Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 24 Nov 1954

Vol. 44 No. 3

Cork Fever Hospital (Amendment) Bill, 1954—Second and Subsequent Stages.

Question proposed: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."

The Long Title of this Bill is "An Act to amend and extend the Cork Fever Hospital Acts, 1935 and 1938." It will be of assistance to Senators in considering the measure if I review briefly the broad provisions of those Acts.

The 1935 Act, which was amended slightly in 1938, authorised the replacement of an old fever hospital situated at Richmond Hill in Cork by a new infectious diseases hospital. The Cork Corporation was charged with the building work which was to be financed mainly from the Hospitals' Trust Fund. It was the intention that when the new building was ready the committee of the old hospital, which includes representatives of the Cork Corporation and Cork County Council, would hand over its administration to a new board. That board would have consisted initially of five representatives of Cork Corporation, five of the county council, and five elected by the old committee. As members of the latter group disappeared, by death, resignation or otherwise, they would be replaced by representatives of the two local authorities. In time, therefore, the new board would have been itself a local authority. The staff was to have been taken over by the new board on their existing conditions of service.

Those then were the terms of the 1935 Act and they seemed wise and prudent provisions until subsequent events made them out of date.

A site for the new hospital was chosen at Gurranebraher and development work started in 1940. This took four years to complete but, happily as it transpired, emergency conditions delayed the erection of a new hospital.

A significant and sustained decline had in the meantime been noted in the incidence of infectious diseases and by the time building work could commence it was evident that fresh consideration must be given to the proposal to proceed with the building of a new hospital for that specific purpose. For example, the number of cases of diphtheria in Cork City and County fell from 186 in 1935 to 22 in 1950 and of typhoid from 57 in 1935 to one in 1950.

This meant simply that so many less beds were needed for the treatment of infectious diseases. Over the whole range of infectious diseases there was a welcome falling off in demand for hospital treatment, a falling off which modern treatment procedures emphasised and increased. This desirable and wholesome trend called for a general review of the hospital needs in the area and led to the conclusion that the expected future requirements in Cork for infectious disease accommodation could be met by existing institutions, thus releasing the Gurranebraher hospital for other use. There are in the area an insufficient number of beds for the treatment of orthopaedic defects and it was agreed with the Cork Corporation that the new hospital could best be used as an orthopaedic hospital. The incidence of orthopaedic defects is remarkably high and the 133 beds in the Gurranebraher Hospital will be fully utilised. The Bill now before the House will permit this change to be made.

It is not now considered necessary to set up a special board for the new hospital as the 1935 Act contemplated. Instead, it is proposed to hand over its administration to an existing joint board, the South Cork Board of Public Assistance, which consists of members of Cork Corporation and Cork County Council. This board is already administering St. Finbarr's Hospital, Cork, and district hospitals in Bandon, Kinsale, Macroom, Midleton and Younghal. The board of assistance and the committee of the old hospital agree with this.

I have been asked about the position of the existing paid officers of the old hospital. The Act of 1935 provided that they should be taken over by the authority administering the new hospital on the same tenure of office and rights as they previously had. This still holds good although, of course, the authority will now be the board of public assistance. The provisions of the 1935 Act regarding the superannuation of such officers have been added to in order to take the later provisions of the Local Government (Superannuation) Act, 1948, into account.

The committee of management have, I am glad to say, agreed to the present proposals.

I have paid tribute to them before and I do so again for their long and faithful work in the public service. I know that the people of Cork appreciate the services given to them by the committee who have now placed in the competent and able hands of the South Cork Board of Public Assistance responsibility for the hospital treatment of infectious diseases in the area.

I wish to express my approval of this Bill. Its necessity arises because of the very good news conveyed to us by the Minister that the incidence of infectious diseases such as diphtheria and typhoid in Cork City and County is now almost nil, thank God. This Bill seeks to convert what was originally intended as the Cork Fever Hospital into the orthopaedic hospital. I think we should at this stage join with the Minister in paying tribute to the committee and staff of the Richmond Fever Hospital in Cork who throughout the years gave such unselfish and faithful service to those suffering from these dreadful diseases.

It is a great source of satisfaction to the committee and staff to know that the incidence of these diseases has been reduced almost to nil.

I regret the report of the increased incidence of orthopaedic ailments in Cork City and County, and to hear that in that respect the position is not so good. Unfortunately at the moment we have in the city and county a waiting list of 200, or perhaps more people awaiting treatment for this ailment. This hospital will, I understand, be ready for opening probably early in the new year. We in Cork feel that every day on which it is not available to the people is a day too long, in bringing relief to those suffering from orthopædic ailments and waiting for hospital treatment. I trust that, please God, when this hospital is fully equipped, and working satisfactorily, in a few years' time we will have the same good news from it as we have had from the Richmond Hospital —that it is no longer required for its purpose.

