Skip to main content
Normal View

National Broadband Plan Expenditure

Dáil Éireann Debate, Thursday - 18 October 2018

Thursday, 18 October 2018

Questions (249)

Catherine Murphy

Question:

249. Deputy Catherine Murphy asked the Minister for Communications, Climate Action and Environment if the amounts expended on the national broadband plan from the appropriation accounts of 2015, 2016 and 2017 are the total amounts spent to date on the project; if he will provide a schedule of all payments made to date on this project by year and companies paid and or services engaged; the overall expenditure to date; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [43080/18]

View answer

Written answers

Expenditure on the National Broadband Plan was first incurred in 2013. 

The total expenditure to date since then is approximately €22.2 million. This expenditure includes the cost of corporate finance and economic advice, technical support and network design, the cost of legal advice, environmental advice and process auditor costs.  These services were procured by way of competitive tender. 

In addition, the Department also has staff and other administrative costs, along with travel and expenses costs for independent Steering Group members and event costs related to the NBP.  The following table sets out payments by year.

Total spend by Year

Year

Cost

2013

€394,507.01

2014

€681,326.58

2015

€2,978,462.99

2016

€2,345,659.49

2017

€10,050,457.78

2018

€5,745,111.99

TOTAL

€22,195,525.84

All figures include VAT

The schedule of companies paid and services engaged by year is also included.

A schedule of payments made to date on the NBP is set out in the following tables for each year, specifying the companies paid and the services engaged.

Schedule of NBP Payments in 2013

Company/Payee Name

Services Provided

Cost

PRISA Technologies Ltd T/A Prisa Consulting

Technical, commercial, economic, financial and procurement advice

€323,491.23

Transport Infrastructure Ireland

Staff secondment

€67,899.16

Word Perfect Translation Services Limited

Translation services

€3,116.62

TOTAL for 2013

€394,507.01

Schedule of NBP Payments in 2014

Company/Payee Name

Services Provided

Cost

AVC Ltd

Audio visual services

€2,257.05

Clever Cat Design

Design and branding services

€12,346.70

D4 Catering 4. U.

Catering

€231.08

Strategic Scout Ltd

Steering Group costs

€6,101.07

Kieran Clancy Photography

Photography

€346.86

Mason Hayes and Curran

Legal advisory services

€12,286.22

Mespil Hotel

Steering Group costs

€423.50

National Adult Literacy Agency Ltd ( NALA )

Literacy advisory services

€854.29

Park Town Consulting

Policy advisory services

€6,089.25

PRISA Technologies Ltd T/A Prisa Consulting

Technical, commercial, economic, financial and procurement advice

€494,981.54

Consultant A (Anonymsed under GDPR)

Steering Group costs

€4,195.07

Tony Harris Design

Design services

€2,324.70

Transport Infrastructure Ireland

Staff secondment

€109,417.11

Vilicom Engineering Ltd

Technical advisory services

€25,184.68

W1 Design

Design services

€4,287.46

TOTAL for 2014

€681,326.58

Schedule of NBP Payments in 2015

Company/Payee Name

Services Provided

Cost

Analysys Mason

Technical advisory services

€449,210.01

Buswells Hotel

Steering Group costs

€958.40

Café Sol

Catering

€434.02

Club Travel Ltd

Travel costs

€1,747.95

Department for Digital, Culture Media & Sport

Steering Group costs

€100.65

Doyle Kent Planning Partnership Ltd

Environmental advisory services

€7,995.00

Dublin Chamber Of Commerce

Steering Group costs

€832.60

Strategic Scout Ltd

Steering Group costs

€15,997.32

Consultant B (Anonymised under GDPR)

Process auditor for legal tender evaluation

€4,458.75

KPMG

Financial and procurement advisory services

€729,831.57

Mason Hayes and Curran

Legal advisory services

€339,615.23

Mediavest Ltd

Newspaper publication costs

€4,646.89

Mespil Hotel

Steering Group costs

€922.00

PricewaterhouseCoopers

Economic and strategic advisory services

€1,040,440.67

PRISA Technologies Ltd T/A Prisa Consulting

Technical, commercial, economic, financial and procurement advice

€302,020.35

Consultant A (Anonymised under GDPR)

Steering Group costs

€8,305.18

Transport Infrastructure Ireland

Staff secondment

€69,629.07

Vilicom Engineering Ltd

Technical advisory services

€1,317.33

TOTAL for 2015

€2,978,462.99

Schedule of NBP Payments in 2016

Company/Payee Name

Services Provided

Cost

Analysys Mason

Technical advisory services

€556,924.82

Club Travel Ltd

Travel costs

€422.48

Deloitte

Tax and VAT advice

€5,412.00

Department for Digital, Culture Media & Sport

Steering Group costs

€441.91

Doggett Group

Design and print services

€4,314.84

Elaine Tohill Ltd T/A Press

Catering - bidder dialogue

€7,512.00

Here and Now Business Intelligence

Communications advisory services

€7,380.00

Hilton Dublin (Charlemont Hotels Group Ltd )

