Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Thursday, 6 Mar 2003

Vol. 562 No. 6

Ceisteanna – Questions. Priority Questions. - Mental Health Care Policy.

Dan Neville

Question:

4 Mr. Neville asked the Minister for Health and Children the way in which he proposes to deal with the concern of Amnesty International at the inattention of the Government to a series of national and international reports critical of its failure to fully respect the human rights of people with mental illness and the view of Amnesty International that Irish mental health care policy and service provision remain out of step with international best practice, and as such, fail to fully comply with international human rights law. [6830/03]

Amnesty International's recently published report, "Mental Illness: The Neglected Quarter", highlights areas of genuine concern in relation to mental health services. These are concerns which the Government shares and which it intends to address. To its credit, Amnesty International's report acknowledges the substantial progress that has been made in recent years in improving the mental health services.

In the period 1999-2002, an additional €70.7 million revenue funding was invested in the mental health services. In the current year, additional revenue funding of €7.6 million will be provided for ongoing developments in mental health services, including the areas of child and adolescent psychiatry, psychiatry of later life, liaison psychiatry, suicide prevention initiatives and support for the voluntary sector for the development of advocacy services in Ireland. Overall, about €190 million in capital funding is being provided through the national development plan to facilitate the development of acute psychiatric units attached to general hospitals, as a replacement of services previously provided in psychiatric hospitals. The latest of these, at St. Luke's Hospital, Kilkenny, opened its doors to patients yesterday, 5 March.

There are now 15 general hospital psychiatric units operational throughout the country. A further two units will become available in the near future, two more are under construction and several others are at various stages of planning. There are now approximately 400 community psychiatric residences in the country, providing over 3,000 places. This compares to 111 residences providing less than 1,000 places in 1984. As for day hospitals-day centres, there are approximately 2,000 providing over 3,500 places, compared with 39 such centres providing approximately 1,200 places in 1984.

Additional information

I agree with Amnesty International's views on the importance of providing advocacy services for people suffering from mental illness. The Government made clear its support for the development of advocacy services in Ireland by its commitment, contained in the Programme for Prosperity and Fairness, to assist initiatives to provide independent advocacy services for people who are involuntarily detained under the provisions of the new Mental Health Act 2001. In a concrete expression of the Government's commitment in the health strategy to develop advocacy services in mental health, €251,000 was provided by my Department to health boards and voluntary agencies for this purpose in 2002. An additional €50,000 has been provided for 2003.

In relation to mental health services for children and adolescents, services for this age group still require substantial development. However, we have already come a long way. In 1997, there were few child and adolescent psychiatric services available outside the major cities. Now each health board has approval and funding for a minimum of three consultant led, multidisciplinary child and adolescent psychiatric teams. In 2002, additional revenue funding of €6.061 million was allocated to provide for the appointment of additional consultants, for the enhancement of existing consultant led multidisciplinary teams and towards the establishment of further teams. A further €1.64 million was allocated in 2003.

The development of child and adolescent psychiatric services has been a priority in recent years. The first report of the working group on child and adolescent psychiatric services, which was presented to the Minister on 1 March 2001, contained recommendations for the development of seven child and adolescent psychiatric in-patient units. Project teams have now been established in respect of proposed units in Cork, Limerick, Galway and one in the Eastern Regional Health Authority area, at St. Vincent's Hospital, Fairview.

The health strategy "Quality and Fairness – A Health System for You", contains a commitment to prepare a new national policy framework for the further modernisation of the mental health services. The mental health services have not been reviewed in a systematic way for almost 20 years and the need for such a review is one of the key recommendations of the Amnesty International report. I expect work on the new policy framework to begin in the coming months.

The Mental Health Act 2001 represented the first significant reform of mental health legislation in this country for over 50 years. Its purpose was to update legislation concerning the involuntary detention of persons for psychiatric care and treatment and to establish mechanisms by which the standards of care and treatment provided in the mental health services would be supervised and regulated. When fully implemented, the Mental Health Act 2001 will bring Irish mental health law fully into conformity with the European Convention on Human Rights and into line with best practice in the field internationally.

The Act contains many positive provisions which improve the rights of patients. These provisions have been warmly welcomed by Amnesty International in its report. In the report, the organisation notes that the Act expressly provides for the right to information about the circumstances of a detention and any proposed treatments. It also provides that patients must be informed of their right to a review of their detention, their right to legal representation and to legal aid where appropriate.

The main vehicle for the implementation of the Mental Health Act 2001 will be the Mental Health Commission. The commission's primary function is to promote and foster high standards and good practices in the delivery of mental health services and to ensure that the interests of detained persons are protected. The establishment of the commission in April 2002 is also welcomed by Amnesty International in its report.

I am disappointed the Minister did not address my question by outlining how he proposes to deal with the concerns of Amnesty International. Does the Minister agree that the systematic discrimination against people with mental illness is an abuse of their human rights?

I agree that, since the foundation of the State, there has been underfunding of the psychiatric services. However, in the past six or seven years this Government gave more money for psychiatric services than any previous Government.

Does the Minister agree that the present systematic discrimination is an abuse of their human rights?

Yes, but I also agree with what Seán Love from Amnesty International said to me in a letter and in the report, that significant improvements have taken place. I will meet Seán Love later this month to discuss what we will do over the next several years. Only yesterday, we opened another psychiatric hospital, a 50 bed unit, in Kilkenny. By opening and providing these services we are assisting the human rights of psychiatric patients.

Does the Minister agree with the statement in The Irish Times that the failure of the coalition Government to provide for the care of citizens experiencing mental illness is a scandal? Does he further agree that it is all the more terrible because the extent of the neglect visited upon persons with psychological ill-health has been carefully documented over the past five to six years by both national and international reports?

In my reply—

Does the Minister agree it is a scandal?

Does the Deputy mean historically?

Obviously, all Governments—

Two Ministers are replying. Good.

The Deputy deserves it. He is consistent. Unfortunately that has been the history of the provision of psychiatric services. I agree with both the Deputy and the Amnesty International report that the provision of psychiatric services has been a scandal. There is no doubt about that. However, the provision of psychiatric services has improved enormously. More was done by the last Government in the past five years than by any other Government.

Can the Minister give a final date for when people with intellectual disability will be removed from psychiatric hospitals and put into institutions dedicated to their needs?

The Government's target is to achieve that by 2006. In the past five or six years the number has halved—

It will be four more years?

If the Deputy asks a question, he must listen to the answer.

It is four more years.

The number has halved from 960 to 450. I agree that the 450 intellectually disabled people should not be in psychiatric institutions. It is the goal of this Government to ensure that by 2006 these patients will be moved out into the community.

The time for this question has concluded.

The Deputy is aware that there are industrial relations problems in our health board area. The money has been provided for 36 patients—

Sort them out.

There are industrial relations problems and I ask the Deputy to help me in trying to resolve them.

The same rules apply to Ministers as to other Deputies.

Top
Share