Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Thursday, 5 May 1994

Vol. 442 No. 4

Adjournment Debate. - UN Mandate in Rwanda.

I thank the Chair for allowing me to raise this matter and the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs for coming in to reply.

In a world where our sense of outrage has become dulled by the endless cycle of death and destruction portrayed on our television screens: sectarian murders on our own doorstep in Northern Ireland, ethnic cleansing and countless local regional conflicts in Bosnia, the sheer scale and viciousness of the killings in Rwanda still chills the heart. The murder of 21 children and 13 Red Cross volunteers at the weekend is part of the much wider and more horrifying picture.

Since the present phase of violence erupted after the death of the President of Rwanda in a mysterious plane crash on 6 April 1994, some 200,000 people have been killed, many in the most appallingly cruel circumstances. Close to 500,000 have been forced to leave the country and almost two million people have been left homeless. It has been described by the international aid agency OXFAM as the worst humanitarian crisis since the killing fields of Cambodia in the 1970s. The people of Cambodia were largely abandoned by the international community and left to their terrible fate and the same cannot be allowed to happen to the people of Rwanda. The international community, through the United Nations, must act to stop further violence and provide aid for those who are suffering.

The roots of the conflict are complex. It is not simply a tribal conflict as suggested in the European media. It has more to do with politics and grinding poverty than with tribal allegiance. There is no doubt, however, that the principal victims on this occasion are the minority Tutsi tribe who have suffered most of the casualties and comprise the majority of the refugees.

There has been an unfortunate history of violent conflict in this central African country of eight million people. When the violence escalated at the beginning of April there was already a small UN force, the United Nations Assistance Mission for Rwanda, UNAMIR. The UN had 2,000 troops which operated a very limited mandate, but astonishingly in spite of the slaughter in the country the Security Council decided to reduce troop strength to 270. The UN troops had been providing protection for approximately 16,000 people who had taken refuge in special sites and such a drastically reduced force could not continue to provide protection, never mind offer hope to the hundreds of thousands at risk.

I understand that the Secretary General is due to report to the Security Council by tomorrow. It is essential that Ireland exerts all possible pressure on the United Nations to act. The fact that the genocide is thousands of miles away and that the colour of the victims' skin is black does not lessen our moral obligation to act. I know in calling for United Nations intervention we may be asked to back this up by providing Irish troops. Given the scale of the violence we should be prepared to make this commitment although it may be more appropriate to have a peacekeeping force comprising troops from other African countries. Irish troops served with distinction more than 30 years ago in the then Congo and helped to end the violence there. In spite of the clear risks involved I am sure there will be no shortage of volunteers in the Defence Forces who will be prepared to serve with the UN in Rwanda, if this is considered necessary. If we are to halt the violence, the United Nations Security Council under the authority of Chapter 7 of the Charter must immediately increase the mandate and strength of UNAMIR and bring all possible pressure to bear on the combatants to meet to negotiate a ceasefire, to provide for the free passage of relief supplies, to provide safety guarantees for both the international and national humanitarian efforts and provide for the free movement of citizens who seek refuge in neighbouring countries.

There is also an urgent need to provide financial and humanitarian aid to neighbouring countries such as Tanzania and Burundi which have to cope with the huge influx of refugees and are in danger of being overwhelmed by the scale of the problem. The Dáil should be asked, if necessary, to agree to a Supplementary Estimate to increase the allocation for overseas development aid so that we can provide some of the assistance that is badly needed.

There is also an urgent need to address the question of how outbreaks of violence such as this can be prevented. We need to address the policies that are being pursued by international financial agencies and world trading policies which, in many instances, are driving states such as Rwanda into abject poverty which is the breeding ground for this kind of violence.

I am grateful to the Deputy for raising this matter. The reports of the conflict and associated atrocities in Rwanda are among the most horrific I have seen. Since the killings of the Presidents of Rwanda and Burundi on 6 April almost 200,000 have been reported killed and more than 400,000 have fled to neighbouring countries, mainly to Tanzania. The flight of refugees from Rwanda is the largest and fastest that the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees has ever seen.

