Skip to main content
Normal View

Consultancy Contracts Issues

Dáil Éireann Debate, Wednesday - 17 October 2012

Wednesday, 17 October 2012

Questions (197)

Mary Lou McDonald

Question:

197. Deputy Mary Lou McDonald asked the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources if he will provide details in tabular form for the years 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011 and to date in 2012 the total amount of expenditure on consultancy by his Department, any body under his aegis or State agency for which he has responsibility; the names of the consultancy companies awarded contracts; the nature of the work concerned; the fees paid to each consultant; if the matter was advertised for competitive tender; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [45293/12]

View answer

Written answers

The total amount of expenditure by my Department from its consultancy services and value for money and policy reviews budget in the years 2010 and 2011 and for the first eight months of 2012 is set out in table 1.

My Department administers a very diverse and complex brief, and procurement of specialist consultancy advice is necessary to enable the Department to discharge its responsibility in this regard. This includes major projects such as an intensive and nationwide campaign on Digital Switchover, strategic review of oil refining capability, complex telecommunications contracts such as the MANs and the National Broadband Scheme, and oversight of compliance with the Corrib consent conditions (the cost of which is recouped from the developer). In procuring these specialised services, my Department always seeks to ensure value for money and the keeping of expenditure to the minimum necessary. In this regard, the Deputy might note that expenditure from my Department’s consultancy services and value for money and policy reviews budget has reduced from €2.249m in 2008 to €1.372m in 2011. The Department also necessarily incurs some expenditure on outsourced services as part of programme expenditure, an element of which is consultancy in nature. The overall spend for this consultancy element is set out in table 2.

My Department will continue to keep spending on all consultancies to a minimum consistent with ensuring the necessary expertise is available to discharge the Department’s wide and complex brief. Details of expenditure on consultancy is set out in the tables below.

Table 1.

Period

2008

2009

2010

2011

Jan – 15 Oct 2012

Amount

€2.249m

€0.739m

€1.257m

€1.372m

€0.657m

Table2.

Period

2008

2009

2010

2011

Jan – 15 Oct 2012

Amount

€3.590m

€1.043m

€0.675m

€1.338m

€0.980m

Administrative Consultancy Expenditure in 2008:

Consultancy

Purpose

Amount

Corporate

Helm Corporation Ltd

Temporary Head of Internal Audit Unit

56,217.85

Siobhan Fay

DCENR Audit Committee

3,000.00

Pamela McDonald

DCENR Audit Committee

2,000.00

Crowleys DFK

Spot Checks on DCMNR Capital Projects 2006

10,748.63

ESB Independent Generation

Financial Advisor to DCMNR

16,940.00

Stephen O’Connor

Financial Advisor to DCENR

206,876.96

Mason, Hayes & Curran

Provision of Med. Services arising from 2005 CSCOP

7,578.23

Mason, Hayes & Curran

HR Needs

4,198.10

307,559.77

Broadcasting

Gary Tonge

Technical advice in relation to Digital Terrestrial Television Trials

5,445.75

PriceWaterhouse Cooper

Re-Engineering of TV Licence Fee Review System

102,196.84

Media Literacy Education

Media Literacy (Broadcasting)

10,000.00

Margaret O’Driscoll

Legal Advice for Broadcasting Bill 2008

7,865.00

Marie McGonagle

Legal Advice for Broadcasting Bill 2008

7,500.00

133,007.59

Communications

Norcontel (Ireland) Ltd

Technical Review of the Emergency Call Answering Service (ECAS)

129,318.75

Norcontel (Ireland) Ltd

Legal Advice on procurement of an ECAS Provider

74,387.50

Matheson Ormsby Prentice

Legal Advice on procurement of an ECAS Provider

24,542.73

PA Consulting

Review of Public Sector Benefits of Postcodes

54,450.00

Mason Communications

Next Generation Network Expert Advice

30,848.90

313,547.88

Natural Resources

A & L Goodbody Solicitors

Legal Advice for Bord na Mona – Employee Share Ownership Plan (ESOP) documentation

65,120.21

Matheson Ormsby Prentice

Legal Advice re post sale of Irish National Petroleum Corporation (INPC)

