Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 20 May 1992

Vol. 132 No. 12

Adjournment Matters. - Conflict in Thailand.

I welcome the Minister to the House and congratulate him on his appointment as Minister for Foreign Affairs. Like everybody else I was delighted to see him becoming Minister.

One of the reasons I put down this motion is that some years ago I lived in Thailand for approximately nine months. I have a special regard for Thailand and its people; you could not meet nicer or more friendly people anywhere. The events over the past few days were tragic and, hopefully, the situation will not deteriorate.

Over the years a military type officer class has grown up in Thai society. There have been, approximately, 17 military coups since 1932. The aim of this military class is to get their hands on power and they do not like anything that might disturb the cosy arrangement which has been in place since, approximately, 1932. Because Thailand has changed dramatically in economic terms over the years, it is now one of the more successful countries in that part of the world. In fact, it is one of the few countries in that area that has been a huge exporter of food for many years. That has always been to its advantage because of the food shortage in so many other countries.

Because the country has grown economically, the middle class people are demanding a normal democratic system of government to try to develop the country on an economic and social basis. For example, in a recent election more than 50 per cent of the people voted, whereas normally approximately 30 per cent cast their vote. The country is changing and there is huge support for change in Thailand at present. This afternoon I spoke with some friends, one of them an Irish person, who live there and they told me there is great support from all people in Thailand, for change and especially for the former Governor of Bangkok, Mr. Scrimuang who is well respected and showed he is free of corruption which, unfortunately, has been almost a way of life for certain politicians and military officers in Thailand.

There is great concern at the indiscriminate shooting of citizens in Bangkok and other parts of Thailand. There is a TV and radio black-out at present and I gather this evening that some units of the Army are now approaching Bangkok. There is a great fear that this could lead to direct clashes between the ruling military people in Bangkok and other forces who do not go along with their policies. This could have serious consequences for the people of Bangkok.

The Government, in conjunction with the EC partners, should take a stand against the military governors in Thailand. This conflict is having a huge effect on the tourism industry in Thailand. I believe tourists are not being allowed into the country for obvious reasons and that the tourists there at present cannot leave. As part of our role in the EC, Ireland and the Minister should take a stand against what is going on and economic sanctions should be imposed against the military officers in Thailand to show them that the action they have taken in the past few days is totally unacceptable.

The people of Thailand want a democratic system and that is obvious from the numbers who have been out on the streets protesting over the past few days. We should give a lead here with our extra power in the European Community and tell the military people in Thailand that what they are doing is unacceptable and that everybody wants to see a democratic system restored once again in that country. It is bizarre that an unelected general can be elected Prime Minister but I believe that happened because people are nominated to the Senate in Thailand. They can elect a Prime Minister with the MPs.

They would never get away with that here.

They would not. They twisted things around and they now have an unacceptable situation. Therefore, I ask the Minister to do whatever he can to convey the feelings of his partners in Europe to the ruling junta in Thailand.

I am grateful to Senator Ryan for his remarks in welcoming me to this august body for which I have the greatest respect. This is not my first occasion to be here as Minister for Foreign Affairs.

I would like to distinguish my period in the Department of Foreign Affairs in the area of human rights whether on this island — which needs to be addressed from time to time — or human rights elsewhere in the world. I would like to think that my term of office would be seen as an effort by Ireland to address the abuse of human rights of whatever kind anywhere in the world.

I am glad of this opportunity to address the Seanad on the tragic developments that have taken place in Thailand over the past number of days. I express my appreciation to Senator Ryan for his concern in raising the matter. In his short term as a Member of the Seanad he has a distinguished record in the area of human rights and his concern in relation to this issue is consistent with that record.

We were all shocked at the television pictures and the other widespread reports of the Thai army's brutal and violent suppression of the protesters in Bangkok who were calling for the resignation of General Suchinda from the office of Prime Minister. Full details of the numbers of protesters killed and injured in the violence are not yet available but preliminary reports indicate that up to 500 people may have been killed, many of these reportedly shot by the Army, and hundreds more injured. This brutal military response to legitimate and peaceful protest is unacceptable in any modern society.

Ireland and our partners in the European Community have today issued a statement expressing our great concern at the recent tragic events in Thailand. I accept that statements are no substitute for action, nevertheless, it is a strong and worthwhile statement and while it will not, necessarily produce a magic formula to stop the military junta in Thailand from oppressing the people there, it is an indication of the Community's concern for this serious and savage abuse of human rights. Ireland fully supports this statement by the Twelve.

We condemn the use of force by the military forces against unarmed civilians. We urge the Thai authorities to refrain from further violence and appeal for maximum restraint by all parties involved in the events. We wish to see an end to the bloodshed and an early return to a normal situation. We also call for a peaceful and democratic solution to the problems in Thailand as well as full respect for human rights, for which Senator Ryan rightly called. Only a democratic Thailand, respecting fully human rights norms, can play a constructive role and contribute to the peace and stability of the Asia-Pacific region.

In view of the present situation my Department are advising intending Irish visitors to Thailand to postpone their travel plans until such time as the situation there returns to normal. We are, of course, in touch with our Community partners regarding developments in Thailand. Like Senator Ryan who worked there for nine months, I, too, have been there on a number of occasions. It is a magnificant country. Bangkok is a beautiful city and the people are particularly gentle and hard-working in every respect and it is tragic to see what is happening to them at present.

Thailand has made remarkable economic progress over the past decade, moving rapidly from a largely rural society to an increasingly urbanised and industralised one. However, the political system, largely based on military influence, has not developed to meet the aspirations of the people. The social transformation of Thai society has produced a politically more sophisticated middle class who are no longer satisfied with the existing political structures and are demanding a more responsive democratic government.

A general election was held in Thailand in March and the coalition that came to power requested General Suchinda, who had not stood for election and was not, therefore, a member of parliament, to become Prime Minister. The General's acceptance of this offer gave rise to widespread public demands for a democratically elected Prime Minister. The fact that General Suchinda had stated in 1991, after he had led a coup against the previous government, that he did not wish to become Prime Minister fuelled public disenchantment with the existing power structures. The recent widespread public demands for political change found a focus in the person of the former Governor of Bangkok, Chamlong Srimuang, a devout Buddhist, who has long demanded that the army leave politics to civilians. Mr. Chamlong has now been detained by the military. We hope that the Thai authorities will release him immediately.

Reports today indicate that the situation in Bangkok remains tense. Disturbances have been confined to the government office area and to the university in the east of the city. Businesses and schools remain closed and hotel guests are being advised to stay off the streets. Thai authorities, in reaction to the international outcry over this week's tragic events, may be considering taking the soldiers off the streets. I am sure all in this House would welcome such a move as a first step in defusing tension in the city. Reports from Bangkok indicate that the business community is deeply concerned and angry at the effect this week's events are having on the economy and are acting as a powerful lobby to find a solution quickly.

We shall continue to follow developments in Thailand with the greatest attention. I hope that the responsible Thai leaders will ensure that this tragic situation is brought to end and that the Thai people's democratic wishes are fully respected.

Again, I want to express my deep appreciation to Senator Ryan for raising this matter. Issues of this nature are not raised often enough and I hope I will be in the Seanad from time to time, not necessarily on issues of this nature, but on issues pertaining to the Department of Foreign Affairs. I am grateful to you, a Chathaoirligh, for your kindness and courtesy and to the House for its attention.

I thank the Minister for his comprehensive reply, it is much appreciated.

We will move on to Matters of Concern to Members under Standing Order 29 (a). As Members know, these questions will be of two minutes duration.

Top
Share