Child Benefit was paid to the person concerned in respect of one child for the period June 2006 to September 2008. Payment was stopped from September 2008 as she failed to return a certificate confirming her continued residence in Ireland. Separate claims were received in 2009 from the people concerned and contradictory information has since been provided which requires clarification before a decision can be made. The information has been requested but has not yet been provided. When the requested information is received a decision will be made and the persons concerned will be notified of the outcome in writing.