Skip to main content
Normal View

Tuesday, 5 Nov 2013

Written Answers Nos. 107-127

Exports Data

Questions (107)

Lucinda Creighton

Question:

107. Deputy Lucinda Creighton asked the Taoiseach if he will provide in tabular form the total exports by industry category in euro for 2011, 2012 and to date in 2013; if he will provide a breakdown between foreign direct investment companies exports and indigenous small and medium enterprises exports in euro terms for 2011, 2012, and to date in 2013; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [45948/13]

View answer

Written answers

Data for total exports of goods and services by industry category/economic sector or by country of ownership of the exporter is not available. However, a breakdown of service exports by sector is available. Data on total exports of goods and services (2011, 2012, Q1/2013 and Q2/2013) is included in Table 1. Annual data on exports of services by economic sector (2008-2012) are included in Table 2.

Table 1: Exports of goods and services for 2011, 2012, Q1/2013 and Q2/2013 (€ millions):

-

2011

2012

Q1/2013

Q2/2013

Total exports of goods & services

166,475

176,147

41,296

45,809

of which: exports of goods

85,007

85,852

19,690

21,738

of which: exports of services

81,468

90,295

21,606

24,071

Table 2: Exports of services classified by NACE Rev.2 Economic Sector for 2008 to 2012 (€ millions):

Economic sector

Description

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

All sectors

Total Exports of Goods (for information)

81,037

77,647

82,607

85,007

85,852

All sectors

Total Exports of Services

67,947

67,602

74,311

81,468

90,295

B-E & F

Service exports - from Industry & Construction Sectors

14,914

14,279

13,555

14,174

14,890

G-U

Service exports - from Services Sectors

53,033

53,323

60,756

67,294

75,405

-

of which:

-

-

-

-

-

J

Information and Communication Sectors

25,686

26,560

30,823

35,377

40,583

K-L

Financial, Insurance and Real Estate Sectors

15,966

15,297

17,045

17,231

18,918

-

All other service sectors

11,381

11,466

12,888

14,686

15,904

National Risk Assessment

Questions (108)

Stephen Donnelly

Question:

108. Deputy Stephen S. Donnelly asked the Taoiseach his plans for ensuring that the new national risk assessment which is to be published annually will include risks faced by the country in the areas of unemployment, emigration, poverty, income inequality, early school leaving, health inequalities, gender inequality and personal over-indebtedness; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [46401/13]

View answer

Written answers

One component of the Government's programme of Dáil reform published in September 2013 was completion of a National Risk Assessment which the Government will publish for debate in the Dáil alongside the Stability Programme and National Reform Programme that are produced as part of EU-wide economic planning; and a National Progress Report, produced independently by the CSO.

It is intended that the National Risk Assessment will set out the risks (both financial and non-financial) which the country faces in the period ahead. It will facilitate an opportunity for members of Oireachtas to discuss and contribute to this Assessment.

It is premature to say what risks will be encompassed within the National Risk Assessment, but in carrying out this exercise the Government will draw on international experience and best practice. I understand that the most well-developed risk assessments involve reference to a broad range of risks, be they economic, environmental or social in nature.

Proposed Legislation

Questions (109)

Barry Cowen

Question:

109. Deputy Barry Cowen asked the Taoiseach if he will provide in tabular form the number of Bills published by his Department since March 2011 and the number of regulatory impact assessments published by his Department since March 2011. [45625/13]

View answer

Written answers

One Bill was produced by my Department since March 2011.

The Thirty-second Amendment of the Constitution (Abolition of Seanad Éireann) Bill 2013, was published in June 2013, further to a commitment in the Programme for Government. A regulatory impact analysis (RIA) is normally required for all primary legislation but there are certain exceptions to this rule which are set out in the relevant guidelines. As the Bill concerned involved amending the Constitution for the purpose of abolishing the Seanad rather than significantly impacting on the regulatory environment, an RIA was not completed in keeping with precedents for Bills of this nature.

State Gifts

Questions (110)

Patrick Nulty

Question:

110. Deputy Patrick Nulty asked the Taoiseach the total number of State gifts presented to foreign dignitaries during each of the past ten years; the total value of such gifts; if he will provide an itemised list of the gifts by country of the dignitary being presented with the gift; the nature of the gift and manufacturer; the value of the gift; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [45853/13]

View answer

Written answers

The following schedule details the gifts presented by Taoisigh during the last ten years to foreign dignitaries, including Heads of State or Government, their deputies, and Heads of International Organisations. Gifts are carefully sourced in Ireland, with the emphasis on suitability and value for money.

Country and Date

In

bound visit

Out

bound visit

Recipient

Gift

Cost - €

Algeria

09.04.2008

X

President of the Council of Nations

Dublin a Celebration book in slipcase

30.00

Austria

[Tour of Capitals 2003]

X

Chancellor

Wolfgang

Schussel

Leather Bound Book

Wild Geese

150.00

Australia

22.05.2006

X

PM John Howard

Silver Photo frame with harp

105.15

Bahrain

03.10.2003

X

Sheikh Khalifa

Waterford Crystal 10” Bowl

200.00

Bahrain

12.10.2004

X

Prime Minister

Waterford Crystal Vase

148.22

Belgium

08.10.2007

X

King of Belgium

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

148.21

Bulgaria

12.12.05

X

H.E. Georgi Paranov, President

Pair Metalcraft Candlesticks

198.00

Canada

05.07.2005

X

PM Martin

Waterford Crystal 9” Bowl

136.00

Canada

16.03.2004

X

PM Martin

Waterford Crystal John Rocha Platter

168.00

Canada

16.06.2013

X

PM Harper

Crystal ‘Gathering’ Rose Bowl.

