Skip to main content
Normal View

Dáil Éireann debate -
Wednesday, 5 Mar 2008

Vol. 649 No. 2

Adjournment Debate.

Health Services.

I thank the Ceann Comhairle for affording me time to raise this important matter, namely, the need for the Minister for Health and Children to provide an urgent update on her plans for a realistic transport service for cancer patients in rural areas who are not being adequately provided for in terms of travelling to Dublin or other centres of excellence for treatment, despite the Minister's assurance that such provision would be made. These patients are falling between health clinics and the HSE and failing to get funding or compensation for such expenses, not to mention the exhaustion caused by inadequate transport provision.

I am sure the Minister of State will agree that nothing illustrates a point better than example. I have had recent correspondence from the Society of St. Vincent de Paul outlining an appalling situation regarding an extremely ill lady who has to travel to the Mater Hospital weekly and sometimes twice weekly.

Travel difficulties have forced this lady to miss urgent hospital appointments because of exhaustion, ill-health and lack of funding. Her travel costs are €89 per day and she has no idea how the frequently required journeys will be financed or how she will be able to withstand the long hours spent travelling.

On one occasion this constituent managed to get an ambulance bus from the Mater which took from noon until she arrived in Longford at 7 p.m. and then had to take a taxi to her home, arriving at 9.10 p.m. This would be a gruelling journey for an able-bodied person but it was a nightmare for an extremely ill cancer victim.

Although the woman had an important appointment at the hospital the next morning, she was unable to undertake such an arduous journey again due to the toll on her health. For anyone in the whole of their health to undertake such stressful travelling on a regular basis would be daunting but for a person already weakened by a debilitating illness, it is totally untenable and a shameful indictment of the Minister's lack of concern for individual patients who are falling victim to cost-cutting measures which have seen essential services centralised without adequate transport measures being put in place.

This patient has fallen between the local health clinic and the HSE with regard to funding. The end result of the system of passing the buck which extends across all Departments, is that she feels abandoned by the health services and has no idea from one visit to the next how she is going to be able to afford to get to the hospital. Because of travel expenses this lady has allowed her rent, her electricity bill and other pressing accounts go into arrears. She is the real casualty of the cutbacks with which the Minister and her colleagues have rewarded those who put them back into Government.

This is not a stealth tax or a rise in the cost of luxury cars. This is a matter of life and death and no Government has the right to jeopardise people's health or impose unduly harsh and inhumane measures on them when they pursue treatment. This is the situation for a large number of patients in the midlands.

The bottom line is that people in the midlands are not getting the service they deserve. Expecting extremely ill people to undertake marathon journeys to access treatment is scandalous. We could point the finger and say that the Government simply does not care, because it does not.

We heard this morning that the HSE is to introduce new health service cutbacks to the tune of €300 million in the weeks ahead. These are cutbacks which the Minister will be forced to admit are needed to cover the financial mismanagement of her Department for which she has the nerve to expect the chronically ill to bear the brunt of and to forego essential treatment and services. It is not an exaggeration to say that very soon this Government will expect the seriously ill to cycle to so-called centres of excellence because there will be no money for ambulance buses or taxis as it will all have been used up by scandalous waste on one fiasco after another.

I ask the Minister of State to outline how long more this lady and others can be expected to endure such hardships. It is bad enough to be a victim of cancer and to have to undertake treatment. However, to endure constant worry about transport and the added stress of financial difficulties in doing so, is unbearable for many patients in the midlands. Even Dickens could not have envisaged such misery. I ask the Minister of State to take action and provide a good and reliable transport service for victims of cancer in the midlands. I have spoken to several officials in the HSE and they say the transport system for patients in the midlands is nothing short of a disgrace and a shambles. It is up to the Minister to ensure that proper transport services are put in place for people from the midlands. The way this Government has behaved towards cancer victims in the midlands over the last number of years is a shame and a disgrace.

I am taking the Adjournment on behalf of my colleague, Deputy Mary Harney, Minister for Health and Children. I welcome the opportunity to address the issues raised by the Deputy and to set out the current position regarding the national cancer control programme and the provision of transport services for cancer patients.

