Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 24 Oct 2007

Vol. 187 No. 10

Rail Services.

As a Member from County Donegal, I seek a direct train service from Dublin to Derry, which potentially might continue into County Donegal. I do so because neither air access nor the welcome improvements to road access are sufficient and rail access is also required. While it might have been difficult to achieve this in the past, this is no longer the case. Formerly, trains from Derry terminated in Belfast's York Street station while those from Dublin terminated in Belfast Central Station. However, as there is now a bridge linking the stations, there is no physical reason to prevent a direct Dublin to Derry train service.

I accompanied the Into the West rail lobby to Stormont last Thursday and the First Minister, Ian Paisley, was also present. He spoke lovingly about his train trips in the past from Ballymena to Portrush. I wish to underline the issue from the perspective of Into the West's founder, Eamonn McCann, who is well known in Derry. A decision by the Department for Regional Development on whether to approve a railway spending plan that does not include money for the Coleraine to Derry route in the second investment strategy for Northern Ireland is now imminent. The lobby group seeks a plan that does include money for the Coleraine to Derry line to prevent it from falling even further behind the rest of the network. If this is not achieved now, the upgrade of the line will be postponed until 2010 or 2012, by which time it will be too late.

There is a long-term vision for a modern all-Ireland rail network that will serve the north west as well as other regions. However, unless the immediate demand is achieved, such long-term aspirations will become academic. The 55 miles of train track from Ballymena to Derry is now the worst section of track in Ireland. The track's deterioration has been accelerated due to the tonnage of the new 150-tonne trains. While one department complains the new trains are damaging the track, the mechanical department complains that the poor state of the track is damaging the new trains and decreasing their longevity.

The Into the West group has suggested the solution to both problems would be to weld the track and remove the outdated jointed track. There are three densities of rail, namely, 70 lbs., 90 lbs. and 113 lbs., which are calculated on a weight per yard basis. The existing jointed rail track is mostly 70 lbs. and has a shorter lifespan than the 113 lbs. rail. Depending on funding, the company has plans to weld the existing 70 lbs. rail under a life extension plan and asserts this should prolong its life. However, the Into the West group believes this to be a false economy. An expenditure of £60 million now would deliver 98 mph track, which would reduce journey times from Derry to Belfast to 90 minutes. This would get rid of the aforementioned false economy.

It was announced last Thursday that £12 million will be spent on the Ballymena to Coleraine section of the line. While undoubtedly this will help improve a section of the track, the investment that is badly needed and which has not been forthcoming is that from Coleraine to Derry. The provision of passing lanes and the upgrade of the existing track are required.

One might ask what this has to do with us in the South. This line serves the north west as much as would any other form of access. People from the region continually call out for more investment in tourism and jobs. The mantra when buying a house is, "location, location, location" and when trying to sell a region, it is, "access, access, access". New trains have been deployed on this route and usage has increased by 60% since 2001. There is an economic argument for investing in this line. The State has taken a role in respect of the Belfast to Dublin Enterprise train service. Tonight, I seek clarification as to whether there is an impediment to designating it as the Dublin to Derry service instead. If the State was able to secure European funding for the Dublin to Belfast Enterprise train service, there is no reason not to rename the route the Dublin to Derry service. One could make use of the existing track, the new trains that run on it and the real economy. Moreover, one could cite the argument regarding the false economies involved in doing patch-up jobs to which one must revert continually.

I ask the Minister of State to ask the Minister for Transport, Deputy Noel Dempsey, who is not present this evening, to consider the findings of the recent report on this matter. While there have been decades of neglect, it is being reversed and there have been line speed upgrades and more trains as a result of providing passing points. It would be useful if such improvements could effected on the Derry to Belfast route and on the section between Derry and Coleraine in particular, as there will be an investment of £12 million from Coleraine to Ballymena.

The Minister has his own connections to this region and while I do not suggest he should take a personal interest in this matter, it is highly important to the people of the north west. I hope the work that has been done on the western rail corridor in respect of bringing rail services to County Donegal will ultimately yield a high quality all-Ireland rail service. However, my immediate concern pertains to the issue under discussion. I can discern no reason to prevent the establishment of a Dublin to Derry train service. The Minister of State should either give me an answer this evening or ensure that the Minister for Transport responds with reasons the State cannot make such an investment and designate it a Dublin to Derry, rather than a Dublin to Belfast, service, which would provide the people of the north west with a service they badly need and deserve.

The Minister for Transport is aware of Senator Keaveney's sustained efforts to improve transport links in the north west, including Derry. The Minister for Transport will raise the matters she has brought up in this House with the Minister for Regional Development in Northern Ireland.

However, Transport 21, which is the medium-term investment framework for transport, does not provide for a direct Dublin to Derry rail link. Our resources for rail investment under Transport 21 are focused on the implementation of the railway safety programme, the complete transformation of rolling stock and projects such as the western rail corridor, the Cork-Midleton link, the Navan link, the Kildare route upgrade project and the interconnector in Dublin.

Currently, rail services to Derry are available via Belfast. The Minister for Transport understands this service is being considered by the Northern Ireland authorities in the context of overall plans for the development of Northern Ireland's railways. Both larnród Éireann and Northern Ireland Railways are also working on proposals to improve the Dublin-Belfast service in terms of service frequency and journey times. The North-South Ministerial Council will consider this matter again at its December meeting.

In considering the case for a direct Dublin-Derry rail link, it is important to bear in mind the improvements that have been made in transport links generally to the north west. In recent years major upgrades of roads serving the north west, such as the N2, N4 and N15, have been completed. Substantial support is also being provided for air services between Dublin and Derry and between Dublin and Donegal Airport. These links are supplemented by hourly bus services between Dublin and Derry, including nine daily services each way operated by Bus Éireann. Senators will also be aware of the Government's intention to make available a contribution of £400 million sterling, which amounts to €580 million, to help fund major road projects in Northern Ireland and in particular to upgrade the route serving the north-west gateway to dual carriageway standard. The Northern Ireland Executive has confirmed its acceptance of this funding. At its meeting on 14 September, the North-South Ministerial Council agreed on the management structure for the project and to the early appointment of consultants to enable a route corridor study for the project to commence. The management structure is now in place and arrangements to procure the consultants are proceeding.

Investment under Transport 21 will result in further improvements in the transport infrastructure serving the north west, including the Atlantic road corridor, which will link the Derry-Letterkenny region to Cork and Waterford. In recognition of the need to move quickly ahead with this corridor, the national development plan provided for the acceleration of funding for the N18 Crusheen-Gort and Gort-Oranmore schemes. Both schemes will now commence in 2008. Between them, they will provide a total of about 50 kilometres of high quality dual carriageway, forming an important artery in the west of the country.

Good progress is being made, therefore, in improving transport links with Derry and with the north west generally. This must be taken into account in considering proposals for a direct Dublin-Derry rail link. I thank the Senator for her contribution and will bring her comments to the attention of the Minister.

Top
Share