Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 25 Jun 1985

Vol. 359 No. 9

Estimates, 1985. - Air India Aircraft Crash: Statements.

I know that all Members of the House will wish to join with me in expressing our deepest sympathy to all those bereaved or who otherwise suffered loss as a result of the tragic crash of Air India flight AI 182 which occurred off the Kerry coast last Sunday morning. A tragedy which claimed the lives of all 329 people — passengers and crew — on board the Boeing 747 is truly horrific and our heartfelt sorrow, and that of the entire Irish nation, goes out to all who have lost their loved ones in the disaster.

Air India flight AI 182, a Boeing 747, Registration No. VT. EFO, en route from Montreal to London and destined for Bombay was in radio communication and radar contact with Shannon Air Traffic Control and the last voice contact with Shannon was at 0709 GMT (0809 local time). At 0713 GMT (0813 local Irish time), the aircraft disappeared from the radar screen. The position of the aircraft at the time was 51º N 12.50º W, which is approximately 100 nautical miles from the Kerry coast. No distress message was received from the aircraft but at approximately 0803 GMT (0903 local time) signals were picked up from an emergency location transmitter.

A massive search and rescue operation was immediately launched under the control of the Marine Rescue Co-ordination Centre, Shannon, involving a wide range of services, Air Traffic Services, the Air Corps, the Naval Service, the RAF, the Royal Navy, the US Air Force, the lifeboats from Valentia, Courtmac-sharry, Baltimore and Ballycotton, land based services such as Shannon Aeradio (Ballygirreen), Valentia Coast Station, the Meteorological Service, the Garda and the Southern Health Board. An emergency plan for the reception of casualties was put into immediate operation at the Cork Regional Hospital.

On being informed of the incident just before 10 o'clock on Sunday morning, I immediately notified the Taoiseach and other Ministers who might be affected. The Indian Ambassador was notified by the Department of Foreign Affairs. I assembled a team of technical and administrative officials from my Department, together with representatives from the Department of Foreign Affairs, from the Office of the Attorney General and from the Government Information Service. A team of officials was subsequently despatched to Cork Airport and an all-night emergency telephone service was opened up within my Department.

Wreckage from the aircraft and bodies were located over a five square mile stretch of the sea about 112 miles southwest of Mizen Head. Unfortunately, no survivors were found and up to midnight on Sunday 130 bodies had been recovered, most being brought to Cork Regional Hospital. The search was continued through Sunday night by the LE Aisling, the LE Emer and HMS Challen-ger, supported by a Nimrod aircraft, and the full air and sea search was resumed at dawn yesterday morning. While further wreckage was recovered, only one body was located; 198 victims are still missing and, with the hopes of finding them diminished, the search has been scaled back. However, the LE Aisling and LE Emer, with assistance from the Irish Air Corps, will continue to search.

Investigation of the accident will be conducted under the provisions of Annex 13 to the Chicago Convention and will also, we understand, be subject to a judicial inquiry under Indian law. While the aircraft was under the control of Shannon Air Traffic Control at the time of the crash, it was operating in international air space over the high seas. Annex 13 provides that in such situations responsibility for the investigation of an accident rests with the state of registry of the air-craft—in this case the Indian authorities. Official representatives from India have already arrived in Ireland and have visited Cork and overflown the scene of the crash. Preliminary consultations have taken place with officials from my Department and with representatives from the Canadian and United States authorities. I had a meeting this afternoon with the Indian representatives and have pledged the full co-operation and assistance of my Department in the investigation. It is our intention that, subject to the agreement of the Indian authorities, a representative of the Department of Communications will participate in the investigation. The United States, as country of manufacture of the aircraft, and Canada, as country of origin of the flight, are, of course, keenly interested and already have representatives in attendance in Cork.

I understand from the Indian authorities that they are currently exploring with experts from the United Kingdom, the United States and Canada possibilities for recovery of the aircraft's "black box" from the ocean bed.

While there has been speculation as to the causes of the accident, we must await the outcome of the official investigation before any definitive conclusions are drawn. Nonetheless, given the speculation that has taken place, it makes it all the more important that the autopsies, forensic, ballistic and other tests be absolutely thorough in order to adduce every bit of evidence as to the cause of the disaster. The work being conducted under the Chief State Pathologist in this regard will be completed as speedily as possible. The Cork City Coroner is addressing the problem of identification of those bodies recovered which is a necessary prerequisite to the release of the bodies.

Aside altogether from the present tragedy, the happenings of recent weeks in the aviation world have served to point up the vulnerability of the industry to acts of terrorism. The civil aviation community has adopted comprehensive and resolute measures at international level to ensure the maximum safeguards against hijacking and other acts of terrorism—as evidenced by the Conventions of Tokyo, the Hague and Montreal — and the industry, at governmental level under the auspices of ICAO — the International Civil Aviation Organisation, which is the governing body for international civil aviation — and at airline level under the auspices of IATA, the International Air Transport Association, is urgently reviewing the world aviation security situation. Because of the tragedy I was unable to attend a meeting of EC Ministers of Transport held in Luxembourg yesterday, but I know that the Council was both shocked at the disaster and, on a wider level, concerned about the safety exposure of passengers and air crews and of aircraft and airports to acts of terrorism.

For our part in Ireland, I should say that we have ratified all three international Conventions and we observe a very high standard of security both at our airports and by the national airline. We must exercise constant vigilance in this area and yesterday I directed both Aer Rianta and Aer Lingus to take any necessary additional precautions in the area of security in the light of recent events.

