Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Tuesday, 3 Mar 2009

Vol. 676 No. 4

Adjournment Debate.

Job Losses.

Tá lúcháir orm go bhfuil deis agam an t-ábhar tábhachtach seo a thógáil ar an Athló agus go bhfuil an tAire i láthair. Is buille mór do thionsclaíocht i gceantar Gaeltachta Ghaoth Dobhair dúnadh monarchan Euro Iompú Teoranta tráthnóna inné. Mar atá ráite, tá breis agus trí scór post caillte de bharr dúnadh an tionscail sin. Tá an tionscal lonnaithe ar Pháirc Ghnó Ghaoth Dobhair, nó ar Eastát Tionscalaíochta Ghaoth Dobhair mar a tugadh air roimhe seo, le breis agus fiche bliain agus chuir sé busanna den scoth ar fáil fá choinne margadh na tíre seo agus thar lear. Bhi scaifte de dhaoine óga ag obair ann a bhí sár-oilte agus a raibh ard-scileanna acu fá choinne an obair thábhachtach sin a dhéanamh, ach anois tá na daoine sin fágtha gan fostaíocht.

Tá go leor poist caillte ar an eastát le roinnt blianta anuas, mar shampla, monarchana cosúil le Comar Yarns, RMT, Europlast, MDR Leictreonach Teo., BMR agus go leor eile. Fuair an eastát buille i ndiaidh buille le roinnt blianta anuas agus shíl muid go raibh an t-am sin thart, ach is é seo an buille is deireanaí a fuair muid.

Is tionscal é seo a fuair cabhair agus tacaíocht ó Údarás na Gaeltachta. D'fhéadfá a rá gur tionscal áitiúil a bhí ann, mar gur bunaíodh é go h-áitiúil agus mar gur teaghlach áitiúil a thóg é agus a rinne forbairt air le fiche bliain. Tá ár mbuíochas ag dul don teaghlach sin as an fhostaíocht a chuir siad ar fáil. Ach mar adúirt mé, tá na poist sin caillte agus is beag deis do phoist eile atá ag na daoine a chaill iad. Ba mhaith liom a iarraidh ar an Aire, ar Údarás na Gaeltachta agus áisíneachtaí eile traenála agus mar sin gach cuidiú a chur ar fáil don cheantar le malairt fostaíochta a chur ar fáil dóibh siúd atá i ndiaidh a gcuid poist a chailliúnt.

Yesterday's announcement by Údaras na Gaeltachta to the effect that Euro Coach Builders on the Gweedore industrial park will close with the loss of 62 jobs is another severe blow to employment in that Donegal Gaeltacht area. Coming in the wake of so many other closures and job losses in the park in the past six or seven years, it leaves this part of County Donegal with possibly the highest unemployment rate in the country.

One could say that Euro Coach Builders was an indigenous industry in that it was created, grew and flourished for 24 years through the initiative and entrepreneurship of local business acumen. It was a truly home grown industry and our thanks and gratitude go to Mr. Joseph Ferry and family who created and sustained the business for so many years and provided such excellent employment.

Each job that has been lost is devastating for one family or another. Many of those workers were the sole family bread winners with financial responsibilities, such as mortgage repayments and health and insurance charges. It is tragic that there are few alternative employment opportunities in the area. Skills and expertise have been built up through the years. The workers are being relegated to the dole queues or the emigrants's trail. There is little hope of alternative employment. On my way to the Dáil this morning, I met two local young men on their way to Australia to join dozens of their friends who have already left.

I appeal to the Minister, Údaras na Gaeltachta and all of the agencies to redouble their efforts in seeking and creating alternative employment for those affected. Re-training must be provided, redundancy terms must be generous and new jobs, the only long-term solution to the problem, must be created.

Tá súil agam go bhfógróidh an tAire go ndéanfaidh sé iarracht speisialta le Údarás na Gaeltachta agus go gcuirfidh sé brú orthu tuilleadh fostaíochta a fháil don cheantar fíor-Ghaeltachta seo.

