Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 12 Dec 2000

Vol. 528 No. 1

Priority Questions. - Private Rented Accommodation.

Ivan Yates

Question:

7 Mr Yates asked the Minister for the Environment and Local Government if he has carried out any assessment on the reduced construction activity and the supply of private rented accommodation and the withdrawal of investment from that sector, arising from the implementation of the third Bacon report; if his attention has been drawn to the prediction of a further 20% increase in rents because of the scarcity of private rented accommodation; if he will ensure that the recommendations of the Commission on the Private Rented Accommodation Sector in regard to investment will be reviewed; and the steps he will take to increase compliance in the sector regarding the registration of all private rented property. [29227/00]

In June last, the Government published Action on Housing, which set out a comprehensive package of measures, taking account of recommendations made by Dr. Bacon in his report and including a range of improvements to the social and affordable housing schemes. It is too early to assess the full impact of the measures taken in Action on Housing, but the indications to date are positive. House price increases are moderating, housing output has increased and first time buyers are gaining an increasing share of the new housing market.

Stamp duty changes introduced in Action on Housing were designed to ease the burden on first time buyers and owner occupiers and to discourage speculative investment which was negatively impacting on the ability of first time buyers to enter the market. A temporary anti-speculative property tax was also introduced to discourage short-term speculative investment by those seeking to make a quick capital gain, with exemptions for landlords who comply with specific regulatory requirements, indicating a commitment to the long-term availability of the accommodation for renting. The measures introduced to discourage speculative investment do not affect the existing supply of rented accommodation. On the other hand, speculative investment provides little long-term accommodation in the rental sector and by driving up house prices also fuels rent increases. The increasing share of first time buyers in the market, as a result of measures to curb speculative investment, should ease somewhat the demand for private rented accommodation and moderate the rate of increase in rents, as those potential first time purchasers had previously been forced into private rented accommodation.

Measures to improve the position of tenants in the private rented residential sector have been introduced in the last two budgets. The ceiling for income tax relief in respect of rent paid by tenants under 55 has doubled. In the case of tenants over 55 a doubling of the ceiling, coupled with standard rating of the relief means that 80% of such tenants gain a doubling of relief. Further measures to increase the availability of private rented accommodation announced in the recent budget include a rent-a-room scheme which provides for an exemption from income tax in respect of gross rental income of up to £6,000 per annum, for accommodation provided in a person's principal private residence.

Additional Information.This measure will facilitate the provision of accommodation thereby easing the pressure on the private rented sector and will improve the utilisation of the housing stock.

I understand that the projected increase of 20% in rents referred to by the Deputy relates to rental properties in premium locations in Dublin and not the wider private rented residential market.

I established a Commission on the Private Rented Residential Sector which reported in July last. The commission identified a growing need for accommodation in the private rented sector and set out a number of recommendations to increase supply, including recommendations aimed at increasing long-term investment in private rented accommodation. The commission also recommended improvements to the regulatory regime for the private rented residential sector with a view to ensuring full compliance with the requirements of the regulations on registration, rent books and standards. The Government is considering its response to the report of the commission.

The Minister of State's long winded reply did not deal with the question. The question asked if he is aware that the Commission on the Private Rented Residential Sector, Threshold, representing tenants and the Irish Property Owners Association have all said that there is a standstill in investment in new private residential accommodation because of the Government's measures, such as the third Bacon report. Is he also aware that people have estimated that the annual requirement is an extra 33,000 units a year and the Government's policy has brought this to a standstill? Will he explain why there was no response in the budget to the commission's recommendations on investment in private rented accommodation? The result of all this will be higher rents.

I am sure the Deputy is aware that I established the Commission on the Private Rented Residential Sector, which reported to me last July. The commission identified the growing need for accommodation in the private rented sector and set out a number of recommendations to increase supply, including recommendations aimed at increasing long-term investment in private rented accommodation. The commission also recommended improvements in the regulatory regime for the private rented residential sector with a view to ensuring full compliance with the requirements of regulations – registration, rent books and standards.

The Government is actively considering its response to the report of the commission and appropriate measures will be introduced by the Government when it has concluded its consideration of the matter. I am anxious that this happens as soon as possible. The Deputy must bear in mind that when the Government introduced the 9% stamp duty level it was done for a specific purpose and that has had an effect. Developers are rethinking a lot of their planning and many developments are now more focused on first time buyers and starter homes than was the case previously, when developers were pitching their plans and buildings at investors. We know what that did to the availability of houses for first time buyers. Government policy in this area is working. Things do not work overnight.

It is getting worse.

There is a lot of readjustment in planning and we are satisfied. We keep a constant eye on the situation and it is under continuous review. Some of the measures taken are short-term but they are having the desired effect, which is reflected in the substantial increase already in the number of dwellings that have been constructed for and purchased by first time buyers. That is reflected in the statistics.

Does the Department monitor the latest situation in relation to the construction of what will be private rented accommodation? Is the Minister of State aware of the predicted 20% cutback in this sector? Will he say why the Government ignored the principal recommendation vis-à-vis tax incentives for private rented investment and say why no aspect of the budget deals with that recommendation? This is separate from legislation.

As I said, the Government has not concluded its deliberations. There was no point in rushing on this matter until we had finally settled and agreed what we were going to do. The Deputy seems happy to throw around the figure of 20% in his question and supplementaries.

Rent increases.

That relates specifically to rental properties in the premium locations of Dublin. The Government is mostly concerned with ensuring that houses are available at a cost which new family formations can afford to purchase – in other words, a first time buyer. That is where our priority lies.

Top
Share