Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Thursday, 23 Oct 2003

Vol. 573 No. 2

Adjournment Debate. - Hospital Services.

I thank the Chair for giving me the opportunity to raise this matter on the Adjournment. I urge the Minister for Health and Children to approve an allocation of €3.2 million for the South-Eastern Health Board to permit the opening of the new surgical unit at St. Joseph's Hospital, Clonmel. I hope the Minister of State will be in a position to give us some good news in the matter, the background to which is the fact that acute surgical services in south Tipperary have been divided for many years between Our Lady's Hospital, Cashel, which provides surgical services and St. Joseph's Hospital, Clonmel, which has traditionally provided medical and maternity services. Many difficulties were encountered in the division of services. Even the best efforts of staff meant a less than adequate service was available to patients for many years.

Approximately ten years ago there was a decision and an agreement to amalgamate all of the acute surgical services on the campus at St. Joseph's Hospital. Following seven or eight frustrating years, the facilities for the transfer of the services were in place at the hospital and ready for occupation from 31 March 2003. The facilities available include an accident and emergency department, a CSSD unit, 39 surgical beds, three operating theatres, an intensive care unit, a day care unit, including a dedicated endoscopy suite, a cardiac rehabilitation unit, a CT unit, a medical ward, a coronary step-down unit, a medical assessment unit and a library and education centre. This development cost in the region of €25 million to €30 million. It has been a long drawn out process which has frustrated staff and patients alike in both hospitals and throughout County Tipperary.

The position is that while the facilities are available and ready for occupation, they remain empty due to the fact that the Department has not approved funding for their staffing. They have been available for occupation since March. The South-Eastern Health Board met staff and agreed staffing levels which have been pared to the bone. It has forwarded a request to the Department for a sum of €3.2 million to enable this development which is urgently needed to continue. The facilities for patients will be adequate and of an acceptable standard. The difficulties arising from a patient point of view, where surgical patients at Cashel with an underlying medical difficulty have to be transferred to Clonmel and medical patients at Clonmel with an underlying surgical difficulty have to be transferred to Cashel, will come to an end, as will the associated dangers for the health and lives of patients. This will happen only if the Department funds the development and the opening of these facilities.

Hospital staff were informed earlier in the year that the facilities would be opened at the end of March. They were later informed that they would open in June and then in September but all to no avail. I ask the Department to approve immediately the provision of funding to staff the facilities and allow them to open. This will have knock-on effects for the Cashel site in the sense that staff will be necessary for a significant development being undertaken there. I ask the Minister to approve the allocation of €3.2 million requested by the South-Eastern Health Board.

I am replying on behalf of the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin.

I avail of the opportunity to set out the position on the development of hospital services at St. Joseph's Hospital, Clonmel. The Deputy is well aware that the provision of hospital services for south Tipperary is a matter for the South-Eastern Health Board. The south Tipperary hospital agreement signed in January 1996, paved the way for development of hospital services in the region and the bringing together of surgery and medicine on a single site. The Deputy outlined the relevant developments in the course of his contribution.

A major capital development programme to provide the infrastructure to facilitate the transfer of surgical services from Our Lady's Hospital, Cashel, to St. Joseph's Hospital, Clonmel, was undertaken. The building work is now complete. This landmark development, which has to date cost in the region of €30 million, involves the provision of a new accident and emergency department, ward accommodation, operating theatres , an intensive care unit, a day care unit, a central sterile supplies department, a physical medicine department, an education centre and consulting rooms. Following the transfer of the surgical services, Our Lady's Hospital will be used to provide services for the elderly and also services for those with mental and physical disabilities.

In this context the Minister for Health and Children gave approval to the South-Eastern Health Board last year to proceed with the building of the first phase of the new capital development at Our Lady's Hospital, Cashel. The estimated overall capital investment for the first phase of this development is in the region of €12 million and will provide the following facilities on the site: A 20-bed elderly mentally infirm unit; a 12-place supervised hostel for mental health services; 12 independent living units or respite care places for persons with physical disability; a day hospital or day centre for mental health services and a day centre for persons with physical disabilities.

The Cashel project, together with the major construction project completed at St. Joseph's Hospital, Clonmel, represents a significant capital investment for the development of health services in south Tipperary. Deputy Healy acknowledged that in his contribution. This investment is an indication of this Government's commitment to the provision of optimum health care facilities to the people of the region.

Last week St. Joseph's Hospital celebrated the 150th anniversary of its foundation and these celebrations coincided with the official opening of a number of new facilities at the hospital. These included a coronary care step-down unit, a medical emergency and assessment unit, a new 35-bed medical ward, a cardiac rehabilitation unit and a CT department and library-education centre.

The integration of acute services on one site will greatly enhance the services available to patients in the region. The Minister for Health and Children stated that he is fully committed to achieving this objective in as timely a manner as possible. The South-Eastern Health Board has sought significant resources to complete the transfer. Deputy Healy mentioned a staffing allocation figure of €3.2 million. This allocation is not of a capital character but represents a permanent increase in the current expenditure at the hospital.

The board has been asked to finalise its discussions with staff to identify the numbers that will transfer. It has also been asked to identify the level of services that can be provided at St. Joseph's Hospital within existing resources.

The overall objective of the capital developments at Clonmel and Cashel is to ensure that the services available to the people of south Tipperary respond to their needs.

The Dáil adjourned at 5.20 p.m. until 2.30 p.m. on Tuesday, 4 November 2003.

Top
Share