Professor Tom Keane took up his post as national cancer control director on 19 November last. The decisions of the Health Service Executive to designate four managed cancer control networks and eight cancer centres will be implemented on a managed and phased basis.

The designation of cancer centres aims to ensure that patients receive the highest quality care while at the same time allowing local access to services where appropriate. Where diagnosis and treatment planning is directed and managed by multidisciplinary teams based at the cancer centres, then much of the treatment, other than surgery, can be delivered in local hospitals.

A detailed transitional plan is being put in place to facilitate the progressive, gradual and carefully managed transfer of services over the next two years or so. The HSE plans to complete 50% of the transition of services to cancer centres by the end of this year and 80% to 90% by the end of 2009. The HSE is putting in place a structured programme of quality assurance, support and information services to underpin the re-organisation of services to ensure that cancer patients will receive quality services as close to home as possible.

Professor Keane and the HSE have emphasised the importance of mobilising existing resources and redirecting them to achieve the national cancer control programme objectives. Arrangements are in hand to enable Professor Keane to take control of all new cancer developments and, progressively, all existing cancer services and related funding and staffing. Additional funding of €35 million has been allocated for cancer control in 2008, representing a 71% increase over the equivalent funding for last year which was €20.5 million. This includes funding of €15 million for the implementation of the national cancer control programme. Further investment in cancer control will be based on the reform programme now being implemented by the HSE.

The HSE currently provides transport for cancer patients in a range of circumstances. In many cases this is managed locally at the hospital or at community level. The HSE has advised that it makes every effort to assist patients who require transport and patients are encouraged to make direct contact with the treating hospital to determine suitable arrangements. Where difficulties are brought to the notice of any staff member, options are explored and the most suitable arrangements put in place for patients.

Following completion of the current HSE review on transport services, the national cancer control programme expects to be in a position to administer current expenditure on cancer transport. The programme has also allocated €750,000 to the Irish Cancer Society which will administer a grants programme based on agreed criteria to enable patients to be transported to designated cancer centres for necessary treatment. This will be in addition to the existing hardship-related programme which the Irish Cancer Society administers.

The Government is committed to making the full range of cancer services available and accessible to cancer patients throughout Ireland in accordance with best international standards. The developments which I have outlined to the House will ensure that comprehensive quality-assured treatment and support services are available to all cancer patients nationally.

Search and Rescue Service.

I look forward to the reply with the specific data I seek as I am only working on anecdotal information at this stage. From my information, between 2001 and 2007 more than 111 rescue missions in Lough Foyle were carried out by Malin Head rescue centre. Within that figure there were a number of joint operations between the rescue centres in Clyde in Scotland, Belfast and Malin Head. These joint operations used each other's intelligence in a collaborative way and have been going on for many years. I have singled out Lough Foyle because it is unique on the island as we have a joint jurisdiction under the auspices of the Loughs Agency. The two jurisdictions have worked together to manage the fishing operations in Lough Foyle.

The issue I wish to raise is of the utmost importance. Before North-South joint operations and connectivity, and cross-Border co-operation, when the Rev. Dr. Ian Paisley was leading the charge against working in a collaborative way, we had unique relationships regarding marine safety on this island. There were operations involving services based in Scotland, Northern Ireland and Malin Head at a time when such collaboration did not appear to exist. However, there has been a unique understanding, interrelationship and interdependence between services based in three jurisdictions, namely, Malin Head, Clyde and Northern Ireland.

I have a number of questions for the Minister of State though I accept he will not have a reply for me tonight. What consultation has gone on between our Department of Transport, which has responsibility for the marine, and the Northern Administration regarding the proposed closure of the station at Malin Head? What consultation has taken place between the Loughs Agency and the Department of Transport regarding the proposed closure of that station? What consultation has taken place at the North-South Ministerial Council, which proposes that there should be North-South co-operation on aquaculture and marine issues? These are the questions that need to be answered. What consultation has taken place between the Scottish Administration and our Minister regarding the proposed closure of the station at Malin Head? I ask this because there have been ongoing rescue missions involving the Scottish service based in Clyde and the service in Malin Head. Has the British-Irish Interparliamentary Body been consulted by the Minister, Deputy Dempsey, regarding this issue? If it has, why have I not been consulted as a member of that body? If it has not been consulted, the British-Irish Interparliamentary Body must be asked whether the Scottish Administration has been consulted regarding the proposed closure of the station at Malin Head?