Ba mhaith liom buíochas a ghlacadh leis an Teachta as ucht na ceiste seo a thógáil. Mar a deir sé, is cúis imní agus díomá dom féin agus d'Údaras na Gaeltachta aon phoist a bheith á gcailliúint in aon tionscal Gaeltachta. Ba mhaith liom a rá leis na fostaithe go dtuigim a gcás agus gur oth linn gur tharla sé seo. Is cúis imní don Teachta McGinley, dá phobal agus do ghach éinne an líon poist atá caillte sa cheantar. Caithfear a chur san áireamh go bhfuil lagú an-mhór tarlaithe i ngach earnáil le tamall anuas, mar gheall ar chuinsí náisiúnta agus idirnáisiúnta. Ar an drochuair, tá drochthioncar aige seo ar leibhéal fostaíochta sa Ghaeltacht.

Mar is eol don Teachta, cheadaigh an Ard-Chúirt comhshocraíocht a mhol scrúdaitheoir Euro lompú Teoranta don Chúirt i mí na Nollag 2007. In Aibreán 2008, ghlac an t-údaras le togra forbartha a cuireadh faoina bhráid, ina raibh pacáiste deontais taighde agus forbartha, fostaíochta, caipitil, oiliúna agus eile de €1.465 milliún, d'fhonn cuidiú a chur ar fáil do Euro lompú Teoranta chun an gnó tógáil mótarchóistí agus busanna a dhaingniú agus a fhorbairt ar Pháirc Ghnó Ghaoth Dobhair. Tá €716,843 den mhéid sin íoctha leis an gcomhlacht. Dar ndóigh, mar is iondúil, beidh plé ar bun idir an t-Údaras agus an comhlacht i rith na míonna seo romhainn maidir le deontais a bhaineann leis an gcúnamh Stáit sin.

Bhí 30 duine fostaithe in Euro lompú Teoranta ag an am agus bhí bainisteoir ginearálta ceaptha ag an chomhlacht, a bhí tar éeis straitéis forbartha gnó a ullmhú i gcomhar le príomhaithe an chomhlachta. Chomh maith leis sin, bhí roinnt gnóthaí eile a bhí ag cur seirbhíse ar fáil agus a raibh nasc gnó cruthaithe acu le Euro lompú Teoranta, go háirithe ó thaobh oibreacha cumhdaigh agus seirbhísí innealtóireachtade. Bhí sé beartaithe go dtiocfadh fás agus athbheochan ar an fhostaíocht indíreach seo i gcomhlachtaí Gaeltachta a bhí ag freastal ar riachtanais an chomhlachta le forbairt agus daingniú Euro lompú Teoranta féin. Ba é 130 an sprioc nua fostaiochta don chomhlacht féin agus é faoi lánseol. Ba é líon na bpost a bhí sa chomhlacht ag an deireadh na 62.

Bhí idir déantús busanna agus seirbhís iardhíola le forbairt ag an gcomhlacht, dírithe ar mhargaí na hÉireann, na Breataine agus na Mór-Roinne. Bhí deacrachtaí móra ag an gcomhlacht le heaspa díolacháin le roinnt míonna anuas, de bharr deacrachtaí trádála idirnáisiúnta san earnáil gluaisteáin agus mótarchóistí agus, ina cuideachta seo, an ráta malartú idir an euro agus sterling.

Nil aon amhras gur buille trom é seo don Ghaeltacht, ach caithfear a aithint go raibh an comhlacht seo ag feidhmiú go héifeachtach go dtí le déanaí agus gur cuinsí taobh amuigh de smacht an chomhlachta is mó ba chúis leis an gcinneadh atá déanta. Tá sé cruthaithe ag an údaras gur féidir le infheistíocht nua a mhealladh go dtí an Ghaeltacht agus beifear ag féachaint le fostaíocht malartach a mhealladh go Gaoth Dobhair do na daoine a chaill a gcuid post.

Ba mhaith liom aird a tharraingt ar chúrsaí fostaíochta ar Pháirc Ghnó Ghaoth Dobhair, áit a bhfuil méadú suntasach tagtha le cúpla bliain anuas ar an líon daoine atá fostaithe i gcliant-chuideachtaí de chuid Údaras na Gaeltachta. Is dea-scéala é seo nuair a chuimhníonn muid go raibh an figiúr seo tite faoi 450 in 2003, tráth ar chailleadh líon mór post déantusaíochta ansin. Tá go leor infheistíochta á dhéanamh ar an bPáirc Ghnó seo, ach go háirithe, forbairt ar Áislann Ghaoth Dobhair le lárionad ilfheidhmeach cultúrtha, pobail agus áineasa, ar chostas os cionn €8 milliún.

