Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 19 Nov 1997

Vol. 483 No. 1

Adjournment Debate. - Cork-Roscoff Ferry Service.

I wish to share my time with my colleague Deputy Bradford.

I thank the Ceann Comhairle for giving me the opportunity of raising this important matter in the House. The decision of Irish Ferries to terminate its ferry service from Cork to Roscoff, which has been operating for 14 years, is a detrimental step and will have serious effects on the tourism economy of the south west region. This is a clear signal demoting such services to and from the region. It is of paramount importance that direct services with the Continent be maintained by all means.

What will the Cork-Kerry tourism region receive from the extra £5 million recently announced by the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation to attract more tourists from EU countries? In view of the withdrawal of this service, I urge the Minister to make a substantial amount of that £5 million available to the Cork and Kerry region to offset any damage inflicted on the tourism potential of the south-west.

The Irish Ferries connection with Cork goes back to 1820 through B & I and the City of Cork Steam Package Company. Almost 180 years of association has now been brought to an abrupt end. If the Minister fails to get Irish Ferries to restore the service, he should consider the construction of an airport in Bantry, the heart of the Cork and Kerry tourism region. There should be a direct flight from the Continent to that airport. If the Minister cannot convince Irish Ferries to change its attitude and maintain the service from Cork to Roscoff, he must try to get an alternative.

Any erosion of services to an area which relies on tourism will have devastating results for its economy. I urge the Minister to act before it is too late. We cannot live on fresh air and cold water; we need our tourism economy. I urge the Minister to convince Irish Ferries to restore the service or to construct an airport for my maternal town of Bantry.

I had hoped to start by saying I agreed fully with Deputy Sheehan but when he mentioned overflying the towns of Mallow and Fermoy on the way to Bantry, I had to rethink my position.

We can redirect them to Mallow.

The 50 per cent reduction of carrier space between Cork and continental Europe is a serious blow to tourism. It is ironic that next summer, when participants in one of the world's major sporting events, the Tour de France, leave Cork harbour by ferry to travel to France, we will lose a major ferry service into Cork. Pressure must be exerted by the relevant Government authorities, particularly the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation, to ensure that Cork and the south-west region will not lose out as a result of the vastly reduced numbers of people coming to the area. I saw the benefits of the Cork to continental Europe service during the summer months when thousands of motorists passed through the towns of Fermoy and Mallow. This had a positive impact on the tourism industry in those areas.

Irish Ferries made its decision for commercial reasons. I do not expect the Minister to reverse that decision but I appeal to him and to the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation to do everything possible to ensure that the long-term future of the tourism industry in Cork and the south-west region is not affected and that it will be protected and developed by other means.

I thank the Deputies for raising this issue and I appreciate their concerns about this matter. I will convey the views expressed tonight to the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation. I am sure he will bear in mind the impact this decision by Irish Ferries will have on tourism in the south-west.

Irish Ferries has, as part of its rationalisation process, decided to reduce the number of ports serviced on the Ireland France route. Until now the company operated out of two Irish ports, Cork and Rosslare, to three French ports, Le Havre, Cherbourg and Roscoff. The decision was taken on a commercial basis by a privately owned company and I have no function in the matter. However, I welcome the company's continued commitment to the continental route.

Maintenance of direct maritime links with continental Europe remains an important and essential strategic objective. It is my policy not only to ensure the maintenance of this link but also to expand services where possible and commercially viable. In terms of quality service provision, it is important to note that the introduction of the new vessel represents a significant upgrading. Passengers on the route to and from Ireland will welcome increased standards of comfort for what is a relatively long journey, particularly for families.

I take this opportunity to reaffirm the Government's commitment to the shipping sector under the Action Plan for the Millennium. The plan accords full recognition to the strategic importance of our shipping industry and the development of a comprehensive policy for the industry. This commitment is given concrete expression in the Department's strategy statement for 1997-99.

A number of initiatives have been undertaken or are under active consideration, including fiscal concessions such as reliefs introduced in the 1996 Finance Act. These enable vessels dry leased by Irish interests to qualify for 10 per cent corporation profits tax while double ring-fencing against tax based ship leasing has been removed. A second initiative is the refund of employer PRSI for seafarers. The provisions introduced in the social welfare regulations in 1997 represent considerable cost savings for Irish registered and controlled ships. Approval from the European Commission for this scheme has been sought and is expected shortly.

A third initiative is seafarer taxation. This issue is being discussed with the Minister for Finance by myself and by officials of both Departments in the run up to the forthcoming budget and Finance Bill. A fourth initiative deals with seafarer training. The shipboard training subsidy introduced in 1996 has helped to secure essential training placements for students at Cork Institute of Technology. These measures were taken to try to improve the situation for shipping companies. A task force to examine all aspects of seafarer training with representation from those engaged in the shipping sector, including shipowners and trade unions together with education and training interests, will commence its work shortly.

A final initiative is the duty free campaign. Several sectors of the Irish economy, including passenger ferries, have expressed concern at the possible effect of the abolition of the intra-EU duty and tax free sales on 1 July 1999 and adverse effects on revenue, employment and profitability. An initiative under the auspices of the Department of the Taoiseach involves a number of key Departments and agencies. The objective is to maximise support in EU member states to persuade the Commission to rethink the abolition policy and to highlight the issue at every available opportunity in relevant fora. The previous Government took a similar line when trying to improve the situation.

The Government's policy is fully compatible with Commissioner Neil Kinnock's communication, Towards a New Maritime Strategy, published in March 1996. It is principally concerned with the competitiveness of the EU shipping sector, establishes a definite link between substandard ships and unfair competition and emphasises the importance of training for EU seafarers. I am satisfied that the pursuit of this policy rather than the direct intervention in the affairs of individual companies offers the best prospect for enhancing the competitiveness of the service provided and the sustainable development of the shipping sector, including ferry services.

That is cold comfort for those who have to travel many miles to get a ferry.

Top
Share