Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 6 Apr 1993

Vol. 429 No. 3

Adjournment Debate. - Scotstown (Monaghan) Garda Station.

Thank you, Sir, for giving me the opportunity to raise this matter. I wish to clarify one point. I was led to understand that the site was acquired over 30 years ago but in fact the site was purchased 20 years ago, which is not quite as bad.

The gardaí are in the present rented bungalow since about 1966. This two-bedroomed bungalow may have been all right in 1966 but now with 16 to 17 gardaí and three sergeants based in it, it is totally unacceptable as a Garda station and does not meet the requirements under the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act, 1989.

I thank the Minister for her written reply on 12 February where she points out the problems the Office of Public Works has with the site it bought in the mid-seventies. These discussions or lack of them have gone on for far too long. The lease on the present station is, I understand, nearly up. The premises may then be re-leased or bought, or better sites may be available. What is the cost to date of the site investigations of the past 18 to 20 years? The Minister should remember that this station provides Garda cover for a difficult Border region in which almost all roads are closed, which, in turn, creates security problems. Gardaí in this station who are on duty in all weathers do not have proper washing or drying facilities for their clothes. There is no private room in which to interview people and radio communications and telephone calls are made in one public office.

Deputies Leonard, O'Hanlon and I met Garda representatives at Scotstown station on 16 January last. From what we saw that day there is an urgent need to update the accommodation there — I know the other Deputies support me in this matter. If we are serious about law and order in this area we should ensure that gardaí have reasonable accommodation with proper interviewing rooms and a possible holding room. Above all there should be proper accommodation for gardaí to clean themselves and dry their clothes and a room in which to relax.

I realise that money is scarce but this is an urgent matter. The Minister should do his best to provide the necessary Garda station for Scotstown. It is a coincidence that after I received permission to raise this matter tonight I was advised of an article in last Sunday's edition of The Sunday Times which outlines the difficulties facing gardaí in this area. I would point out to the Minister that as a result of the bad state of repair of roads in the area, £6,000 had to be spent last year on servicing one Garda car.

On behalf of the Minister for Justice I thank Deputy Crawford for raising this issue on the Adjournment. I assure the Deputy that the Minister is fully aware of the conditions at Scotstown Garda station. The situation, however, is not as black as it has been painted. The chief source of the problem relates to overcrowding in that the building was never designed to accommodate the present complement of 19 members and has become run-down as a result. While saying this, the Minister hastens to add that most of these members are on out-door duty and use the station only as a base.

It is proposed to rectify the situation by building a new station at Scotstown. However, the site which was acquired in 1976 is not suitable for the erection of a septic tank and access is required to the public sewerage system. The Minister understands that the Office of Public Works is investigating this problem in an effort to find a solution.

Irrespective of this problem, the Deputy will appreciate that, given available resources, each project must be addressed within the context of overall priorities thoughout the country. A considerable investment has been made in improving Garda accommodation in recent years. Last year alone over £3.8 million was spent on new works and more than £2.5 million on maintenance projects. In 1986, only six miles from Scotstown, a new divisional headquarters was provided at Monaghan at a cost of £1.8 million.

In view of the many demands on available resources, no commitment can be given on the replacement of this station in the short term. However, the Garda authorities have a certain amount of delegated responsibility in relation to maintaining stations and the Minister is advised by them that an application for improvement works has been sanctioned to go ahead later this year. The station will be painted and decorated internally, toilet facilities will be upgraded and a shower unit will be installed. In addition, kitchen facilities will be upgraded and new kitchen units will be provided. These works should make accommodation at Scotstown more comfortable until it is possible to commence work on a new station. This is the ultimate objective and will be achieved within the shortest possible time-scale.

I thank the Minister for his reply but I am disappointed the Minister for Justice was not here.

Top
Share