I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce on 4th February:—
"If the Government will take steps to have a public inquiry conducted into the sale of Bord Fáilte property at Tramore, County Waterford, in view of the great prevailing dissatisfaction therewith, such inquiry to investigate the circumstances in which the property was sold privately and to ascertain why the property was sold at a figure much below the amount of public expenditure involved; and, if so, if the proposed inquiry will be a judicial one or by a Committee of the Houses of the Oireachtas with power to send for persons, papers and records."
That was a question which I addressed to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and in his reply the Minister said:—
"I am aware of no grounds on which an inquiry should be held and it is not intended to adopt the proposal."
This whole transaction, Sir, is a transaction surrounded by very grave suspicion. It is surrounded by suspicion in the mind of every honest citizen, in the mind of every taxpayer and particularly in the minds of the people of County Waterford and in Tramore. But it is not something that concerns County Waterford alone. It is something that concerns the taxpayers of the whole country, when we see that the Hydro, the Casino, the Boys' Club and the pitch and toss course, the property of Bord Fáilte in Tramore, involved a total expenditure of £84,550.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce states that in 1950 the Tourist Board recommended that this property should be sold. The usual procedure for the sale of Tourist Board property was that announcements would be made in the public Press advertising the sale. In most cases public auctions were conducted and it was only in the event of public auctions not realising the amount required, that attempts were made to secure more than the highest bid that could be secured at a public auction. Here, however, we see in the case of Bord Fáilte property in Tramore a situation which has been responsible for bringing protests of a very serious nature from the Tramore Town Commissioners who represent the people of all political classes and all political creeds. Quite recently the Tánaiste received a deputation of members of the Tramore Town Commissioners, and published in the daily papers on the day after was a report of a meeting of the Tramore Town Commissioners in which they called for a public inquiry, and in the public Press the chairman of the Tramore Town Commissioners is reported to have said that he led a deputation and that the decision to dispose of the property by private treaty had been made in May of last year although the Minister, in a by-election speech in Tramore in June stated that the sale would be by public auction. It isdespicable that a responsible public person, in order to capture the votes of the people of that particular district, should make a statement to the effect that this sale would be by public auction and then reverse the decision later. If there is a public inquiry I can challenge the Minister to deny that two of the four people that were interested in this sale were subscribers to the Fianna Fáil election fund. That is well known in Waterford. It is well known by the Tramore Town Commissioners and by the general public in Waterford. The people who subscribed so generously to the Fianna Fáil election fund in that year knew that their voluntary subscription to Fianna Fáil was the first instalment on £87,000 worth of property for £22,500.
In my opinion, this is a scandalous state of affairs, and it is a racket sponsored by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. This transaction stinks in the nostrils of every decent taxpayer in the country, when we see that the taxpayers' money has been sunk into £87,000 worth of property and that the local people were denied the right of forming a company of their own for the purpose of purchasing this property.
We are told that the three people who purchased this property have not purchased it as a company, not as the Tramore Development Company, but that they have purchased it as private individuals. What guarantee have we that these people will not erect tin huts and have pitch-and-toss schools, everything that would be contrary to the decent regulation of the tourist trade in this country? What guarantee have we that there would not be advertisements appearing in the English and continental newspapers asking racketeers to come and spend the season in Tramore and giving such groups or individuals £600 or £700 a year in order to carry on chancing their arm and making a good thing for themselves during the tourist season?
I believe that the sale of this property is something that should command the serious attention of the Government. I am quite well aware that, under the administration ofFianna Fáil, we have had a number of serious scandals and rackets during years past, and into one of them an inquiry was conducted at my instigation and only for that the distillery at Kilbeggan would not be there to-day.