112.50

Chile

10.07.2003

X

President Lagos

Waterford Crystal Lismore Bowl

200.00

China

11.05.2004

X

PM Wen

John Rocha Crystal Wine set

167.16

China

17.01.2005

X

H.E.Hu Jintao

John Rocha Crystal Wine set

167.16

X

H.E.Wen Jiabao

Waterford Crystal Vase

148.22

China

19.10.2008

X

Premier Minister Wu Jinato

Crystal Louise Kennedy Photo Frame

140.00

China

19.02.2012

X

Vice President

H.E. Xi Jinping

Set [12] Galway Crystal Glasses

71.90

China

25.03.2012

X

Premier State Council H.E.Wen Jiabao

Chairman National Peoples

Congress Wu

Vice Premier Li Keqiang

Vice President

H.E. Xi Jinping

Crystal Fitzgerald 15cm Platter

Waterford Crystal Fitzgerald 15cm Platter

Crystal Trillium Vase

Dublin Crystal Harp Bowl

43.30

43.30

21.25

100.00

China

30.10.2013

X

Vice Premier of State Council Ma Kai

Waterford Crystal Engraved Bowl

120.00

Colombia

23.03 2004

X

Vice President

Encyclopaedia of Ireland in presentation case

93.50

Croatia

29.11.2005

X

Croatian President

Croatian Prime Minister

Silver King Sitric Cufflinks

78.00

78.00

Cyprus

05.11 2003

X

President Yassos

Papadopoulos

Silver Salver

283.14

Cyprus

30.11.2005

X

President Yassos

Papadopoulos

Waterford Crystal Lismore 9” bowl

136.00

Czech Republic

10.11.2008

X

PM Spidla

Silver Danu Cufflinks

28.34

Czech Republic

10.11.2008

X

President Claus

Bog Oak

Basketball Player in Frame

200.00

Denmark

10.03.2004

X

Prime Minister of Denmark

Encyclopaedia of Ireland in presentation case

93.50

East Timor

18.10.2003

X

President Xana Gusamo

Waterford Crystal Candleticks

148.22

East Timor

08.03.2010

X

President Jose Ramos Horta

Book – Limited Edition

215.00

Egypt

07.12.2006

X

President Mubarak

Waterford Crystals Candlesticks

148.21

Estonia

04.04.2012

Estonia

14.04.2008

X

President of Estonia

President of Estonia

Newbridge Prelude Cufflinks

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

45.00

152.99

EU Day of Welcomes.

Irelands EU Presidency 01.05.2004.

X

All EU Heads of State and Governments + Commission President and Parliament President participating in Day of Welcomes Ceremony..

‘Dublin a Celebration’ in presentation case.

Seamus Heaney Poem in binder.

Commemorative Boxed Silver Coaster & Disc.

1,050.00

total

1,070.52

total

9,449.22

total

EU/ Russia Summit

21.05.2004

X

President Putin

Silver Salver

283.14

EU Comm. Meeting

06.01.2004

X

EU Commissioners

EU President Romano Prodi

Encyclopaedia of Ireland in presentation case.

Leather Bound Encyclopaedia of Ireland.

910.00

total

305.00

EU / Latin America Summit

11.05.2006

X

President Fischer

Great Houses of Ireland Book

22.45

EU/US Summit

26.06.2004

X

President George Bush

Encyclopaedia of Ireland in presentation case.

Aran Sweater

93.50

125.64

EU Parliament

27.11.2003

X

Mr. Pat Cox,

President of the EU Parliament.

Encyclopaedia of Ireland in presentation case.

95.50

EU Parliament

07.04.2008

X

Mr. Hans Pottering, President EU Parliament

Silver King Sitric Cufflinks

92.00

EU

Comm.

17.04.2008

X

Mr. Jose Manuel Barosso,

President of the EU Commission.

Silver King Sitric Cufflinks

92.00

EU Parliament

04/10/2012

X

Mr. Martin Schulz, President of the EU Parliament.

Galway Crystal Tumblers

35.95

Finland

23.02.2004

X

PM Matti van Hanen

Encyclopaedia of Ireland.

45.50

Finland

05.11/2007

X

Ms. Tarja Halonen, Presidentt

Waterford Crystal Bethany Candlesticks

76.50

France

22.03.2004

X

President Chirac

Waterford Crystal Vase

327.71

France

24.05.2004

X

P.M. Jean-Pierre

Raffarin

Metalcraft Candlesticks

198.07

France

03.06.2004

X

President Chirac

Encyclopaedia of Ireland in presentation case.

93.50

France

14.07.2008

X

President Sarkozy

Waterford Crystal Vase

84.63

France

21.09.2007

X

President Sarkozy

Silver Cufflink

DVD Ireland from the Air

92.00

36.30

France

01.10.2008

X

President Sarkozy

Waterford Crystal Flutes

198.00

France

21.07.2008

X

President Sarkozy

Bog Oak Sculpture

415.00

Georgia

11.11.2010

X

PM Nika Gilauni

Silver Cufflinks and Tie Pin Set

160.00

Germany

09.04.2004

X

Chancellor Schroeder

Silver Salver

374.62

Germany

14.04.2008

X

Chancellor Merkel

Damask Linen Tablecloth

240.00

Great Britain

17.05.2011

X

HRM Queen Elizabeth 11

Special Edition Sweeney Guide to the Irish Turf

1501-2001

200.00

Great Britain

05/03/2003

X

PM Blair

Music Book & Music CDs

93.16

Greece

23.05.2013

X

PM Samuras

Celtic Knot Cufflinks

55.00

Hungary

10.01.2005

X

Hungarian President

Metalcraft Candlesticks

198.07

Hungary

24.11.2005

X

PM Gyurcsany

Silver Cufflinks

78.00

Iceland

12.09.2007

X

PM Mr. G. Haarde

Ogham Cufflinks

88.80

India

16.01.2006

X

President of India

PM India

Chief Minister Delhi

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

Waterford Crystal Vase

Silver Cufflinks

148.21

136.00

78.00

Italy

10.06.2013

X

Prime Minister

Silver Celtic Knot Cufflinks

55.00

Japan

11.01.2009

X

PM Aso

Crystal Louise Kennedy Candlesticks

180.00

Japan

19.06.2013

X

PM Abe

Cufflinks -Salmon of Knowledge

94.50

Japan

07.05.2005

X

Emperor & Empress of Japan

Crystal Oriental Dragon on Ebony Plinth

1,972.50

Jordan

01.03.2004

X

King of Jordan

Waterford Crystal Bowl

251.08

Kosovo

22.12.2008

X

PM Thaci

President Fatmir Srjdiu

Waterford Crystal Vase &

Silver Cufflinks

Waterford Crystal Vase & Silver Cufflinks

/Tie Pin set

84.63

125.00

84.63

160.00

Latvia

06.06.2013

X

President Andris Berzins

PM Valdis Dombrovskis

Silver Cufflinks

Foxford Woolen Scarf

55.00

17.05

Lebanon

26.04.2004

X

Prime Minister

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

148.22

Lithuania

08.10.2007

X

Prime Minister

Waterford Crystal Square Bowl

134.00

Macedonia

19.11.2009

X

President

Waterford Crystal

Bowl

21.25

Madmoud Abbas

22.09.2008

X

President

Silver Cufflinks and Tie Pin Set

160.00

Malaysia

16.06.2003

X

King

Waterford Crystal

Vase

251.08

Malaysia

10.10.2004

X

King

Prime Minister

Waterford Crystal Bowl

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

200.16

148.22

Mexico

26.05.2004

X

President Fox

Encyclopaedia of Ireland in presentation case.