I would like to suggest to the Minister that in Section 6 of the Bill it should be no longer necessary to refer to it as the Cork Fever Hospital Bill, or Act, when it is passed, and I would suggest that the title be amended from Cork Fever Hospital Bill, 1954 to the Cork Orthopaedic Hospital Bill, 1954. There is surely no necessity to have the word fever any longer associated with that hospital.

I wish to commend this Bill to the House and I trust that it will have a speedy passage and that the arrangements will be made before the end of the year, if possible, to open the doors of this hospital to the very large number of people who so urgently need treatment for orthopaedic ailments.

May I, as a Corkman, say how gratifying it is to know that the Cork health authorities have by their efforts nullified the necessity for additional accommodation for infectious diseases. I am sure the Minister must be very pleased to see the success which has attended State medicine in its preventive aspects, and like the other speaker I certainly trust that the public health authority in Cork will have as great a success in the curative aspect of public health as they did in regard to the prevention of infectious diseases.

I want to endorse the statements of the two Senators who have spoken, and to express pleasure that this hospital in Cork is going to be opened soon to fill a very long felt want in the city and county. When we hear of the increase in the orthopaedic ailments and the large numbers waiting for hospital treatment, I would be rather inclined to suggest to the Minister that so far as the health of children is concerned there are other things beside hospital treatment which mean much.

We talk too much about health, while we hardly ever speak about the root causes of ailments. I think that ailments in young children are due to the lack of sufficient food and nourishment. We talk about the health of the people, but I believe we should pay more attention to prevention rather than cure, because in the case of the fever hospital that is a question of prevention and having attention paid to sanitary conditions. I think, however, as regards the increased number of children awaiting treatment in the new hospital, that is due also to lack of sufficient food and nourishment.

I should like to thank the House for the co-operative manner in which they have received this Bill. It is a great pleasure to me as Minister for Health to have co-operation in a matter of this kind.

The new hospital in Cork which will deal with orthopaedic ailments will, of course, take on a big task in the beginning. The question of dealing with orthopaedic defects and providing an orthopaedic service is, of course, going ahead at the moment and has been for some time past. One reason why there is such a large waiting list in Cork, and indeed elsewhere, is the development of a fine diagnostic service for these ailments. More orthopaedic cases are being discovered nowadays and are being rightly regarded as cases for hospital treatment. Formerly, they were not discovered and in fact it let to persons being made permanent invalids. Now, with the development of the orthopaedic service, more cases have been discovered, and therefore there is a waiting list, for instance, in Cork and the new hospital will have to discharge that waiting list, but I believe that, once it is opened, it will gradually be able to deal with the needs of Cork City and County, and also with the needs of nearby regions.

I agree with what has been said by Senators with regard to the need for preventive medicine and that has always been pressed forward by me and by my predecessors. It is an old saying that prevention is better than cure. We have to cure, but we should also aim at prevention. A very good example of the success of preventive medicine is found in the need for this Bill. The development in this country over the last 30 years of our public health services dealing with diseases has brought about a remarkable change in the incidence of diseases here. The development of immunisation against diphtheria, smallpox, vaccination and other preventive measures of the kind has brought a situation in this country to-day when diseases and fevers have ceased to be a serious menace. There is, of course, a danger that a feeling of public complacency may arise. Since fevers are no longer commonplace, people may regard them as not dangers. For that reason, in recent health conferences which I had with different health authorities, I appealed to public representatives to help to inform public opinion and to continue co-operation with immunisation schemes and other branches of preventive medicine. They have succeeded, but it would be very regrettable if that very success caused such a public complacency that these voluntary preventive services were no longer availed of. If that happened, fevers could again become a social menace and indeed we might be looking for further fever hospital accommodation.

Senator O'Sullivan mentioned the Title of the Bill. The reason the Bill is entitled the "Cork Fever Hospital (Amendment) Bill" is that it is designed to amend the Cork Fever Hospital Act of 1935. Indeed, if it were called, as the Senator suggested, the Cork Orthopaedic Hospital Bill, I think it would be necessary for myself or some future Minister to come back to the Oireachtas and ask it to change the Title of the Bill to enable the hospital to be used for some other purpose.

Question put and agreed to.
Agreed to take remaining stages now.
Bill considered in Committee.
Sections 1 to 5, inclusive, agreed to.
Question proposed: "That Section 6 stand part of the Bill."

On Section 6, I would like to urge that the title be amended to the Cork Orthopaedic Hospital Bill. I cannot see any reason why this Bill cannot be so called and I ask the Minister to accept that amendment.

I am afraid it could not be so called and, even if it could be, I would not like to call it the Cork Orthopaedic Hospital Bill because I hope, as a result of the Cork hospital, orthopaedic ailments will cease to be a problem in Cork and that the hospital will in future be used for something else. If it is not tied down to a particular use, it could be used for any purpose, and I think that is a better way to leave it.

Question put and agreed to.
Title agreed to.
Bill reported without amendment, received for final consideration and passed.
Top
Share