Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 16 May 1979

Vol. 314 No. 5

Adjournment Debate. - Candidates' Free Postage Rights.

(Cavan-Monaghan): At Question Time today I asked the Minister for the Environment the arrangements made or proposed for postal voting, polling cards and candidates' free postage rights in the forthcoming European Assembly elections and local elections in view of the postal strike and if he would make a statement on the matter.

As Deputies will appreciate, under the European Assembly Elections (No. 2) Bill, 1977, provision is made for postal voting for the Garda and members of the Army, for the sending of a polling card to each elector entitled to vote and——

On a point of order, is this debate confined to free postage?

Free postage rights only; it covers nothing else.

(Cavan-Monaghan): The Minister should have patience and wait to hear what I have to say. Provision is made whereby candidates have the right to send a communication to each elector in their constituencies. In answer to my question the Minister informed me that he had made regulations in regard to postal voting and in regard to polling cards. I understand——

We cannot discuss polling cards. The debate is confined to free postage for candidates.

(Cavan-Monaghan): If the Chair would have patience with me——

No one has more patience than the Chair.

(Cavan-Monaghan): I was told by the Minister today that he had made arrangements by regulations. Because he has made arrangements I understand that I am precluded from raising these two matters in the debate. The Minister did not tell me how he proposed to deal with the rights of candidates to send a communication to each elector on the register, which they are entitled to do by virtue of Rule 18 of the First Schedule to the European Assembly Elections (No. 2) Bill, 1977, which reads:

Subject to paragraph (3) of this Rule, each candidate at an Assembly election shall, subject to such conditions as may be determined by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, be entitled to send, free of any charge for postage, to each person on the register of European Assembly electors for the constituency, one postal communication containing matter relating to the election only and not exceeding two ounces in weight.

That is a statutory right conferred on each candidate nominated for the European election.

While the Minister has made provision for postal voting and for sending polling cards, which I do not agree with but which I am precluded from discussing during the debate, he has not made alternative arrangements and has not amended the Act, or apparently does not propose to do so, in regard to the rights of candidates to send a communication to each elector on the register.

I want the Minister to tell me what he proposes to do in the matter. It is obvious that the postal strike will not be settled in sufficient time to allow such communications to be sent. Even if it were settled now it would not be possible for such communications to be despatched and delivered in time.

Every Electoral Act since the foundation of the State—I think the first one was in 1923—made provision for free postal facilities for candidates in elections and the latest Act makes provision for free postal facilities for candidates in the European election. The fact that the General Post Office has not been closed since the Rising in 1916, except on Sundays and Bank Holidays, until the current dispute will go down in history.

Unless the Minister convinces me otherwise, I believe that a candidate who is defeated or wants to question the election on the grounds that he was deprived of the right to send out a communication to the electors might well succeed in upsetting the election. Perhaps the Minister can convince me that is not so and I will be glad if he can. Apart from that, it is a national disgrace with the forthcoming election which is making history in the country because it is the first time that our citizens, in common with the citizens in eight other countries, will go to the polls to elect representatives to the same assembly. It is the first time since this country was partitioned that members of every county will go to the polls on the same day to elect representatives to the same assembly. That will go down in history.

It is appalling that candidates are to be deprived of the fundamental right to send communications to electors. Has the Minister given any thought to this? What does he propose to do about it? Perhaps I should address this question to his colleague the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs: why is something not being done to settle this strike? The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs claims that he could not get down to discuss the matter with the striking union——

The Deputy is getting into the area of the strike.

(Cavan-Monaghan): If the strike was settled this would not arise.

The Deputy cannot discuss the strike on this question. Nothing arises under the question except free postage for candidates.

We have no post.

(Cavan-Monaghan): While the Minister is not prepared to speak to the striking union personally he is speaking to them in a roundabout way through a third party.

I have told the Deputy we cannot discuss the strike on this question because there is nothing on this question, only one simple thing, free postage for candidates.

(Cavan-Monaghan): We have no free post because there is a strike. If I could persuade the Minister to settle the strike my problem would be solved.

It does not arise on this question.

(Cavan-Monaghan): Of course it does. We have no free postage because this country is crippled by a strike and the Chair tells me that the strike does not arise.

The Chair is telling the Deputy that he received permission to raise on the Adjournment one matter and one matter only. The strike cannot be raised on the Adjournment. That is a matter, for another Minister.

(Cavan-Monaghan): I do not care what Minister it is for it is a national disgrace and will become an international disgrace. Our candidates are the only candidates in the whole European Community who have no post.

The Deputy seems to have made up his mind once and for all that there will be no free postage. Whether there is or not, it is not for me to find a substitute way of delivering these letters. The man who gives this service is the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. Under the 1977 Act, as the Deputy rightly mentioned, provision is made for free postage for each candidate for the European Assembly. There is no provision in any Act which provides this for the local elections, as the Deputy knows.

(Cavan-Monaghan): I did not say there was.

The Deputy may be right in his assumption about the service not being available due to the strike.

The Minister is not supposed to mention the strike.

There are still three weeks to go to polling day. The wiser people will have their election material ready to post in the hope that they will be able to do so. Perhaps the Deputy is attaching too much importance to the free postage. The most effective way to get to any electorate is by personal canvassing. During this canvass——

Thank you for the advice.

——it is possible to deliver whatever one wants to deliver under the free postage. Perhaps this party is more fortunate than the Deputy's because we have an organisation which will cover any part of any constituency——

The Minister is out of order.

He is giving advice on how to get out of the free post situation.

The Minister is in the Dáil now, not in the RDS.

I was asked for a substitute for having no postage. Our organisation should be taken as an example by Deputies——

(Interruptions.)

(Cavan-Monaghan): I was trying to help the Minister to solve the problem.

The Minister is out of order.

The Minister is not out of order. He is not discussing the strike. He is putting forward an alternative and he is entitled to do so.

I am stating that in our party we are prepared for any emergency as we have always been. We will be able to deal with this matter. We are certain that what would be sent under the free postage we will be able to deliver——

Will that not break the strike?

We will be canvassing every household in the country and, as in the normal way, we will hand people literature.

If the Minister proposes to deliver it by hand he is breaking the strike.

Do not worry, Deputy, we will get over that. With regard to polling cards and the other matters, I took care of that. We are dependent on the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the present situation in the post office as to whether we can give free postage to the Deputy who seems to be a pessimist.

(Cavan-Monaghan): Where is the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs? Has he emigrated? He has not been seen or heard of. Hugh Leonard thinks he was stuffed.

The Deputy's party must not be going to do any canvassing at all. We do not attach the same importance to this matter as the Deputy does. The wiser people will have it ready if they still want to post it. There are still three weeks to go. I would advise the Deputy and his party to get their literature ready if they are totally dependent on the postal service.

(Cavan-Monaghan): I put one question to the Minister and he has not answered it yet.

It is not for me to find the alternative in this instance. I do not provide the service. Under the 1977 Act I make it possible to have free postage but the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs provides the service. I have tried to be helpful to the Deputy and his party by making the suggestion about personal delivery. Personal contact is far more important, as the Deputy know, than letters thrown in through the letter box.

The Dáil adjourned at 9 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Thursday, 17 May 1979.

Top
Share