Skip to main content
Normal View

Seanad Éireann debate -
Thursday, 1 Feb 2024

Vol. 298 No. 8

Finance (State Guarantees, International Financial Institution Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2023: Second Stage (Resumed)

Question again proposed: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."

I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Byrne, here this afternoon. While he is acting for the Minister, he might ask for more funding for his Department in the upcoming sport capital programme.

The Bill follows the approval at Cabinet last April when the Minister for Finance, Deputy McGrath, announced plans to bring forward this legislation so that Ireland can participate in a number of key financial supports for Ukraine. These supports will enhance Ireland’s comprehensive response to the crisis. The Minister of State has already outlined some of the main points. The legislation allows for Irish Government contributions to EU support programmes totalling up to €375 million. These contributions are based on the provision of each support scheme involved. The EU's macrofinancial assistance, MFA, is of the utmost importance to Ukraine because it helps the Ukrainian Government to maintain essential state services during challenging and traumatic circumstances. Ireland’s full participation in this initiative demonstrates the EU's solidarity with the people of Ukraine. We also saw that with this morning's announcement.

The legislation also enables once-off payments of up to €35 million from the European Investment Bank, €10 million from the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development and €10 million from the Council of Europe Development Bank.

The Minister for Finance’s legislation includes a provision to facilitate Ireland’s participation in international responses by international financial institutions during times of crisis. This ensures timely support for Ukraine and similar future crises. In summary, the legislation underscores Ireland’s commitment to supporting Ukraine and reflects our role in the global community in times of crisis.

The Minister of State is very welcome. The Bill is required for Ireland to participate fully in some of the institutional mechanisms available in Europe to support the people, the economy and the infrastructure of Ukraine. The Bill seeks to enable the State to take part in donor and trust funds that have been established by the European Investment Bank and the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development and, for that purpose, to allow the State to enter into contribution agreements related to these funds as prescribed by the Minister.

Since the illegal Russian invasion of Ukraine began on 24 February 2022, the United Nations human rights office, the OHCHR, has verified 29,579 civilian casualties, with 10,242 people killed, including 575 children, and more than 19,300 injured, including 1,264 children. Some 14.6 million people, roughly 40% of the population, require humanitarian assistance. Attacks and extreme weather have left 1,000 villages and towns across the country without electricity or water. The economic impact on Ukraine will have long-lasting consequences. Huge parts of the country’s infrastructure have been destroyed. Public debt has soared and the fiscal deficit has spiralled. The total amount of direct damage to the country’s infrastructure exceeded €143 billion last year. Buildings, family homes, transport and road infrastructure and education and health facilities have all been destroyed. There is no end in sight to the war and the devastation continues. It is not just in our economic interests but it is a moral imperative to support Ukraine and its people with its future recovery. For those reasons, Sinn Féin will support this legislation.

However, I have to ask where is the EU solidarity with other countries suffering the effects of war or climate change, which is causing starvation and desperation for millions of people. The EU leaders should be ashamed that they have failed to call out Israel for its war crimes and its genocide of the Palestinian people. Even the human rights arm of Europe, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, voted in favour of a report which failed to condemn the actions of Israel as the death toll there reaches 25,000. I have to call out the behaviour of the Fine Gael MEPs who voted down a call for a ceasefire at the European Parliament two weeks ago. I find that absolutely unacceptable and I hope all of us in this Chamber recognise that for what it was. It was an absolute disgrace.

I hope the Government will change its position and join the South African case at the International Court of Justice and show real leadership in relation to what is happening to the people of Palestine. We support this Bill, of course, but I cannot help but point out the hypocrisy in political stances across the EU where human rights are concerned.

On behalf of the Minister, Deputy McGrath, I thank Senators for their contributions and full engagement today on the Finance (State Guarantees, International Financial Institution Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill. It is a very strong signal of Ireland’s commitment to Ukraine and to ensuring it has the necessary resources to adequately support its ongoing hardship and future reconstruction. Many Members of the Oireachtas have visited Ukraine since the invasion and have seen at first hand the devastation and human impact of the war. Many of us know personally many ministers and members of parliament from Ukraine, with whom we are in regular contact. In my previous role as Minister of State with responsibility for European affairs, I was heavily involved in the responses of Ireland and the EU during 2022. As Minister of State with responsibility for sport, the Ukraine crisis also features regularly in relation to issues around Russian and Belarusian athletes. The message from our Ukrainian friends is one of relentless resilience and determination. The various supports we can give via trusted international bodies will reinforce our national response. Substantial international assistance is needed to keep Ukraine’s Government and public services going while the ground work for the eventual recovery and the reconstruction of their economy will be the legacy of the European family.

