Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 26 Feb 1992

Vol. 416 No. 3

Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - UK Registered Spanish Boats.

Gerry O'Sullivan

Question:

3 Mr. G. O'Sullivan asked the Minister for the Marine if his attention has been drawn to (1) the serious concern expressed by Irish fishermen at the continuing breach of EC fishery regulations by UK-registered Spanish trawlers off our coast and (2) the allegations that landings of fish have exceeded the two ton per month quota at Castletownbere and that no departmental inspectors have been present when these landings have occurred; if he intends to take action to remedy this situation; and if he will make a statement on the matter.

I am aware of, and share, the concerns of fishermen about the activities off our coasts of UK-registered Spanish fishing boats who disregard Community fishing control regulations.

The operations of all fishing boats, including those of UK-registered Spanish boats, are monitored closely at sea by the Naval Service and onshore by my Department's sea fishery officers. Over the past three years 16 of these boats have been detained for suspected infringements of Community fishery regulations. Fifteen of the boats in question were subsequently charged with fishery offences. To date seven cases have been dealt with in the courts and fines totalling £144,000 have been levied.

The enforcement of UK boat quotas, established for the purposes of managing quota allocations, is a matter primarily for the UK authorities. The Irish protection services do not have a function with regard to the monitoring of internal UK management regimes. My Department's sea fishery officers when inspecting landings from UK-registered Spanish boats are concerned mainly with ensuring that the boats comply with all relevant Community regulations. It is, of course, open to the UK authorities to take action against any of these boats on the basis of periodic returns which my Department send to the UK.

I would not accept any suggestion that my Department have not been monitoring landings by these boats at Castletownbere. Under an arrangement with the boats' agents, my Department's sea fishery officer at the port is informed in advance of all landings and despite an increase in recent months in the number of landings, periodic monitoring has continued to take place.

The level of monitoring is designed to ensure that Community regulations are being adhered to by the UK-registered boats landing in the port. The position will be kept under constant review and I am prepared to consider strengthening these arrangements if necessary.

Boats fishing off our coasts which land their catches at our ports help the local economy by creating employment onshore and also make it easier to monitor the activities in our waters.

Like the Minister I congratulate our fishery service on the work they are doing in controlling illegal fishing in our coastal waters. They have done an excellent job to date and I want to be the first to congratulate them. I wish to point out to the Minister that the present position——

Ceist, le do thoil, a Theachta.

Does the Minister accept that the present position is far from satisfactory, as it appears that Spanish steel hull trawlers can come right into our ports and discharge their catches without being checked or monitored? Is he aware that these same Spanish trawlers can shoot their 25-mile-long nets off our coast and leave them unattended and collect them the following day? This type of practice is completely unacceptable to Irish fisheries and, I am sure, to the Minister also.

I have the reports at this stage from my Department and the advice from my Department which I have given to the Deputy. Periodic monitoring takes place. On that basis I take it that the monitoring is not continuous but rather on a set basis. I will look further into this matter. I said at the end of my reply I am prepared to consider strengthening these arrangements if necessary. In that connection I intend to visit the port in the near future and to have discussions with the people who are directly concerned.

A brief question, Deputy O'Sullivan.

Mr. O'Sullivan

I welcome what the Minister has said. Would he not consider the confiscation of trawlers which have deliberately and consistently broken EC regulations in our waters?

I will be prepared to use the law to the fullest possible extent and if that is not adequate to review the fines and the other measures. The Deputy will be aware we discussed this morning the fines that might apply in other circumstances. It appears from the fines which are applied here by the courts that the level we were talking about was very much higher than what appears to be applied in practice. I will examine the matter further and I appreciate the point raised by the Deputy.

Let us try to dispose of the other three remaining questions. Question No. 4, please.

Top
Share