Dáil Éireann Debate, Wednesday - 15 July 2015
113. Deputy Mattie McGrath asked the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation the policy relating to the allocation of cases to the vice-chairpersons of the Employment Appeals Tribunal, together with year-by-year details of the earnings of each vice-chairperson of the tribunal, from 1 January 2010 to 30 June 2015, inclusive; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [29433/15]
View answerThe Employment Appeals Tribunal (EAT) is independent in the exercise of its quasi-judicial function and I have no direct involvement in its day-to-day operations. However, I understand that it is the Tribunal’s policy to allocate new cases to vice chairs primarily on their location and availability.
The following Table outlines fees paid to vice chairs from 1 January 2010 to date.
|
Vice Chairmen |
2015 |
2014 |
2013 |
2012 |
2011 |
2010 |
|
Sinead Behan B.L. |
€1,079.76 |
€1,305.98 |
€2,202.36 |
€2,669.38 |
€0.00 |
€4,605.82 |
|
Olive Brennan BL |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
|
Kieran Buckley |
€2,632.55 |
€3,105.58 |
€3,367.80 |
€4,689.19 |
€4,957.42 |
€7,739.91 |
|
David Cagney BL |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€530.14 |
|
Pamela Clancy |
€8,144.46 |
€10,550.79 |
€5,479.30 |
€7,358.57 |
€8,681.60 |
€5,541.09 |
|
Charles Corcoran B.L. |
€13,070.23 |
€13,183.34 |
€9,679.22 |
€17,767.86 |
€16,355.61 |
€9,491.49 |
|
Ann-Marie Courell B.L. |
€4,792.07 |
€9,717.84 |
€12,580.00 |
€16,623.84 |
€10,027.95 |
€9,646.61 |
|
Fiona Crawford B.L. |
€2,272.63 |
€8,843.71 |
€16,952.94 |
€13,304.89 |
€11,285.08 |
€9,914.84 |
|
Emile Daly B.L. |
€7,558.32 |
€11,496.85 |
€14,508.95 |
€5,720.10 |
€11,130.53 |
€12,672.87 |
|
Dorothy Donovan B.L. |
€12,710.31 |
€29,379.74 |
€25,917.50 |
€38,699.55 |
€30,083.85 |
€15,861.16 |
|
Catherine Egan B.L. |
€7,897.65 |
€15,682.19 |
€7,928.47 |
€11,666.42 |
€6,482.78 |
€9,759.72 |
|
John Fahy B.L. |
€4,432.15 |
€6,591.67 |
€5,259.09 |
€10,367.28 |
€9,807.97 |
€15,574.05 |
|
James Flanagan B.L. |
€0.00 |
€359.92 |
€7,068.92 |
€6,327.66 |
€16,504.88 |
€17,361.69 |
|
William B Garvey BL |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
|
Veronica Gates B.L. |
€7,311.51 |
€12,669.13 |
€6,559.06 |
€5,678.09 |
€5,296.75 |
€3,926.51 |
|
Myles Gilvarry |
€6,344.86 |
€15,342.86 |
€11,973.27 |
€13,841.35 |
€1,409.29 |
€18,851.93 |
|
Clodagh Gleeson BL |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€4,814.10 |
|
Bernadette Glynn |
€5,758.72 |
€3,352.39 |
€5,634.42 |
€6,101.44 |
€4,957.42 |
€5,892.69 |
|
Dara Hayes B.L. |
€3,959.12 |
€11,136.93 |
€10,753.80 |
€6,977.23 |
€6,590.04 |
€9,586.56 |
|
Graham Hanlon |
€2,519.44 |
€6,951.59 |
€10,597.85 |
€9,491.49 |
€8,997.04 |
€8,615.70 |
|
Eamon Harrington |
€719.84 |
€1,799.60 |
€3,502.33 |
€3,432.06 |
€3,658.28 |
€4,194.74 |
|