Given the scale and the complexity of the devastation in Ukraine, a sustainable solution is needed to ensure that the funding is well co-ordinated and used efficiently, and that it ties recovery and reconstruction to Ukraine’s EU accession track. While the Bill deals with supports put in place for 2022 and 2023, the European Commission’s proposed Ukraine facility will cater for short-term stated recovery needs and medium-term reconstruction and modernisation this year and beyond. The facility will be financed through a special instrument, the Ukraine reserve for €50 billion, of which €33 billion is for loans and €17 billion is for grants and provisioning of the loans. As Members have mentioned, this morning in Brussels, heads of State and Government, including the Taoiseach, agreed this facility and the funding arrangements for it. I know the House joins me in welcoming this news.

Since the start of the invasion in 2022, the EIB, as the EU’s bank, has mobilised and disbursed €1.7 billion in emergency relief to Ukraine with the support of the European Commission. The EIB has an important role in the wider EU response and it has established the EU for Ukraine, EU4U, initiative and trust fund as well as €100 million in technical assistance to Ukrainian authorities, prioritising schools and hospitals, SME support and repairing transport networks.

Member states continue to voluntarily contribute towards this package through the trust fund with almost €400 million which is expected to grow further with future commitments. In July 2023, the Minister for Finance indicated to the EIB his intention to seek approval for Ireland to make a contribution of €7 million towards the EU4U trust fund. When this Bill is enacted, it will enable the Minister for Finance to make this contribution as soon as is practicable. This legislation will provide the necessary legal basis to enable Ireland to contribute to any multilateral response. The Minister is conscious that the level of expenditure in this regard needs to be controlled and the Bill sets limits on the amount that Ireland can contribute under the terms of any single contribution agreement. In the case of the EIB, this will be capped at €35 million and €10 million for the EBRD and the CEDB. In addition, an overall cap on expenditure is set at €375 million, or €175 million for the EIB and €100 million for each of the EBRD and the CEDB. Provision is made to ensure that any repayment of sums paid in accordance with the relevant contribution agreements can be refunded to the Central Fund.

To ensure full transparency, Oireachtas approval will be required on each occasion when the State proposes to enter into a contribution agreement with an IFI.

Ireland has been one of the strongest supporters of Ukraine's EU accession aspirations. It is important, however, we back up our words with concrete actions with continued strong financial support, which should go hand in hand with Ukraine's ongoing reform efforts. As a first step, I reiterate the importance of the quick passage of the Bill to ensure Ireland can meet its EU and international commitments to support Ukraine. Again, I thank Senators for their co-operation and I hope we can move this legislation so that it can be finalised as quickly as possible.

I thank the Minister of State. As he is Minister of State with responsibility for sport, I am sure he will join with me in wishing Charlie O'Leary, who played a pivotal role in Irish sport, a happy 100th birthday today. I know it is not related to the Bill, but as we are marking St. Brigid's Day, we should mark Charlie O'Leary's birthday as well.

As Minister of State for sport, I will join in that, a Chathaoirligh, if that is okay. Charlie has made a huge contribution over many decades. He refereed matches that my father played in the League of Ireland in the sixties and continued refereeing at the highest level. He was involved in leagues and, most famously, as a kit man during the football era that probably all of us grew up in, including Italia 90, and he became very famous. To this day, he continues to have an active role in football and the FAI and attends football functions. I met him on a number of occasions, and it is wonderful to see a man at 100 so healthy, fit and interested in everything that goes on in football. He deserves the praise of the nation and the words of the Cathaoirleach today.

I thank the Minister of State. That was well said. We all join in wishing Charlie O'Leary a happy 100th birthday. As the Minister of State said, he has given huge service to football. He is the epitome of what we should all aspire to, which is to live life healthily and give back to others. We wish him a very happy birthday.

Question put and agreed to.

When is it proposed to take Committee Stage?

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Committee Stage ordered for Tuesday, 6 February 2024.

I propose a suspension until 1.15 p.m.

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Cuireadh an Seanad ar fionraí ar 12.12 p.m. agus cuireadh tús leis arís ar 1.15 p.m.
Sitting suspended at 12.12 p.m. and resumed at 1.15 p.m.
Top
Share