Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Thursday, 7 May 1992

Vol. 132 No. 9

Adjournment Matters. - Homeless Young People.

I welcome the Minister to the House and congratulate him on his appointment as Minister for Health.

I raise this issue of homelessness among young people in Ireland for a number of reasons, but primarily because of a survey carried out by the Streetwise organisation in January which indicated that Ireland had 150 homeless young people, a very disturbing figure. The problem is even more disturbing when one reflects that the homeless who did not approach hostels for accommodation are not included in the survey. It is fair to assume that the number of young homeless is greater than 150 but it is not possible to know how much greater. The survey further indicates that only 40 per cent of those who were accommodated were in what were considered satisfactory conditions. That is very worrying and unacceptable.

It is clear from those data that there is a lack of accommodation for homeless people generally and I am primarily concerned about the young homeless. It also emeged that of the order of 43 per cent of those seeking accommodation were under 16 years of age. There has been an increase in the proportion of homeless people under 16 years. In 1987 the figure was 28 per cent and in a survey done in 1989 the figure was 38 per cent. We are seeing a pattern which indicates an increasing problem of young homeless.

It also emerges in the Streetwise survey that 41 of the total 150 people in the survey had previously been in residential care. We are seeing repeat cases and it must be clear from that data that the system is unable to deal adequately with this problem; if it were the problem would not recur. That is a matter which needs to be attended to and addressed by the Minister.

Appropriate aftercare service should be provided for homeless people even when the emergency services are able to cope with individual cases. There is a need for an intermediary level of care between the emergency services and the reintegration of these children with their families or communities. We are talking of second level care which does not have to be as intensive as the initial care provided by the emergency services but is vital to prevent the recurrence of homelessness. There are serious deficiencies in the data available on the problem of homelessness here. This survey was carried out by a voluntary organisation. As far as I am aware no longitudinal studies had been carried out in relation to homelessness or homeless young people here. What becomes of homeless people as they make their way through life? What generates homelessness in the first instance? What is the life history of homeless people? When that data becomes available it may then be possible to work out ways in which the problem can be solved.

There are further problems in centres for the homeless outside the main urban areas. Many of these centres have no emergency accommodation. I have asked for information on the number of homeless young people accommodated in bed and breakfast establishments and the amount of money spent on this type of accommodation. I have nothing against bed and breakfast outlets; they provide a worthy service and one has to pay tribute to those who take in homeless young people. However, such accommodation is totally inappropriate for young homeless people and I am very concerned that it is being used for that purpose.

There is need for a series of differing approaches to care and the present attitude seems to be to provide emergency accommodation only in unsatisfactory arrangements.

The data reveals disturbingly that 60 per cent of the homeless people surveyed who contacted hostels were female which raises questions about the options open to young homeless females. There seems to be a greater tendency to homelessness among young females but without data and analysis it is not possible to be categorical. In relation to the Dublin area with which the Minister is very familiar there is a serious problem given that of the 150 children surveyed 108 were accommodated or sought accommodation in Dublin based hostels. The problem is primarily centred in Dublin and the numbers accommodated in that area, as far as I can see from the survey, amounted to something like 42 per cent although, according to the data, there are some hostels for which the information is not available.

We can accept that there is a serious recurring problem with young homeless in the Dublin area. In many ways the problem is getting worse and I sincerly hope the Minister will address it in a coherent way and extend to it the vigorous, aggressive attitude he has adopted to the AIDS problem and to some other aspects of the health services.

I am sure the Minister is too well aware of the risks attached to homelessness, the risk of prostitution, drug abuse, criminal involvement and so on. I will be interested in the data the Minister can provide in relation to the numbers of young people accommodated in bed and breakfast outlets and the amount of money spent on it.

I thank Senator Upton for raising an important issue. I would like to assure Senators at the outset that the Government are extremely concerned about young homeless and are fully committed to resolving this serious problem.

The Government have initiated a wide ranging package of developments with a view to effecting substantial improvements in the availability of services and accommodation for the young homeless. The aim of this programme is to ensure that no young person should have to sleep rough on the streets of our cities and towns.

I am pleased to inform the House that considerable progress has been made. Over 40 additional places for the young homeless are being provided in Dublin; 12 of these are already available and I expect the balance to be in place shortly. New services are also being developed in Cork, Athlone, Limerick, Galway and Sligo which will provide about 30 extra places.