93.50

Monaco

04.04.2011

X

Prince Albert

Waterford Crystal Wedding Flutes

240.00

Newfound-land

16.09.2005

X

Hon. Danny Williams Premier

Bronze Hurler on Mahogany Plinth

158.54

Newfound-land

28.02.2007

X

Hon. Danny Williams Premier

Book on Ancient Ireland

19.99

Norway

13.02.04

X

Prime Minister

Encyclopaedia of Ireland

45.50

Norway

18.09.2006

X

King Harold

Queen of Norway

Golden Age of Irish Art

18ct Gold

Cufflinks

18ct Gold Ear Studs

64.72

281.60

222.80

Palestine

12.02.2004

X

Prime Minister

Waterford Crystal Vase

148.22

Papal Visit

20.07.2005

X

Pope Benedict

Hand painted Batik of St. Benedict gift boxed

394.70

Poland

29.01.2004

X

H,.E. Mr. Leszek Miller PM

Encyclopaedia of Ireland.

45.50

Poland

26.02.2008

X

PM Tusk

President Kaczynski

Waterford Crystal Vase

Waterford Crystal Vase

84.63

84.63

Poland

19.02.2007

X

President

Silver Picture Frame with Harp

212.00

Romania

19.11.2003

X

Prime Minister

Antique Map of Ireland

500.00

Russia

29.05.2003

X

President Putin

Waterford Crystal Bowl

327.71

Saudi Arabia

18.02.2008

X

HRH Prince Faisal

Waterford Crystal Square Bowl

134.00

Saudi Arabia

14.01.2007

X

King of Saudi Arabia

H.H. Prince Abdullah

Crown Prince Sultan

Prince Abdu Aziz

HRH Prince Salmon Bin Abdul

Waterford Crystal Lamp

Waterford Crystal John Rocha Vase

Waterford Crystal Centrepiece

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

Waterford Crystal Bowl

368.18

185.95

185.95

148.21

130.17

Scotland

13.01.2012

X

Scottish First Minister Salmond

History of Ireland Cufflinks

102.00

Serbia & Monte-

negro

20.06.2005

X

President

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

148.21

Slovenia

25.02.2008

X

PM Jansa

Turned Wood Rimmed Bowl

99.00

Singapore

12.10.2004

X

President

Prime Minister

Waterford Crystal Centrepiece

Waterford Crystal Vase

148.22

148.22

Slovakia

26.03.2007

X

President Gasparovic

Silver Picture Frame with Harp

212.00

Slovakia

13.11.2006

X

Prime Minister

Dublin of Celebration Book

30.00

South Africa

09.04.2008

X

Deputy President

Linen Table Runner Napkin & Tray Cloths Set

76.04

South Africa

14.01.2008

X

Deputy President

Vice President

President

Waterford Crystal Centrepiece

Waterford Crystal Centrepiece

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

67.71

67.71

152.99

Sweden

22.01.2004

X

PM Goran Persson

Silver Paper Knife

93.22

Switzerland

18.10.2003

X

Confederation President Pascal Couchpin

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

148.22

Switzerland

16.02.2004

X

President Joseph Deiss

Encyclopaedia of Ireland.

45.50

Tanzania

14.01.2008

X

Prime Minister

President

Linen Damask

Tablecloth

Newbridge Cutlery

240.00

218.00

Tanzania

25.02.2009

X

Prime Minister

Waterford Crystal Bowl

85.00

Thailand

06.10.2004

X

PM Thaksin Shinawtra

Waterford Crystal Vase

104.99

Turkey

17.07.2003

Turkey (continued)

X

Prime Minister

President

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

Waterford Crystal Vase

148.22

148.22

United Arab Emirates

16.01.2007

X

HH Sheikh Khalifa, President UAE & Ruler of Abu Dhabi

HH Sheikh Mohammed Prime Minister UAE

Waterford John Rocha Vase

Waterford Crystal Candlesticks

185.95

152.99

United Nations

31.05.2006

X

General Secretary U.N. Kofi Annan

Silver King Sitric Cufflinks

78.00

U.S.A.

24.05.2005

X

Former President, Mr. Bill Clinton

Special Midleton Rare Whiskey

135.00

U.S.A

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2003

X

President Bush

Shamrock Bowl

247.60

U.S.A

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2004

X

President Bush

Shamrock Bowl

352.78

U.S.A. St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2005

X

President Bush

Former President, Mr. Bill Clinton

Shamrock Bowl

Silver King Citric Cufflinks

296.04

78.00

U.S.A

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2006

X

President Bush

Shamrock Bowl

365.39

U.S.A

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2007

X

President Bush

Shamrock Bowl

701.00

[Master -cutter’s Bowl]

U.S.A.

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2008

X

President Bush

Retirement gift for President Bush

Shamrock Bowl

Bog Oak

355.00

197.82

U.S.A

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2009

X

President Obama

Shamrock Bowl [Ormonde Footed Bowl]

714.93

U.S.A

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2010

X

President Obama

President Obama

Shamrock Bowl

Set of 2 (rare Yeats Plays and Poetry

391.96

265.00

U.S.A

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2011

X

President Obama

President Obama

Vice President Joe Biden

Shamrock Bowl

Historical Framed Photo of John F. Kennedy

Hand Crafted inscribed Hurley set

400.00

198.00

50.00

U.S.A.