Regarding proposed new funding avenues through INTERREG, what consultation regarding the proposed closure of the station at Malin Head has taken place between the Department and the Scottish agencies that were seeking transnational links between Northern Ireland and this jurisdiction? An area of interest to you, a Cheann Comhairle, is Valentia and the southern channel. What consultations have taken place with French authorities regarding the proposed closure of the station at Valentia?

There are so many questions regarding the intrinsic relationships and linkages of the existing infrastructure in Valentia and Malin Head that have not been answered. The rigid tool of the administrative stroke of a pen is being used to close a station at Malin Head, taking away all the good work and capacity building that has gone on over the years between three jurisdictions.

This decision goes against our constitutional rights because we bought into the Good Friday Agreement and into integrated strategies for the marine and aquaculture. We are removing existing infrastructure, interrelationships and interdependence, North and South. We are making a serious mistake. What external consultation has taken place outside the Department of Transport regarding these issues? These are important issues that need to be clarified.

I call on the Minister of State to respond and she has five minutes. I know there is considerable detail in the response because the Deputy sought details. The statistical information can be handed by the Minister of State to the Editor of Debates for inclusion in the Official Report. There will not be a necessity for the Minister of State to read all the statistics although they may be provided to the Deputy in that way or through a letter. If they must be included on the record, it is possible to do that as well.

I would be happy with an overall number rather than needing to go into it in depth.

For the purposes of the Deputy's submission and for the purposes of the record, it is possible to put the statistical information on the record. That is what I am saying if that is helpful to the Deputy.

I will respect the five minutes and I am sure the Deputy will also be happy to receive these statistics. We will see how the script actually goes.

I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak on this subject on behalf of the Minister for Transport, Deputy Dempsey. The organisation responsible for marine emergency management in the Irish search and rescue region is the Irish Coast Guard, which is under the remit of the Department of Transport. Prior to 2001 both Malin Head and Valentia were commercial coast radio stations whose principal responsibility was to carry out ship-to-shore links to shipping, issue weather forecasts and navigational warnings, and log fishing reports. From 2001, the co-ordination of search and rescue services for the north and north-west coast was delegated to Malin Head from the marine rescue co-ordination centre in Dublin. Prior to 2001 emergencies occurring in the north and west regions had been co-ordinated from the marine rescue co-ordination centre in Dublin since the early 1990s, and before that from the marine rescue co-ordination centres in Shannon and Haulbowline.

There may be some confusion between the work done in co-ordination centres and that undertaken by local volunteers. The location of a co-ordination centre and local knowledge are not entirely linked as the principal element of local knowledge comes from the local coast guard coastal units and lifeboat crews strategically positioned around our coast. Their local knowledge of tides, currents, bays and local historical incident locations is invaluable to the watch officers of the Irish Coast Guard. The volunteers in the Lough Foyle area are the RNLI at Portrush and Lough Swilly, and the Irish Coast Guard unit at Greencastle. This unit is both a cliff and boat rescue unit, and is one of the most advanced teams in the country.

I would like to put on record again my appreciation and that of the Minister, Deputy Dempsey, for the selfless voluntary efforts of the Irish Coast Guard, RNLI and community rescue boat crews in rescuing those in trouble off our coasts, cliffs and offshore islands. We are also indebted to a wide range of organisations, both public and private, that make their facilities available to the Irish Coast Guard on a 24-hour basis or which have operational or liaison agreements with the coast guard.

