. Not wishing to speak for either Mr. Barron or Mr. Hamilton, I am sure both would like to see their work completed and handed over. They have no reason other than to see it completed as soon as possible. However, I do not want to set a time.

As regards Deputy Gregory's point about the Justice for the Forgotten group and the relatives, Mr. Hamilton met them and briefed them fully, even after his departure, because he wished to do that.

They are au fait with the position. Mr. Barron will also do that. They have an officer working with the system and that has been funded.

In reply to Deputy O'Keeffe, a group of the relatives and their legal advisers had a meeting with Mr. Adam Ingram to underscore the desire for full co-operation from the authorities in Northern Ireland. I know that during Mr. Hamilton's period there were no difficulties but they had that meeting to emphasise that they wanted that co-operation and I am sure it will continue.

Have they been so assured?

They have been assured of that.

Top
Share