I move:
That Dáil Éireann deplores the emergence over the last three years of a housing crisis which is rapidly becoming more acute; deplores the Government policies which have brought this about; and calls for urgent Government action to alleviate the crisis which affects every city and county in the State.
The Fianna Fáil Government which took office in 1987 and the present Coalition Government which took office following the June 1989 general election have effectively sabotaged the local authority house building programme.
When the Labour-Fine Gael Coalition Government came into office at the end of 1982 we were in the midst of a major housing crisis. There were 30,000 people on local authority housing waiting lists and many of them believed that they had little hope of proper housing for many years. New housing policies, together with a substantial increase in local authorities' housing capital allocation, resulted in a dramatic decrease in the housing waiting lists. In excess of 6,000 houses per year were built during the lifetime of that Government and, as a result of their policies, the waiting lists fell to approximately 17,000. At the end of the life of that Government few of those entitled to local authority housing would have been on a housing waiting list for more than 12 months and many would have expected that, within 12 to 16 months, local authority housing would have been made available to them.
The statistics of the achievements of that period are worth recording because of what I anticipate will be the misleading remarks likely to be made by the Minister in the light of an amendment to our motion which has been circulated about what took place during that period. The Minister, in a foolish amendment which has been circulated to the House, talks about welcoming the strong reversal in 1989 of the eight year decline in new house completions. That amendment is in the realm of fantasy and wishful thinking on the part of the Minister. It brings us back to the sort of Opposition politics that we saw exhibited in this House on a week to week basis during the lifetime of that Government.
Before the Minister misleads the House about the achievement of the Fine Gael-Labour Coalition Government, the statistics of their achievements in the housing area should be read into the record. The statistics show that in 1982 there were 5,686 houses completed; in 1983, 6,190; in 1984, 7,002; in 1985, 6,523; and in 1986, 5,516. In 1987, the first year of the Fianna Fáil Government, there were 3,074 houses completed, a figure which declined to 1,450 in 1988 and there was a further decline in 1989 to below 1,000. Those figures are from the Annual Bulletin of Housing Statistics 1988 published by the Department. How could any Minister seriously be party to tabling a motion in this House which welcomes “the reversal of the eight year decline”? The decline only started when this Minister took office.
The problems in the whole local authority housing area have been the product of this Government's policies. The impact of Fianna Fáil entering office was traumatic. Capital financing for local authority housing was drastically curtailed, which resulted in 1988 in only 735 local authority housing starts. The capital allocation, as I said, fell dramatically. For example, in 1984, there was an allocation of £207 million for local authority housing; in 1985, £193 million; and in the last year of the Fine Gael-Labour Coalition Government, £147 million. In 1988 the allocation, the first for which this Minister was responsible, fell to £48 million, and in 1989 to £39 million. This latter allocation was not only to cover house building but also repairs and refurbishment. The extraordinary reductions of 1988 and 1989 resulted in local authority house building programmes effectively grinding to a halt. In 1989 building commenced countrywide on approximately 750 local authority houses. This countrywide figure is less than the total number of new houses provided by Dublin Corporation in each of the years between 1980 and 1986. In each of those years the corporation completed on average 1,500 new houses. Last year, to the lasting shame of this Government, Dublin Corporation did not complete a single house, an extraordinary record from the largest local authority in the country.
There are currently an estimated 22,000 people on local authority housing waiting lists. By the end of this year, on the basis of the Government's current policies, the figure may have grown to 25,000. The Minister for the Environment, overflowing with his usual political hyperbole, announced last November in the Estimates debates — and again just over two weeks ago — the local authority housing capital allocation. "Flynn announces increased local authority housing allocations" screamed the headline of the press release from the Minister's press and information office. We were told that capital allocations totalling £51 million for the local authority housing programme in 1990 were announced, £33 million of which was to be spent on new local authority housing. I suppose the figures sounded impressive in the context of the Minister's preceding two year offering. The Minister described this allocation as an increase of 50 per cent in the 1989 outturn. Of course it was not very difficult to increase the 1989 outturn by 50 per cent.
This self-indulgent piece of ministerial back slapping fooled the media into thinking that something meaningful was happening and that real additional resources were being provided for the local authority house building programme. The press release was not, of course, deliberately misleading, it was just economical with the truth. It did not state that the 1990 capital allocation is less than one-sixth in real terms of the allocation made a decade ago. It did not state that the 1990 capital allocation is lower than any sum allocated in any year by the Government in office between 1982 and 1986 for local authority housing. It did not mention, as I already said, that for the first time in living memory, Dublin Corporation had no house building programme for 1989 and that, incredibly, not a single new house was completed by the corporation last year.
It omitted to mention that in our capital city the housing waiting list had grown from 1,800 in May 1988 to 3,970 in September 1989. If you add Dublin Corporation and Dublin County Council lists together at 31 December 1989 there were approximately 5,000 families on the housing waiting lists in Dublin, the vast majority of whom have no hope of being allocated a house this year or next if the Government continue their present policies. Will this figure reach 10,000 in Dublin by the time our capital city features as the cultural capital of Europe? Of course Dublin is not the only area in which the local authority housing waiting lists are growing. The statistics show that throughout the length and breadth of this country there is a rapid increase in numbers on the housing waiting lists, with very limited hope of houses being allocated to them.