Among the important new developments in the Eastern Health Board area are, a new emergency hostel providing ten places for homeless girls now in place at Sherrard House, Dublin 1; a new therapeutic unit for eight difficult adolescents, boys and girls, operated by the Eastern Health Board near Naas, County Kildare opening shortly; a new residential unit for ten boys to be operated by the Los Angeles Society due to open in Dalkey in June 1992; the hostel for homeless boys run by the Catholic Social Service Conference has been relocated from Percy Place to newly refurbished accommodation at Eccles Street resulting in an increase from ten to 12 in the number of places and a new aftercare service for up to four boys leaving that hostel at Eccles Street has been established at Lennox Street.

In addition, the Eastern Health Board are taking a number of other initiatives, including the establishment of an after hours social work service to deal exclusively with the young homeless; a carers for young people scheme to provide family care for adolescents who have had difficulty adapting to other settings and developing other short term accommodation such as digs, sheltered flats and semi-independent living accommodation.

While the problem of youth homelessness arises mainly in the Dublin area, it is not confined to that area. Discussions have been held with the chief executive officers of the other health boards concerning appropriate measures to assist the young homeless in their areas. The aim is to ensure, as far as possible, that each health board is self-sufficient in residential places. This is fully in keeping with the Child Care Act and the new obligations it imposes on health boards to provide accommodation for homeless children. Progress is being made on a number of fronts. A new hostel for homeless youth is being established in Athlone by a voluntary group in association with the Midland Health Board. A new residential service for 8-10 adolescent boys is being developed near Limerick by the Mid-Western Health Board and additional places have been provided at Stranorlar, County Donegal for children and adolescents with behavioural problems. A new hostel for homeless youngsters is being developed in Sligo by a voluntary body with support from the North-Western Health Board and the building of a new residential unit for teenage boys in Cork city is now completed and will open shortly. A specialised foster care programme for difficult children is also being developed by the Southern Health Board and a new hostel for homeless girls is being developed in Galway by the Western Health Board in association with a local voluntary group.

When all of these developments are fully in place, they will represent a substantial addition to the range of facilities and services currently available to assist the young homeless. At times, however, the situation can arise where the demand for residential places outstrips supply and it is in this context that the provision of bed and breakfast accommodation for some homeless youngsters has to be considered by the health boards. While as a general rule such accommodation can be an unacceptable response to the problem, the reality is that it is sometimes the only form of accommodation available at the time. Senator Upton will appreciate that placing a young person in bed and breakfast accommodation in a crisis is preferable to leaving the youngster on the streets although it is not a satisfactory answer.

The specific information requested by the Senator in relation to the placement of homeless children in bed and breakfast accommodation is not readily available in my Department. However, from preliminary inquiries I have been able to make in the short time available to me, it would appear that the practice is mainly confined to the Dublin area where, as I have already said, the problem of youth homelessness is mainly concentrated. I will be in contact with the Eastern Health Board and I will communicate with the Senator when the information is to hand. The preliminary information I have received indicates that bed and breakfast accommodation is not widely used.

As the Senator can see from the developments which I have outlined, the problem of youth homelessness is being targeted by the Government for particular attention. The need for further facilities to deal with this problem is being urgently examined by the health boards in consultation with the relevant voluntary agencies in the context of the additional £2 million for child care set aside in the budget.

I should say, however, and I feel very strongly about this, that the response to the apparent increase in the level of youth homelessness is not simply to provide more and more residential places. We need to look more closely at the reasons which give rise to a young person becoming homeless in the first instance, and our objective should be to put measures in place which will minimise the incidence of youth homelessness. It is a primary objective of the social work services to seek to reconcile a young homeless person with his or her family and have him or her reintegrated into the family home where such a home exists and where circumstances permit.

There are all sorts of reasons a young person would leave home — it could be a row, incompatability with family, refusing to accept parental discipline, etc. Sadly, no matter what we do such situations will arise and we must provide the necessary resources to ensure the homeless can be accommodated and not by way of bed and breakfast.

It is my intention that much more effort will go into the prevention of this problem so that the need for special accommodation for young people will be kept to a minimum. Towards this end, the development of our preventive services will be a priority in the allocation of the £2 million available for child care. I will have the other points raised by the Senator examined by my Department and will make the information available to him as soon as it comes to hand.

I thank the Minister for his comprehensive reply and I particularly want to thank him for his commitment to obtain and supply the information requested. Can he give any indication when the extra facilities he outlined as being at the planning stage will be made available?

Some of them will be available in June 1992 — such as a new residential unit in Dalkey — and I expect that many of them will be available before the end of this year. I will get specific information for the Senator as to when each facility will become available. We read about places becoming available and then wonder if they will ever do so. I agree with the Senator that that is the frustrating part.

The Seanad adjourned at 4.40 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Thursday, 14 May 1992.

Top
Share