Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Tuesday, 12 Oct 1999

Vol. 509 No. 1

Adjournment Debate. - Domiciliary Care Allowance.

Parents caring for children under two years of age at home do not qualify for domiciliary care allowance. The original Department of Health circular, No. 24/73, was issued as far back as 25 November 1973. Parents find it difficult to come to terms with the problems which arise in the early years of a child born with a disability. The historical reason for the State not extending DCA to cover children under two years was based on the then medical assumption that many of these children would not survive to come out of the maternity hospital. However, with advances in medicine, there has been a dramatic decrease in the incidence of infant mortality. Many handicapped children under two years have disorders which put great pressure on their parents. Some suffer from epileptic seizures or need, usually a parent to change a nasal gastric tube. Some children suffer seizures from as early as four weeks and need 24 hour a day attention. One parent has described coping with a child under two years with such an ailment as living on a knife edge with a huge weight pressing down on one's head.

The Jack and Jill Foundation, established to help parents with disabled children at home, estimates that it alone will have 120 families under its wing before the end of the year. More children with handicap are being born and surviving because of the advances in medical care. The rate of domiciliary care allowance is £111.20 per month so the overall cost of addressing this anomaly – we supposedly treat all children equally – is not a large financial sum, and the Minister has received the findings of a review of the matter which was completed more than 12 months ago. I hope he can inform the House that he will be in a position, possibly in the upcoming budget, to address this injustice affecting parents caring for disabled children under two years of age at home. These parents have a worthy case. I do not intend to take up the time of the House other than to hear from the Minister that he can address what is a genuine and pressing need of these parents.

The Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Cowen, fully understands the Deputy's concerns. He fully appreciates the demanding role facing parents and guardians of children of all ages with a disability, and he is very conscious of the dedication and commitment demonstrated by these carers. For many, this commitment is a life-long dedication and is not only confined to the childhood years.

It is worthwhile, however, to explain the nature and background to the scheme. The domiciliary care allowance is paid by health boards in respect of children between the ages of two and 16 years who are so severely physically or mentally disabled that they require care and attention which is considerably in excess of that normally required by a child of the same age. The scheme operates under section 61 of the 1970 Health Act. This section empowers a health board to make arrangements to assist in the maintenance at home of a sick or infirm person, a dependant of such a person, or a person who, but for the provision of a service for him under the section, would require to be maintained otherwise than at home. Eligibility is subject to a means test but only the means of the child are taken into account. For example, a child who receives a payment of compensation resulting in an income in excess of the allowance does not qualify. The rate of the allowance is £111.20 per month. More than £12 million was paid out under the scheme in 1998 in respect of 9,108 children.

The criteria under which the scheme operates state that the handicap must be present at the time of the application, have been present for at least six months prior to that date and be likely to continue to last for at least another year. The necessary medical assessment is carried out by health board medical personnel. In some cases, depending on the medical condition, eligibility is reviewed at regular intervals. Following such a review, if a child's condition has improved, he or she may no longer meet the criteria for eligibility. These reviews also provide an opportunity to ensure that the services available and the care plan in place meet, to the extent possible, the needs of the recipient on an ongoing basis. The allowance is not paid in respect of children maintained in institutions. However, where a child is at home for a continuous period of more than two months, for example, summer holidays, the allowance may be granted for that period.

The Minister is conscious of the many requests made by concerned individuals and representative organisations urging that the scheme be extended to cover severely disabled children under two years of age. The guidelines state that "children below the age of two are not regarded as eligible as such children normally require constant care and attention in any event". However, there is a view that children under two years who have a severe disability need a greater level of care than a healthy baby. The Deputy will appreciate that any decision to extend the domiciliary care allowance to children under two years of age who are severely disabled will impact not only on the scheme itself but on the provision of other assistance provided by the State in the sphere of care and income support. Issues such as means testing and appropriate medical criteria require also to be addressed in this context.

As indicated in replies to recent parliamentary questions, the Minister arranged for the issue of an extension of the domiciliary care allowance to be examined. This examination involved consultation with the health boards, concerned groups and other Departments. The review concluded that best international practice recognises the additional care required for children under two years of age with a disability. The Minister accepts that very often it is not simply a matter of care but the kind and intensity of the care required. While the international experience var ies in the type of and eligibility for schemes, the underlying trend is to offer some support to children under two years of age. Having examined the findings of the review, the Minister remains sympathetic to the principle of extending coverage of the scheme. Consequently, he has instructed officials within the Department to consider the possibility of granting such an extension sooner rather than later. In this context, these officials are discussing the possibility of funding being sourced in the Estimates for the year 2000. I take on board what the Deputy said in regard to the forthcoming budget and consideration will be given in the Estimates.

The Dáil adjourned at 9.10 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Wednesday, 13 October 1999.

Barr
Roinn