Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Tuesday, 22 Feb 2000

Vol. 514 No. 6

Priority Questions. - Milk Quota.

Paul Connaughton

Ceist:

47 Mr. Connaughton asked the Minister for Agriculture, Food and Rural Development if the sale of dairy farms as a going concern will be allowed under the new milk regime which comes into effect on 1 April 2000; the criteria relating to the new temporary leasing scheme; if this scheme will exist after 1 April 2000; the price at which the quota will be set; the basis on which this price will be calculated; the plans, if any, he has to help small producers to purchase extra quota in any way other than by the announced tax relief system; and if he will make statement on the matter. [5213/00]

The regulatory framework arising from the Agenda 2000 agreement allows for greater flexibility in the operation of the milk quota regime.

I have decided to make changes in the system which operates in Ireland to ensure that active, committed producers have greater access to quota on a permanent basis at a reasonable cost in the coming years and that the Irish dairy sector is positioned to face the competitive challenges that lie ahead.

On 13 October, I announced my intention to introduce, by way of national regulations, applicable from 1 April 2000, an arrangement for the transfer of milk quota other than the current system whereby such quota transfers with land. The objectives of the new arrangements are to provide for more flexibility and certainty for milk producers in the operation of the milk quota regime; greater priority access to additional permanent milk quota for small scale and medium size producers; the retention of as many dairying enterprises as possible and greater competitiveness within the Irish milk production sector.

Under the provisions of Article 8 of the European Community regulations, I have decided that with effect from 1 April 2000 milk quota will no longer transfer with land, subject to certain exceptions. Those exceptions will cover family transactions, renewals of existing leases between the original lessor and lessee, sale of a dairy holding as a going concern and the transfer by way of lease or sale of land purchased with quota between 13 October 1999 and 31 March 2000. Detailed conditions in relation to these exceptions will be defined in the national regulations.

Apart from the exceptions outlined above I have decided that, under the provisions of Article 8(b), the transfer of milk quota will be through a scheme to be operated by way of a pooled system at co-operative or dairy level. Under this scheme, quota holders may, at the end of each milk quota year, offer all or part of their milk quota for sale to their co-operative or dairy. The co-operative or dairy, in turn, may sell milk quota only to pro ducers attached to that concern on the basis of priority categories and detailed rules which will be determined in advance.

The maximum price for the sale of milk quota under this scheme will also be fixed at national level and priority will be afforded to small and medium size producers.

Additional Information.

In this regard, I welcome the recent announcement by the Minister for Finance of favourable tax treatment in the purchase of quota. This will enable his scheme to operate all the more effectively.

With effect from 1 April 2000, it will be no longer possible for quota holders, not engaged in milk production, to temporarily lease their milk quota under the provisions of Article 6 of Council Regulation (EEC) No. 3950/92 and Regulation 16 of the European Communities (Milk Quota) Regulations, 1995, where the milk quota has been temporarily leased for the preceding three milk quota years (1997/98, 1998/99 and 1999/2000) or for a longer period.

In cases other than these it will be open to quota holders to offer all or part of their quota into the temporary leasing scheme, which will continue to operate after 1 April 2000. The maximum price of quota under the scheme will continue to be set at national level. As in the past, the milk quota review group will be consulted in relation to that as well as in relation to establishing the priority criteria for producers purchasing quota under the scheme. I have consulted widely before taking these decisions and I believe they have the support of those involved in industry.

The Minister did not answer the question I asked but perhaps it is because of the procedure. This is a very important issue for every dairy farmer. Will the Minister outline his proposals in the House before the legislation is brought into being on 1 April, so that every Deputy can be involved? We owe it to all dairy farmers, new entrants, quota holders who do not supply milk and dairy processors to have a debate on those proposals. What is wrong is that nobody knows what is happening? The Minister might indicate if he is prepared to do that.

The new quota regulations emanate from Agenda 2000. They have been drawn up with the widest possible consultation with representatives of all the farming organisations at all times – so much so, that they have been written into the partnership programme which was concluded only a few weeks ago.

What about the 500 at the meeting in Dunmanway the other night?

So the Deputy does not agree with the current proposals.

I do not.

The Deputy does not. That is on the record.

These are priority questions and only the Deputy in whose name the question was put down is in order in intervening.

At least we know where the Deputy stands.

The idea of changing the quota system was to introduce flexibility and permanency for those committed to milk production, particularly young people who can acquire the quota on its own, to retain as many dairy enterprises as possible and to underpin a competitive dairy industry.

I also had legal consultations with the Attorney General's office and the legal experts with the EU Commission. I will proceed, in the first instance, with statutory instruments to give effect to the proposals and underpin that with legislation to which everybody will have a chance to contribute and amend, if they wish.

On behalf of every dairy farmer, I am extremely disappointed that the Minister does not see fit to bring his proposals to the House. That is what this House of Parliament is for.

The Ministers' backbenchers are bad mouthing them.

We want clarity. Like every other scheme, there are good and bad points but at least let us tease them out.

In so far as the temporary leasing scheme is concerned, will there be a scheme for widows with farms whose children may show an interest in milking cows but who have to be educated or for those who experience sickness? Will such milk quotas be held for them? Perhaps the Minister might indicate how the new legislation will deal with that.

On dairy farms being sold as going concerns, if a farmer with a 20,000 gallon farm decides to buy another 20,000 gallon farm two miles away, can both farms be operated as the one unit or does the quota have to be milked on the farm on which the quota is held? Will the Minister explain that?

On temporary leasing, there will be exceptions which will, in particular, take into account family circumstances.

Will the Minister spell them out?

Yes. They are spelled out—

They do not seem to be getting across.

—in the regulations, as advertised in all the national media on 13 October last and in umpteen replies in the Dáil since. A teenager of 13 or 17 years of age who is still at school and who may wish to take over the family farm will be provided for. We need balance.

The reason for the provision on selling farms as going concerns is that if a person buys a farm, he or she will want to know if the quota goes with it. If it is a dairy farm with all the facilities, including a milking parlour and so on, there is a provision that a person may buy it as a going concern.

Barr
Roinn