Meeting room hire

€470.00

Strategic Scout Ltd

Steering Group costs

€591.15

KPMG

Financial and procurement advisory services

€513,409.38

KPMG

Specialist personnel

€585,206.33

Mason Hayes and Curran

Legal advisory services

€456,505.65

Pricewaterhouse Coopers

Economic and strategic advisory services

€143,145.58

PRISA Technologies Ltd T/A Prisa Consulting

Technical, commercial, economic, financial and procurement advice

€11,070.00

Public Affairs Ireland

Training course

€362.85

RPS Consulting Engineers

Environmental advisory services

€27,312.15

T Kilmartin & Sons

Design and print services

€178.35

The Irish Farmers Association

National Ploughing Championships 2015 costs

€25,000.00

TOTAL for 2016

€2,345,659.49

Schedule of NBP Payments in 2017

Company/Payee Name

Services Provided

Cost

Achilles Procurement Services

Procurement advisory services

€5,166.00

Analysys Mason

Technical advisory services

€1,302,540.54

Andrew Fox Photography

Photography

€450.00

Bernard Coyle Enterprises

Event costs

€1,353.00

Café Sol

Catering

€104.01

Club Travel Ltd

Travel costs

€38.94

Commerce Decisions Limited

Tender evaluation tool

€41,294.10

Deloitte

Tax and VAT advice

€16,236.00

Doggett Group

Design and printing services

€942.18

Elaine Tohill Ltd T/A Press

Catering

€5,602.80

Here and Now Business Intelligence

Communications advisory services

€5,904.00

Hilton Dublin (Charlemont Hotels Group Ltd )

Meeting room hire

€1,282.00

Strategic Scout Ltd

Steering Group costs

€6,317.73

Consultant C (Anonymised under GDPR)

Independent Chair costs

€5,000.00

KPMG

Financial and procurement advisory services

€3,342,817.76

KPMG

Specialist personnel

€1,434,957.98

Consultant D (Anonymised under GDPR)

Communications advisory services

€4,305.00

Consultant E (Anonymised under GDPR)

Procurement board costs

€1,932.63

Mason Hayes and Curran

Legal advisory services

€3,003,411.09

Maxwell Photography

Photography

€499.38

Mespil Hotel

Steering Group costs

€109.65

Consultant E (Anonymised under GDPR)

Independent Chair costs

€3,546.90

Pembroke Hall Limited

Meeting room hire

€254.61

Peter Smyth Management Consultancy Ltd

Process auditor costs

€1,968.00

PricewaterhouseCoopers

Economic and strategic advisory services

€759,926.73

Consultant A (Anonymised under GDPR)

Steering Group costs

€2,082.45

Quigg Golden

Independent Chair costs

€1,650.00

RPS Consulting Engineers

Environmental advisory services

€43,190.22

Shearwater Hotel

Event costs

€1,154.85

The Gap Partnership Ltd

Specialist training

€27,378.93

Think Media Limited

Design and printing services

€29,040.30

TOTAL for 2017

€10,050,457.78

Schedule of NBP Payments in 2018 (to date)

Company/Payee Name

Services Provided

Cost

Analysys Mason

Technical advisory services

€1,115,387.37

Bank of Ireland Visa (Department credit card)

Administrative procurement process costs (PMO)

€310.97

Club Travel Ltd

Travel costs

€1,493.96

Deloitte

Tax and VAT advice

€24,354.00

Department for Digital, Culture Media & Sport

Steering Group costs

€250.50

Doggett Group

Design and printing services

€510.45

Elaine Tohill Ltd T/A Press

Catering - bidder dialogue

€849.00

Here and Now Business Intelligence

Communications advisory services

€16,236.00

Strategic Scout Ltd

Steering Group costs

€6,941.94

Consultant C (Anonymised under GDPR)

Independent Chair costs

€2,000.00

KPMG

Financial and procurement advisory services

€2,497,834.80

KPMG

Specialist personnel

€902,993.92

Marsh Ireland

Insurance advice

€11,531.25

Mason Hayes and Curran

Legal advisory services

€1,021,850.64

Mediavest Ltd

Newspaper publication costs – public consultation

€9,736.89

Patrick Ring

Independent Chair costs

€7,500.00

Pembroke Hall Limited

Meeting room hire

€444.22

Peter Smyth Management Consultancy Ltd

Process auditor costs

€7,872.00

PricewaterhouseCoopers

Economic and strategic advisory services

€75,031.93

Consultant A (Anonymised under GDPR)

Steering Group costs

€4,264.20

Professor Martin Cave

Telecommunications regulatory advice

€6,150.00

Quigg Golden

Independent Chair costs

€602.70

RPS Consulting Engineers

Environmental advisory services

€30,965.25

TOTAL for 2018

€5,745,111.99

Top
Share