8,492.05

(AEGIS MEDIA IRL)

Study on Transmission Line Infrastructure  EirGrid

22,100.24

ECOFYS GMBH

Study on Transmission Line Infrastructure  EirGrid

145,052.21

Golder Associates Ltd

Study on Transmission Line Infrastructure  EirGrid

3,388.00

Beauchamps Solicitors

Legal Advice re Bord Gais Eireann Employee Share Ownership Plan Documentation

80,531.55

Eneclann Ltd

GSI Geological Heritage

2,855.60

KPMG

Financial Advice for Project Virginia

181,500.00

Mason, Hayes & Curran

Legal Advice for Project Virginia

22,578.36

Purvin & Gertz Inc.

Security of Ireland’s Access to Commercial Oil Supplies

271,766.15

ECOFYS GMBH

All Island Grid Study including Demand Side Management

54,093.30

Noel J Travers

 Drafting of PSO under Section 39 of Electricity Reg Act 1999

9,075.00

Keane Offshore Integrity

Corrib Verification Process

177,962.40

Charles Desmond

Environmental Monitoring Group

1,737.81

Eamon O’Duibhir

Environmental Monitoring Group

2,043.62

Patrick Barrett

Environmental Monitoring Group

1,389.32

Clare Morgan

Geophysical Support

62,685.00

Arthur Cox Solicitors

Legal Advice on the Corrib Gas Pipeline

42,945.98

David Fox Associates

Petroleum Engineering Support

179,634.00

Cefas - Lowestoft

OIC 2007 Action

3,527.45

AEA TECHNOLOGY Plc

Assessing of EIS according to Section40 Apps

56,116.20

GL Industrial Services UK

Technical Assistance Corrib Gas Safety

22,869.75

CSA Group

Oil and Gas Industry Support Service

10,248.70

CSA Group

GSI Management

14,338.00

Not available

Provision of Geological Advice on Selected Projects

29,720.63

Ralph Horne

Advice on GSI library acquisitions & management 07

5,670.00

Petra Coffey

GSI Archivist Services

17,500.00

1,494,941.53

Total

2,249,056.77

Programme Consultancy Expenditure in 2008:

Consultant

Purpose

Amount €

Subhead A5 – Office Machinery & Supplies

Astron

ICT Strategy

80,310.00

Sonas Innovation

ICT Strategy

8,470.00

88,780.00

Subhead A9 – Value for Money & Policy Reviews

Petrus Consulting

Expenditure Review of MANS and GBS

3,388.00

Subhead B1 – ICT Programmes

Arthur Cox Solicitors

569,579.58

Magnum Opus

1,137,507.18

Norcontel (Ireland) ltd

19,063.35

Quantum Equity

ICT Project Consultancy

12,584.00

Mason Hayes & Curran

Legal Advice – Schools Broadband

9,273.38

Next Utility (Ireach)

Make IT Secure

20,000.01

ESRI Ireland

39,440.89

McCann Fitzgerald Solicitors

912,230.96

Toorane Technology

2,065.50

Mason Communications

Project Kelvin

24,263.40

2,746,008.25

Subhead C6 – Digital Terrestrial Television

Mason Communications

30,875.00

Mason, Hayes & Curran

Advice on DTT Trials

30,824.52

61,699.52

Subhead D3 – Energy RTDDI

Network Resources Ltd

Energy Research Strategy

65,049.60

Subhead E1 – Petroleum Services

ERT (Scotland)

Strategic Environmental Assessment

354,226.82

Subhead E2 – Mining Services

Cantab Consulting

Examination of planning application for K2 extension to Galmoy Mine

12,122.40

Camp Dresser & McKee

Avoca Remedial Study

174,113.73

Hayes Higgins Partnership

Rehabilitation of Clashdugg Mine

1,214.84

Dara Design & Print Ltd

Corporate Branding & Web Design

19,946.91

Eugene Daly Associates

484.00

207,881.88

Subhead E5 – National Seabed Survey

PriceWaterhouse Coopers

INFOMAR

66,085.65

3,589,731.72

Administrative Consultancy Expenditure in 2009:

