Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 22 Mar 2000

Vol. 516 No. 4

Written Answers. - Compensation to Fishermen.

Nora Owen

Question:

51 Mrs. Owen asked the Minister for the Marine and Natural Resources the proposals, if any, he has to compensate a group of fishermen (details supplied) for loss of earnings due to their inability to take their boats out since 14 February 2000; the reason this restriction was necessary; when this restriction will be lifted; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [8392/00]

Scientific advice for the Irish Sea cod stock, which became available in late 1999, suggested that the stock was in danger of total collapse unless an urgent stock recovery plan could be put in place during the current year. At the December Fisheries Council, the council and commission agreed that a recovery plan would have to be put in place this year to save this valuable fishery. Following detailed consultation with East coast fishermen in January and February discussions took place in Brussels between the commission and the member states and their fishing industries.

The first phase of the Irish Sea cod recovery plan, involving a closure of the northern part of the Irish Sea from mid-February to the end of April for the directed cod fishery was introduced by the commission on 10 February. As part of the recovery plan the commission had proposed a closure of a large area of the western Irish Sea for prawn fishing for the ten week period. Ireland opposed this closure and worked to keep as much as possible of the prawn grounds open in the interests of our fishermen. A small area of prawn grounds overlaps with the biggest concentration of spawning cod in the Irish Sea. The commission insisted on closing this particular area for the ten week period.

I accept that some prawn fishermen will have longer steaming times to get to the prawn grounds during this period. However, the bulk of the grounds are still open for prawn fishing. From the end of April all prawn grounds will be fully open for the rest of the year. Fishermen have indicated that the prawn grounds overall are heavily fished and that prawn catches will in fact probably be better in the areas which are currently closed when the fishery reopens.
The measures in place to protect the Irish Sea cod stock have been structured to cause the minimum disruption to fishing activity and to retain the maximum range of fishing opportunities possible for East coast vessels. The measures are essential to ensure a viable future for east coast fishermen, they are of short duration and limited impact. In these circumstances the payment of compensation would not be appropriate.
Top
Share