Skip to main content
Normal View

Select Committee on Enterprise and Economic Strategy debate -
Tuesday, 7 Dec 1993

SECTION 4.

I move amendment No. 16:

In page 4, lines 20 and 23, to delete subsection (1), and substitute the following:

"4.—(1) Section 23 (5) of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the deletion of all words after ‘Day' and the substitution of the words ‘or Good Friday"'.

This amendment takes the explanatory memorandum at its word and takes the Minister, in what he said on Second Stage, at his word. I do not believe that the Minister's intention is to promote racing on Good Friday and Christmas Day. I understand, however, from information given to me by the Minister, that he does not feel he can accept the amendment because, apparently, the principle is that there should be equality of treatment of all sports. Apparently, such is the way that the legislation is written, if there are other sports where racing is allowed on Sundays it is also by extension allowed on Christmas Day and Good Friday, because the same approach was taken to these matters back in God's time. I cannot see why we should get ourselves tied up in a bureaucratic tangle and, therefore, have to accept that we cannot say that there should be no racing on Good Friday or Christmas Day. It appears to me to be another example of the futility of consistency in these matters, as Deputy Lenihan might say.

I will not press the amendment, but if the Minister were to decide to make a bold, adventurous move and treat this board differently from others I would be fully prepared to support him.

Deputy Dukes is aware of my view on this issue. It is about equality of treatment between sports. There is no restriction here as to the days on which sports can operate of which I am aware. We are not promoting greyhound racing on Christmas Day or Good Friday. Indeed, I suspect it would be improbable if any commercial decision would be taken to have a greyhound racing meeting on Christmas Day or Good Friday. However, it was in the interests of equality that we framed the amendment.

I find that so laughable as to be incredible, but I will not press the amendment.

Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Sections 4 and 5 agreed to.
Title agreed to.

I propose the following draft report:

The Select Committee has considered the Greyhound Industry (Amendment) Bill, 1993 and has made an amendment thereto. The Bill, as amended, is reported to the Dáil.

Report agreed to.

Ordered to report to the Dáil accordingly.

I wish to thank the Minister and his officials, the Clerk to the committee and the Deputies for their contributions.

I wish to thank you, Chairman, for the way you conducted the debate, and the Deputies for their contributions. We did not agree on everything, but we agree on some areas.

The Select Committee adjourned at 10.45 p.m.

Top
Share