Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 11 Jun 2003

Vol. 568 No. 2

Other Questions. - Coast Guard Service.

Róisín Shortall

Question:

65 Ms Shortall asked the Minister for Communications, Marine and Natural Resources the progress which has been made with regard to his Department's consideration of the recent consultants' report on the Irish Coast Guard; if it is intended to implement the recommendations made in the report; the reason the central rescue co-ordination has been transferred from Dublin to Valentia; if this is intended to be a permanent move; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [15936/03]

The consultants' report in question contains recommendations relating to both the strategic development of the Coast Guard service and day-to-day operations. The strategic issues include, for example, matters relating to the future operation of the three marine co-ordination centres in Dublin, Malin and Valentia. As I informed the House in April of this year, consideration of these issues will also have regard to a wider review that I am undertaking at this time of the organisational structures and operational arrangements within my Department. My overall objective is to improve services delivery across the board, and I expect to be in a position to complete consideration of the matters relating to the Coast Guard shortly.

Work on assessing and, as appropriate, implementing recommendations which relate to the day-to-day operations of the Coast Guard service is also in hand. A working group of the Department's partnership committee, which comprises management and staff interests, has been considering the recommendations. Over one third of the approximately 100 recommendations made by the consultants have already been accepted and are in the course of being implemented. Consideration of the remaining recommendations will continue over the coming weeks and months. The Marine Rescue Co-ordination Centre, Dublin, staff and functions were transferred to the Valentia and Malin Head centres in May 2003, to enable asbestos to be removed from ceilings of two of the five floors of the building where they were located in Leeson Lane. The asbestos has now been removed and arrangements are in hand to enable the MRCC, Dublin, staff to return to Leeson Lane this week.

I thank the Minister of State for his explanation of the move from Leeson Lane.

In view of the Deloitte & Touche report, what is the current position with regard to Valentia and Malin? There is grave uncertainty about the coastguard operation in Malin and its impact on the Inishowen Peninsula in north east Donegal where the unemployment rate is 17%. Does the Minister of State agree that one of the core problems which must be addressed from the report's recommendations is whether to reduce the service from a three centre command to two? Can he assure the House that the concerns about Malin and Inishowen are misplaced and that the three location command structure will continue? Does the Minister of State further agree that, given the major pollution problems we face on our sea lanes, it is critical we have this three centre command structure?

As the Deputy said, the Deloitte & Touche report was wide-ranging and made a huge number of recommendations. In general, the report found that the coastguard services are excellent. It recommended that the IRCG should continue to provide its current functions and services. However, the most controversial recommendation refers to reducing the number of control centres from three to two and establishing the IRCG as an agency. Advances in communications have obviated the necessity for three centres and savings from the closure of one centre, estimated at €500,000per annum, could be used to develop other aspects of the coastguard service. The report does not recommend which centre should be closed. In deciding on whether the coastguard should be established as an agency, the future costs of the maritime safety directive also need to be considered, as well as the general structure of the Department of Communications, Marine and Natural Resources. The Minister has said for some time that he is examining the recommendations with regard to the three centres, as well as the possibility of developing an agency, rather than the service remaining within the Department.

Will that include Irish water safety?

There are a number of areas within the Department which could possibly be transferred to agencies. These possibilities are being examined, but no firm decisions have yet been made. We will keep the Deputy informed as soon as decisions are made. I am sure the Minister is anxious to make these decisions.

Will that require legislation?

I think it will, but I am not sure. I will check it out for the Deputy.

We will need such an opportunity to discuss the issue.

Even if it is to be set up as an agency without legislation, I am sure we will have a discussion on the matter.

Our list of Bills will get even longer.

Top
Share