Consultant

Purpose

Amount €

Communications

Mason Communications

One Stop Shop

5,000.00

5,000.00

Broadcasting

Mason Hayes & Curran

Legal Advice on Broadcasting Bill

27,366.85

Pricewaterhouse Coopers

TV Licence Fee Review

11,846.25

39,213.10

Energy

NCB Corporate Finance

Advice to Minister on BGÉ / TSO Arrangements

48,600.00

Reidy Brophy

Security of Irelands Access to Commercial Oil Supplies

3,600.00

Fergus B Cahill

Chairman of Independent Analysis into the Transfer of Transmission Assets from ESB to EirGrid

3,629.37

55,829.37

Natural Resources

Ralph Horne

Advice on GSI Library

1,470.00

Petra Coffey

GSI Archivist Services

4,600.00

Pamela Austin

GSI Archivist Services

18,225.02

Parkmore Environmental Services

Specialist Groundwater Advice

2,126.25

Bruce Misstear

Specialist Groundwater Advice

3,000.00

Jenny Deakin

Specialist Groundwater Advice

4,981.75

Ben Dhonau

Specialist advice - Minerals Development Bill

40,987.39

Arthur Cox Solicitor

Corrib Verification Process

19,287.92

Arthur Cox Solicitor

Legal Advice on Seven Heads

1,215.00

Keane Offshore Integrity

Corrib Verification Process

88,609.95

Members of EMG

Environmental Monitoring Group

33,765.18

David Fox

Petroleum Engineering Support

175,366.95

Clare Morgan

Geophysical support

67,464.02

AEA Technology

Assessment of EIS

30,693.44

491,792.87

Corporate Support

Stephen O’Connor

Financial Adviser to DCENR

42,382.24

ESB 1927 Properties

Financial Adviser to DCENR

39,204.41

KPMG

Financial Adviser to DCENR

60,750.00

Legal Island

HR MS

345.00

DCENR Audit Committee

External Chair & Board of DCENR Audit Committee

4,320.00

 

 

147,001.65

 

 

738,836.99

Programme Consultancy Expenditure in 2009

Consultant

Purpose

Amount €

Subhead A5 – Office Machinery & Supplies

Bianconi Research Ltd

ICT Strategy

11,390.63

Subhead A9 – Value for Money & Policy Reviews

Indecon

Value for Money Review

6,860.00

Subhead B1 – ICT Programmes

Magnum Opus Ltd

MSE for Procurement E-Commerce Measures

117,032.66

KPMG

27,823.50

Magnum Opus Ltd

MSE for Contract Management for E-Commerce Measures

187,549.83

Arthur Cox Solicitors

8,649.85

Magnum Opus Ltd

Broadband Project Management Consultancy BMW

365,261.66

Magnum Opus Ltd

Interim MSE Costs

290,663.91

996,981.41

Subhead E1 – Petroleum Services

ERT (Scotland)

Strategic Environmental Assessment

1,305.19

Subhead E2 – Mining Service

Cantab Consulting

Closure of Galmoy Mine

23,721.82

GWP Consultants

Inspection of East Avoca after Heavy Rainfall

3,190.90

26912.72

1,043,449.95

Administrative Consultancy Expenditure in 2010:

Consultant

Purpose

Amount €

Communications

Norcontel (Ireland) Ltd

Supervision of testing of new ECAS system

95,541.60

PRICEWATERHOUSE COOPERS

Liberalisation of Irish Postal Services Market

15,125.00

Economic and Social Research Institute

ESRI Programme of Research in Communications

75,000.00

 

 

185,666.60

Broadcasting

Indecon

Review of designated events of public importance

73,386.49

Energy

Steelhenge Crisis and Risk consulting

Energy Emergency Arrangements (Avogadro)

5,545.91

Eric van Rongen

Report on Health Issues re HVDC Cable Technology

3,630.75

A & L Goodbody Solicitors

Legal Advice

65,037.50

IBI Corporate Finance

Financial Advice

98,800.00

Fergus B Cahill

Independent Chairman of Elec Trans Assets Analysis

6,464.64

Department of Enterprise, Trade & Investment NI

Energy Emergency Arrangements (Refund)

