Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Wednesday, 1 Oct 2003

Vol. 571 No. 2

Hospital Services.

I welcome the opportunity to raise this issue on behalf of my constituents and to protest at the continuing downgrading of services at Louth County Hospital. Since the Dundalk catchment area is one of the fastest-growing urban centres in the country, health services in it should be expanded. The increasing numbers of people living in Dundalk and the north Louth area generally, like all citizens of this State, deserve the best possible health care services. Access to health care is a fundamental human right, as outlined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The Government has a responsibility to deliver those services and the Minister is obliged to ensure their delivery. Yet the actions of the Government and its agents, the North-Eastern Health Board, have left the people of the Dundalk catchment area without any proper health care services.

Cutbacks, which have been made for purely financial reasons, deny people the essential health services to which they are entitled. Louth County Hospital once had an excellent paediatric unit, a fine maternity unit and a first-class gynaecology unit, all of which are now closed. It appears that the accident and emergency unit is to face the same grim future. Now all minor and major road traffic accidents are sent to the already overcrowded accident and emergency unit at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda. There are major concerns for the future of accident and emergency services at the Louth hospital because of the failure to appoint a consultant.

Does the Minister think it acceptable that trauma cases now have to travel an extra half hour to Drogheda? He must realise that the extra time involved significantly increases the risk in life-and-death situations. Can he stand by that? Can he explain to me the status of the accident and emergency unit at Louth County Hospital? Can he confirm if it is true that, from January 2003, the unit will close at 5 p.m. on weekdays and over the entire weekend? If that is the case, it will not be viable to have anaesthetists on call, meaning that the hospital's surgical unit will not survive. It is scandalous that services for women and children at Louth County Hospital were the first to be cut.

The absence of adequate maternity services is reprehensible since maternity and major gynaecological services transferred to Drogheda, I have continually been approached by expectant mothers who are both annoyed and frightened by the prospect of travelling so far when they go into labour. At the back of their minds, no doubt, is the tragic case of a young Monaghan mother whose baby died en route to hospital in a similar situation where a community had been deprived of maternity services. The people of Dundalk were promised a midwife-led unit. In June I inquired of the Minister when that unit would be functional and what capacity it would have. I was informed that the building identified for future use as a midwife-led unit would require some modification and extension, that a suitable scheme would be prepared for consideration and that the work should be completed in 2004 – this is the critical point – subject to funding being made available.

Will the Minister for Health and Children assure me that that funding has been made available? We simply cannot wait any longer. I was further told that only two beds would be made available to the midwife-led unit from the existing bed compliment at the hospital. That last sentence demonstrates the misleading nature of the whole midwife-led scheme. From the outset, it was planned that there would be only two beds and that they would come from the existing bed compliment. That is madness.

The situation is critical. A whole community is being deprived of essential services. The Minister must intervene immediately and there must be no more passing the buck to consultants and health boards. There must be no further downgrading of Louth County Hospital. All essential services must be restored to the hospital without delay.

On behalf of my colleague, Deputy Martin, I welcome the opportunity to clarify the position regarding Louth County Hospital, Dundalk. The Deputy will appreciate that responsibility for the provision of services at Louth County Hospital rests in the first instance with the North Eastern Health Board. My Department has been advised by the board that there are no plans to downgrade Louth County Hospital and that the hospital is guaranteed an active role in the delivery of acute hospital services within the Louth-Meath hospital group. The health board is also committed to maintaining surgical services and a 24-hour accident and emergency service at the hospital.

The September 2001 report of the maternity services review group commissioned by the North Eastern Health Board, known as the Kinder report, recommends that safety and evidence-based care for mother and baby must remain the foundation of an effective maternity service.

The Comhairle na nOspidéal review of maternity and related services in the North Eastern Health Board area recommends that there be regular and frequent consultant input into Louth County Hospital by the consultant obstetric and gynaecological staff and the paediatric staff based at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, and that the hospital should continue to provide out-patient maternity, gynaecology and paediatric clinics. The board is continuing to provide those services at the hospital.

The board acknowledges that there have been difficulties in securing training recognition for surgical junior doctors at the hospital from the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland. The board had discussions with the college in an effort to resolve those issues and has been successful in securing four fully registered non-consultant hospital doctors for the 12-month period commencing in January 2003. Accordingly, accreditation from the RCSI has not been required for general surgery for the current year.

As the surgical unit at Louth County Hospital is part of the joint department of surgery with Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda, the Royal College of Surgeons will be invited to inspect both hospitals and it is envisaged that approval will be forthcoming for both basic surgical training and higher surgical training posts from 1 July 2004.

Currently, the permanent filling of two consultant posts in surgery at Louth County Hospital has been approved by my Department and by Comhairle na nOspidéal, and they are now with the Local Appointments Commission for processing. The board expects that those joint appointments will significantly enhance surgical services in the Louth-Meath hospital group, as well as meeting the revised standards and regulations which have been stipulated by the RCSI concerning training of non-consultant hospital doctors.

To date, responsibility for the accident and emergency department in Louth County Hospital has rested with the consultant surgeons and physicians at the hospital. The Department issued financial clearance to the board on 23 December 2002 for the filling of three new consultant posts in emergency medicine in the region. Two of those posts are in the Louth-Meath hospital group, to be based in Drogheda, one of which will have a sessional commitment to Dundalk, and the second post will have a similar commitment to Our Lady's Hospital, Navan. Those appointments are in line with the Comhairle na nOspidéal 2002 report of the committee on accident and emergency services and its recommendations on how hospital emergency services should be delivered and organised in the north-eastern region.

Pending the filling of those posts in a permanent capacity, the board has appointed temporary consultants to them. The permanent posts have already been approved by my Department and by Comhairle na nOspidéal, and those are also currently with the Local Appointments Commission for processing. It is hoped these appointments will assist in securing accreditation for 2004.

In 2002, Louth County Hospital received funding for the provision of an additional 14 beds under the national bed capacity initiative. My Department is advised by the board that these beds were commissioned in December 2002. A new post of consultant physician with a special interest in endocrinology received financial clearance from my Department in 2002. A temporary appointment has been made to this post pending permanent recruitment. This additional bed capacity will allow the hospital to significantly increase activity levels for its public patients.

A project team under the national development plan has been established at each hospital in the region, including Louth County Hospital. The initial responsibility of the project team is to identify service requirements and to prepare a planning brief for the preparation of an outline development control plan in respect of the hospital site. The preparation of these briefs is now at an advanced stage.

The combination of additional investment and capacity at the hospital represents tangible evidence of the commitment by this Government to the continuing development of services to the people in the catchment area served by Louth County Hospital and the Louth-Meath hospital group as a whole.

The Dáil adjourned at 9.20 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Thursday, 2 October 2003.

Barr
Roinn