Sa cheantar máguaird tá forbairtí tábhachtacha eile curtha ar bun le cúpla bliain anuas, mar shampla, leathnúchán ar lonad Seirbhisí Mara agus Turasóireachta ag cé Machaire Rabhartaigh, cultúrlann le 450 suíochán ag lonad Chois Locha i nDún Lúiche agus ionad fiontair agus pobail nua i Rann na Feirste. Chomh maith leis sin, dar ndóigh, tá ionad fiontair tógtha ag Westbic i mBaile na Móna, Cill Chárthaigh. Go hachomair, tá an t-Údarás dóchasach gur féidir malairt deiseanna fostaíochta a chur ar fáil i gceantar Ghaoth Dobhair sa ghearr go meántéarma.

Mar fhocal scoir, is féidir liom a gheallúint don Teach seo go mbeidh mo Roinn ag tacú leis an údaras na hiarrachtaí leanúnacha atá ar bun aige chun fostaíochta a ghiniúint agus a dhaingniú sa Ghaeltacht. Sa chomhthéacs sin, tá thart ar €35 milliún curtha ar fáil ag mo Roinn don údaras dá chlár gníomhaíochta sa bhliain 2009. Is féidir liom a rá freisin go bhfuil mé dóchasach ón gcomhoibriú iomlán idir mé féin agus mo chomhghleacaí, an Tánaiste agus an tAire Fiontair, Trádála agus Fostaíochta, an Teachta Máire Ni Chochláin — agus go deimhin idir an t-údaras, an IDA agus El — go mbeidh rath ar na hiarrachtaí atá ar bun le déileáil leis na dúshláin chun a chinntiú go mbeidh deiseanna fostaíochta fiúntacha inmharthanacha ar fáil do phobal Ghaeltacht Dhún na nGall.

Garda Operations.

It is important that this House should have the opportunity to discuss the facts and consequences of last Friday's tiger kidnapping and bank heist, which resulted in the most substantial theft of cash in the history of the State. It is clear from the reports on this robbery that criminal gangs have the resources and manpower to mount the type of surveillance operation the Garda no longer can carry out due to the financial constraints and cuts imposed by the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform.

The Garda is reported to be concerned at the volume and high grade of intelligence gathered on this occasion by the gang regarding the living arrangements of Mr. Travers and his colleagues and their role in Bank of Ireland. At the same time, the Garda is reported to be furious that surveillance on the chief suspects in this raid had to be withdrawn due to a lack of funding. Soon after the surveillance ceased, the raid took place and the surveillance was then reinstated, resulting in the arrest of some suspects and the recovery of a small amount of money. In early December 2008, gardaí foiled two major attempted heists in counties Clare and Dublin, one involving a planned tiger kidnapping, thanks to a surveillance operation.

The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform is present in the House and I ask him whether he is satisfied that the Garda has the capacity to carry out surveillance on criminal gangs it suspects of being likely to carry out future raids and that effective Garda surveillance is the key to preventing such future raids. The ease with which this operation was carried out is disturbing. It will act as encouragement for others to follow suit. Members have been told the State's financial institutions are now looking at security procedures. At a hastily convened press conference after the event, the Minister stated this is happening. What has held them back thus far? How many tiger kidnappings have taken place in this State in the past 12 months? What is the Minister doing about the fact that Dublin is now the tiger kidnapping capital of the world? If he has the answer, he clearly is not engaged with the issue but is showing that his meeting with senior gardaí after the big heist is nothing but a charade. If the Minister knows the answer, and I seek the figure from him this evening, why has he taken no action until now? How often have representatives of the Garda Síochána or senior officials from the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform met senior bankers in the past year in respect of security arrangements and similar matters? What contingency plans have been in place to deal with tiger kidnapping?

When this State was under threat and attack from terrorist organisations and the Provisional IRA in the 1970s and 1980s, it always held firm and did not buckle under pressure. What action is the Minister now taking, or does he propose to take, to disabuse criminal gangsters of the notion that tiger kidnapping is an easy way to obtain millions, such as the €7.8 million handed over by Bank of Ireland last weekend? The State and other financial institutions did not give in to terrorists in the past and it is essential they do not do so now. The Minister is not encouraging and I ask him to take appropriate action on this matter.