As an island nation, tragedies at sea are nothing new to us. A disaster on the scale suffered last Sunday, involving as it did the largest ever loss of lives in an air accident at sea, cannot but touch all of us very deeply. The Taoiseach on Sunday spoke by telephone to the Indian Prime Minister, Mr. Rajiv Gandhi, and to the Canadian Prime Minister, Mr. Brian Mulroney, and conveyed his sympathy and that of the Irish people at the very tragic loss of life. A personal message of thanks has been received by the Taoiseach from the Indian Prime Minister. I have conveyed my sympathy directly to the Canadian Minister for Transport, Mr. Donald Mazankowski, and have met the Indian Ambassador through whom I have conveyed my sympathy to the Indian Minister of State for Civil Aviation.

I believe that all in this House will, on behalf of the Irish Government, both Houses of the Oireachtas and the Irish people, wish to convey to the Indian and Canadian authorities, and to all who have been bereaved or have suffered in any way from the disaster, our heartfelt sorrow.

In conclusion, I would like to place on record my thanks and the thanks of the Government to all who assisted in the rescue effort — to the Air Traffic Control service at Shannon, whose diligence and professionalism speedily identified and pinpointed the incident, to the staff of the Marine Rescue Co-ordination Centre who set the rescue mission in motion and who were assisted by Shannon Aeradio and Valentia Coast Radio and by the Falmouth and Swansea Rescue Co-ordination Centres, to the Air Traffic Control Services at Cork and Dublin, to all those who participated in the search at sea, including the members of the Irish Navy and Air Corps, the members of the Royal Air Force and the United States Air Force, the Royal Navy, the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, the captains and crews of other vessels that assisted in the search, to the Meteorological Service, to all of the staff at Cork Airport, to the Garda and the Army, to the staff of Telecom Éireann, to the staff of the Southern Health Board, and in particular to the staff of the Cork Regional Hospital who are dealing with the situation in a most professional way. It would be very remiss of me not to thank the administrative and technical staff of my own Department, the Department of Foreign Affairs, the Attorney General's Office and the Government Information Service. Finally, I would also like to place on record in a special way the Government's appreciation of the kindness and generosity of the Cork people who offered all possible assistance to the relatives of the dead. I am sure that the House will wish to join with me in conveying the sincerest thanks to everyone associated in any way with the rescue mission and in conveying to the Indian and Canadian peoples our profound sympathy.

On behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party I wish to express sympathy with the Government of India, Air India and the relatives of the people who were killed in this dreadful disaster. As the Minister has coupled Canada, the place where the flight originated — it is appropriate that he should do so — I wish to include the people who have a responsibility in Canada for the airports and security. It strikes a chord in Ireland when we read that the majority of the people who were travelling were of the Indian diaspora. It is something that is appreciated here that they were for the most part emigrants from India who were returning on holiday. That is an added motive for the House, and the people of Ireland, to feel an empathy with them and sympathy for their relatives.

Comparatively recently I travelled part of a journey in the United States with a family that was returning to India on holidays. The little girl who sat beside me emigrated at three years of age, had returned to India on a holiday at seven years of age and then, at 11 years of age, was joyfully returning to India as a result of the better economic circumstances which her parents who were with her had found in the United States. This adds to the tragedy which we now have to deal with in the manner outlined by the Minister.

The Minister very wisely avoided any speculation as to what caused the accident. We know what the media are saying and we will have to await a specific judgment of what actually happened. One of the possibilities indicates that our civilisation, our civilised modes of behaviour, are in danger. I should like, with the Minister, to commend the Irish air and sea input into the recovery effort which has been taking place. We had to change the word "rescue" for "recovery" seeing that nobody could be rescued. In particular, the Cork Airport authorities, and the Cork medical people in general, deserve our commendation for their efforts and the work which must have been very testing and severe and called on all their resources without sleep or rest for a long period when the disaster struck. The House should emphasise that in a world where media often belong in certain areas the efforts of a country where there is not such widespread media power should be highlighted by the House.

I note that the Minister referred to the thoroughness with which all operations, particularly the medical ones, post mortems, inquests and so on, will have to be carried out. It is important that this should be done thoroughly to give the people who will be assessing the cause of the disaster a proper scientific basis upon which to base their judgment.

There have been reports that the Xray or testing mechanisms at the airport of origin failed for a period on that day and I would like the Minister to take into account that danger at our airports. There should be some kind of fail-safe apparatus to deal with cases like that. We have considerable traffic through Shannon and Dublin and some international traffic through Cork. I should like to commend the Minister — it may not have been necessary but it was the proper exercise — for warning the authorities to see to it that no opportunity is given to people who are evilly disposed to board airplanes here with arms, bombs, explosives or hand grenades. With renewed sympathy to the Government and people of India and the relatives of the deceased, with a note of sympathy for the Canadian airport authorities and Government, I should like to support what the Minister has said.

On behalf of The Workers' Party I should like to extend sympathy to the Government and people of India on this dreadful tragedy. The scale of the loss on life on this occasion was truly horrific, particularly as all of them were innocent people, including children, on their way to their home country. Coming less than 12 months after the assassination of the Indian Prime Minister, Mrs. Gandhi, it is indeed a terrible blow to the Indian people. If, as has been suggested, the disaster was due to a bomb being placed on the plane it is a shocking indictment of the lengths to which terrorists, especially those motivated by religious or racial hatred, are prepared to go. Our people, North and South, understand the effects of terrorists bombs on innocent people and the brutalising effect they can have on society. We sympathise in this regard with the Indian people.

Anyone who was watching the film of the search operation immediately after the crash and the subsequent efforts to recover bodies and establish the cause of the disaster cannot but have been impressed by the way our emergency services reacted to the disaster. All those involved, including the Naval Service, the Army, the lifeboat service, medical personnel and so on, deserve the appreciation of all Members. I am sure, as the Minister stated, that a warm welcome and full assistance will be given to relatives of the victims when they come here.

Top
Share