Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Tuesday, 7 Apr 1998

Vol. 155 No. 1

Conditions in Cancer Clinic.

I raise this matter — conditions in the breast clinic in St. Vincent's Hospital — because it has been brought to my attention by a number of my constituents and by other women, some of whom have attended the clinic to be treated for breast cancer. While they have high praise for the service provided by the staff at the hospital, they are particularly concerned that the clinic is under severe pressure.

There appears to be an increasing incidence of breast cancer throughout the country. In recent weeks I have encountered eight women who have been treated for breast cancer of varying degrees of severity; in fact, two of the women were in my class in school in Roscrea. It is particularly worrying to meet women of one's own age and with whom one grew up who have been stricken by breast cancer.

There is a weekly outpatients' clinic at St. Vincent's Hospital which caters for between 200 and 300 women each week. As a result, there are long queues and long waiting periods for attention. While patients receive a courteous and good service from the staff, they are under considerable pressure when attending the clinic. One woman, who is in recovery and must attend the clinic on a monthly basis, is obliged to travel from Nenagh on the train and spend a number of hours waiting in the clinic to see a doctor for 20 to 25 minutes before returning to Nenagh. This places additional pressure on a woman in recovery after already having been through a traumatic experience or on a woman being treated for the first time or who is unsure whether a lump she has found is cancerous.

I want to know whether past indications of additional funding for the clinic and the expressed wish of staff that it should be a daily clinic, something which would obviously relieve pressure, are being responded to by the Department of Health and Children. Will the Minister tell me if there are any plans, possibly in the overall context of the development of St. Vincent's Hospital, to give increased funding to the breast clinic? I look forward to his response.

I know the Department of Health and Children and successive Ministers have done excellent work in raising consciousness of breast cancer, providing services at health board and at local levels and providing support services. I do not deny that. However, I raise this matter because it has been mentioned to me by a number of people and because it is part of the role we play in this House. Has any thought been put into the need for support services for spouses of those suffering from cancer and breast cancer especially? I await the Minister's response to the need for additional funding for the development of this clinic in St. Vincent's Hospital.

Breast cancer is a major contributor to the premature death of women in this country resulting in approximately 640 deaths per annum. In 1996, 278 women aged under 65 died from breast cancer. I fully appreciate the great level of trauma and stress experienced by women found to be suffering or who suspect they are suffering from this condition. The Government is committed to the enhancement of services in this area at both national and regional levels.

A key principle of the health strategy is the need to develop regional self-sufficiency in the provision of health services. This principle is reflected in the national cancer strategy which sets out a plan for reorganising cancer treatment services around supra-regional and regional cancer centres. Each region will have a high quality cancer service for treatments which can be administered locally with speedy access to appropriate specialist services in the supra-regional centres. Each centre has a regional director of cancer services who is currently overseeing the reorganisation process and preparing a regional plan for the development of services. A number of these plans have been prepared while others are being finalised. Part of the approach under these plans will be to develop appropriate services for the detection and treatment of breast cancer. In this regard, a number of breast clinics in hospitals throughout the country have already been financially assisted.

Another key objective in the national cancer strategy is the establishment of screening programmes for the earliest possible detection of breast cancer. It is hoped to commence screening in phase one of the breast cancer screening programme in September of this year. As part of my Department's national breast screening programme, the sum of £360,000 has recently been allocated to St. Vincent's Hospital against the cost of priority equipment required for phase one of the programme.

I am aware of the difficulties faced by patients attending the breast clinic at St. Vincent's Hospital. One of the principal difficulties is that there has been a significant increase in the number of patients attending the clinic, many of whom are referred from outside the St. Vincent's Hospital catchment area. For example, the number of attendances at the clinic has increased from approximately 6,200 in 1996 to nearly 7,300 in 1997. The clinic at St. Vincent's was the first of its kind in this country and, to some extent, its reputation has led to this dramatic rise in referrals. The breast clinic at St. Vincent's Hospital is not a national centre; rather it should be seen as a model for the development of breast clinics on a regional basis. The priority is to ensure that women who need to avail of the services of a breast clinic can receive a multi-disciplinary service at local level.

The hospital management and the clinic staff are doing everything possible to alleviate waiting times and to improve services. The hospital has stressed that women referred to the clinic who require urgent appointments are given appointments at the following Friday clinic. A series of measures has been put in place to reduce pressure on the clinic and further improvements are planned. The hospital is conscious of the need to curtail the number of inappropriate referrals to the clinic and it has been in contact with general practitioners as part of an ongoing education campaign.

The hospital operates a consultant led clinic every Friday. To improve the level of service provided, my Department made additional funding available to the hospital to facilitate the introduction of new nurse led clinics which are held twice weekly on Mondays and Thursdays. These additional clinics deal with return patients who would not necessarily require to be seen by a consultant. In addition, one of the consultant surgeons and the specialist breast clinic nurse are seeing patients every Wednesday. These clinics are focused on return patients who require time for discussion and counselling. The authorities at St. Vincent's have advised me that the block booking of patients on Friday has ceased and patients are now given appointment times.

Since October 1997 the hospital has carried out a review of the systems currently in place at the breast clinic and has issued recommendations for improvement of the service for clinic users. I understand many of the recommendations are in the process of being implemented and improvements to date include the computerisation of the breast clinic since 27 February of this year, which includes patients receiving appointment times, patients outside the catchment area being facilitated in relation to appointment times, new patients being seen first as many require access to diagnostic facilities on the same day, a senior administrative officer who also acts as a liaison officer being appointed to improve the patient services, the general manager responsible for clinical services receiving a weekly management report on the breast clinic and the chief executive at the hospital intending to have a follow up on the original review of the breast clinic services after six months.

The major capital upgrading programme approved in 1997 for St. Vincent's at a cost of approximately £50 million includes provision for the complete upgrading of the breast clinic. This work is progressing and construction work will commence at an early date.

I thank the Minister for his comprehensive reply.

The Seanad adjourned at 6 p.m. until 2.30 p.m. on Wednesday, 8 April 1998.

Top
Share