Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Thursday, 17 Dec 1992

Vol. 134 No. 11

Adjournment Matter. - EC Funding for Education.

Before we adjourn I, too, would like to be associated with those words. On the Order of Business earlier today I congratulated Deputy Pádraig Flynn on his elevation to the post of European Commissioner. As a fellow teacher and INTO member, I am delighted that he has been promoted and hope that his experience as a primary teacher in the west and INTO member will stand him in good stead when he comes to deal with the Eurocrats and the Europeans, generally. I also hope that the primary education sector will receive attention from the European Commission.

Education is excluded from the Treaty of Rome but, for me, the most progressive and positive development in relation to the Maastricht Treaty is that for the first time education is included. I also note that last week at Edinburgh the way was opened for new funding arrangements in relation to the Structural and Cohesion Funds.

A document from the OECD, which was published in September of this year, clearly outlined the problems in relation to funding at primary level and established a number of facts beyond yea or nay. First, within Ireland the primary sector receives less funding than any other sector of education and on a pro rata basis less money is spent on primary education in this country than in any other country in the OECD. In addition, we have the largest classes and the least amount of resources and funding.

The reason I raise this matter today is that I would like the Government to take an interest in it. The Minister of State has always taken an interest in education matters but I would like the Government to take a real interest at this stage. It is a little known fact that the primary sector is the only sector which has never received any European funding. All the other sectors, including the regional technical colleges and second level education have received funding.

At this stage most of the Commissioners have been assigned their portfolios and know what their job is going to be. This is an open secret in Brussels. I was in touch with a number of people in Brussels today to confirm this. What is left at this stage? Two major portfolios are still available for the Irish Commissioner — the Regional Affairs and Social Affairs directorates. If our Commissioner is not given one of these all that will remain is what is termed a "rag bag" or "mixed bag" of lesser portfolios.

I am asking the Minister for Education to highlight the needs and primary sector in Brussels and I am asking the Government to make an initial move and move immediately and use its influence to endure that the Irish Commissioner is given the social affairs portfolio. The Minister for Education should convince the Government that there is need for it to use its influnece to ensure the Irish Commissioner is given the education portfolio. It would be particularly appropriate on this occasion that an educationist be given the social affairs portfolio given that for the first time the Commissioner for social affairs will have responsibility for education.

The Cohesion Fund was set up to ensure that levels of support were equalised in European countries. It is quite clear that this fund could be used to great effect in disadvantaged areas in Ireland and should be extended to include the education sector which is the main point of intervention in dealing with the underprivileged.

I have written to the new Irish Commissioner this afternoon seeking a meeting with him and his new staff in Brussels at the earliest possible date in January. At that meeting I intend to make a number of proposals. Among other things I intend to propose that a pilot scheme for the introduction of modern languages into our primary schools should be established; that a comprehensive literacy programme, involving the creation of literacy projects and extra remedial posts, be introduced; the introduction of in-service training and education for teachers; that we respond to the needs of those from under-privileged backgrounds in relation to education, that a building plan be drawn up to ensure that schools throughout the country have a general purposes room and that the caretaker and clerk-typist schemes be extended to all primary schools.

These are all practical steps and when I meet the Commissioner I intend to price them and ensure that the Structural and Cohesion Funds are extended to include education. Some of these are already included but in the case of others a liberal interpretation would be required on the part of people in Brussels to ensure that they are included but it is important that we note at this point that at their meeting at Edinburgh last week the Heads of Government made a commitment to education.

For the past 40 years Brussels has been dealing with the question of training, not education. In more recent times, however, it has begun to deal with the regional technical colleges and other areas and has an interface with both third level and second level education. Nobody has experience of being in charge of developing a primary education programme. Europe is inexperienced in making decisions in the area of primary education. For that reason, recognising that it is completely outside the experience of DG5 — the directorate dealing with social affairs, human resources and education — I would ask the Minister to request the Government to ensure that we press for the immediate establishment of a European advisory commission on primary education.

The Government should also insist that the Commission applies itself to determining a common education policy on those aspects of primary education in which member states have a common interest. It was never intended by anyone in Brussels that Europe would make decisions on education, but there is an intention there to develop co-operation. Therefore we should identify the areas of common interest for primary education and establish a common education policy in those areas. The last time I spoke on this matter I suggested that if we are doing away with the Common Agricultural Policy we should introduce a CEP, a common education policy.

I have covered most of the items I wished to refer to. I would make it quite clear that the funds are there and the Government should ensure that some of that funding goes to primary education. I am asking for the setting up of a European primary education advisory committee and a common education policy as well as the channelling of finance from the Structural and Cohesion Funds to primary education. I congratulate Deputy Flynn on his appointment as Commissioner. I would ask that primary education be given consideration after decades of neglect, having been identified nationally and internationally as the only sector in education which has never received European funding. That sector now deserves support and I would ask the Minister to respond in a positive way.