Lough Foyle divides the search and rescue regions of the Irish Coast Guard of the Department of Transport and the Northern Ireland Coastguard. Half of the lough lies in the Irish search and rescue region and half in the UK region. It has long been the practice, however, that search and rescue knows no borders, only boundaries. There is close co-operation between the Irish Coast Guard and the Northern Ireland Coastguard across the Lough Foyle boundary. Search and rescue helicopters at both Dublin and Sligo support search and rescue operations in Northern Ireland. This assistance is managed through the Irish Coast Guard co-ordination centres at Dublin and Malin Head. The helicopters are contracted to be airborne within 15 minutes between 7.30 a.m. and 9 p.m. and within 45 minutes between 9 p.m. and 7.30 a.m. Irish Coast Guard search and rescue helicopters add to the ongoing co-operation through the provision of training, and search and rescue assistance to Northern Ireland-based RNLI lifeboats and mountain rescue teams.

Much of the current search and rescue already takes place on an all-Ireland basis. The organisation of mountain and cave rescue, RNLI, Commissioners of Irish Lights and Waterways Ireland are set up on that basis. Irish Coast Guard teams regularly exercise with their Northern Ireland counterparts in the Border area. The Irish and UK coastguard services continue to discuss procedures to harmonise search and rescue techniques north and south of the Border. There is work in progress by Ireland on the extension of the Irish search and rescue region to coincide with the Irish pollution region and European economic zone. Work has begun as part of a UK-Irish memorandum of understanding and this element will require agreement between the Department of Foreign Affairs and the UK Foreign and Commonwealth Office.

The Irish Marine Emergency Service was established and named by a Government decision in 1991. In 2000, it became the Irish Coast Guard which better denotes the service provided. Detailed records have been compiled of all marine incidents following the establishment of the Irish Marine Emergency Service. Records from earlier years are in long-term storage. Records available show a detailed breakdown of incidents by type across the three co-ordination centres at Malin Head, Valentia and Dublin, but they do not provide a breakdown by specific location.

For the purpose of this debate and within the short timeframe available for compiling the information, Malin Head records since it became a search and rescue co-ordination centre in 2001 have been examined and the following information can be made available. It refers to incidents in Lough Foyle and several of these involved joint operations with the Belfast coastguard. The latter has advised the Irish Coast Guard that it had eight incidents in Lough Foyle in 2007.

The number of incidents recorded for the following years are as follows: ten incidents in 2001, 13 in 2002, 23 in 2003, 15 in 2004, four in 2005, nine in 2006 and eight in 2007. As my time has elapsed, I will make the information available to the Deputy in hard copy form if he is prepared to accept it in that format.

Additional information not given on the floor of the House.

Details of the incidents that were dealt with by the marine rescue sub-centre at Malin Head are as follows:

On 1/01/2001 a sighting of an upturned hull off Moville Light was reported.

On 10/02/2001 a flare report in Lough Foyle.

On 07/04/2001 three flares were reported off Greencastle.

On 24/05/2001 a speed boat was reported adrift off Greencastle with four people on board.

On 07/07/2001 the FV Day Dream was reported drifting without power at Redcastle.

On 15/08/2001 a sick crewman taken ashore from the fishing vessel Castle Queen.

On 17/08/2001 report of a log at mouth of lough with possible danger to navigation for small boats.

On 07/09/2001 the Éireann Sea was reported aground on sandbank off Redcastle.

On 25/09/2001 a small boat was reported dragging anchor off Greencastle.

On 09/12/2001 assistance to gardaí in search of a missing person in Moville Bay.

On 26/01/2002 a report of a dredger causing danger to fishing vessel Girl Nicola.

On 28/01/2002 report of an old fishing vessel Sans Peur broke moorings and drifting.

On 03/02/2002 request for assistance to police in Northern Ireland with search of missing person at the mouth of the River Foyle.

On 14/05/2002 report of a yacht Morning Glory going aground south of Moville.

On 09/06/2002 report of yacht Jade broken from moorings and drifting.

On 13/06/2002 report of an oil slick off Carrickarory pier.

On 23/06/2002 report of fishing vessel Random Harvest — water in engine room at Greencastle.

On 08/07/2002 nets in propeller of fishing vessel Bangor Crest, towed to Greencastle

On 15/08/2002 report received of ferry Greencastle/Magilligan with a lost forward ramp with danger of taking water.

On 13/09/2002 fibreglass boat was reported adrift off Greencastle.