The Minister also did not publicise the contents of the circular letters his Department are sending to local authorities about their capital allocation. He did not tell the general public or the media who received his press release that the capital allocations to many local authorities are merely illusory and that instead of providing additional resources for housing the Government were diverting housing resources to other uses such as road building. In the case of Dublin County Council, for example, no direct capital grant is to come from the Department of the Environment for housing this year. This local authority have been notified by the Department that a capital sum of £2,621,000 can be used by them for their local authority house building programme. Of that, £2,196,000 is for the provision of local authority houses and £425,000 is for halting sites or residential caravan parks for travellers. This total allocation is to be financed from the internal housing capital receipts of Dublin County Council, that is, from money raised from the sale of existing houses. Apart from meeting existing commitments, this sum will enable the council to commence the building of only 50 new houses this year, not all of which will be completed during 1990. With the additional families it is anticipated will come onto this local authority's waiting list, the impact of this allocation will be minimal.
Many will take the view that it is reasonable that moneys raised from the sale of houses should be used for the provision of new houses. Similar requirements are being imposed on other local authorities throughout the country. For example, Dublin Corporation are in a position similar to that of Dublin County Council. All the moneys they are to use for the provision of local authority housing accommodation are to come from internal housing capital receipts and the same applies to the Cork local authorities. There is, however, more to the story. We are not simply recycling moneys that are normally obtained from the sale of houses for the building of new houses. Until this year these moneys were normally made available for local authority loans or remedial works on existing local authority accommodation but the matter goes further. Not only will moneys no longer be available for these purposes but Dublin Corporation, Dublin County Council and other local authorities have been instructed to use some of the moneys realised from the sale of houses for other purposes. The Dublin local authorities have been instructed that £500,000 of their 1990 road grant in respect of each authority is to be resourced from internal housing capital.
It is a scandal that at a time when there are growing housing waiting lists this uncaring, anti-social and heartless Government have taken the unprecedented step of directing local authorities to divert housing finance to the building of roads. In Dublin alone this year a total of £1 million that should be used in the provision of local authority housing accommodation will be used for roads purposes. At no stage has the Minister brought this information before the Dáil and at no stage has he told the Dáil exactly how much money the other local authorities in the State have to divert from housing finance into road construction.
We are sitting on a social time-bomb that is slowly ticking away as housing lists are building up all over the country. Emigration resulting from unemployment has delayed the explosion but will not prevent it. We are rapidly developing a two tier society with growing deprivation and homelessness. This Government choose to ignore the problem they have created and will no doubt this evening in response to this motion engage in another misleading and dishonest public relations exercise.
Recently the Minister in response to Dáil questions talked of meeting "acute housing needs" only. For each and every family on a housing waiting list their need is acute. For the increasing number of people who require housing this Government offer no hope. The Government have not only turned their back on those who require accommodation through local authorities but they have not done enough to tackle the problems of those who live in inadequate and dilapidated local authority accommodation which lacks the basic essentials of life. It is a national disgrace that in the Ireland of the nineties there are families living in 2,500 local authority dwellings which have no indoor toilets and over 8,000 local authority dwellings with no proper bathroom facilities. While the majority of such accommodation lacking these basic facilities is to be found in Cork and Dublin, most local authorities have some accommodation in which such facilities are lacking.
The statistics of local authorities with accommodation that lack such facilities were given recently in the Dáil by the Minister. You could go through each local authority area in the country and you would be hard pressed to find some local authority with accommodation in which such basic facilities are not lacking. For example, in Cavan there were 25 local authority houses with no indoor toilets and 30 with no bathrooms or showers; in Longford there were 36 houses with no indoor toilets and 38 with no bathrooms or showers; in Waterford there were 403 houses with no indoor toilets and 403 with no bathroom or shower and in the Dún Laoghaire Borough there were 203 houses with no indoor toilets and 758 with no bathrooms or showers. In Dún Laoghaire, which is often viewed as being a rich part of the world, there are people living in conditions which should not be tolerated in the nineties and which are familiar to the Ireland of the thirties. There is a whole list of local authorities with accommodation in which the basic facilities, that many of us as Members of this House take for granted as part of our day to day comforts, are sadly lacking.
For those currently purchasing their own home, this Government are also responsible for creating major difficulties. The decrease in interest rates which resulted from the policies of the Labour-Fine Gael Coalition Government and which was maintained by the Fianna Fáil Government when constrained by Fine Gael from the Opposition benches has now been reversed. We have had five increases in mortgage interest rates in the past 12 months and in the current economic climate the possibility of further interest rate rises cannot be ruled out. Young couples who obtained mortgages at a time of low interest rates now find themselves paying approximately £100 more per month in repayments to building societies and banks. The reduction by the Government in the Finance Acts of the mortgage interest allowance was justified by the Minister on the basis of the low interest rates payable by house purchasers. I recall being in this House when the present Minister for the Environment, never slow to heap modest praise on himself, said that the changes in the Finance Act were justified as a result of the Government's policies in reducing interest rates. The Minister claimed credit for the reduction in interest rates and he cannot now throw his hands in the air and disclaim responsibility for the savage rises that have occurred.