-1,476.27

 

 

176,002.53

Natural Resources

Keane Offshore Integrity Ltd

Corrib Verification Process

74,421.97

Committee Members

Consent Conditions Monitoring Committee

9,512.02

David Fox Associates

Petroleum Engineering Support

210,421.98

Clare Morgan

Geophysicist Consultancy

65,342.90

AEA TECHNOLOGY plc

Assessing of EIS according to Section40 Apps

5,155.35

AMEC Environment & Infrastructure UK Ltd (Entec)

145,204.99

Environ uk ltd

Assessment of Corrib Gas Pipeline

91,799.18

Mr. Ben Dhonau

Provision of Specialist Geoscience Advice

35,723.13

 

 

637,581.52

Corporate Support

KPMG

Financial Advisor to DCENR

157,300.00

Murray Consultants Ltd.

Media Services

12,206.42

Ernst & Young

Financial Advice

12,402.50

Committee Members

DCENR Audit Committee

2,736.00

 

 

184,644.92

 

 

1,257,282.06

Programme Consultancy Expenditure in 2010:

Consultant

Purpose

Amount €

Subhead B1 – ICT Programmes

Mason Communications

NBS Consultancy

95,538.96

Magnum Opus

Interim MSE

144,741.60

MANs Phase 2 Project Management

132,297.48

Magnum Opus

MSE Process Management

80,150.40

   452,728.44

Subhead C5 – Grants to DTT

Behaviour & Attitudes Limited

DTT

49,912.50

Subhead E1 – Petroleum Services

Xodus Group

Strategic Environmental Assessments

150,631.89

Subhead E2 – Mining Services

(AEGIS MEDIA IRL) Brindley Advertising Ltd.

Avoca Mine Public Meeting

1,575.37

CDM (Camp Dresser & Mc Kee Irl Ltd)

Avoca Mine Public Meeting - Support

12,705.00

Cantab Consulting

Advice in relation to closure of Galmoy Mine

7,893.38

22,173.75

675,446.58

Administrative Consultancy Expenditure in 2011

Consultancy

Purpose

Amount €

Communications

Deloitte & Touche

Communications Policy Consultancy

45,919.50

Economic and Social Research Institute

ESRI Programme of Research in Communications

75,000.00

PA Consulting Group

National Digital Research Centre

29,040.00

 

 

149,959.50

Energy

Purvin & Gertz  Inc

Strategic Case for Oil Refining Requirements

154,688.65

Fergus B Cahill

Independent Chairman of Elec Trans Assets Analysis

1,446.36

IBI Corporate Finance

Financial Advice on Elec Transmission Asset Review

18,150.00

OHH Energy

Independent Commission Meath Tyrone Power Lines

36,109.29

2B Energy

Independent Commission Meath Tyrone Power Lines

32,284.71

Elimark AB

Independent Commission Meath Tyrone Power Lines

34,134.85

 

 

276,813.86

Natural Resources

SLR Consulting ( Ireland Ltd

Core Library Holdings Review

39,688.00

Jenny Deakin

GWPS

1,750.00

Arthur Cox Solicitor

Legal Advice on the Corrib Gas Pipeline

161,297.04

Arthur Cox Solicitor

PAD - Legal Advice in Relation to Seven Heads Gas Field

2,420.00

David Fox Associates

Petroleum Engineering Support

181,254.74

Clare Morgan

Geophysicist Consultancy

64,904.40

Keane Offshore Integrity Ltd

Corrib Verification Process

141,733.26

Committee Members

Consent Conditions Monitoring Committee

538.05

AMEC Environment & Infrastructure UK Ltd (Entec)

Assessment of Corrib Gas Pipeline

22,918.94

Environ uk ltd

Assessment of Corrib Gas Pipeline

14,928.81

Environ uk ltd

Monitoring of Corrib Gas Consent Conditions

99,352.95

 

 

730,786.19

Corporate Support

Murray Consultants Ltd

Media Services

8,349.00

KPMG Fees Account

Financial Advisor to DCENR (KPMG Secondment)