I accept that Deputy Flanagan must make noise and look busy in the aftermath of this incident.

This is not noise. This was the biggest armed robbery in the history of the State and the Minister held a press conference after the event.

However, I am more than happy to reply to this Adjournment debate and to give the Deputy the figures he requested. Last year, there were six so-called tiger kidnappings, six in the previous year and nine in the year before that.

The world capital.

Consequently, the Government's record is of a reduction in such activities.

First, I wish to extend my sympathy to the victims caught up in this crime. I am sure I speak for all sides of the House when I express my hope that they will soon recover from this awful trauma. Members will also appreciate that it is incumbent upon me to remind the House that the robbery last Friday is the subject of an intensive and ongoing investigation. A number of individuals have appeared in court charged in connection with it and I suggest that all Members should be careful to avoid saying anything that could be prejudicial to the case.

There are agreed response procedures between the Garda Síochána and the banks and financial institutions to deal with hostage situations in which members of staff or their families are taken hostage to facilitate robberies. These response procedures are detailed and all-encompassing. It is clear that some of the aforementioned security protocols were not followed in this incident. A number of questions arise regarding the apparent ease with which such a large amount of money was accessed. I accept that everyone is worried about how easily this money was taken from this bank.

Shortly after the incident, I had a conversation with the chief executive of the bank involved. I also met the Garda Commissioner and the Deputy Commissioner of operations in the immediate aftermath of the robbery. Following our consultations, it was agreed that senior gardaí should immediately meet the heads of security of a number of financial institutions to consider the implications of last Friday's robbery. That meeting took place yesterday and the institutions have undertaken to carry out a fundamental review of their procedures and to report back, while working with the Garda in this respect. Further meetings are envisaged.

It is no surprise that in the wake of ongoing improvements to the physical security of banks and to the cash in transit industry — Deputy Flanagan must admit the cash in transit issue has been taken care of reasonably successfully in recent years — these thugs have shifted their focus to the human vulnerability within the system. In general, the Garda Síochána will continue to combat such so-called tiger raids as part of the concerted efforts being made to tackle organised criminal gangs and the continuing measures being taken as part of Operation Anvil. In recent years we have introduced tough new measures, including seven-day detention periods, that have been used in the recent past highly successfully by the Garda Síochána with the consent of the courts, for those suspected of various serious crimes, including kidnappings and mandatory sentences in respect of firearms offences.

The Garda is continuing to make every effort to defeat the crime gangs responsible and I reiterate that I will not be found wanting in ensuring that it has the necessary support, both from a resources and legislative perspective, to so do. For example, I emphasise and have indicated in the House many times, the budget for Operation Anvil has been increased and ring-fenced from €20 million last year to €21 million this year. This is in spite of an overall reduction in my Department's Estimate.

In response to the claims made by the Deputy, while it would be completely counter-productive for me to comment on any detail of the surveillance activities of the Garda, I can confirm to him that the Garda Commissioner, at a follow-up meeting in this House today, assured me there is absolutely no basis for any suggestion that the resources devoted to the targeting and surveillance of such gangs have been reduced or withdrawn. Such claims are as baseless as they are irresponsible.

The surveillance was taken off the gangs.

That is a fact.

The Minister knows it and it is in his report. The Garda has stated he removed that surveillance.

The Deputy is not correct in this regard. The Government is devoting enormous resources to the fight against crime. I have made it clear that it has absolute priority in the allocation of resources within my Department. That will remain the case, even though I am criticised by Deputies opposite for the consequences of that approach.

The Government has also approved my proposals to introduce new legislation underpinning the use of covert surveillance methods by the Garda. Under the legislation, the State will be able to use collateral material obtained by means of covert surveillance as evidence to support or strengthen the case for the prosecution at a criminal trial. This legislation will be introduced to the Dáil shortly and should be of considerable assistance in achieving successful prosecutions of gang members.

The Minister's time has elapsed.

Perhaps I will be allowed to continue, with the consent of the House.

