Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 5 Nov 2008

Vol. 191 No. 17

Museum Projects.

I wish to share one minute of my time with Senator Hannigan if that is agreed.

I thank the Cathaoirleach for allowing me to raise this matter on the Adjournment. I also declare an interest in that my grandfather, James Keaveney, spent 13 months in hut 27 of one of the camps in Ballykinlar. As he did not speak to many about his experience afterwards, as is the case with most prisoners, we hold on to the one story he did leave. He had a white handkerchief with a red stain on it. When in later years his son asked him about it he said that one of two men who were in two huts separated by a wire fence had received a package from home. They tried to share information with each other about what was in a letter. The guards watching decided that they were planning an escape and so they shot one of the men but the bullet went through him and also killed the other. My grandfather said he dipped his handkerchief in the blood so that he would never forget what had happened.

I have read in archival sources that this episode is recorded simply that the guards had orders to shoot anyone approaching the wire and no one doubted they were quite prepared to shoot. In January 1921, James Sloan and James Tormey, both from County Westmeath, were shot down in Ballykinlar camp for getting too close to the wire, as it were.

I maintain we should not forget James Keaveney and the many other prisoners of the internment camps of Ballykinlar, Frongoch and the Curragh. As we move into a new phase in Irish history, the ability to look at our history, to understand what brought us to where we are and to explore remembrance is needed as much as ever. There are many people on the island of Ireland who had relatives in these camps and who struggle to get any information as to who was there, how long they were there and the reason for their internment.

The websites show the autograph books and the comments made by many of the families and comments made by the prisoners. Many people of my generation do not even know that Ballykinlar existed. I have visited other locations recently as I am currently doing a report for the Council of Europe on how to teach history in areas of recent conflict and the message is clear: to proceed by ignoring history can only lead to problems. Remembrance and viewing history from many perspectives can only enhance the experience for the student. It assists them to develop a critical and analytical mind, which is what all employers want.

I suggest that talks be commenced with our Northern counterparts to develop an interpretative centre at Ballykinlar where all archives can be sourced, collated and put on display. This could link into a larger project in the other two internment camp locations which would thereby link Wales and the North and South of Ireland. I have already had interactions with people who hold significant photo, arrest warrant and death certificate primary source materials. If these types of resources are not collated now they will be gone for good. Already we have lost the primary source of the prisoners and guards themselves; we have no more time to lose.

This may be controversial. Some people say they cannot decide on what to do with the site of the Maze Prison but I do not regard these two issues as being the same. The time factor is significant, as is the historical context. We are approaching the anniversary of the 1916 Rising and the 1920-21 activities evolve from that. It is an opportunity to work to putting the various bits of information in some format that will be accessible for all. Marc Bloch said that history can be a knife to kill or cut meat. In this instance I want history to be useful and just to cut meat. As I search the web pages under Ballykinlar for more information and more understanding of my past, I trust this Adjournment matter may be the beginning of what I call an all-Ireland cultural tourism project similar to those taking place across Europe and beyond. The fact I am sharing my time with a colleague on the Opposition benches shows that this is a consideration worthy of more thought.

I welcome the Minister of State to the House and thank Senator Keaveney for being so generous with her time. I echo the call she makes for an interpretative centre at Ballykinlar camp.

My grandfather, Patrick Boylan, was a member of the old IRA in County Monaghan. He spent nine months in Ballykinlar in the early 1920s. I remember well the stories he told me as a boy. For him and for many small farmers who took up arms on behalf of their country, this was their first time being away from their homes and families and it was a very frightening period for them. In the words of Michael Collins, it became a university of revolution for them. As a tribute to the efforts they made in the cause of our independence, this interpretative centre would be very fitting. I ask the Minister of State to give serious consideration to progressing such a scheme so that it will be in place in time for the centenary of the War of Independence in 13 short years' time. Go raibh maith agat.

I am taking the Adjournment on behalf of my colleague, the Minister for Arts, Sport and Tourism, Deputy Martin Cullen. I thank Senators Keaveney and Hannigan for raising this matter.

I applaud the well-informed and sincere interest shown by Senators in matters relating to our archival heritage. With regard to the Ballykinlar material and site, I understand that the Department of Culture, Arts and Leisure in Northern Ireland does not have ministerial responsibility for the site in question which is still the property of the United Kingdom Ministry of Defence. In the UK the principal repository for records relating to internment camps and prisons in Ireland for the 1914 to 1922 period is the UK national archives in Kew, but not all of these records are currently publicly accessible.

In this jurisdiction, the only State collecting agency with any records of significance in relation to Ballykinlar is the National Library of Ireland in the Seán O'Mahony collection. Mr. O'Mahony is a former bank manager who enthusiastically collected republican memorabilia over many years and the National Library purchased his collection some years ago. During the War of Independence, republican prisoners were interned in the camp at Ballykinlar, County Down, controlled by the British garrison in Ballykinlar Barracks. Prisoners within the camp produced arts and crafts, plays, a journal called The Barbed Wire and their own money tokens. The O’Mahony collection contains copies of some contemporary items from Ballykinlar as well as letters and notes produced while he was researching his own book on the camp. The list of the collection can be viewed on the National Library website under the heading, Manuscripts Collections. I also understand there is a similar collection of Ballykinlar material in Kilmainham Gaol.