The United Nations has informed us that the capital city, Kigali, is effectively divided into sectors controlled by the Rwandan Government forces and the Rwandan Patriotic Front, with frequent exchanges of artillery and mortar fire between the two sides. Attacks on defenceless civilians have occurred throughout the country especially in areas under the control of the members or supporters of the armed forces of the interim Government of Rwanda. Some of these have been the work of uncontrolled military personnel but most have been perpetrated by armed groups of civilians taking advantage of the complete breakdown of law and order. The United Nations force in Rwanda, UNAMIR, reports strong evidence of preparations for further massacres of civilians in the city and that there are several large concentrations of civilians who fear for their lives but enjoy little effective protection.

The Government is appalled at the fighting and at the continuing reports of the slaughter of innocent civilians in Kigali and other parts of Rwanda. The killings and atrocities are an affront to everything we stand for and to the international system of order and justice for which we work. The situation calls for the highest level of co-ordinated action by the international community.

The UN Security Council is already seized of the matter. On Saturday, in calling for an immediate ceasefire and cessation of hostilities, it demanded that the interim Government of Rwanda and the Rwandese Patriotic Front take effective measures to prevent any attacks on civilians in areas under their control. It called on the leadership of both parties to commit themselves to ensuring that persons who instigate or participate in such attacks are prosecuted and punished. It condemned all breaches of international humanitarian law in Rwanda and recalled that persons who instigate or participate in such acts are individually responsible.

Ireland supports these demands by the Security Council and the efforts of the UN Secretary General to bring an end to the conflict. Civil war of the kind we are witnessing in Rwanda is among the most difficult and complex for the international community to deal with. Nonetheless there is an urgent need for intensified action by the international community to bring the killings to an end and to promote the restoration of civil order.

First, the UN must step up its efforts to bring about a ceasefire and a cessation of hostilities. The UN's Special Representative in Rwanda and the commander of UNAMIR have a key mediation role here, but so too does the Organisation of African Unity and we expect that the OAU and the countries in the region will use their influence with the parties.

Second, the Security Council should review the role of UNAMIR to establish the contribution that a larger force with a new mandate could make. We must recognise that in conditions of civil strife, and in a situation where the parties to the conflict cannot agree on a UN role, the Security Council has no easy task. Already the UN Secretary-General has pointed to the complications arising from the fact that in recent days both sides have begun to express lack of confidence in UNAMIR's impartiality. I believe that renewed efforts must concentrate on persuading the parties to accept an increased UN presence to protect the civilian population.

Third, the international community must increase its humanitarian aid, particularly for the hundreds of thousands of refugees who have fled to neighbouring countries. The Government is ready to play its part. We have already allocated £200,000 to Trócaire and the Red Cross and we are making available a further £300,000 for urgent needs. Beyond this Ireland will, at tomorrow's Development Council in Brussels, propose that the European Union send an urgent mission to the neighbouring countries to discuss the situation with the authorities there and to assess the immediate needs of the refugees.

Fourth, we support a visit to the area by the newly-appointed UN Commissioner for Human Rights and an early meeting of the UN Commission on Human Rights in Geneva. Among the issues that should be considered is the establishment of a human rights presence in the area through the sending of human rights monitors.

Fifth, the international community must act to prevent the supply of arms to the parties. Already the Security Council has appealed to all states to refrain from providing arms or military assistance to the parties to the conflict. The Security Council should now consider the application of an arms embargo to Rwanda.

Rwanda is a small country, distant from us, but we cannot ignore the suffering of its people. The proposals I have outlined are designed to create a framework within which a political solution to the crisis can be found. We will be pursuing these aims with our partners in the European Union and with the relevant international organisations in the days ahead.

Barr
Roinn