However, Members should not forget that the banks and other institutions have their part to play in this regard. If tried and trusted protocols are put in place to defeat criminal attempts to rob cash, it is imperative that these are followed to the letter. That is the important lesson from last Friday. I echo the words of the chief executive officer of Bank of Ireland that the objective of the protocols is to provide for the "safety and well-being of all staff". I have stated repeatedly that my primary priority is to focus on the fight against crime. That remains the case. By the end of this year, there will be just short of 15,000 gardaí on the streets, the same number which Deputy Flanagan's party pledged to have in place by the end of 2012, a full three years later.

Regarding the events of last Friday, I do not underestimate the difficulties involved in trying to deal with incidents where people are taken hostage. For those involved, their instinct is understandably to protect their loved ones. However, this only makes it more important that financial institutions follow the robust protocols and procedures in place to ensure employees are, to the greatest possible extent, not placed in such a position in the first place.

There was nothing robust about the procedures last Friday.

The protocols are there, first and foremost, to protect employees. It is only by rendering these so-called tiger kidnappings unsuccessful that we will stop them happening, thereby protecting innocent employees in future.

Care of the Elderly.

I thank the Ceann Comhairle for selecting this important issue for discussion. Home help services have been of enormous benefit to the many people throughout the State who avail of them. These worthwhile schemes allow elderly people to remain in their homes, surrounded by their family, friends and community, thus enjoying a better quality of life.

Some months ago, it came to my attention that the Health Service Executive was experiencing difficulties in providing home help services to all in need of them. In some areas, no funding is available for new applicants, regardless of their level of need. In other areas, staff can only provide home help to a new applicant when an existing patient no longer needs them. In other words, staff are obliged to wait until one person dies before "recycling" home help hours. In recent weeks, it has become clear that instances of cutting people's hours and placing applicants on long waiting lists have become increasingly prevalent throughout the State. The many cases in my own constituency are undoubtedly replicated elsewhere.

For example, I was recently made aware of a shocking situation where an 83 year old man who is suffering from cancer, diabetes, and other complications was, upon his release from hospital, granted a mere one hour per day of assistance in the form of home help. His family were pleased to receive even this much but they are under enormous pressure and in a very stressful situation. I have come across cases where desperately needed hours of home help were drastically cut and where seriously ill people were put on waiting lists for home help. Families are coming under severe pressure as a result of this shortfall in home help services.

There has been a catalogue of decisions in recent months where the needs of older and more vulnerable people in our society were trampled by the Government. The Health Service Executive and the Department of Health and Children should not erode by stealth the essential provision of home help for people who are seriously ill. Will the Minister clarify the current situation? I reiterate how invaluable these services are to people who wish to remain in their homes. Given the large increases in unemployment, many people are now available to work with older people. An emergency plan should be drawn up to ensure older people receive the assistance they need to enjoy the best possible quality of life. Unemployed people should be allowed to register for some type of short-term scheme whereby they would assist elderly people in their homes. This would relieve pressure on the nursing home subvention scheme and the health service in general while also providing employment in local communities. If we do not look after older people, we cannot be proud of our society. I urge the Government to introduce the type of emergency plan to which I referred.

Ba mhaith liom buíochas a ghabháil leis an Teachta as ucht na ceiste seo a thógáil. Beidh me in ann anois an fíorscéal a chur ar chuntas na Dála. I am taking this Adjournment matter on behalf of my colleague, the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Harney. I thank the Deputy for raising this issue as it provides me with an opportunity to reaffirm the Government's continued commitment to services for older people generally and, in particular, to the important area of home care.

Government policy in regard to the elderly is to support people to live in dignity and independence in their own homes and communities for as long as possible. Where this is not feasible, the health service supports access to quality long-term residential care where this is appropriate. This policy approach is renewed and developed in the partnership agreement, Towards 2016. The home help service, delivered by or on behalf of the Health Service Executive, is a community service enabling people who otherwise might need to be cared for in long-term residential care to remain at home, where appropriate.

It is important, in the context of the issue raised, to point out that the home help service has undergone a significant degree of professionalisation in recent years, with the implementation of the national home help agreement. This has resulted in greater flexibility in service delivery and has improved consistency and service quality, through measures such as training, to the benefit of service users.

The home care package scheme is a relatively new scheme that has been developed in recent years throughout the State. A package comprises a number of community-based services and supports, provided in a planned way to meet the needs of an older person. The person will have significant medical, nursing or therapy requirements and may be recently discharged from hospital or at risk of being admitted to hospital if these needs are not met in a planned way.