23.05.2011

X

President Obama

History of Ireland Cufflinks

102.00

U.S.A

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2012

X

President Obama

Vice President Joe Biden

Shamrock Bowl

Bronze Maquette of James Hoban

Irish Coin Cufflinks

200.00

250.00

40.00

U.S.A

St. Patrick’s Day Visit 2013

X

President Obama

Vice President Biden

Shamrock Bowl

Crystal Picture Frame

300.00

26.10

Vietnam

06.10.2004

X

PM Pham Van Khi

Waterford Crystal Vase

148.22

Vietnam

10.03.2008

X

President Dung

Waterford Crystal Square Bowl

134.00

Vietnam

22.10.2009

X

Prime Minister

Book – Great Houses of Ireland

22.45

Income Data

Questions (111)

Thomas P. Broughan

Question:

111. Deputy Thomas P. Broughan asked the Taoiseach further to Parliamentary Question No. 37 of 15 October 2013, if he will provide details on the nature of the survey to be undertaken by the Central Statistics Office as part of its Household Finance and Consumption Survey referred to in that reply. [45423/13]

View answer

Written answers

The Household Finance and Consumption Survey (HFCS) is a household survey which is being conducted by the Central Statistics Office as part of a programme of similar surveys in Eurozone countries. The survey covers households usually resident in Ireland and the main topic headings covered in the survey are:

1. Socio-demographic data (age, gender, education achieved, marital status, household composition etc.)

2. Real assets and their financing (mortgages and loans, property, cars, jewellery etc.)

3. Other liabilities/credit constraints (lease payments, credit lines, overdrafts, credit cards etc.)

4. Private businesses and financial assets (business ownership, interests in business etc.)

5. Employment (occupation, job status etc.)

6. Pension and insurance policies

7. Income (employee, self-employed, transfer payments etc.)

8. Intergenerational transfers as gifts

9. Consumption (how much spent on food/beverage in the month etc.)

The main aim of the HFCS is to provide structural information on households’ assets and liabilities, based on a representative sample of households. This will address gaps in knowledge about the economic well-being of households, the distribution and type of wealth (and liabilities) among households and individuals, as well as the factors that affect financial planning by households and individuals.

Work began on the survey in 2012 and the main field work was done between March and September 2013. In total the CSO collected data from approximately 5,250 households across the country. The HFCS data is currently being processed and first results are due to be released in mid-2014.

The total cost of the survey over the period 2012 to 2014 is estimated to be approximately €1,357,000 of which the Central Bank will pay €990,000. The remaining €367,000 is being covered from the CSO Vote.

Under the Statistics Act, 1993 the survey data collected on individuals and households is confidential and may only be used for statistical purposes.

Departmental Expenditure

Questions (112)

Mary Lou McDonald

Question:

112. Deputy Mary Lou McDonald asked the Taoiseach if he will provide in tabular form the partial year and the full year monetary effect of his Department's Budget 2014 reductions to expenditure. [47084/13]

View answer

Written answers

The Department's estimate for 2014 is €17.931m, a reduction of 19% on the 2013 estimate.

This reflects a range of savings all of which take full effect in 2014.

Trade Relations

Questions (113, 124)

John Lyons

Question:

113. Deputy John Lyons asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if he has a dedicated strategy in relation to building bilateral relations with China; if he plans to visit China in the next 12 months; if he has invited the Chinese Premier to Ireland; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [45660/13]

View answer

John Lyons

Question:

124. Deputy John Lyons asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade the total percentage of Ireland’s overall exports accounted for by exports to China; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [46953/13]

View answer

Written answers

I propose to take Questions Nos. 113 and 124 together.

Overall exports of goods from Ireland in 2012 amounted to €91.7 billion. Services exports amounted to a further €90.3 billion, for a combined total of €182 billion. The trade balance in Ireland’s favour was some €45.7 billion, including the highest services trade surplus since records began. Total goods exports to China (including its various territories) in 2012 were €2.3 billion, while services exports were €3.1 billion. Goods exports to China were thus 2.5% of total goods exports, with services exports to China 3.5% of total exports of services. Combined goods and services exports to China were €5.4 billion, or 3% of total exports from Ireland. These figures make China Ireland’s 9th biggest export market, and our largest in Asia. China is also a key market for indigenous exports from Ireland. In 2012, these amounted to €346 million, an increase of 19% from 2011. Enterprise Ireland has set a target of €600 million of indigenous exports to China by 2016, with a focus on six priority clusters: Financial Services, Clean technologies, Information & Communication Technologies, Pharmaceuticals, Medical Devices & Education. China is also a key market for food and agriculture exports. These amounted to €323 million in 2012, an increase of 93% since 2010.

Ireland’s overall relations with China are based on ongoing assessment by Government of Ireland’s key strategic, political and economic interests. The Government recognises that the rapid development of China, along with other countries in Asia, has significant global implications, while providing many opportunities for Ireland. The Government has intensified Ireland’s bilateral relations with China since the visit of then Vice President Xi Jinping in February 2012. The Taoiseach made a return visit to China in March of last year, during which a Strategic Partnership for Mutually Beneficial Cooperation was agreed between the two countries. This Agreement provides a comprehensive framework for the development of further co-operation across a wide range of areas, including trade, investment, culture, and education. I made an official visit to China in July/August of this year, at the invitation of Foreign Minister Wang Yi. I used the visit to further strengthen relations with a key global actor, as well as supporting Irish companies doing business in China, promoting Ireland as a tourist destination, and promoting Ireland as the best investment location for Chinese businesses looking to expand in Europe.

Last week, the Taoiseach and I met separately with Vice Premier Ma Kai, who visited Ireland at my invitation. We had substantive exchanges on all aspects of the bilateral relationship. Vice Premier Ma indicated a firm wish on the part of China to intensify co-operation across a range of areas including trade, investment, education, food and agriculture, and research and development.

Since the visit of President Xi to Ireland, 8 members of Government in addition to the Taoiseach and myself have visited China, with a similar number of Chinese Ministers visiting Ireland. At present, I do not have plans to return to China (for which an invitation would be required). The Chinese Premier, Li Keqiang, is not currently scheduled to visit Ireland.

The Government will continue to seek to develop and expand Ireland’s bilateral relationship with China in a mutually beneficial way.

Human Rights Issues

Questions (114)

Seán Crowe

Question:

114. Deputy Seán Crowe asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if his attention has been drawn to the recent ruling in the European Court of Human Rights case (details supplied) which ruled that the Spanish Government, through the so-called Parot Doctrine, has kept a large number of Basque political prisoners in detention despite the fact that they should have been released years ago; if his further attention has been drawn to the fact that this is affecting 76 long-term Basque prisoners; and the steps he will take to ensure Spain rectifies its actions and fulfils its legal duties as a party to the European Convention on Human Rights. [45735/13]

View answer

Written answers

I am aware of the ruling of the European Court of Human Rights on 21 October in the case of Inés del Río v Spain regarding eligibility for sentence reduction. The relevant Spanish authorities will assess the full implications of the ECHR judgement and will consider the actions that are required in light of the ruling. In the circumstances, it would not be appropriate for me to become involved in the matter.

