asked the Minister for External Affairs whether he is aware that Samuel White of Creighanroe, Castleblayney, County Monaghan, is alleged to have been assaulted by members of the Royal Ulster Constabulary within the territory of Ireland, and whether he will take steps to secure adequate compensation for Mr. White from those responsible for the conduct of his assailants.
Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - County Monaghan Man's Complaint.
I am aware of this case, but there is a conflict of evidence with regard to it.
Mr. White states that he was assaulted at a point which is about 55 feet on this side of the Border by two members of the Royal Ulster Constabulary, who seized two of his cattle and his bicycle.
On the other hand, I am informed that, according to the Royal Ulster Constabulary, the incident took place in the Six County area at a point 50 yards from the Border, and the injuries which Mr. White received were the result of his having resisted arrest there. So far as I know, the occurrence was not witnessed by any person other than those concerned. In view of the conflict of evidence I am having the matter further investigated.
Would the Minister for External Affairs consider having some local police inquiry between representatives of the Gárda Síochána and the Royal Ulster Constabulary with a view to determining what actually happened on this occasion and whether the conduct of the members of the Royal Ulster Constabulary was proper or improper; or can he suggest any remedy that Mr. White may have in order to have his case independently investigated by somebody who he feels will secure justice for him?
The trouble is the conflict of evidence. Naturally, we have got in touch with the Gárdaí to find out what the situation is. As I told the Deputy, there still remains this conflict of evidence, and I am doing my best to have that cleared up, if possible. I have given thought to the matter as to whether there is any other way in which this could be adjusted, and I have not been able to reach any conclusion on account of the conflict of evidence—I have not been able to think of any way in which the matter could suitably be dealt with.
May I expect that the Minister will communicate with me when he comes to a decision in this matter?
I shall let the Deputy know if there are any steps I can take.
The Minister will let me know?
Yes, as soon as I can get anything definite.