On 14/09/2002 a broken down speed boat was reported requiring a tow.

On 30/09/2002 a 24 ft. fishing vessel with a rope around propeller required tow.

On 31/12/2002 assistance requested for UK coastguard with search of Donegal shoreline for missing anglers.

On 22/02/2003 car reported stuck on beach.

On 13/04/2003 jet ski adrift and towed ashore.

On 19/04/2003 an overturned yacht in water was reported and two persons were recovered.

On 22/04/2003 two large floating objects required towing ashore.

On 07/05/2003 yacht Firecracker was reported broken free, towed to Greencastle.

On 11/05/2003 four barrels floating reported as a danger to small craft were taken ashore off Warrenpoint.

On 11/06/2003 a mussel dredger sank off Ture Light.

On 15/06/2003 the yacht Ryvoran reported aground near Tuns Buoy. On 16/06/2003 a small inflatable reported adrift off Greencastle.

On 18/06/2003 fishing vessel Seacraft reported broken down off Warrenpoint Light.

On 18/06/2003 the cruiser Fair Maid broke moorings and reported drifting off Moville.

On 19/06/2003 fishing vessel Helen Mary reported broken down and drifting off Benowen Strand.

On 06/07/2003 a small fishing vessel reported adrift off Moville.

On 06/07/2003 the yacht Niamh reported aground off Redcastle.

On 10/07/2003 dinghy reported capsized off Moville.

On 11/07/2003 the yacht Streaker reported adrift off Greencastle.

On 26/07/2003 a speed boat reported broken down and drifting.

On 27/07/2003 the Swiller Warrior was reported taking water off Moville.

On 25/08/2003 request to assist gardaí in shoreline search for missing persons.

On 31/08/2003 the Foyle Venture reported aground at Magilligan.

On 26/10/2003 report of a glider down near Greencastle.

On 01/11/2003 red flare report in Greencastle area.

On 09/11/2003 fishing vessel Spiritual Vessel reported going on rocks near Moville.

On 18/01/2004 three persons in difficulty in a rowing boat at Lisahally.

On 10/02/2004 report of red flares.

On 28/03/2004 report of a dive boat broken down, requires tow.

On 04/05/2004 persons reported in the water off Culmore Point.

On 16/05/2004 report of the yacht Saratoga aground on sandbank.

On 28/05/2004 report of the yacht Mucmara aground off Moville.

On 28/05/2004Foyle Venture ferry reported loss of engine power.

On 14/06/2004MV Topgallant reported an injured crewman.

On 10/07/2004 the yacht Cruisen reported aground at McKinneys Light.

On 26/08/2004 the yacht Astral reported aground at Saltpans.

On 26/08/2004 the yacht lolar na Mara reported adrift off Moville.

On 26/08/2004 the fishing vessel Celtic Dawn reported taking water alongside Moville pier.

On 13/09/2004 a 20 ft. yacht reported aground Moville.

On 30/09/2004 request to assist ambulance control with missing person outside Greencastle.

On 18/10/2004 report of warhead on Redcastle beach.

On 02/05/2005 windsurfer reported in difficulty off Magilligan.

On 10/07/2005 report of boat aground off Redcastle.

On 21/07/2005 report of Bayliner vessel aground Lough Foyle.

On 21/07/2005 the cruiser Uptown Girl reported aground in Lough Foyle.

On 16/07/2006 yacht Nokomis reported aground near Greencastle harbour.

On 23/07/2006 person in water in River Foyle near Craigavon bridge. UK coastguard requested assistance.

On 20/10/2006 report of a red flare off Greencastle.

On 10/08/2006 report of canoe capsized, three persons in water near Greencastle.

On 16/08/2006 fishing vessel Eliz Christine reported engine failure requiring tow off Moville.

On 22/08/2006 report of a red flare off Magilligan point.

On 08/09/2006 the fishing vessel Eliz Christine, broken down requiring a tow.

On 05/10/2006 an overturned canoe reported floating off shore.

On 20/10/2006 report of a red flare off pier Greencastle.

On 18/01/2007 the fishing vessel Giolla Na Mara EPIRB detected.