UN Resolutions

Questions (115)

Patrick Nulty

Question:

115. Deputy Patrick Nulty asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade the reason Ireland abstained from the 2010 United Nations General Assembly vote to adopt a declaration on the right to water; if his attention has been drawn to the declaration that states the right to safe and clean drinking water and sanitation as a human right that is essential for the full enjoyment of life and all human rights; if he will outline in detail the objections Ireland had to this declaration; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [45747/13]

View answer

Written answers

The 7th session of United Nations Human Rights Council in March 2008 adopted by consensus a Resolution (7/22) which recognised the existence of human rights obligations relating to access to safe drinking water and sanitation. Ireland actively supported this Resolution and was amongst those United Nations member states which co-sponsored it.

Ireland actively engaged in the negotiations at the 64th session of the United Nations General Assembly in July 2010 which led to the adoption of a Resolution on the ‘human right to water and sanitation’ (Resolution 64/292). Ireland supported suggestions put forward by the EU that, in our view, would have both resulted in a more balanced text and allowed the General Assembly to reach consensus on this issue. Unfortunately, on this occasion, many of the EU suggestions were not taken into consideration.

The Bolivian-led resolution bypassed the United Nations Human Rights Council process in Geneva and risked introducing division where consensus should have been sought. Following careful consideration it was decided that Ireland could not support in its entirety the final Bolivian text presented to the General Assembly. On 28 July 2010 the Resolution was adopted following a recorded vote of 122 votes in favour, none against and 41 abstentions. Ireland, along with 17 of our European Union partners, abstained from voting on this Resolution.

Ireland continues to actively engage in discussions within the international community on access to safe drinking water and sanitation, including at the 21st session of the United Nations Human Rights Council in September 2012, which adopted a resolution on ‘the human right to safe drinking water and sanitation’. Ireland co-sponsored this Resolution.

Ireland agrees in principle that all persons, wherever located, should have access to clean drinking water and sanitation facilities and remains convinced that the only manner in which to achieve real progress on access to safe drinking water and sanitation is to maintain consensus within the international community.

Ireland remains fully committed to the achievement of the Millennium Development Goal of reducing by half, by 2015, the proportion of people without sustainable access to safe drinking water and sanitation. In 2012, Ireland allocated over €5 million in support to water and sanitation activities to improve availability of services and to address the structural causes of exclusion from access to water and sanitation services.

Diplomatic Representation Expenditure

Questions (116)

Clare Daly

Question:

116. Deputy Clare Daly asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade further to Parliamentary Question No. 68 of 17 October 2013 in relation to the payment of allowances to embassy and consular staff abroad, the guidelines under which a decision is made whether or not to refund the cost of items purchased by officers under this scheme; if there is an asset register of items purchased under this scheme; if this scheme applies to officers who are on temporary secondment to the Department of Foreign Affairs; and if a mechanism exists for recovering equipment and furniture purchased under this scheme or if the officer may retain these items for private use on conclusion of the officer's posting abroad and re-assignment to a position in here. [45931/13]

View answer

Written answers

As outlined in the reply to Question No. 68 of 17 October 2013, the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade provides financial assistance to officers going on posting abroad towards the cost of representational furniture and equipment. In this context, official representation refers to work-related events, official functions and networking opportunities held in the homes of officers on posting as part of their official duties. The scheme covers a small range of items which are necessary to provide a suitable home environment for the purposes of official representation, with particular regard to the representational areas of an officer’s residence. It is governed by detailed internal guidelines, which I would be happy to make available to the Deputy on request. Access to the scheme may also be granted by the parent Department of officers temporarily seconded to the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade on a case-by-case basis. The amount provided ranges from €2,000-€4,000 depending on the officer’s grade. It may be paid only in respect of an officer’s first posting. The items purchased may be retained by the officer for use during future postings and details of those items are also kept on file. A total of €64,268 was refunded to officers in 2012.

Military Aircraft Landings

Questions (117)

Seán Crowe

Question:

117. Deputy Seán Crowe asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade further to Parliamentary Question No. 6 of 15 October 2013, if the US military aircraft that recently landed at Shannon Airport with a fixed weapon was a Hercules AC-130W; if he will confirm the type of fixed weapon it had; and if there were any other ammunitions, including depleted uranium munitions, on board. [45933/13]

View answer

Written answers

As outlined in this House on 15 October 2013, I am aware that one US military aircraft recently landed in Shannon Airport armed with a fixed weapon and therefore did not comply with the normal conditions that apply to foreign military aircraft overflying or landing in Ireland. I am not in a position to provide further information on the aircraft in question.

A longstanding system for dealing with requests for landings by US military aircraft at Shannon is in place and is being fully implemented. The Government views breaches of the conditions attached to permission for such landings with the utmost seriousness and the case in question was raised at the highest possible level with the US Embassy. The Embassy official expressed regret at this isolated incident, explained that it was due to an administrative error and provided assurances that steps had been taken by the US authorities to prevent any recurrence.

Diplomatic Representation

Questions (118)

Michael Healy-Rae

Question:

118. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade the reason the original plaques on the entrance to the Villa Spada have been removed and replaced with new plaques; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [46075/13]

View answer

Written answers

Following the closure of the Embassy to the Holy See in November 2011, the Embassy to Italy and the residence of the Ambassador to Italy were relocated to the State owned Villa Spada, formerly occupied by the Embassy to the Holy See. The change of plaques represents the change of designation of the building.

Diplomatic Representation

Questions (119)

Michael Healy-Rae

Question:

119. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if he will agree to a meeting with representatives from an organisation (details supplied); and if he will make a statement on the matter. [46076/13]

View answer

Written answers

In November 2011, the Government announced its decision to close Ireland’s Embassy to the Holy See. This decision was driven by economic factors deriving from our need to cut public expenditure and focus the modest resources of our diplomatic service on economic recovery.

The closure of the resident embassy to the Holy See has yielded substantial savings as it enabled the significantly larger embassy to Italy, and the residence of the ambassador to Italy, to be relocated to the State-owned Villa Spada, which was formerly occupied by the embassy to the Holy See, thereby saving €445,000 per annum in rent on two properties.