Senators will appreciate the financial limitations placed on Departments in relation to new projects that require buildings. However, the collection and the making available of heritage data such as the Senator has mentioned can be made a reality without the need for buildings by means of digitisation and the Internet. In this regard, I am pleased to report that the digitisation of the 1901 and 1911 census returns undertaken by the National Archives in conjunction with its partner, Library and Archives Canada, is progressing well. The Irish census returns of 1901 and 1911 are an extremely valuable part of Irish documentary heritage. They are the individual household returns completed by each head of household and supplementary records created by the census enumerators. These records are an invaluable resource for family historians, genealogists, local historians and other scholars.

The returns for 1901 and 1911 are arranged by townland or, in urban areas, by street. The 1901 census lists for every member of each household the name, age, sex, relationship to head of the household, religion, occupation, marital status and county or country of birth. The census also records an individual's ability to read or write and ability to speak the Irish language. The same information was recorded in the 1911 census, with one significant addition — married women were required to state the number of years they had been married, the number of their children born alive and the number still living. In addition to returns for every household in the country, both censuses contain returns for police and military barracks, public and private asylums, prisons, hospitals, workhouses, colleges, boarding schools and industrial schools, among other institutions.

The Minister for Arts, Sport and Tourism launched the first live phase of the project in December 2007. The website www.census.nationalarchives.ie contains the 1911 census returns for Dublin city and county and is free to access online. Ireland is the first of the English-speaking countries to make its census records, with an index to every name, available free online. For the first time, the people of Ireland and the Irish diaspora spread across the globe will be able to search for their ancestors by name. The new website also features a wealth of historical and illustrative material to bring alive the Dublin of 1911. Many beautiful photographs from partners in the project, including the National Library, the Royal Society of Antiquaries, Dublin City Archives, the Railway Records Society and others, are available to view on the website.

This is but the first phase of the project, which will be followed in phases with the digitisation of the remainder of the 1911 census and then the 1901 census. Since Dublin city and county for 1911 went live last December on the National Archives' website, it has resulted in phenomenal interest both in Ireland and abroad, with in excess of 2.5 million site visits and in excess of 39 million hits. It has also resulted in members of the public actively visiting the National Archives premises to make family-tree related inquiries.

Senators will also be interested if I mention the military service pensions project. The State holds nearly 300,000 files in the military archives relating to the period from Easter Week 1916 through the War of Independence and the Civil War up to October 1924. The intention behind this project, which was announced by the Taoiseach in 2006 in the context of the 90th anniversary of the Easter Rising, is to make these records publicly available in the run-up to the 1916 centenary in 2016. Already, a specialist steering committee and an advisory board of historians are working on the project. The data and accounts contained within this archive are second to none in relevance for anyone studying family or other histories in the 1916 and War of Independence period and, undoubtedly, Ballykinlar will feature strongly in the personal stories contained in that archive. These records will greatly enhance our understanding of this period and the people who played a direct role in the historic events.

I note the worthy contributions to this debate and I assure this House that the relevant officials will carefully consider these contributions as projects are progressed. I thank Senators for their interest.

Following from the Minister of State's comments that the details we need are currently under lock and key in the UK Ministry of Defence, will he take back the message to the Department that the Minister for Arts, Sport and Tourism would talk to his counterpart in the UK — perhaps the Secretary of State, Mr. Shaun Woodward — to encourage the UK to release those archives to us in order that we can display them?

While I accept the budgetary parameters are tight, this project is different given it has a tripartite dimension between the North, the South and Wales. There used to be a soldiers and sailors fund relating to peace and reconciliation in the International Fund for Ireland. With the Ministry of Defence moving out of the North, a fitting tribute would be for it to make some contribution to developing a commemoration.

As far I am concerned, this is the start of the road, not the end. I would like to think the Minister of State will take our suggestions back to the Department. As the report states, much of this is not financially driven. First, it involves a recognition by the Departments of the need to release the information. Second, it does not need to be a massive project because a small commemorative location would bear tribute, as Senator Hannigan said, to those who served many cold, quiet, weary months and dismal days, with very little food.

There are some very interesting pieces of information. I would like to think the Minister of State can reflect what we are saying to the Department on those two points, first, the release of information from the UK to us and, second, that the Department would not take this project on itself as its own individual event but that it would work in collaboration with the many other funding agencies to put in place a commemorative tribute to those who were there, and as a remembrance for those who might have missed out to date on this episode of Irish history.

I will have the comments of the Senator conveyed to the Minister.

The Seanad adjourned at 7.40 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Thursday, 6 November 2008.
Top
Share