On 18/05/2007 the yacht Aquilla reported aground off Moville.

On 26/05/2007Bay Cruiser reported broken down off Magilligan point requiring a tow.

On 01/08/2007 a report of a boat, details unknown, broken down at mouth of Lough Foyle requiring a tow.

On 25/07/2007 the dinghy Laura reported semi submerged off Whitecastle.

On 02/08/2007 report of three flares in Lough Foyle.

On 24/08/2007 report of a small punt in the approaches to Lough Foyle.

On 26/09/2007 report of a sick person on boat in Lough Foyle.

I pay tribute to all the women and men who have worked for and with our marine emergency services on call 24 hours a day. It is truly no mean commitment to give of their time and be brave and selfless enough to carry out sea and coastal rescues.

Job Creation.

I thank the Ceann Comhairle for allowing me to raise this issue for the second time in a month. Although I am probably not allowed to talk about the Ceann Comhairle, he has shown a great interest in and support for Tallaght over the years, particularly in his previous portfolio.

So has the Deputy.

I am happy to put on record the fact that the Ceann Comhairle is spoken of in glowing terms concerning the Shamrock Rovers stadium.

A month ago I spoke in the House about job losses in Jacob's where 230 permanent jobs and 130 seasonal jobs will be phased out over the next year. I took the view then that it was a big blow for Tallaght. Over recent days we heard another bad announcement, this time from Microprint, another good company in Tallaght, which is ceasing production at that facility. Microprint is the computer manual and magazine printing company which, among other publications, produces the RTE Guide. I thought everybody read the RTE Guide but it is a blow and I do not want to be flippant about it.

Tallaght is the third largest centre of population in the country and, as I have said on many occasions, it cannot afford to lose jobs. We must focus on creating jobs there. As I said with regard to Jacob's a month ago, our first priority is to express our solidarity with the workers in Microprint. Some 130 families will be affected by the job losses there. We hope the company will be generous and not only provide a high level of redundancy payments but also take account of its employees' future needs. I appeal to the company to do precisely that.

I acknowledge the interest of the Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, Deputy Billy Kelleher, who addressed this issue for me a month ago. He is present in the House again now. He certainly has been supportive concerning the issues I have raised. Apart from the need for Jacob's and Microprint to look after their workers, these job losses, which total almost 500, highlight the fact for the Government and State agencies that Tallaght has the same job creation needs as everywhere else. Deputies from Limerick, Kerry, Cork and elsewhere will make the same point about their communities. I believe, however, that I can make a very strong case for Tallaght which is a huge population centre with at least 25,000 school students. If we start haemorrhaging jobs it will put us under even more pressure.

The Tallaght that I moved to almost 40 years ago is a different place today, thank God. Since the Square opened on 23 October 1990, there has been major job creation with significant progress in the town. Tallaght is now a city in all but name. It is a great place. One can drive there on great roads or go on the Luas. One can visit the hospital, the civic centre, the theatre, the Square and the National Basketball Arena, where I was this morning. It is a vibrant and positive place but we are concerned about job losses and account must be taken of these blows to Tallaght.

I want to stress that Tallaght has major needs. While not wishing to compete with anyone else around the country, I expect the Minister to prioritise the job creation requirements of Tallaght which needs special attention. I hope that not only will we see job creation initiatives for Tallaght in the coming months but also help for companies that are in difficulty. I appeal to the Minister of State not only to deliver his reply but also to stress to his senior Minister tomorrow the concerns I have raised in this regard. I thank the Ceann Comhairle for his courtesy in allowing me to raise this matter on the Adjournment.

I thank Deputy O'Connor for raising this matter. I was disappointed to hear about the further job losses announced last Monday at a company in Tallaght, coupled with the previous announcement of job losses at Jacob's. It is obviously disturbing news for the community. I commend the Deputy on continually highlighting the need for job creation in the Tallaght area generally.

While I am conscious of the effect that job losses have on the workers involved, their families and the local community, I assure the House that State agencies will make every effort they can to develop new employment opportunities for Tallaght. The role of FÁS, the industrial training agency, is especially important in assisting those who lose their jobs. The agency has written already to the company that announced the job losses last Monday advising of the services available to the company and its workforce. The agency is prepared to offer its full range of services to any employees who lose their jobs and wish to avail of its services.