133,100.00

Iron Mountain

P&T Pension Consultancy

30,430.19

Ernst & Young

Financial Advice

12,402.50

Dept of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation

Irish Commitment to Reducing Admin Budget by 25%

14,000.00

Committee Members

Consultancy to Audit Committee

4,446.00

Ronan Tierney (Tierney & Associates )

Temporary Head of IAU

11,560.34

 

 

214,288.03

 

 

1,371,847.58

Program Consultancy Expenditure in 2011:

Consultant

Purpose

Amount €

Subhead B1 – ICT Programmes

PA Consulting

Implementation of National Post Codes System

339,942.24

Magnum Opus Ltd

MSE for Contract Management

66,792.00

Magnum Opus Ltd

Interim MSE Costs

50,062.00

Analysys Mason Ltd.

NBS Consultancy

207,826.97

664,623.21

Subhead C5 – Grants to DTT

Latinollo Ltd (Trading as McConnell’s)

National Digital Switchover Campaign

574,897.18

Subhead E1 – Petroleum Services

Xodus Group

76,353.86

Fugro Survey Ltd

IOSEA 4 (Irish Offshore)

805.67

77,159.53

Subhead E2 - Mining Services

Dr. Michael Johnson

Silvermines Vegetation Study

1,210.00

Dr. Michael Johnson

Silvermines Vegetation Management Review

5,848.68

CDM (Camp Dresser & Mc Kee Irl Ltd)

Sampling of Gortmore and Silvermines Vegetation

13,890.80

20,949.48

 

1,337,629.40

Administrative Consultancy Expenditure in 2012:

Consultancy

Purpose

Amount €

Communications

Deloitte & Touche

Procurement Advice on Sensitive Comms Issue

12,054.00

Indecon

National Broadband Plan

28,167.00

Mason Communications Ltd.

National Broadband Plan

30,522.45

 

 

70,743.45

Energy

Purvin & Gertz  Inc

Strategic Case for Oil Refining Requirements

39,311.55

Kylemore Services

Security of Ireland’s Access to Commercial Oil Supplies

367.50

Reidy Brophy Limited

Security of Ireland’s Access to Commercial Oil Supplies

7,100.00

OHH Energy

Independent Commission Meath Tyrone Power Lines

5,012.57

Elimark AB

Independent Commission Meath Tyrone Power Lines

4,653.36

 

 

56,444.98

Natural Resources

Petroleum Infrastructure Programme Fund

Petroleum Engineering Support

3,780.00

David Fox Associates

Petroleum Engineering Support

118,820.36

Clare Morgan

Petroleum Engineering Support

6,918.75

Clare Morgan

Geophysicist Consultancy

56,032.66

Keane Offshore Integrity Ltd

Corrib Verification Process

59,392.02

Committee Members

Consent Conditions Monitoring Committee

2,277.20

Environ uk ltd

Monitoring of Corrib Gas Consent Conditions

151,493.01

 

 

398,714.00

Corporate Support

KPMG Fees Account

Financial Advisor to DCENR

12,129.17

Pricewaterhouse Coopers

Financial Advisor to DCENR

49,200.00

Cloda Ryan

Pension Advisor Services

3,439.47

Committee Members

Consultancy to Audit Committee

1,368.00

Tierney & Associates

Temporary Head of IAU

40,183.49

Bearingpoint Ireland Ltd

HR Skills Survey

24,600.00

 

 

130,920.13

 

 

656,822.56

Programme Consultancy Expenditure in 2012:

Consultant

Purpose

Amount €

Subhead A3 – ICT Programmes

Analysys Mason Ltd.

National Broadband Scheme

41,737.80

Analysys Mason Ltd.

Kelvin Project

6,157.66

Mason Hayes & Curran

Post Codes

25,719.30

PA Consulting

Post Codes

140,367.60

213,982.36

Subhead A5 – Information Society and eInclusion

VBF Technology

Cyber Security

31,126.16

UCD CCI

Cyber Security

41,010.98

72,137.14

Subhead B7 – Grants For Digital Terrestrial Television

Latinollo Ltd. (Trading as McConnell’s)

Digital Switchover Campaign

681,328.40

Subhead D3 – Petroleum Services

Xodus Group Ltd.