The development of these services nationally in the period 2006 to 2008 reflects the prioritisation and significant investment by the Government in recent years. This involved the allocation of €211 million in revenue funding, including €55.6 million in development funding. Some 10.8 million hours were provided in 2006; 11.78 million in 2007; 11.96 million in 2008; and an estimated 11.98 million will be provided in 2009. The numbers benefiting increased from 41,400 to 54,500 from 2006 to 2008, an increase of 13,100 people.

Community-based services for older people have also been augmented in the period 2006 to 2008 by the development of home care packages. This involved the provision of €55 million in each of the years 2006 and 2007, with a further €10 million provided in 2008. This gives a total of €120 million in development funding in this three-year period. More than 4,600 packages were provided by the Health Service Executive in 2008, with some 8,700 people in receipt of a package at any one time and some 11,500 people benefiting during the course of last year.

The Health Service Executive service plan for 2009 aims to deliver the same quantity and quality of home help and home care package services as delivered in 2008. The capacity of the executive to provide approved levels of home help and home care package services continues to be reviewed in the context of overall resources available. It is incumbent on each local health manager to ensure that both home help and home care packages are delivered within allocated budgets. This requires a stringent ongoing review of the application of resources. As with every service, the Deputy will appreciate that there are not limitless resources available for the provision of home help and home care packages.

Levels of services for home help and home care packages for existing clients are reviewed regularly and, as a result, the service in individual cases may increase, decrease or remain the same, based on the assessed needs of the individual. Professional staff on the front line who are aware of local circumstances undertake individual client assessments and services are targeted at those with a high level of dependency, in accordance with assessed need.

An individual assessment is undertaken in the case of new clients for home help or home care packages. The requirements will vary from case to case and may subsequently change over time. An example would be a person discharged from an acute hospital who may require a package for a period following discharge until he or she regained independence. In this case, the level of service provided on discharge is kept under review and when the person is in a position to live more independently, the elements of a home care package may be adjusted in line with changed care needs.

It is particularly relevant, in the context of the issue raised by the Deputy, to highlight that the Department of Health and Children has recently commenced an independent evaluation of the home care package initiative and a report on this, which will help inform future policy and service direction, is expected to be completed around mid-year.

It is clear that the Government has made considerable improvements in recent years to enhance home care provision generally across the country. There is no doubt that demand can at times exceed service resources. It is a matter for the HSE, however, to deliver services both nationally and locally, in the context of Government priorities and its overall resources, and taking account of the individual circumstances of each case.

School Accommodation.

I thank the Ceann Comhairle for affording me time to speak on this important matter, namely, the need for the Minister for Education and Science to expedite a new school building for Forgney national school, County Longford, which was given the go-ahead in 2006, in light of the recent highly alarming engineer's report, which indicates that the 42-year old wooden pre-fab structure in which the school is accommodated is in a serious condition and in danger of collapsing. This poses a major threat to the health and safety of the pupils and teachers.

The comprehensive report was made by Cunningham Consulting Engineering Limited and has been with the Department of Education and Science and the Minister since before Christmas. The most damning and specific finding of the report is that the temporary wooden structure in which the school has been accommodated for the past 42 years should be condemned and the site closed off.

The walls and roof are rotten, cannot be replaced and are ready to collapse on the children and teachers at any moment. The windows are single glazed, the doors are a safety hazard and dampness is rife. The structure, which I would not call a building, is similar to a slatted shed and cannot be heated because the storage heaters are obsolete and cannot be controlled. It has a BER rating of G; there are no vents and there is rot and mould everywhere. The public water supply to the building is contaminated and the wooden floors are rotten and patched.

The threat posed by fire in this antiquated wooden structure is very real. The entire wooden environment is no longer sound nor sustainable. An accident is waiting to happen but I query whether it could be called an accident if it were to happen. The Minister has been alerted to the dangerous state of the school on many occasions, so ignorance is not an excuse.

Forgney national school was given the go-ahead for a new building in 2006 by the Department of Education and Science and the Minister after 40 years of lobbying but there was no follow through. I have raised this matter on the Adjournment, both here and in the other House, most recently last October. I have made repeated representations on behalf of the school, the principal, the board of management, teachers, parents and pupils and I have worked tirelessly to achieve a safe and healthy built environment.