When such job losses are announced, the State development agencies — Enterprise Ireland, IDA Ireland, FÁS, the South Dublin County Enterprise Board and the South Dublin County Development Board — adopt a co-ordinated approach in dealing with the situation and in making the workforce aware of supports available to assist in finding new employment or to start their own businesses.

I am confident that the strategies and policies being pursued by the State development agencies will continue to drive investment, enterprise development and job creation in Tallaght. In terms of job creation, Enterprise Ireland's activity is focused on the creation of new jobs through supporting entrepreneurs in manufacturing and internationally traded service companies that are setting up high potential start-up companies. The agency also supports the provision of incubation space for new start-up companies and works toward enhancing the innovation capability in its client companies through the support of research both in companies and in third level institutions. In addition, the agency also focuses on the retention and creation of new jobs in existing companies.

Since the beginning of 2004, Enterprise Ireland has made payments of more than €8.7 million to companies in south County Dublin to enhance their capacity, capability and performance. Working in partnership with the local community, Enterprise Ireland has approved support for the development of community enterprise centres. These are located in Bawnogue, Neilstown, Whitestown, Main Road — Tallaght, Bolbrook, Avonbeg, Brookfield and Killinarden. The M50 enterprise platform programme is under way in Tallaght's institute of technology, in conjunction with Blanchardstown Institute of Technology and Dublin City University. This is a one-year rapid incubation programme designed for entrepreneurs who wish to start their own business. The agency also works closely with the Institute of Technology, Tallaght in encouraging the commercialisation of research and has approved financial support of more than €2.6 million to the institute for the development and management of a campus-based incubation centre.

At present, IDA Ireland's strategy is to progress the development of a knowledge economy so that we can compete internationally for foreign direct investment. The agency continues to work with its existing clients to develop their businesses further and provide world class property solutions with supporting infrastructure.

Tallaght and south-west Dublin is actively promoted and marketed by IDA Ireland to potential investors and is well equipped to compete with other areas for potential foreign direct investment. The attractions of the area include a third level institute and excellent infrastructural facilities at Citywest and Grangecastle. The further development of the business parks at Citywest and Grangecastle will ensure the area remains an attractive location for investment, particularly foreign direct investment.

The announcement in November last that Microsoft Corporation had selected Grangecastle as the location for its new European data centre reflects Ireland's standing internationally as a global knowledge based economy. It also demonstrates the commitment of IDA Ireland to growing next generation businesses in south-west Dublin and is evidence of the suitability of the area for world class investments. In addition, the pharmaceutical company, Wyeth Biopharma, has established the world's largest biopharma campus facility in Grangecastle, currently employing more than 1,300 highly skilled people. Wyeth also recently announced its intention to invest an additional €24 million in the creation of dedicated research and design facilities at its Grangecastle campus. It is important that we continue to attract high-end knowledge based jobs, particularly in research and development.

I am confident that the strategies and policies being pursued by the State development agencies in Tallaght will continue to support enterprise development and provide employment opportunities in the area. I reiterate that the State agencies will continue to work closely with each other and with local interests to provide an integrated approach to increasing the flow of potential investors and promoting job creation in Tallaght. Deputy O'Connor outlined some of the fine facilities in Tallaght. I assure him we are conscious of the need to support this area of rapid population growth, with a high proportion of young people and a highly motivated community. I am confident that the supports we are providing and the investment potential that exists will ensure there are plenty of job opportunities for people in Tallaght. I commend Deputy O'Connor on continually highlighting the need not only for job creation but for investment in training, education and the upskilling of the workforce. All this will have a positive impact in the coming years.

Schools Building Projects.

I thank the Ceann Comhairle for allowing me to raise this issue. There is an urgent need for a new national school in Kilfinane. Various promises were made since 2001 and there is deep concern that the school was not included in the most recent announcement on schools building projects.

