asked the Minister for Agriculture the basis upon which, for the purposes of artificial insemination subsidy schemes, the Ayrshire cattle breed is termed a dairy breed rather than a dual-purpose breed; whether he is aware of the qualities of Ayrshire beef and that in some foreign countries Ayrshire outproduce Friesians; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Ceisteanna — Questions. Oral Answers. - Ayrshire Cattle.
9.
The artificial insemination subsidy was part of the EC common measure for the development of beef cattle production. The EC Commission decided that, as the measure was designed to stimulate beef production, the subsidy would apply only to beef and dual-purpose breeds. Accordingly, dairy breeds, including the Ayrshire, were ineligible.
Perhaps the Minister would indicate the basis upon which it was decided that the Ayrshire cattle breed is termed a pure dairy breed rather than a dual purpose breed? Was that decided by the EC or by the Department?
It was decided by the EC.
Is the Minister aware that there is ample evidence to suggest that the Ayrshire breed can outstrip its black and white rivals in terms of weight, percentage of fat and production efficiency? If he accepts this evidence it is unfair to the promoters of the Ayrshire breed to be treated in this way.
It is of historic interest now because the subsidies are gone.
I accept that but my question is still valid because I want to know whether the Department take the view that the Ayrshire breed is a pure dairy breed. Does the Minister accept that there is evidence to suggest that it is a dual purpose breed and that, in future circumstances, as for example in relation to the AI subsidy, they should not be discriminated against?
I consider the Ayrshire to be a pure dairy breed.
(Limerick West): That view is as good as the Deputy will get.