Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 20 Nov 2001

Vol. 544 No. 3

Other Questions. - Migrant Workers' Rights.

Liz McManus

Question:

82 Ms McManus asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment if her attention has been drawn to concerns expressed by a person (details supplied) that the experience of migrant workers raised serious concerns in relation to the recruitment process and the extent to which migrant workers understand their rights before taking up positions; the steps she will take to promote greater awareness of their rights among immigrant workers; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [28645/01]

The chief executive of the National Equality Authority has not brought to my attention any concerns he may have about the experience of migrant workers in relation to either the recruitment process or the extent to which they understand their rights before taking up employment in Ireland.

Virtually all migrant workers coming to Ireland are recruited through employment agencies of one kind or other. There is anecdotal evidence of some workers being required to pay fees etc., to recruitment agencies or other intermediaries. Irish law requires that the recruitment costs be borne by the employer. While we do seek to influence the behaviour of such companies, clearly Irish legislation cannot apply overseas. Neither are we in a position to dictate the nature of their links with other overseas recruitment agencies.

I made it clear in the Dáil on 21 March, in response to a parliamentary question, that we need to tighten the legislation on the authorisation and registration of employment agencies and I promised a fundamental review of the Employment Agency Act, 1971, to determine the nature and scope of regulatory control appropriate to modern practices in the employment agency business. This review is continuing. I am aware, from reports in the media from time to time and complaints investigated by the Employment Rights section of my Department, that non-EEA workers in this country are not always aware of the rights and protection afforded to them under our legislation. In contacts between my staff and some of the embassies of the countries of origin of our migrant workers they continue to emphasise the array of rights which migrant workers have and copies of booklets produced by my Department, which set out clearly the rights of all workers in Ireland have been handed over.

In addition, the new format for the work permit application form which has been in use since 1 July sets out in summary form the principal rights to which a worker is entitled to and the declaration which the prospective employee must sign states that he/she has been supplied with a copy of the details of his/her employment rights. In addition, the employer is required to sign a declaration that the full benefit of all relevant Irish employment rights will be applied to the migrant worker.

In an effort to try to overcome the difficulties which can arise with workers who may not understand English my Department has produced and made available a short summary document setting out the main employment rights. This paper has been translated into eight different languages consistent with the principal foreign languages of the migrant workers coming to Ireland. It is also available on my Department's website.

I apologise to the Minister of State as I have to leave the House soon for another engagement.

What does the Minister of State mean by saying that these matters have not been brought to his attention? Surely, the Minister is aware that the chief executive of the National Equality Authority is on record stating that 20% of his caseload concerns racially motivated cases. Surely the Minister has read the various stories in the media about the abuse of immigrant workers which are, in many cases, reminiscent of the abuse of Irish emigrants in the 1950s and 1960s. Is the Minister aware of the case of a Romanian worker in Limerick who testified that, as part of the bonded labour contract to which Deputy Flanagan referred, he is committed to staying in a house owned by the employer and that, as a result, the rent which would normally be £700 per month is £2,240 a month?

Obviously I am aware of the chief executive's public statements. I simply made the point that he has not been in touch directly with me. I am aware of the type of cases Deputy Rabbitte has cited, although not necessarily the one he mentioned. Many cases have been brought to our attention by the trade union movement and others. The Deputy may be aware I intervened in the case of Filipino workers in that I contacted their Ambassador and was involved in putting in place a support system for workers from that country. As I outlined in my reply, there were issues surrounding payments made by workers in their own countries. We have dealt with individual cases and groups of workers from certain countries.

I have outlined the types of measures we have taken which come under the jurisdiction of our legislation. The fundamental review is also taking place. We have also improved the work permit application form. In the absence of the fundamental review, we have undertaken many good measures in updating the legislation and dealing head-on with issues where workers need protection. Workers from abroad or from outside the European Economic Area, EEA, have the same rights in Ireland as Irish workers.

Top
Share