The Department of Education and Science commissioned a feasibility study for the school in 1999 which recommended that a new school be built on a greenfield site. The project has advanced to the tender and construction stage and planning permission was granted in 2007. The existing school still has outside toilets and these have always been a significant cause of concern to parents, guardians and school staff. The board of management and staff continually strive to put measures in place to ensure pupils' safety at all times. It is becoming increasingly difficult to guarantee that safety, particularly in the wake of a sinister event that occurred during the summer. This incident highlighted the vulnerability of pupils when they leave the school buildings to use the toilets and has struck fear in the hearts of parents, guardians and staff. Nothing will allay this fear other than the construction of a new school.

The inadequate conditions of the existing buildings have been well documented to the Department. The building was constructed as a church in the 19th century and remodelled as a school in 1887. The last major refurbishment was undertaken in 1909. The classrooms are cramped, with three measuring only 35 sq. m, and there is no room for sinks. The learning support and resource teacher and the secretary work in cubicles partitioned off the classrooms, which is totally unacceptable. There are no indoor physical education facilities and the high windowsills reduce visibility for teachers and pupils. There are continuous ventilation and heating problems despite the remedial measures taken to address this. The glass and timber partitions between class rooms lead to significant noise interference. The staff room serves also as a store room, principal's office, library and music room. There is cramped yard space and play opportunities are severely restricted for pupils. The high degree of variation within the site results in dangerous drops. There are no parking facilities for staff or parents and no private spaces to make telephone calls, speak to parents privately and so on.

The deputy principal and a member of the board of management had a meeting with the Department in 2004 at which documentation on the proposed housing developments for Kilfinane were presented to officials. Many of these houses have subsequently been built and the first phase of 60 social and affordable houses is under way. The school will not be able to cater for the influx of children these houses will bring.

Despite inadequate working conditions, the staff of the school is totally committed to delivering the revised curriculum in its entirety to pupils. Subjects such as art, science, drama and music, which require modern conveniences and facilities, are not neglected. Physical education activities, however, are limited to outdoors. The constant strain of maintaining a high standard of teaching and learning in inadequate conditions while also being constantly vigilant about children's safety creates a stressful working environment for members of staff and takes its toll on their health.

In November 2007, the Department confirmed that the contractors for the project had been shortlisted. We were informed that the new regulations issued by the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance, Deputy Cowen, regarding bills of quantities will not be applied to the project because it was first advertised under the old criteria and it was the policy of the building unit to get approval for both tender and construction at the same time. The building project is ready for tender and construction and the board of management expected it to be included in the latest announcement. There was no mention of it, however, when the Minister for Education and Science ran around last month telling various Deputies which building projects in their constituencies had been approved.

Will there be a further announcement at Easter and will Kilfinane be included in it? It is a simple question and I hope the Minister of State will answer it.

Deputy Neville knows I like to be the bearer of good news. I thank him for raising this matter and affording me the opportunity of outlining to the House the position in regard to the proposed building project for Kilfinane national school in County Limerick.

Under the lifetime of the national development plan, almost €4.5 billion will be invested in schools. This is an unprecedented level of capital investment which reflects the commitment of the Government to continue its programme of sustained investment in primary and post-primary schools. In the next several years, this investment will facilitate the provision of new schools and extensions in developing areas and the improvement of existing schools through the provision of replacement schools, extensions or large-scale refurbishments.

The Department of Education and Science intends to provide Kilfinane national school with a new six-classroom facility together with a general purpose room and ancillary accommodation on a greenfield site.

The Department has advanced the project to the stage where it has gone out to tender.

The Deputy will appreciate that the progression of all large-scale building projects from initial design through to construction stage is considered on an ongoing basis in the context of the national development plan and the Department's multi-annual school building and modernisation programme. Progress to construction on the proposed project for Kilfinane national school will likewise be considered in this context.

I assure the Deputy that the Minister is committed to providing a new school for Kilfinane national school and that this will be done as quickly as possible.

Will it be announced at Easter? It was promised last year.

In the context of the overall investment envelope for schools building projects, the Department is committed to providing modern facilities for the pupils of Kilfinane national school.

The Dáil adjourned at 9.40 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Thursday, 6 March 2008.
Top
Share