At least 90,000 farmers will be brought into the tax net. The Minister assured us that the farm profile he mentioned would be very simple and he gave us examples of the type of questions that would be on it, for example, the number of cattle, acres, and so on. I am not doubting what the Minister said but it seemed a bit too simple. What the Minister and the people who make out these forms regard as simple may not be that simple to farmers around the country, not necessarily in disadvantaged areas only, which Senator O'Toole mentioned this morning. Having sat on many committees and councils over the last few years, I know that pensions officers often disallow pensions because they feel the margins of profit should debar people from receiving pensions. When we talk about the numbers and sales of cattle we have to remember the margins of profit. These will differ greatly from one farmer to another and, indeed, in different parts of the country, as well. It can well happen that the times of selling can vary from one farm to another and prices also. For that reason I am particularly worried about this farm profile.
In spite of the Minister's assurance here that this will be a very simple type of form, I am still convinced that almost all farmers, before they fill in that form, will get advice. I would not tell them that they should not get advice, but this is a very simple form. Whatever they put down on that paper stays. There is an old saying that you cannot unscramble the egg. What they put down may not necessarily be the full truth. I am sure some people often do not necessarily put down the full truth of these forms. The farmers will probably get some advice as to what to put down in relation to the margins of profits. They will have to put down margins of profits because this will differ perhaps from area to area. It would seem strange for example, if it were acceptable to put down the number of acres and the number of cattle. Some investigation of some type would then have to be made.
Senator O'Toole mentioned this morning the number of farmers who have from one to 15 acres. I have no doubt at all that those farmers with one to 15 acres will not have to pay tax. Nonetheless, they will still have to fill in their forms. I believe, although I may be wrong, that these people will still engage accountants. It will still cost them some money to satisfy, not necessarily the Revenue Commissioners, but themselves that what they are putting down is right.
Having worked with farmers for many years and with many farming bodies I would have to say that farmers would be hardly as scared of a war as they would be of tax. In fact, foot and mouth disease would not scare them as much as tax and tax forms. It is true that most farmers are not afraid of work, of using picks and shovels and all those types of implements, but they are very afraid of the pen. Somebody once said that the pen is mightier than the sword. They would much prefer to work for perhaps two more hours out in the yard and in the fields than to work for five minutes with a pen. I do not know who may disagree with me in this House today on that, but I believe that is the truth. I know many farmers. I have worked closely with ACOT committees and many of their advisers. Many simple forms which have gone out in the past are still not filled in by the farmers. They still seek the advice or assistance of the ACOT advisers and as a last resort go to the accountant if they have any greater difficulties.
Very often we see in industry if people are asked to work a few hours overtime in the evening they find that it is scarcely worth working because the tax is such that at the end of the day they do not gain much. I must point out, though I do not agree with it, that some people are so reluctant to pay tax that they feel when they come to a certain stage, possibly the limit when they would have to pay tax, they say "Look, there is not any point in killing ourselves. If we now produce more, we are going to have to pay more tax". It is not a good argument and I am not saying that it is, but it does happen.
What I hope will not happen as a result of this tax is that many farmers, not necessarily from the £1 to £15 valuation but perhaps closer to the £40 valuation, who will survive this year and in the years to come without paying tax on whatever margins of profit or whatever income they have, will have a certain reluctance to increase their output. They may feel that if they increase their output they are going to be caught within that tax net. I want to express the view myself publicly — and I do not mind doing it now — that many farmers would have been happier if they had been hit for a certain figure, whether based on poor law valuation or something else, when they would not have to fill up forms, but would be asked for £X per acre. It is true that the IFA agreed to this, although not in all counties. If they had to pay £X per acre through poor law valuation — that may be gone by the board now — it would mean that these people might well be anxious to work and if they were we should not try to stop them. They could work all night if they would like to. There would be no disincentive there.
I hate to see any disincentive in farming, where we have ready markets for all out produce, be it cattle, corn, or whatever we have. I accept what the Minister and Senator McDonald said, that perhaps there may not be many people whose profits would be such that they would have to pay tax, to whom that would apply. I appeal to the Minister to keep this farm profile which none of us has seen at the moment, very simple. Otherwise, accountants are going to get handy money and farmers are going to have to pay them.
The first time that farmers get this tax profile into their hands, I can see them running to their neighbour almost immediately to see if they got it and what they are going to do with it. I am quite sure that their next trip will be to somebody who has some experience of these forms. They are going to get advice and I want to be on record as saying that I believe it is going to cost them money, unless the form is very simple. He said here yesterday that this form will be very simple and perhaps many of the ACOT advisers will be able to help farmers among their other duties. I do not want it to cost farmers £50, £100 or £200 to get forms filled in. They cannot afford that. I would not like to see them scared into doing that. For that reason, I make this appeal now to the Minister.