Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 15 Feb 1977

Vol. 296 No. 10

Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Selenium Poisoning.

6.

asked the Minister for Agriculture if he is aware of the upsurge in the level of selenium poisoning in cattle and horses within a radius of 15 miles of the Hill of Tara in the last two years; if the last two dry summers are the cause; if it has been caused by the disturbance of shale in the drainage of the river Boyne and the spreading of spoil on the banks; the action that was taken to inform farmers in the risk areas of County Meath after the Agricultural Institute had marked the area on their maps in the mid-sixties; the research that has been carried out since then to find a cure for it; and the action being taken at present.

7.

asked the Minister for Agriculture if areas in County Meath have the highest level of selenium in the soil in the country.

With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 6 and 7 together.

Varying levels of selenium have been found in soil samples from ten counties, the highest concentration being found in samples from County Meath.

In the past two years samples from two horses and three cattle in County Meath were referred to my Department's Veterinary Research Laboratory for investigation of suspected selenium poisoning. Levels indicative of toxic intake were found in a horse and two cattle.

No case involving suspected selenium poisoning had been referred to the laboratory from any part of the country in the ten years prior to 1975. There are no scientific findings to indicate that the dry summers of the past two years caused an increase in the risk of selenium poisoning nor is there any reason to believe that the disturbance of shale or the spreading of spoil from the river Boyne increased the risk.

As regards the Deputy's reference to the information on selenium levels in certain areas of County Meath issued by the Agricultural Institute in the mid-sixties, the position is that the specific areas pinpointed as presenting a selenium problem are well known to the agricultural advisory officers in the area who tailor their advice to the farmers involved accordingly.

There is no formal programme of research on selenium poisoning at present but the subject has been dealt with at a number of scientific meetings and seminars in this country. The problem was researched in considerable depth in Meath, Limerick and Tipperary in the 1950's.

Acute selenium poisoning has not been found to be amenable to treatment. The various forms of chronic selenium intoxication have been treated with a variety of substances with variable results.

I am surprised the Parliamentary Secretary has had only three cases referred to him. Is the aware there are eight farms in County Meath which have had cases of selenium poisoning in the past two years?

The information I have does not indicate that, but if the Deputy has any information on other affected farms he should submit them to the Department and we will investigate without delay.

Is he aware that the disease usually occurs in areas which have been drained—that the poisoning shows itself in cattle and horses in such areas?

As I have said, there are no scientific findings that the dry summers in the past two years caused an increase in the risk of selenium poisoning, nor is there any reason to believe that the disturbance of shale or the spreading of spoil from the River Boyne increased the risk. Our contention is that shale or the spreading of spoil from the Boyne did not increase the risk.

In the areas in which the eight farms I have mentioned are situated there were drainage operations either by the Bord of Works or the farmers themselves. The few cases we have become aware of in the past 100 years have been always associated with drainage operations of one kind or another. Would the Parliamentary Secretary examine that aspect of it?

Naturally, the Department would be only too pleased to examine all aspects of it and if the Deputy has additional information I will arrange for him to meet officers of the Department so that the matter can be discussed further. We know it is a serious matter for the affected farmers.

Since these cases came to light what research have the Department initiated to try to get a cure? I understand there is no known cure.

That is the problem. A number of treatments have been tried and the Department will do everything possible to help in the eradication of the disease.

Top
Share