Last year the cost of providing a new school building for Forgney was estimated at €1.3 million. A state-of-the-art school could now be built for €850,000 to €900,000. This is a small sum when contrasted with the €113 million that has been spent on pre-fabs throughout the country from 2006-2008.

The health and safety of the 33 children and teachers is my primary concern. I ask the Minister to make it his concern and to provide the necessary funding to ensure the safety and well-being of the children of this school. Should anything happen to the children in Forgney national school the finger of blame would point firmly at the Minister for Education and Science and the Department. Condemning young children in the 21st century to a 40 year old substandard wooden structure is extraordinary and extremely dangerous, even for this Government. The report by the building energy consultant, Cunningham Consulting Engineering Limited, ends as follows:

It is my professional opinion this school is no longer fit for purpose and that this has been the case for quite a considerable period of time. The only reasonable course of remedial action is demolition and replacement with a modern, well designed and constructed building for the purpose of educating growing children.

The ball is in the court of the Minister. The safety of 33 children is in the hands of the Minister. If there is not a response that this school will be built immediately, I want the Minister to meet the board of management, the principal and the parents because they are anxious and concerned at what may happen. There may be a catastrophe if action is not taken immediately.

Gabhaim buíochas leis an Teachta as ucht an ábhar seo a ardú. I am happy to reply on behalf of my colleague, the Minister for Education and Science, who, unfortunately, cannot be present.

Forgney national school has a staffing level of a principal and one mainstream assistant. The school's enrolment at 30 September 2008 was 26 pupils. The school authority has applied to the Department of Education and Science for capital funding for a new school building. In the context of this application, the local inspector has confirmed that the school is expected to maintain its current enrolment and staffing level. It is not, therefore, experiencing the rapid increase in enrolment that has occurred in other schools around the country.

The Department of Education and Science uses published prioritisation criteria for advancing large scale building projects. There are four band ratings under these criteria with band 1 being the highest and band 4 the lowest. Band ratings describe the type of works needed at a school and the urgency attaching to them. A band 2 rating has been assigned to the proposed building project for Forgney national school reflecting the fact that the standard of its existing accommodation is such that it needs to be replaced by a new building. The structural engineer's report recently filed in the Department of Education and Science by the school authority concurs with this, as expected.

Modernising facilities in our 3,200 primary and 750 post-primary schools is not an easy undertaking. The extent of the demand on the capital budget of the Department of Education and Science is enormous providing, as it does, accommodation for new communities together with accommodation for the unprecedented number of extra teachers this Government has put into the system. As well as this, much of the existing stock, like Forgney national school, must be modernised as a result of historic under-investment. This will not all be achieved overnight.

Thousands of building projects were carried out under the last national development plan, NDP, to provide new and modernised educational infrastructure and thousands more will be carried out under the new NDP. The commitment of this Government to ensuring that all children are educated in appropriate facilities to enable the implementation of a broad and balanced curriculum is evidenced by the scale of funding made available under both the former and current national development plans.

A record €656 million has been made available for the school building programme alone in 2009. This level of funding, at a time of great pressure on the public finances, is a sign of the very real commitment of this Government to investing in school infrastructure. This will not only enable the provision of school places where they are needed but it will also allow the Department of Education and Science to build on the enormous progress made in extending and modernising existing buildings.

The level of demand on the school building programme is such that not all projects can be carried out together. They will have to be carried out in a structured and coherent manner and this is the reasoning behind the Department's prioritisation criteria. The project for Forgney, as with all other building projects, will be consistent with this approach.

In the interim, it is open to the school authority to apply to the Department of Education and Science for funding to repair the existing school building if the board of management deems this necessary.

It cannot be repaired.

In this regard, the Department has no record of having received an application from the board for summer works scheme funding, emergency works scheme funding or under the small schools scheme to address its needs. Having said that, the Department is open to receiving and considering an application for grant aid to repair the building and it will be advising the school authority accordingly.

I thank the Deputy again for raising this matter and assure him that the Department of Education and Science is committed to working with the school authority to resolve the school's accommodation needs.

This school cannot be repaired as it is rotten. The timber is rotten. This is unacceptable.

The Dáil adjourned at 10.45 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Wednesday, 4 March 2009.
Barr
Roinn