Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Thursday, 18 Dec 1930

Vol. 14 No. 6

Complaint by Senator.

Cathaoirleach

I have given due consideration to the matter raised by Senator Comyn at the opening of yesterday's meeting of the House, when he alleged that a breach of privilege had been committed in respect of his person by his being stopped by the military guard for the purpose of identification when he was entering Leinster House on Tuesday. Had there in fact been a breach of privilege I should have felt bound to request the House to take action in the matter, but I cannot subscribe to the view that a request to stop for purposes of identification is an arrest within the meaning of Section 18 of the Constitution. I find on inquiry that it is usual for the military guard to request persons to stop whom they do not immediately recognise, but that upon recognition they are allowed to proceed, and that the guard invariably discharge their duties in a courteous manner.

[Mr. Johnson rose.]

Cathaoirleach

There must be no debate on the matter. That is my ruling.

I am not going to debate it. I was going to suggest that it is opportune to express a view that in regard to the premises of the Parliament of this State it is undesirable to continue longer a military guard-that there should be a civil guard and not a military guard at the gate.

Top
Share