Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 28 Mar 2001

Vol. 533 No. 4

Written Answers. - Overseas Missions.

Alan Shatter

Question:

72 Mr. Shatter asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs if it is the Government's policy to support the formation of a United Nations observer force to report on incidents of violence that occur between Israelis and Palestinians; the proposed terms of reference of such observer force; the proposed location of any such force; the discussions to date in which the Government has engaged concerning such proposals; and the role which he envisages the Defence Forces would play in any such force. [9156/01]

The Government is gravely concerned at the violence in Israel and the Palestinian territories. We condemn the latest wave of attacks against civilians and call for an end to all acts of terrorism. The international community can play an important role, in co-operation with the parties, in bringing this violence to an end.

Last December, a draft Security Council resolution which would have expressed the council's determination to establish a UN observer mission in the occupied territories failed to gain sufficient support. In light of the developments since, the Security Council returned to the issue and had a detailed debate starting on 15 March in which Ireland made its position on the violence and the urgent necessity to resume negotiations very clear to the council. During this debate, representatives of the non-aligned movement introduced a similar draft resolution with a view to the establishment of an observer mission to protect civilians from the violence in the occupied territories.

The view of many members of the Security Council, including Ireland, and also of the UN Secretary General, is that any effective presence of UN observers would require the agreement of both sides to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and that a UN mission may in the future be part of a comprehensive settlement.

Ireland has been very active in exploring the possibilities for the adoption of a resolution which could command unanimous support in the Security Council. We see it as essential to preserve the principle of consent of the parties. This is required where any mission is being established other than under the enforcement provisions of Chapter VII of the UN Charter. In the case under examination here, it is very difficult to see how a mission could operate without the co-operation of both sides.

France, Ireland, Norway and UK held intensive discussions with other members of the Security Council, including the non-aligned, in a sustained effort to agree a broader resolution which would deal constructively with the entirety of the situation on the ground and in the peace process. The broader resolution would have set out a number of measures to help bring an end to the current violence and permit the resumption of peace negotiations. It would have referred to the continuing violence, settlements, the closures, the vulnerability of the Palestinian economy and the need to resume peace negotiations.
A key aspect would have been a request to the UN Secretary General to consult the parties on early steps to implement these measures as well as on setting up a mechanism to contribute to the protection of civilians and to report to the Security Council within one month.
In the event, consensus on a comprehensive resolution on the entire situation in the peace process did not prove possible on this occasion. We regret that this proved to be the case, particularly in view of the intensive nature of the discussions in the Security Council since 15 March and how close the council came to agreeing such a resolution, a step that would have marked concrete, practical progress.
As a member of the Security Council, Ireland will continue to urge all parties to agree on practical and useful steps to overcome the real problems obstructing the peace process.
The role which the Defence Forces might play in any such mission, if it is agreed at some future date, will be a matter for consideration at the appropriate time.
Top
Share