Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 21 Oct 2009

Vol. 197 No. 7

Inland Fisheries.

I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Seán Haughey. I had the opportunity of speaking to the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Deputy Eamon Ryan, on this matter when he was in the House.

I call on the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources to instruct the Shannon Regional Fisheries Board to remove the necessity to purchase permits under the auspices of the midland fisheries group, for coarse and pike angling in respect of the Rivers Suck, Inny, Brosna, Little Brosna and Camlin.

This is the only board to impose such charges and this has made it very difficult for people in our area. I live in Castlecoote, County Roscommon. An adult annual fishing permit costs €37; a pensioner annual permit costs €19; a juvenile annual permit costs €13; an adult one-day permit costs €11; a juvenile one-day permit costs €2 and a 21-day permit costs €19. However, 12 km or more away from that area there is no charge. This is an anomaly which I ask the Minister and the Government to examine. I accept that as a result of amalgamation there will be just one fisheries board from next December but in the meantime we want to ensure the Shannon Regional Fisheries Board is directed to dispense with these charges which mean that visiting fishermen and anglers do not come to the rivers in our area.

I do not understand the reason the chief executive of the board has introduced this permit system. The Minister of State is aware of the difficulties we encountered with regard to the trout fishing licence some years ago. One member of the board was involved in an extensive campaign in the 1989 general election in opposition to that particular proposal. This charge was nevertheless imposed on fishermen in our area.

I come from Castlecoote, County Roscommon through which flows the River Suck. The Derryhippo river flows through my family farm into an adjoining lake. In order to fish on the waters flowing through our land we require a permit. It is as bad as in the days of the landlords when permits and rights were needed to fish on the rivers. All our rivers now run free but they certainly do not run free in Castlecoote and that area. In the circumstances I ask the Minister of State to convey to the Minister our concerns in this regard.

Recently, my daughter, Councillor Orla Leyden, and committee members of the international fishing festival which also caters for people with disabilities, ran a fishing competition in Ballinapark on Stoneham's lake. Some concessions were made but generally speaking, the journalists who came from the Netherlands and Germany noted that these charges were being imposed. A level playing pitch is required so everyone is treated equally. I question how one can fish in the River Shannon and not be charged for doing so.

Mr. Geoff Cooper is a countryside journalist from Kilglass, County Roscommon and he has provided me with details in this regard. People were stopped and licences and permits were demanded. I know of instances where anglers have been forced to leave the River Suck and they left the country ahead of time because they were so dismayed with their treatment. I realise that the rod licence covers more than 20 venues and that only five are open to coarse anglers. My request of the Minister is straightforward. I am unsure what powers there are to enforce this position but the Minister should call on the officials of the Department to issue a directive to have this charge removed in advance of the amalgamation of the fishing organisations.

I take this Adjournment matter on behalf of my colleague, the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources. Primary responsibility for the management, conservation, protection and development of inland fisheries stocks rests with the central and regional fisheries boards in accordance with the Fisheries Acts 1959 to 2007. The Acts empower the regional fisheries boards to apply a permit charge for angling on fisheries under their control. The application of such a permit charge is a day-to-day operational matter for the relevant board, in this instance the Shannon Regional Fisheries Board. Within its region, the Shannon board controls 27 fisheries which are collectively known as the midland fisheries group and these include the River Suck, River Inny, River Brosna, Little Brosna river and Camilin river. While a number of these fisheries are better known as trout waters, others are renowned for the quality of the coarse and pike angling they offer.

It is normal practice within Ireland and throughout Europe for fishery owners, angling clubs and fisheries boards to charge an angling permit fee on waters they control. I am advised by the Shannon board that, as with its predecessor the Inland Fisheries Trust, it has imposed a permit charge for trout angling for more than 50 years on fisheries under its control. I understand the board, in reviewing its management and the fees charged for its fisheries in 2002, decided to extend the permit charges to cover coarse angling on the board-controlled fisheries. This was done on the basis that it was unfair to charge one angler to fish for one species while another angler fishing for a different species on the same water was not charged, yet all benefit from investment made in the fisheries.

As can be appreciated, the cost of managing these fisheries has greatly increased over the years. The board was of the view that coarse anglers who utilise the fisheries should contribute to the cost of conservation and protection of stocks as well as the upkeep of the coarse fisheries. A permit entitles the holder to fish in any of the 27 fisheries. The cost of an annual permit is €39 while a tourist angler is required to pay €20 for a 21-day permit. Amounting to less than €1 per day a tourist angler permit is clearly excellent value, especially when compared internationally, where a similar total price could be charged for a single day of fishing in Europe or the UK.

I am advised by the board that the total revenue generated by the permit system, including revenue from coarse fishing permits, during the period 2005 to 2008 is in the region of €317,146. The board assures me that funds raised from the sale of permits are reinvested in the conservation and day-to-day management and development of these fisheries. Therefore, it funds works ranging from habitat maintenance, fish stocking, pollution control and enforcement as well as tourism angling promotion activities. It has been the board's experience that where tourist anglers are informed that funds raised through angling permits, which entitle them to fish on all 27 fisheries controlled by the board, are reinvested in the fishery, they are willing to contribute.

I understand the board continues to develop the angling product and, in partnership with Fáilte Ireland and the Central Fisheries Board, actively promotes the Shannon region as a tourism angling destination. This promotion work includes participation in trade shows. The board also has a dedicated website which provides information on the fisheries. A recent initiative has seen the board make provision for a dedicated angling officer from whom visiting anglers may seek advice. The Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources believes permits for coarse and pike angling at less than €1 per day represent good value and play an important role in providing additional resources to help sustain the fishery in the future.

The board members attempted to have discharge removed in recent days but were prevented by the management of the Shannon Regional Fisheries Board. I am grateful for the Minister of State's appearance before the House but the reply does not refer to the fact that some 12 km or 13 km from the River Suck there is free fishing. It is not a fair system. I am totally opposed to it and I hope the new board, once established, will have a new system applicable throughout the country and there will be no such differentiation.

I will convey the Senator's views to the Minister.

Top
Share