Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 14 Oct 2003

Vol. 572 No. 3

Adjournment Debate. - School Closure.

I thank the Ceann Comhairle for allowing me to raise this matter on the Adjournment. St. Brendan's national school, Blennerville, County Kerry, was closed on Thursday last because of rat infestation. One of the classrooms in which rat droppings were found is used for the teaching of infants. The principal had hoped to reopen the school yesterday but was advised by an environmental officer from the Southern Health Board that it could not be reopened until Monday next. Every room in the school must be sealed and sanitised before the children are allowed to return.

St. Brendan's national school is 70 years old and consists of four classrooms, one temporary type classroom, which was provided in 2003, one portacabin, which is used as a resource teacher room and one portacabin which is divided in half, with one half used as a staffroom and storeroom and the other used as a learning support room. The campaign to have conditions improved at the school has been going on for the past ten years. In 1998, the Office of Public Works drew up a plan to renovate the school at a cost of approximately £300,000. This idea was rejected by the Department of Education and Science's building inspector who claimed that it would be a waste of time and money.

In 2000, an application by the board of management for a new school was approved by the Department and the Office of Public Works was asked to purchase a suitable site. A senior official in the Office of Public Works, having had all the relevant tests carried out and arranged a number of pre-planning meetings with Kerry County Council regarding future planning for the school, successfully negotiated the purchase of such a site. The full report on the proposed site was presented to the Department of Education and Science by the Office of Public Works in December 2002. However, no apparent progress has been made since and St. Brendan's did not figure on the list of schools that was published by the Department of Education and Science earlier this year in respect of which works are to proceed.

At present, there are 125 pupils, five mainstream teachers, one resource teacher and one learning support teacher, whose services are shared with another school, trying to learn and teach under these unacceptable conditions. The school is simply too small and the classrooms are cramped, generally half the size of a normal classroom. Toilet facilities are basic and are constantly overstretched and in need of remedial work. There is no storeroom for school equipment and valuable classroom space must be used for this purpose. The school is situated on the N86, a very busy road, with no set-down area for parents dropping off or collecting children and there is no parking area provided for teachers' cars.

St. Brendan's is on the INTO list of schools in need of urgent replacement. It is obvious that the school does not meet departmental standards. The school authorities are constantly paying out large amounts of money for its maintenance. They have spent over €5,000 since September to this end but the building is impossible to maintain. The principal and his staff are dedicated and conscientious teachers. They are highly regarded and respected by the parents of their pupils and have worked in totally unacceptable conditions for many years. It is time to cut through the bureaucracy and stonewalling, to purchase the approved site and to provide the much needed new school immediately.

The Minister, Deputy Dempsey, will reject the idea that a school could be rat infested in this day and age and will claim that the maintenance grant should be sufficient to ensure that no such infestation should occur. However, despite the fact that the authorities at Blennerville are spending more money than is provided by means of their maintenance grant, it is impossible to ensure that the school is not infested with rats. The problem is not their fault, the building is substandard, outdated and has long outlived its usefulness. Despite the best efforts of the principal and the teachers, it is simply impossible, in light of the current level of grant provided, to maintain this school to an acceptable standard.

I appeal to the Minister of State to bring to the Minister's attention the embarrassment caused to the Department of Education and Science today when national newspapers printed stories about a rat infested school in Kerry. That is just not acceptable. The solution rests in the hands of the Department, the Minister and the Government.

I thank the Deputy for raising the matter as it gives me the opportunity, on behalf of the Minister for Education and Science, to outline to the House the position regarding St. Brendan's national school, Blennerville.

St. Brendan's national school is a co-educational primary school. Enrolments have increased steadily in recent years, from 95 pupils in 1997-98 to 125 pupils in September 2003. The school has a staffing of one principal, four mainstream assistants, one shared learning support teacher and one shared resource teacher.

The board of management of St. Brendan's national school initially applied to the Department of Education and Science in 1996 for refurbishment and subsequently applied for a new school in March 1999. Following examination of the application, it was agreed that accommodation should be provided for a six-teacher school. A technical inspection of the school and site was carried out in 1999 and a recommendation was made that a new school, on a greenfield site, should be provided. The existing school site, at less than 0.5 acres in size, was deemed unsuitable due to the size of the extension required and the limitations of the site. The Office of Public Works, which acts on behalf of the Department of Education and Science in respect of the procurement of sites, was asked to investigate and report on suitable sites for the proposed new school. While a number of sites have been identified, the Office of Public Works has not completed its investigations in this regard.

In order to address the interim accommodation requirements at the school, the Department of Education and Science grant aided the purchase of two portable structures which had been rented at the school. In addition, an application for the purchase of a portacabin was approved and included in the 2003 capital programme. The school was authorised to accept a tender in July 2003 and the purchase was funded in full in the amount of €48,000.

The purchase of a site and the advancement of the school's building project to architectural planning will depend on the budgetary provision for 2004 and subsequent years, the rate of progress of existing projects in architectural planning and the priority afforded to each project by reference to the published criteria for prioritising large-scale building projects. The next schools building programme will be published early in 2004 and will outline details of projects for which funding is to be made available. In the meantime, it is the responsibility of the board of management to ensure the health and safety of pupils and teachers at the school. The school authorities should use the devolved grant to address any urgent works which arise, including the recent rodent infestation at the school.

Top
Share