At the outset I would pay a special tribute to Senator O'Toole on his very fine debate on this matter. I also pay a special tribute to and congratulate my Government colleague and friend, Deputy Pádraig Flynn, on his appointment as the forthcoming European Commissioner for Ireland. I wish him every success and congratulate himself, his family and indeed his country. I think we will all be pleased with his appointment. He will bring to the job a fine intellect. He has a great record of parliamentary and political service to Ireland. I am confident he will follow in the footsteps of previous Commissioners, most notably the immediate outgoing Commissioner, Mr. MacSharry, who has made a great contribution to our country, to Europe and to world affairs. I wish Deputy Flynn every success in his new post.

Ireland was one of the originators of the proposals to have a specific Education Article in the Maastricht Treaty, Article 126. The Treaty provides for Community assistance for the development of quality education by encouraging co-operation between member states. The main areas targeted for action in the article are the European dimension in education, particularly language teaching student and teacher mobility and academic recognition of diplomas and periods of study, co-operation between education establishments, youth exchanges and exchanges of instructors and information and distance education.

Under the existing round of Structural Funds substantial support is received for the education system from the European Social Fund for vocational training and from the European Regional Development Fund for third level infrastructure. The 1992 commitment of aid is of the order of £143 million.

As Senators are aware a substantial increase in Structural funds has been agreed for the new round starting in 1994, with the addition of a Cohesion Fund for projects in the field of environment and trans-European transport networks. It is not envisaged that the education system will benefit from the Cohesion Fund, but the Minister for Education, Deputy Séamus Brennan, has prepared a range of proposals seeking assistance from both the European Social Fund and the European Regional Development Fund within a strategy to achieve greater economic and social cohesion in the coming years.

The key national objective in the new round of Structural Funds will be to seek support for activity which increases the rate of growth of the economy and expands self-sustaining employment. Within this strategy, the aim of the education sector will be to establish greater equity in education particularly of those who are economically or socially disadvantaged, and to broaden the system so as to equip students more effectively for life, for work in an enterprise culture and for citizenship of Europe.

The plans for the education sector focus on a strengthening of vocational training in the science, technology, business and language fields in the third level sector, including increased access to training for those already employed in industry; a major upgrading of education/training infrastructure to enhance the capacity of institutions to provide research and development support and a highly skilled workforce to meet the needs of industry; an expansion of second-chance education and training activity for the long term unemployed; an enhancement of programmes for unqualified early school leavers, allied with a continued investment in intervention measures to tackle disadvantage within the school system; a strengthening of the vocational dimension in senior cycle education through the expansion and further development of the leaving certificate vocational programme offering subjects orientated towards science, technology, enterprise and languages and incorporating work experience in the chosen disciplines; a restructuring of VPT-2 post-leaving certificate course to provide a common form of nationally recognised certification and provision for progression of high achievers to third level, with the thrust of vocational training, moving towards a dual system in which employers play a much greater role, and a comprehensive training of trainers programme in support of these initiatives.

I should like to stress that what I have outlined are the education sector's proposals for support in the new round. Consultations with the social partners, with Government Departments and agencies and with regional advisory groups on the finalisation of the new Development Plan for Ireland are still under way and no decisions have yet been made as to the proposals which will finally be included in the new Community support framework to be negotiated with the EC for Ireland. However, I am confident that the education measures, which are consistent with the policy approach for education outlined in the Green Paper, Education for a Changing World and with those of the Culliton report, will be given a high priority in the plans to promote growth in our economy.

The Department of Education is now the single largest Irish beneficiary under the European Social Fund. This funding is continued by EC regulation to specific vocational education and training measures and recruitment and employment subsidies. ESF funding has not been provided for primary education. The House should be aware that the fund was established under Article 123 of the Treaty of Rome, with the "task of rendering the employment of workers easier and of increasing their geographical and occupational mobility within the Community."

The House will appreciate from what I have said that the Government will seek to ensure that the relevant Structural Funds will contribute to the achievement of our priorities as outlined in the Green Paper for the development of an equitable and effective education and training system.

Finally, I concur with the sentiments expressed by Senator O'Toole in his demands for extra resources for the primary sector. As a parent who has been involved in the primary sector and who has family connections with that sector, as one who represents the public in my constituency and as Minister of State with an interest in education, I readily accept the need for a review of the whole primary sector and with giving priority to funding that sector so as to ensure that it keeps pace with the developments that have taken place at second and third level. I commend Senator O'Toole and the House for their interest in this debate. I wish Senator O'Toole every success in his future discussions and dialogue with the new Commissioner and his officials.

Finally, I sincerely thank you, a Leas-Chathaoirligh, also the Clerk of the Seanad and the staff of both the Dáil and Seanad for their co-operation during the past year. I wish them a very happy and holy Christmas, a peaceful and prosperous New Year and every success in the years ahead.

Mo mhíle buíochas do na Seanadóirí uilig. Guím Nollaig faoi shéan agus athbhliain rathúil dóibh go léir.

An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Before I declare the House adjourned I want to put on record my good wishes to all the Senators who will be seeking re-election. I wish them every success. I record my thanks to Senators for their courtesy and co-operation with me during the life of this Seanad. To the Clerk, the Clerk Assistant and all the other staff of the House I wish to extend sincere thanks to them for their co-operation, courtesy and kindness over the last three and a half years. I also thank those Ministers who came to this House for their co-operation. I will conclude by wishing everybody a very happy Christmas and prosperous New Year.

The Seanad adjourned sine die.

Top
Share