Scientific and Environmental Assessment of the Irish and Celtic Seas

12,151.32

 

 

979,599.22

Programme Consultancy Expenditure in 2011:

Consultant

Purpose

Amount

Subhead B1 – ICT Programmes

PA Consulting

Implementation of National Post Codes System

339,942.24

Magnum Opus Ltd

MSE for Contract Management

66,792.00

Magnum Opus Ltd

Interim MSE Costs

50,062.00

Analysys Mason Ltd.

NBS Consultancy

207,826.97

664,623.21

Subhead C5 – Grants to DTT

Latinollo Ltd (Trading as McConnell’s)

National Digital Switchover Campaign

574,897.18

Subhead E1 – Petroleum Services

Xodus Group

76,353.86

Fugro Survey Ltd

IOSEA 4 (Irish Offshore)

805.67

77,159.53

Subhead E2 – Mining Services

Dr. Michael Johnson

Silvermines Vegetation Study

1,210.00

Dr. Michael Johnson

Silvermines Vegetation Management Review

5,848.68

CDM (Camp Dresser & Mc Kee Irl Ltd)

Sampling of Gortmore and Silvermines Vegetation

13,890.80

20,949.48

 

1,337,629.40

Administrative Consultancy Expenditure in 2012:

Consultancy

Purpose

Amount €

Communications

Deloitte & Touche

Procurement Advice on Sensitive Comms Issue

12,054.00

Indecon

National Broadband Plan

28,167.00

Mason Communications Ltd.

National Broadband Plan

30,522.45

 

 

70,743.45

Energy

Purvin & Gertz  Inc

Strategic Case for Oil Refining Requirements

39,311.55

Kylemore Services

Security of Ireland’s Access to Commercial Oil Supplies

367.50

Reidy Brophy Limited

Security of Ireland’s Access to Commercial Oil Supplies

7,100.00

OHH Energy

Independent Commission Meath Tyrone Power Lines

5,012.57

Elimark AB

Independent Commission Meath Tyrone Power Lines

4,653.36

 

 

56,444.98

Natural Resources

Petroleum Infrastructure Programme Fund

Petroleum Engineering Support

3,780.00

David Fox Associates

Petroleum Engineering Support

118,820.36

Clare Morgan

Petroleum Engineering Support

6,918.75

Clare Morgan

Geophysicist Consultancy

56,032.66

Keane Offshore Integrity Ltd

Corrib Verification Process

59,392.02

Committee Members

Consent Conditions Monitoring Committee

2,277.20

Environ uk ltd

Monitoring of Corrib Gas Consent Conditions

151,493.01

 

 

398,714.00

Corporate Support

KPMG Fees Account

Financial Advisor to DCENR

12,129.17

Pricewaterhouse Coopers

Financial Advisor to DCENR

49,200.00

Cloda Ryan

Pension Advisor Services

3,439.47

Committee Members

Consultancy to Audit Committee

1,368.00

Tierney & Associates

Temporary Head of IAU

40,183.49

Bearingpoint Ireland Ltd

HR Skills Survey

24,600.00

 

 

130,920.13

 

 

656,822.56

Programme Consultancy Expenditure in 2012:

Consultant

Purpose

Amount

Subhead A3 – ICT Programmes

Analysys Mason Ltd.

National Broadband Scheme

41,737.80

Analysys Mason Ltd.

Kelvin Project

6,157.66

Mason Hayes & Curran

Post Codes

25,719.30

PA Consulting

Post Codes

140,367.60

213,982.36

Subhead A5 – Information Society and eInclusion

VBF Technology

Cyber Security

31,126.16

UCD CCI

Cyber Security

41,010.98

72,137.14

Subhead B7 – Grants For Digital Terrestrial Television

Latinollo Ltd. (Trading as McConnell’s)

Digital Switchover Campaign

681,328.40

Subhead D3 – Petroleum Services

Xodus Group Ltd.

Scientific and Environmental Assessment of the Irish and Celtic Seas

12,151.32

 

 

979,599.22

Top
Share