Skip to main content
Normal View

Foreign Conflicts

Dáil Éireann Debate, Tuesday - 3 November 2015

Tuesday, 3 November 2015

Questions (101)

Seán Crowe

Question:

101. Deputy Seán Crowe asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade his views on the deteriorating situation in occupied Palestine; if he is aware of the blatant violations of international and human rights law, many of which have been caught on camera; his views that Palestinians living under such a brutal and violent occupation require international protection; and if he has raised concerns over these international and human rights violations with his Israeli counterpart. [37194/15]

View answer

Oral answers (6 contributions)

As the Minister knows, conditions in Palestine are among the worst faced since its illegal occupation. We have all seen pictures on camera phones and cannot hide the reality of what is actually happening during the occupation. We have also heard eyewitness reports. Gaza is the world's biggest prison and the inhuman occupation of the West Bank and east Jerusalem negatively affects every facet of daily life. Since 13 September, 73 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli authorities while 2,200 have been arrested and 2,250 injured, many by plastic bullets. The international community has largely remained silent. I have not heard any statement from the Minister on the recent human rights and international violations. I know he is busy with the talks and so on but what are his plans in the face of such blatant violations? Has he raised the issue with the Israeli authorities or with his European counterparts?

The clearly deteriorating situation in Palestine and east Jerusalem, which is now spreading to other areas, is a matter of very great concern. The main factors are the operation of policies on the ground intended to push Palestinians out of Jerusalem in favour of settlers, the absence of any political process that might promise an end to this situation and, among Palestinians, the consequent loss of authority by political leaders and loss of belief in a political path forward. Tensions have been increased in recent months by a provocative challenge by minority elements in Israel to the long-respected status quo of the holy places and sites in Jerusalem.

To these now have been added a genuine alarm and fear among Israeli citizens caused by a number of sudden attacks, resulting in pressure for a tougher response by the authorities. The risk of an escalating spiral of violence is now very obvious.

In common with others, I deplore any resort to violent attacks on civilians, be they prompted by revenge or a sense of despair. Any response by the security forces needs to be proportionate. It is the job of local leaders on all sides to go beyond this and a mere security response and to address the underlying issues. I again urge all sides to refrain from any provocation and call on Israel to make clear - in practice as well as words - that the status quo on the Temple Mount will be restored and respected. I note that President Abbas and Prime Minister Netanyahu have already taken some steps in this direction and I encourage them to continue.

More broadly, these events underline the message I have conveyed at international level since I took office. Political leadership, including from the international community, needs to address the problems of the relentless expansion of settlements and the absence of any process aiming at the end of the occupation.

I do not disagree with anything in the Minister's statement. We all want to see an end to violence but the reality seems to be that the Israeli Government continues its occupation, oppression and apartheid policies and Palestinians are subjected to extra-judicial killings. This is the most extreme and right-wing government Israel has had and its promotion of hate and impunity continues to kill the hopes and aspirations of Palestinians. In recent weeks, we have seen the spectacle of Prime Minister Netanyahu seeking to shift the blame for the crimes of the Holocaust from Hitler to the Palestinians.

I want to hear what we can do as a small country and what Europe can do. What will it take for Europe to act finally on these gross violations of international law? When will Ireland take a principled stance and demand an end to the preferable trade association agreement Israel enjoys? We can all see that it is getting worse. What action will we see, particularly from ourselves?

Many of us have seen the most disturbing video clips in recent times of civilians on both sides being killed. Some Israeli citizens have been murdered in clearly sectarian attacks. A greater number of Palestinian civilians have been killed, many of whom have not been directly involved in any attack. There are also concerns that so many of the attackers, despite lacking firearms, were shot dead rather than captured. I agree with Deputy Crowe that if this spiral of violence is not stopped, these tragedies will continue to mount. I repeat my clear call for an end to attacks on civilians.

Ireland continues to play a most important role at international level. The EU has stated clearly that all violence against civilians must end and that both sides should avoid any provocation. In addition, the EU has underlined that the lack of any clear political path is clearly exacerbating the sense of hopelessness that may have fuelled some of the recent attacks. I ask the Deputy and other Deputies to read carefully the content of an address by EU High Representative Federica Mogherini following her visit to Israel and Palestine two weeks ago.

During the past ten years, more than 11,000 attacks have been perpetrated by illegal Israeli settlers against the occupied Palestinian population and their properties. Does the Minister not agree that settlements are one of the biggest obstacles to peace? Will he push for an EU ban on the entry into the EU of goods produced in illegal settlements? If we cannot get this agreement, will he push for unilateral action?

I raised this with the previous Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade and there was talk at that time it would be seriously considered. Would the Minister even consider the possibility of blacklisting illegal and violent settlers who want to enter the European Union? That has been suggested. The symbolism and impact of this would be very important. This is a call for action today. We can say we are concerned about what is happening and so on but unless we actually do something, the call for calm, peace and dialogue will fall on barren ground and we will not achieve anything. I appeal to the Minister to come forward with some unilateral action that Ireland can take on this matter.

I confirm that as far as Ireland and the Irish Government are concerned, a negotiated two-state solution is our goal. It has been for some time and continues to be. It also continues to be the objective of the European Union.

With particular reference to the settlements, the EU has consistently asserted that they are illegal and has condemned their continued expansion and all policies associated with that. I had the opportunity earlier this year to visit some of the land adjacent to the expanded settlement area and expressed my concern in a meeting with former foreign Minister, Mr. Lieberman. I do so on every occasion when I have an opportunity to register a complaint on behalf of the people of Ireland. I again assure the House that the EU continues to prepare guidelines to ensure that settlement goods may not be labelled in a misleading manner. I raised this earlier in the year. Following the intervention of the Irish Government on numerous occasions, this issue remains very much at the top of the agenda at European Foreign Affairs Council level. I expect to see progress on the issue of settlement goods on 11 November, and will be happy to report to the Deputy on that progress.

Top
Share