Since then, the organisation to which the Deputy refers has written to me on a number of occasions outlining its opposition to the closure of the Embassy and seeking a meeting to discuss its re-instatement. In response, I have assured the organisation that its views have been noted and have, in turn, set out the Government’s position in relation to the closure of the Embassy. I have advised the organisation that the Embassy to the Holy See will not be re-opened in the immediate term.

I do not believe that it would be helpful, at this point in time, to meet the organisation to discuss the matter.

Ministerial Appointments

Questions (120)

Róisín Shortall

Question:

120. Deputy Róisín Shortall asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade the name, qualifications and current salary of each political staff member appointed by him. [46088/13]

View answer

Written answers

The information requested by the Deputy is set out in the table below.

Name

Position Held

Qualifications (where stated)

Annual Salary

Mark Garrett

Chief Adviser - Office of the Tánaiste

Postgraduate Dip in EU Competition Law, Masters in Communications, BA in History & Politics

€156,380

Colm O’Reardon

Economic Adviser – Office of the Tánaiste

First Class Honours Degree in Economics, M. Phil in Economics, D. Phil in Economics

€144,550

Jean O’Mahony

Special Adviser – Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade

MSC Econ in International Affairs

€81,676

Niamh Sweeney

Special Adviser – Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade

BA in European Studies, MA in Journalism, MA in Business & Economic Journalism

€75,647

Doreen Foley

Personal Assistant – Office of the Tánaiste

_

€56,060

Karen Griffin

Personal Assistant – Constituency office

Certificate in Managing Organisations in the Voluntary Sector, BA Hons in Drama and Theatre Studies

€56,060

Anne Coleman

Personal Secretary – Constituency office

_

€45,939

Foreign Conflicts

Questions (121)

Maureen O'Sullivan

Question:

121. Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade his response to the ongoing charging of persons for their membership of political parties banned in the Basque; if he has engaged with Spanish officials on their lack of engagement in a peaceful process of resolution to the conflict instead of increasing its repression on political membership and protest activity by individuals; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [46168/13]

View answer

Written answers

I have closely followed developments in relation to the Basque Country since the declaration by ETA on 20 October 2011 that the organisation had “decided on the definitive cessation of its armed activity”. The Government continues to support all efforts to achieve a definitive peace in the Basque Country and I hope that further progress can be made based on democratic principles and the rule of law.

European Council Meetings

Questions (122)

Andrew Doyle

Question:

122. Deputy Andrew Doyle asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if he will discuss the outcomes of the Foreign Affairs Council meeting that took place in October 2013; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [46263/13]

View answer

Written answers

I attended the most recent meeting of the Foreign Affairs Council (FAC) which took place in Luxembourg on 21 October. As the Deputy will be aware, this was the first formal Council meeting of EU Foreign Ministers since late August. A wide range of issues were discussed and important Conclusions were agreed across a number of key policy areas; these Conclusions may be accessed on the official EU website http://www.consilium.europa.eu/ueDocs/cms_Data/docs/pressData/EN/foraff/139093.pdf.

In her opening remarks, High Representative (HR) Ashton gave Ministers a brief overview of recent developments in Iran (latest round of nuclear talks), the Western Balkans (update on the Serbia-Kosovo dialogue and on the current situation in Bosnia and Herzegovina) and the Maldives (elections).

The first item for substantive discussion was the Eastern Partnership, where Ministers took stock of preparations for the Summit in Vilnius later this month (28-29 November). This Summit will mark an important step forward in the Union’s relationship with its Eastern neighbours. There was broad support amongst partners for the initialling of Association Agreements with Georgia and Moldova in Vilnius. In addition there was an exchange of views on the progress achieved to date by Ukraine to enable the signing of the Association Agreement at the Summit; this was also the subject of an informal ministerial level breakfast meeting between members of the Council and Ukraine which I attended immediately before the FAC. I joined with my EU counterparts in welcoming the advances made to date by Ukraine in implementing key reforms and underlined the importance of further progress towards achieving the benchmarks.

Under the Southern Neighbourhood agenda item, discussions focused on recent developments in Egypt, Syria and Libya; I will address each point separately.

On Egypt, HR Ashton updated Ministers on her recent visit to the region. The situation remains tense and many partners – myself included – highlighted concerns related to the security situation generally, the repression of the political opposition, the detention of political prisoners and the treatment of religious minorities. During my intervention, I specifically raised Ireland’s concern for the four Irish nationals who remain in detention in Egypt. While appreciating Egyptian security concerns in relation to the Sinai, I also expressed concern about the impact on the worsening humanitarian situation in Gaza. Conclusions were adopted on a report of the Court of Auditors concerning EU Co-operation with Egypt in the field of governance.

Ministers discussed developments in Libya with a focus on the security situation, related migration issues and the recent horrific drowning of some 500 people off the island of Lampedusa. Partners expressed sorrow for the tragic loss of life and we also conveyed our support for the rescue workers operating in extremely challenging circumstances.

Ministers reviewed developments in relation to Syria with particular reference to the OPCW chemical weapons disarmament process, the prospects for the ‘Geneva II’ talks and the ever-challenging humanitarian situation. While welcoming the encouraging progress made in recent weeks on the disarmament issue, the Council underlined the need to maintain the momentum behind the ‘Geneva II’ process and to prioritise the alleviation of the humanitarian suffering. I took the opportunity to echo these concerns in my intervention, voicing Ireland’s continuing support for Joint Special Representative Brahimi and informing partners of Ireland’s contribution of €200,000 to the OPCW disarmament efforts. The FAC adopted Conclusions which emphasised the need for a political solution to the crisis in Syria and for safe and unhindered humanitarian access to all populations in need of assistance throughout the country. The EU is the largest international donor of assistance to the Syrian people and Ireland, for its part, has contributed a total of €13.8m to date.

Finally, Ministers also discussed recent developments in Myanmar/Burma. HR Ashton briefed us on the progress of the EU Taskforce and the preparations for her visit there this month. Over lunch, the FAC met with Nobel Peace Prize laureate and opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi. Discussions focused on how the EU might best support democratic reforms in Myanmar/Burma. For my part, I emphasised in my remarks, Ireland’s commitment to step up assistance to Myanmar/Burma in the context of our new programme of support, the details of which I hope to finalise in the weeks ahead.

