Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 26 Mar 1924

Vol. 6 No. 31

COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - COUNTY COURT OFFICERS.

I move: "That a Supplementary sum, not exceeding £10, be granted to defray the charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1924, for the salaries, allowances, and expenses of various County Court Officers, bonus to Chairman of Quarter Sessions and Recorders, and to Clerks of the Crown and Peace, and the expenses of revision."

This Supplementary Estimate is taken to make provision for the payment of the deputy County Court Judges who acted for County Court Judge Hynes. The normal method of payment of a deputy is by means of a deduction from the salary of the County Court Judge who is unable to act (Section 7 of the Civil Bill Courts (Ireland) Act, 1851). It was not considered very advisable, for political reasons, to send Judge Hynes to Co. Cork, but as the Judge was willing to act, it was impossible to deduct the remuneration of his deputy from the Judge's salary. Payment of the amount of the remuneration accordingly fell upon the Vote. The amount is larger than it otherwise would have been owing to extra sittings to dispose of compensation cases. The remuneration is at the rate of seven guineas a day for each day that each deputy sits. The savings under other sub-heads are really savings in connection with the payment of bailiffs in various parts of the country.

I would like the Minister to give a little further explanation—I do not want him to go into any details that would be injurious to the State—as to why it was undesirable for political reasons to send a Judge on his ordinary circuit. It seems to me that if political reasons are to be considered in the case of a particular Judge, unless that Judge's life were put in danger, we are setting a bad precedent. The idea that one Judge may be rejected and another Judge sent in in his place because political reasons exist, is not the way to give the people an opinion of the absolute impartiality and the absolute disinterestedness of the law, and I think that the Minister might give us further information on this matter.

The real reason was political. We were advised that the Judge would not be safe, and even if there had been no fatality, we thought it would not be desirable that attacks, or attempted attacks, should occur.

Will the Minister say did the County Court Judge in this case do any other duty while he was idle, or did he take a holiday?

I think he played golf.

Was he receiving a salary for playing golf? I hope he is giving satisfaction to the State on the links.

Question put, and agreed to.
Top
Share