David Herlihy |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€1,525.36 |
€8,770.82 |
€9,152.16 |
€6,595.89 |
|
Patrick Hurley |
€8,864.30 |
€14,982.94 |
€19,530.63 |
€19,745.66 |
€24,631.98 |
€24,720.83 |
|
Elva Kearney B.L. |
€5,018.29 |
€10,797.60 |
€15,497.85 |
€16,397.62 |
€7,853.02 |
€9,414.07 |
|
Margaret Levey B.L. |
€13,388.97 |
€31,025.05 |
€30,904.01 |
€38,389.31 |
€27,891.19 |
€26,334.27 |
|
James M Lucey |
€2,272.63 |
€15,209.16 |
€15,164.53 |
€15,324.70 |
€9,646.61 |
€11,171.97 |
|
Dermot MacCarthy S.C. |
€13,790.07 |
€22,746.89 |
€21,195.70 |
€31,185.86 |
€26,731.76 |
€31,480.34 |
|
Orna Madden B.L. |
€9,584.14 |
€25,852.47 |
€21,180.29 |
€19,024.99 |
€16,581.83 |
€9,640.66 |
|
Roderick Maguire B.L. |
€9,830.95 |
€21,194.10 |
€18,758.55 |
€21,468.15 |
€17,767.86 |
€13,573.12 |
|
Desmond Mahon BL |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€119.06 |
|
Sean Mahon |
€0.00 |
€3,599.20 |
€1,885.28 |
€4,194.74 |
€4,165.00 |
€2,841.97 |
|
Mary McAveety |
€4,792.07 |
€6,478.56 |
€4,743.22 |
€3,432.06 |
€7,650.69 |
€6,041.49 |
|
Jeananne McGovern B.L. |
€7,897.65 |
€14,129.40 |
€19,175.89 |
€21,694.37 |
€17,231.40 |
€10,141.06 |
|
Penelope McGrath B.L. |
€16,268.33 |
€36,588.30 |
€37,956.69 |
€38,841.75 |
€32,442.99 |
€28,128.35 |
|
Saundra McNally |
€5,871.83 |
€12,463.50 |
€9,298.71 |
€7,358.57 |
€7,584.79 |
€11,839.01 |
|
Eamonn Murray |
€1,552.79 |
€4,545.26 |
€5,951.50 |
€7,853.02 |
€7,739.91 |
€12,959.24 |
|
Niamh O’Carroll Kelly B.L |
€13,183.34 |
€29,832.18 |
€30,705.22 |
€33,658.11 |
€26,157.34 |
€29,708.36 |
|
Lachlain S O'Catháin |
€0.00 |
€5,038.88 |
€10,957.77 |
€20,282.12 |
€14,830.25 |
€20,222.17 |
|
Mark O'Connell BL |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€12,429.10 |
€16,504.88 |
€15,247.18 |
|
Jeremiah O’Connor |
€359.92 |
€7,424.62 |
€9,857.42 |
€6,709.00 |
€4,957.42 |
€8,037.88 |
|
Rachel O'Flynn BL |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€530.14 |
|
Peter J O’Leary B.L. |
€17,255.57 |
€26,479.79 |
€28,410.34 |
€33,515.91 |
€32,537.03 |
€29,780.32 |
|
Seán O'Riordáin BL |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€1,882.44 |
|
Marian Petty |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€530.14 |
|
Moya Quinlan |
€0.00 |
€359.92 |
€2,605.12 |
€3,926.51 |
€7,471.68 |
€8,787.92 |
|
Pat Quinn BL |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€119.06 |
|
Joe Revington S.C. |
€11,609.96 |
€10,777.01 |
€14,191.87 |
€13,304.89 |
€13,686.23 |
€8,883.93 |
|
Nicholas Russell |
€14,736.13 |
€23,014.29 |
€16,351.39 |
€20,282.12 |
€22,993.51 |
€16,736.95 |
|
Tom Ryan |
€5,511.91 |
€19,775.01 |
€27,040.93 |
€35,478.17 |
€22,448.23 |
€14,994.84 |
|
Jeremiah Sheedy |
€0.00 |
€0.00 |
€1,144.02 |
€3,658.28 |
€6,440.77 |
€12,535.89 |
|
Tony Taaffe |
€5,625.02 |
€10,643.31 |
€20,391.01 |
€24,053.51 |
€27,206.38 |
€25,721.34 |