Diplomatic Representation Expenditure

Questions (123)

Jerry Buttimer

Question:

123. Deputy Jerry Buttimer asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade the number of Irish embassies and diplomatic missions in use; the number of staff assigned to each mission; the costs of operating same; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [46855/13]

View answer

Written answers

Ireland’s diplomatic network includes 56 Embassies, 7 multilateral missions and 10 Consulates General and other offices. In addition to their country of residence, many Ambassadors are also accredited to additional countries on a concurrent basis which enhances the cost-effectiveness of our external representation.

Our missions abroad work very closely with the state agencies in the promotion of exports, tourism and inward investment. They perform also a wide range of functions in support of Ireland’s foreign policy interests. These include representing and advancing government policies with other states and in international organisations, in particular the EU and the UN; economic, trade and cultural promotion; frontline consular and passport services to citizens overseas; engaging with and supporting Irish communities, and managing Ireland’s overseas development programmes in Ireland’s key partner countries.

The figures provided in the table below for our overseas missions include both Vote 28 - Foreign Affairs and Trade and Vote 27 - International Co-operation. The effective implementation of the aid programme necessarily entails additional management and oversight costs which are included in the figures provided. In addition to 25 locally recruited core staff, in the region of 180 locally-employed staff are engaged on the development co-operation side to meet technical requirements in specific programme areas. The numbers of such staff in each mission at any time varies in accordance with programme requirements.

Mission

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade Officers posted from HQ

Locally engaged (including agency) administrative, clerical and other support staff

Budget Allocation 2013

1 Assistant Secretary

Abu Dhabi

1 Third Secretary

4

428,968

1 Counsellor

Abuja

1 Third Secretary

5

309,070

1 Counsellor

2 Development Specialist

1 Higher Executive Officer

Addis Ababa

1 Junior Professional Intern

4

477,059

1 Assistant Secretary

1 Assistant Principal Officer

Ankara

1 Third Secretary

4

438,195

1 Counsellor

1 First Secretary

Athens

1 Higher Executive Officer

5.3*

466,534

Atlanta

1 First Secretary

1

175,731

1 Assistant Secretary

1 First Secretary

Beijing

1 Third Secretary

12

931,142

1 Second Secretary General

3 First Secretary/APO

Berlin

1 Third Secretary

6

950,225

1 Assistant Secretary

Berne

1 Third Secretary

3

496,260

1 First Secretary

Boston

1 Third Secretary

3

424,996

1 Counsellor

Brasilia

1 Third Secretary

4

569,663

Bratislava

1 First Secretary

2

281,327

1 Counsellor

1 First Secretary

1 Higher Executive Officer

Brussels

(Embassy – including PfP representation)

1 Clerical Officer

4

1,034,224

2 Assistant Secretary

2 Counsellor

11 First Secretary/APO

2 Third Secretary

1 Higher Executive Officer

2 Executive Officer

Brussels

(Permanent Representation to the European Union)

17 Clerical Officer

6

3,669,434

1 Assistant Secretary

Bucharest

1 First Secretary

5

494,007

1 Counsellor

Budapest

1 Third Secretary

4

460,199

1 Counsellor

Buenos Aires

1 Third Secretary

3.4*

408,638

1 Counsellor

1 Assistant Principal Officer

Cairo

1 Third Secretary

6

433,008

1 Counsellor

Canberra

1 First Secretary

7.1*

941,323

1 First Secretary

Chicago

1 Third Secretary

3.4*

358,286

1 Second Secretary General

Copenhagen

1 Third Secretary

4.4*

437,810

1 Principal Development Specialist

1 Senior Development Specialist

2 Development Specialist

1 Higher Executive Officer

Dar-Es-Salaam

1 Junior Professional Intern

3

871,975

1 First Secretary

Edinburgh

1 Clerical Officer

1

261,803

1 Development Specialist

Freetown

1 Third Secretary

1

273,750

1 Assistant Secretary

4 First Secretary

2 Third Secretary

1 Executive Officer

1 Junior Professional Intern

2 Interns

Geneva

(Permanent Mission to the United Nations)

(Including temporary extra staff relating to Ireland’s membership of the UN Human Rights Council)

1 Clerical Officer

3.5*

1,517,915

1 Counsellor

1 Senior Development Specialist

1 Development Specialist

1 Third Secretary

Hanoi

1 Clerical Officer

3

602,000

1 Counsellor

Helsinki

1 Third Secretary

3

534,468

(Ambassador post currently vacant)

1 Senior Development Specialist

Kampala

1 Third Secretary

4

1,526,980

1 Assistant Secretary

Kuala Lumpur

1 Third Secretary

5.5*

418,108

1 Principal Development Specialist

1 Senior Development Specialist

1 Third Secretary

Lilongwe

1 Junior Professional Intern

1

543,420

1 Counsellor

Lisbon

1 Third Secretary

3

429,263

1 Counsellor

Ljubljana

1 Third Secretary

3

424,662

1 Assistant Secretary

2 Counsellor

3 First Secretary/APO

2 Third Secretary

2 Higher Executive Officer

4 Executive Officer

2 Staff Officer

London (including Passport office)

8 Clerical Officer

13.5*

3,275,415

1 Principal Officer

1 Development Specialist

1 Third Secretary

Lusaka

1 Junior Professional Intern

3

1,103,200

Luxembourg

1 First Secretary

4

406,978

1 Assistant Secretary

1 First Secretary

Madrid

1 Third Secretary

10

1,026,844

1 Counsellor

1 Senior Development Specialist

2 Development Specialist

1 Third Secretary

Maputo

1 Junior Professional Intern

3

996,701

1 Counsellor

Maseru

1 Senior Development Specialist

2

561,510

1 Counsellor

1 First Secretary

Mexico

1 Third Secretary

5

487,952

1 Assistant Secretary

1 First Secretary

1 Third Secretary

Moscow

2 Clerical Officer

9

799,665

1 Counsellor

1 First Secretary

New Delhi

1 Third Secretary

6

971,196

1 Counsellor

1 First Secretary

1 Third Secretary

New York - Consulate General

1 Executive Officer

12

1,927,749

1 Assistant Secretary

1 Counsellor

4 First Secretary

2 Third Secretary

New York

(Permanent Mission to the United Nations)

