Skip to main content
Normal View

Departmental Bodies

Dáil Éireann Debate, Thursday - 20 October 2011

Thursday, 20 October 2011

Questions (3)

John Halligan

Question:

3 Deputy John Halligan asked the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government in relation to the five person committee recently appointed to assess the viability of merging Waterford City Council with Waterford County Council, known as the Waterford Local Government Committee, if he will clarify the reason there are no publically elected members from either the city or county councils appointed to this committee; the reason this committee was not chosen by the independent commission; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [30728/11]

View answer

Oral answers (9 contributions)

The Waterford Local Government Committee is a statutory committee established under the Local Government Act 1991 to carry out a review of local government arrangements in Waterford and submit a report containing recommendations on whether the county council and city council of Waterford should be unified. The appointment of members to the committee was undertaken in accordance with, inter alia, section 28(4)(d) of the 1991 Act which provides for the disqualification of certain persons from membership, including members of a local authority. Accordingly, I have no discretion in that regard.

The appointment of the five members in question was based on their range of knowledge, experience and expertise, including in local government matters; public administration generally; business and development; and their knowledge of matters relevant to Waterford. I have full confidence in their ability to examine the issues rigorously and report in an objective and informed manner and in accordance with their terms of reference, a copy of which was issued on 23 September and is available on my Department's website.

The work of the Waterford Local Government Committee is an important component of an overall programme of reform and development in the local government sector, under which significant decisions in the case of counties Limerick and Tipperary have already been taken by the Government. The report of the committee which is to be submitted to me not later than 29 February 2012 will be published and I will bring proposals to the Government for decision in relation to local government arrangements in Waterford in the light of the committee's findings. To ensure public representatives are informed of matters relating to these issues, regular briefings will be provided for the committees of the relevant local authorities on the implementation of any measures to be introduced.

As the Minister is well aware, the merging of Government bodies is always fraught with danger. Job losses are inevitable, whether they are councillors, who one must remember are also workers, or local authority staff. Many are concerned about the potential for job losses. It is still unclear whether the independent commission could have been brought on board in terms of the Waterford Local Government Committee. I hope the committee will not be influenced by the Government. Its members must not be former members or supporters of the Government or related to members of the Government. This is a reasonable concern, given that the decision pending which is due in February could result in job losses.

The Minister who was a very good councillor will know that county and city councillors work at the coalface. I will be nice to the Minister for a couple of seconds. He realises these people know what is happening on the ground. With regard to the European study, we represent more people than many other councils. It would be a disaster were the Minister to consider reducing the size of city or county councils. That would not be in line with local government reform or being up-front with people.

I gather the Minister will be in contact with city and county local authorities before any decision is made and I am delighted this is the case.

I cannot appoint local representatives to this group because it would be illegal to do so. I am sure the Deputy does not advocate that I should do something illegal.

I ask the Minister to meet them.

I will not meet any representative of any local authority until such time as the group reports. It was set up to ascertain the position regarding possible synergy and efficiencies in the Waterford local government system. That will mean reduced charges and reduced waste of resources which occurs because of current duplication. The group is looking at all these issues and its terms of reference are very clear. I have full confidence in every member of the committees whose names I read out.

I do not question that.

The Deputy should wait for the outcome of these deliberations.

I do not question the people appointed by the Minister.

The Deputy may say they were Government appointees. They are, but they are very independent-minded people who are able to make up their own minds, based on the terms of reference laid down for them. I have full confidence that these people will produce a report by the end of February. Let us then discuss the contents of that report. We will give them that chance.

Top
Share