1 Executive Officer

6

1,936,417

Nicosia

1 First Secretary

3

274,940

1 Counsellor

Oslo

1 Third Secretary

3

650,895

1 Assistant Secretary

1 First Secretary

Ottawa

1 Third Secretary

5

647,313

1 Assistant Secretary

1 Counsellor

3 First Secretary

Paris incl.

the Permanent Mission to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development and UNESCO)

2 Third Secretary

14

1,720,595

1 Counsellor

Prague

1 Higher Executive Officer

5

561,301

1 Assistant Secretary

2 First Secretary

Pretoria

1 Third Secretary

8

1,000,658

1 Counsellor

Ramallah

1 Third Secretary

4

422,301

Riga

1 First Secretary

2

191,834

1 Counsellor

Riyadh

1 Third Secretary

8

353,892

1 Deputy Secretary

Rome

1 First Secretary

8.8*

1,007,897

1 First Secretary

San Francisco

1 Third Secretary

3

371,898

1 Counsellor

Seoul

1 Third Secretary

4

806,580

1 Counsellor

1 Third Secretary

Shanghai

1 Clerical Officer

4

613,519

1 Assistant Secretary

Singapore

1 Third Secretary

4

891,147

1 Counsellor

Sofia

1 Higher Executive Officer

4

393,879

1 Counsellor

Stockholm

1 Third Secretary

3

568,195

1 Assistant Secretary

1 Third Secretary

Strasbourg

1 Intern

3

415,255

1 First Secretary

Sydney

1 Third Secretary

3

747,491

Tallinn

1 First Secretary

2

401,716

1 Assistant Secretary

Tel Aviv

1 First Secretary

3.5*

694,147

1 Assistant Secretary

1 Assistant Principal

The Hague

1 Third Secretary

5

772,325

1 Assistant Secretary

1 First Secretary

1 Third Secretary

Tokyo

7

1,391,689

Valletta

1 First Secretary

2

337,661

1 Assistant Secretary

1 First Secretary

Vienna (Embassy)

1 Third Secretary

5

695,595

1 Assistant Secretary

Vienna

(Permanent Mission to the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe)

1 First Secretary

3

464,175

1 Counsellor

Vilnius

1 Third Secretary

3

351,944

1 Assistant Secretary

1 First Secretary

Warsaw

1 Third Secretary

4

777,827

1 Deputy Secretary

1 Counsellor

3 First Secretary

1 Third Secretary

1 Executive Officer

Washington DC

1 Clerical Officer

8

1,148,202

The above table does not include Consulates headed by Honorary Consuls, the staff of which are not employees of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade.

*Full Time Equivalent – this number takes account of officers on work-sharing arrangements.

Question No. 124 answered with Question No. 113.

Overseas Development Aid Issues

Questions (125)

Patrick O'Donovan

Question:

125. Deputy Patrick O'Donovan asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if he has examined the reduction in overseas aid budgets of other troika programme or bailout countries; his views on whether the scale of the Irish overseas aid budget is proportionate to our means in comparison to our EU colleagues; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [47015/13]

View answer

Written answers

The Government is strongly committed to Ireland’s overseas aid programme and to its place at the heart of Irish foreign policy. The programme reflects the values of the Irish people and is a concrete expression of our determination to help those less fortunate than ourselves. Our new policy on international development - One World, One Future - maintains the Government’s focus on assisting the poorest countries and communities, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, renews the focus of the programme in terms of our trading and economic interest with the developing world, and reconfirms the Government’s commitment to achieving the UN target of providing 0.7% of GNP for Official Development Assistance (ODA) when economic circumstances permit.

Over the past three years, despite the very difficult economic circumstances facing the country, the unprecedented demands on the exchequer and the imperative to reduce the fiscal imbalance in the public finances, this Government has managed to largely stabilise our ODA budget. This must be seen as a very significant achievement, particularly in light of the challenging budgetary constraints we faced in that period. It represents a clear demonstration of the Government’s commitment to the international aid programme.

The most recent data published by the OECD Development Assistance Committee relates to aid flows for 2012 and shows that ODA budgets across many donors are under some pressure as Governments have reduced spending in response to the financial crisis. However, the data also clearly shows that Ireland continued to be a generous donor by international standards.

US Surveillance in EU Institutions

Questions (126, 127)

Brendan Smith

Question:

126. Deputy Brendan Smith asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade the actions he has taken in response to the alleged surveillance of government and civilian communications in Europe by US authorities; if he has established if any such surveillance took place here; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [47025/13]

View answer

Brendan Smith

Question:

127. Deputy Brendan Smith asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade further to Parliamentary Question No. 24 of 2 October 2013, if he will provide any subsequent information regarding and arising from his response and the Topical Issue raised on 2 July in Dáil Éireann; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [47026/13]

View answer

Written answers

I propose to take Questions Nos. 126 and 127 together.

Following allegations of US surveillance of European Union institutions earlier this year, the EU has engaged regularly with the US authorities in both Washington and Brussels to seek clarification on the issues raised.

An EU-US High Level Expert Group on data protection has been established, where this and related matters are discussed. The EU is represented on this working group by the European Commission, the Presidency of the Council and the European External Action Service (EEAS), and the work of the group is ongoing. A number of meetings have already taken place in Brussels and in Washington. The next meeting is expected to take place on 6 November in Brussels. Following this work, the Commission and the Presidency are expected to issue a public, factual report which will be followed by an assessment and recommendations before the end of the year.

As regards the allegations of spying on EU delegations, High Representative Catherine Ashton raised EU concerns directly with US Secretary of State John Kerry and National Security Advisor Susan Rice on several occasions. I understand that more contacts at various levels have been established since to further discuss the allegations and obtain clarifications on the surveillance activities undertaken by the US with regard to EU delegations.

At their European Council meeting of 24/25 October last, EU Heads of State and Government issued a statement on the more recent developments concerning possible intelligence issues and the deep concerns that these events have raised among European citizens. They underlined the close relationship between Europe and the United States and the value of that partnership. They expressed their conviction that the partnership must be based on respect and trust, including as regards the work and co-operation of secret services.

For our part, and as I have outlined in a reply to a previous parliamentary question, the Government’s concerns have been conveyed bilaterally in contacts with the US Embassy in Dublin. While the House will appreciate that it is not the practice to comment in detail on surveillance and security issues and that the Minister for Justice and Equality has primary responsibility in this area, we do not have any information that would indicate that surveillance took place here in Ireland. I wish to reiterate that any such surveillance here would be unacceptable to us.

Top
Share